New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

Posts

Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#1

Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

wilbur

This is more of a user report than a engineering-style tool test, but Jameel Abraham recently wrote on his blog about his experience with a Fujihiro chisel made by Imai in making dovetail joints for a chest:

"I'm building a small chest for a friend using some of the hardest, densest, gnarliest maple I've ever come across. It's like working a tropical exotic....

I purchased a 12mm Fujihiro bench chisel from Hida Tool a couple months ago. I chopped all the joints for this chest with this chisel. And I didn't go back to my stones once. That's right. The edge retention simply blew me away. That's about 5 running feet of continuous rock-hard, abrasive birdseye maple end grain work. And for fun I took some wispy thin end grain basswood shavings after I finished the last socket. Simply amazing."


This is the same maker and brand of most of the chisels that I use in my shop. These chisels are made with white steel, which is basically high carbon steel, without much in the way of added alloys. I'm not sure if they are white steel #1 or #2, but they probably are white steel #2. I find these quite easy to sharpen. It usually takes me only about 30-60 seconds with a high grit waterstone to refresh the edge for my 1/2" chisel. If I'm lazy, and have to go back to a 1000 grit waterstone because I let the edge go too long, that's a 2-3 minute process to get back to the sharpest edge that I can manage.

With the recent discussions on looking for improved steels for chisels and plane blades, I've said before that from a practical standpoint, I thought this might be trying to solve a problem that may not exist. I'm sure that there is a steel that will have better edge retention than these chisels, and that this could be demonstrated in a torture test. But if this high carbon steel chisel can chop 4 dovetail joints in hard maple for a chest without needing to be resharpened in the middle, and still stay sharp, I don't think that added edge retention will save much in the way of efficiency.

Quick back of the envelope calculation: If I am making a chest of drawers with 6 chests, with dovetails on the drawers, my experience is that my chisels should be able to chop all the dovetails for a drawer without resharpening. Suppose that I do have to resharpen my chisel between each drawer. That would be a total of 12-18 minutes at most of sharpening time spent on this project. (More likely, it would be less as I probably would only have to do the 30 second honing.) If I had a chisel with better edge retention that could take me through all 6 drawers without resharpening, I'll save that 12-18 minutes. I have no idea how long it should take to make a chest of drawers, but if it takes 60 hours, that works out to a 0.5% increase in efficiency.

Now, I'm not knocking the process of seeing how the CPM steels and so on will work in tool making. I just think that the practical gains from this are going to be less than what we may think.


img

The Economaki-Brese-Imai-Lie-Nielsen Melange

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#2

Are we missing the point?

Bob Hackett

I see all these recent posts about which purchased, finished chisel is most wear resistant,hardest,etc and wonder if we`ve traveled a bit far afield from what some of us were talking about a while back which was what type of steel would be best (as in easiest to get the desired results from thru our own efforts) if we were going to make our own custom made hand tools. In that case the newer steels would be the hands down most reasonable and accessable answer.

Sure you could contact someone who personally knows a Japanese smith and commission a custom made chisel or haunt the flea markets and garage sales till you found an old,high quality chisel that you could modify (the horror) to fit your needs but what Bill,myself and others who make their own tools to fit our own unique methods of work started out saying was that if you want to take middle of the road (or less) metal working skills and get outside the box of what merchants and catalogs are currently offering then these new steels are worth looking at.

I have a pretty large array of high quality old school laminated chisels and plane irons and have never suggested that anyone retire the fine old iron they worked so hard to find. What I said from the beginning is that if you were to pick up an old #40 scrub plane without an iron (or even one with a full length iron) and wanted to put it to use scrubbing down the hump in a 50+ year old floor then substituting a hunk of HSS planer blade might serve you far better than using up to a 1/2" of that no longer available factory iron. Likewise if you want to make a dovetail chisel (in any of the different configurations folks have come to recognize this to mean), a skew chisel or a scraper chisel then rather than grind the corners ,sides or bevel off a premium tool that could easily brought back to working normal condition and is no no longer produced then why not get a chunk of "high tech" steel and have at that instead?

For me the point was to use steel that is readily available, easy to fab,can be reliably heat treated in today`s commercial environment and will probably offer superior results in the end (especially when regrinding) for someone with limited level metalworking skills.

