New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

Posts

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#51

Re: I guess...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Me, too; but honestly, I've had to tolerate this sexism for my whole life. I have no more tolerance left, so I'm well on my way to firming up my crust.

Pam

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#52

Disagree ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Warren

I think that you are way off target here. For a number of reasons.

Firstly, chipping is caused by brittle steel impacting hard wood, and your inference is that my chopping creates more stress at the sharp end than should be if I held the chisel higher up at the handle. Yes? Now, just to remind you, in the recent "chopping with 5 steels" test I did, the 3/4" wide Japanese chisel not only came out on top, but was used to complete all the remaining dovetails, about 10 in all, where the other chisels failed after 1 dovetail.

Secondly, the other chisels failed because the edges folded, not chipped.

Thirdly, do you have another picture to offer than the one you did (below), any other images of my using chisels, Japanese or not? Here is the picture you posted ...


You bet you life I would hold this low down ... the chisel blade is only 1/8" wide! That is too easy to twist if held high up. Hold down low for control.

Here's the next picture in the series from which you picked this: a small dovetailed box (about 6" in length), with really tiny dovetails ..


Four. Now this issue interested me enough to do a search on the internet to find any images of the grip used by others while chopping with a Japanese chisel. I copuld only find this one ...


Link: http://www.theunpluggedwoodshop.com/made-by-hand/project-2

That's Tom Fidgen, and he is not a beginner.

Five. I hold the chisel by a handle as well. The extra length offers "steering". This is important when trying to keep the vertical in mortices, for example ...


6 and last. I am not sure if this is relevant as you can take it different ways, but I toss it into the mix: Japanese bench chisels have short handles. They are not comfortable to hold, which is why they make long handles for paring.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#53

About like you show in your picture...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

I might spread my fingers a little bit more along the blade's length, although in practice I don't pay much attention to that.

Frank Klausz seems to hold his chisels the same way:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aN9l4hQ19HE

So does Rob Cosman, couldn't find a video that showed it clearly although I can see it on my old hand-cut DT video.

DC

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#55

Anyone ever have them hardness tested?

David Weaver

I have a few old laminated chisels, but many more plane irons that are laminated than chisels. It's much easier to find chisels from 1900-1960 than it is to find early 1800s laminated stuff, with the exception being mortise chisels (in my travels).

I have never had one of the old chisels hardness tested, but i tend to think it's the hand forging more than the hardness that makes the old chisels good.

I wonder what they'd test at. I'm sure my irons aren't as hard as modern A2 irons (old laminated irons), but that may have been intentional. It's easier to sharpen a 3/4" very hard chisel than it is to do the same with a very hard 2 1/2 inch iron.

Of the chisels I *did* barter to have tested a long time ago, the hardest of the bunch was an iyoroi mortise chisel, which averaged 61 on three strikes, and the softest was a witherby (a known problem chisel - long parer that was definitely more modern) which came in around 52 and was basically unusable. I think the other 1900s style chisels that warren doesn't favor came in around high 50s in hardness, but I can only remember the hardest and the softest from the test.

If I wanted to find out with a new set of tools, I'd have to have something to barter, and I just don't care that much - it wouldn't prove anything, it was just a curiosity at the time (mostly with why that witherby edge had no durability, and wondering whether or not the cheaper japanese chisels are as hard as they say they are - I would guess not, and I've seen a couple of folks mention comments made by blacksmiths that the buyers of the lower end tools don't like their chisels to be as hard as spec because they consider them to be too hard to sharpen)

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#56

confusing hardness and abrasion resistance

Bill Tindall

There is only a weak correlation between hardness and abrasion resistance for a particular metal composition. Abrasion resistance( sharpening difficulty, or not) is mostly determined by the abrasion resistance of the alloying carbides. Vanadium carbide is the most abrasion resistant and iron carbide much less.

Hence, there will be no significant difference in sharpening a particular steel at Rc 58 vs 60. And two steels each at Rc 60 may have vastly different abrasion resistance.