The reason I haven`t been active in most of the recent chisel posts is because from where I sit I see little difference between them and a chisel review in the latest issue of FWW.

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#4

Impressive......questions?

Bill Tindall

I owned a Japanese chisel during my early quest to find and own a credible set of chisels. For dovetailing it was a delight, balanced just nice for tapping out the waste(avoiding the controversial "chopping" word here). But, at least when I make dovetails there is paring involved, defined in this case as pushing the chisel with the hand as opposed to tapping with some fashion of striker. The Japanese chisel was not comfy for paring.

Question: for those that use Japanese chisels for dovetailing what do you do when you need to pare something- bear the uncomfortable ergonomics, switch to a different chisel, ?? Has anyone ever re-handled one with a handle more suited to multitasking use? The $500 plane iron universe might not see any problem owning a chisel for every need but I would find paying $60/chisel a bit steep, especially if I found it desirable to own a second set for paring.

Regarding the Blog I didn't understand how the person was cutting the dovetails. They seemed to be extolling the virtues of some sort of dovetail saw I never heard of.

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#6

Re: Impressive......questions?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Question: for those that use Japanese chisels for dovetailing what do you do when you need to pare something- bear the uncomfortable ergonomics, switch to a different chisel, ?? Has anyone ever re-handled one with a handle more suited to multitasking use? The $500 plane iron universe might not see any problem owning a chisel for every need but I would find paying $60/chisel a bit steep, especially if I found it desirable to own a second set for paring.

Pain is a sure indicator that you're doing something wrong, so I pick up another chisel. I've got special chisels for mortising, dovetailing, paring, carving, plane making, and other tasks I won't detail now, like cleaning up the bottom of a mortise. So, you ask, how do I afford sets of all that stuff. I answer that I can't afford even one set of super duper Japanese chisels except as bargains on ebay, usually 1/2 price or less (same with Japanese planes, natural waterstones, et al). Instead, I buy a couple or three sizes of each type of chisel as the need arises.

And I found in the process that I don't even need a set of bench chisels, since I've got a specialty chisel for each job. I want to sell that set of Woodcraft chisels that I bought at the start of my Japanese odyssey, but every now and then an odd size in that set saves a day, so I'm gutless.

Pam

Pam

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#7

Concur re: Imai

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

I have three Imai chisels bought through Misugi Designs about five years ago. The edge retention is just incredible. At the time Misugi offered regular and sword steel chisels (basically built to order), so I asked Kayoko about the difference between the steel. Here's the e-mail exchange:

RE: Imai chisel inquiry

...

From:

Misugi Designs <misugidesigns@hotmail.com> [Chat now]

...

To: denis_chenard@rogers.com

Hello,

Thank you so much for your E-mail.

The sword steel is also white steel but much better quality of the white steel. They are more strong, stay sharper longer, easy to sharpening. However, for the craftsman, this steel is more harder to control temperature, more labor to make the chisel. These reasons yes, the sword steel chisels are much expensive. but for the professional wood worker, I will recommend them.

Please let me know if you have any questions and any sizes, we need 2 months to make them right now. ( I am very sorry, he can not make so many in one day)

Another thing, I do not mind you have any man made sharpening stones ( king or shapton etc) however, the finishing stone, I must receommend Natural Finish stone ( grit about #12000) for these chisels or any Japanese tools. You need just one stone for your whole life and some. Make sure you will have a nice Natural stone. ( cost about $750 to $1000 or more) Please ask your friends about the stone, too.

Thank you again and hope I hear from you soon.

Kayoko

> From: Denis "Ch�nard" <denis_chenard@rogers.com>

> To: misugidesigns@hotmail.com

> Subject: Imai chisel inquiry

> Date: Wed, 1 Nov 2006 17:59:38 -0500 (EST)

>

> Good afternoon,

>

> I've been discussing with a number of "influential" people in the woodworking field, and they've recommended Imai chisels as being among the best made. Now I see that you have a "standard" line, and the sword steel line.

>

> My question is, are the sword steel chisels that much better that they justify double the price? Although the sword steel ones are beautiful, I'm interested more in the capability. Are sword steel chisels harder, tougher, etc. than the regular Imai chisels, or is is just the "ornementation" that makes the sword steel line more expensive?