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#57

Re: For whatever the reason..

David Weaver

.. I have two sets of chisels that I think are probably around their hardness spec of 65/66

I have a lot of other chisels that are probably a lot closer to 62 ("soft"). Some are blue steel, some are white, but I have hard and soft of white.

There is a big difference, for reasons i'm not sure of, in how fast a stone cuts a 66 hardness chisel and one that's a lot closer to 60. *especially* when the stone is a natural stone.

I agree at 58-60, I don't notice much difference.

If we keep it all white steel conversation, there should be no material amount of carbides to deal with.

I know that even my "soft" chisels trouble an oil stone (couldn't resist trying) a lot, even when the surface is freshened, especially the harder ones in the set. The set that I believe to be at spec, the oil stones won't do much with them at all.

The comment (from tool dealers relaying what blacksmiths said to them) about sharpenability was w.r.t white and blue steel, which both will have relatively little in carbides compared to even A2 steel.

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#58

Re: How do you hold a chisel to chop dovetails?

TomD

By the handle. The overall pose being like a dagger held in the reverse grip for an attack to the throat or eyes. I used to pinch the blades low down, but I sorta got emabarassed out of it by the fact that some I was copying did not do it that way. Also, early on I was told by a reliable source that japanese blades should have the side edges honed as well, and as a result I got a lot of cuts from handling the blades low down. Reliable source, but I don't think it was correct advice in that one point.

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#59

Re: How do you hold a chisel to chop dovetails?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Reliable source, but I don't think it was correct advice in that one point.

Why not?

Pam

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#60

Re: How do you hold a chisel to chop dovetails?

TomD

Only place I ever heard it, and while it probably does make the chisel shear a little more neatly, I don't find it valuable overall. I asume he correctly reported what he had seen in Japan, I don't get the impresion every woodworker there does it that way. I don't think there is one way, which is a separate topic.

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#61

Re: chipping - The dirty little not so secret

TomD

I virtually never chip Japanese chisels short of having people use them as cold chisels, or my dropping them on the concrete floor. I'm not to sure how people do it. I always asumed they were prying on them.

I remember once being at the LV West store in TO back around the first time they dumped Japanese tools. They had a box of 1/8" chisels they were blowing out. Apparently they decided to discontinue them when 100% of the chisels came back snapped off where the weld transitions into the iron at the handle end of the blade. Nothing wrong with the chisels. 100% pried to death. I think it was also the case that pretty much everyone who returned them denied they had ever put the English to them. But you know who you are if you are out there.

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#62

Re: About like you show in your picture...

TomD

I found video of Jay Van Arsdale holding the chisel low down...

I did a 1 minute zip thorugh various books. Workbench book shows Odate, Swenson, Young and Chase wacking away, and all holding the chisel pretty much up on the handle. I couldn't find many pics in Odate's tool book, but they show him holding the chisel by the grip and wailing away. There are quite a few pics in his Shoji book, and pretty much all holding on the handle. There are pics where his hand is down low, but I am pretty sure they are all hammerless cuts. Part of the reason for holding the grip is that if one is hitting it like it wants to be hit, it is hard to control the chisel from the blade. If one is making a lot of real gentle taps then blade holding is probably fine. Most of the pics mentioned are actually mortise work, though a few appear to be dovetails. It doesn't take all that many hits to get through a dovetail, so the tapity tap approach is pretty reasonable.

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#63

Re: chipping - The dirty little not so secret

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I haven't had any chip either; but I did have one break/fracture about 1/2" above the edge. I figured it was a forging problem.

Pam

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#64

Re: How do you hold a chisel to chop dovetails?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

First time I used Japanese tools was in Odate's shoji seminar. He pointed out that the sharp arrises were a primary feature of Japanese chisels, since they helped with the cutting. I know for a fact that these arrises can make mincemeat of my fingers.

Pam