>

> Thank you for your time,

>

> Denis Ch�nard,

> Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

>

>


I don't know what "much better quality of white steel" means, all I see is the edge lasting an extremely long time. BTW Konrad Sauer commented on the edge holding of the Imai in a 2007 blog post.

I miss Kayoko, but my wallet is glad I can't buy from her anymore (I had also bought a couple Yataiki saws...) :)

DC

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#8

well if that don't beat all........

Bill Tindall

I think I live a sheltered life in TN.

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#9

OMG!!

Bill Tindall

Will I last the day.?. $500 plane irons and now a $1000 stone to just do the final sharpening. And in between I learn of a mechanical hand saw that cost more than what I payed for my Unisaw. Indeed I am orbiting in a different universe.

Where were these people when we sold lumber? The typical customer thought it a crime against nature to have to pay $200 for the lumber for a project.

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#10

Not to worry

Ron in Sterling, CT

Bill,

I still use my Disston hand saws, my Bedrock planes, and an assortment of chisels that includes several brands to cut dovetails. As you know, I do a variety of woodworking projects, including furniture making, and I am enjoying it as if I was in my right mind. I also use my 45 year old 10 Craftsman table saw, but that is a subject for a different forum.

Ron

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#11

Re: Impressive......questions?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I owned a Japanese chisel during my early quest to find and own a credible set of chisels. For dovetailing it was a delight, balanced just nice for tapping out the waste(avoiding the controversial "chopping" word here). But, at least when I make dovetails there is paring involved, defined in this case as pushing the chisel with the hand as opposed to tapping with some fashion of striker. The Japanese chisel was not comfy for paring.

Question: for those that use Japanese chisels for dovetailing what do you do when you need to pare something- bear the uncomfortable ergonomics, switch to a different chisel, ??

Hi Bill

Japanese bench and dovetail chisels are uncomfortable to hold and painful to use to pare. Absolutely.

But then they are not meant to be used to pare. They are designed to be used with a hammer (gennou). This is not used to just force the blade through the wood, but for controlled force, in other words, for control ...


As I reported in my first review on chisels steels, the Koyamaichi dovetail chisels (which are simply bench chisels of a with a bevelled rather than flat top) are designed specifically for the chopping action. They stand head-and-shoulders above anything I have used in regard to getting sharp and staying sharp when used this way.

It was probably not "accurate" to use the same Koyamaicho chisel for the paring test, but I wanted to maintain consistency from one test to the next.

What I could have used was a Japanese paring chisel ... having said that I wanted consistency, I was also not so keen on abusing my nice new Kiyohisa chisels (having waited 3 years for them to arrive). These are so comfortable to hold, take a sharp edge that make paring effortless, and stay sharp (well they seem to do so - I have not compared them objectively).


Sometimes the Japanese handle makes little sense to me. I have just received a sokozari-nomi (mortice cleaning chisel), a Koyamaichi from Stu in Japan. This comes with a hooped handle. Go figure ... ?


(picture taken by Stu)

I shall just remove the hoop.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#12

I guess...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

...You don't want to know how much I paid for my Yataiki saws :D

DC

(It's actually not that bad, I guess...)

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#13

Re: Impressive......questions? *LINK*

wilbur

Of the Imai chisels that I have, I have bench chisels, paring chisels, and mortise chisels. The bench chisels are the hooped ones. I have their bevel angle at about 30�. The paring chisels have longer handles and blades, and their bevel angles are at about 25�. The mortise chisels have beefier, thicker blades, and are at about 35�.

Here's a picture to give you a sense of the relative sizes of these chisels. From left to right there is a Marples chisel from the local borg, a Japanese bench chisel, a Japanese mortise chisel, a Japanese timber framing chisel, and a Japanese paring chisel.


Personally, I don't find the bench chisels uncomfortable for paring. Then again, Japanese chisels are initially set up by driving the hoop down on the handle so that about 1/16" or so of the handle protrudes past the top of the hoop, and then the end of the handle is hammered to deforms the wood so that it covers the top of the hoop like a mushroom. On my chisels, I try to get the mushrooming to go to the edge of the hoop.


Maybe that covering of wood makes them seem more comfortable than what others think, if their Japanese chisel handles aren't mushroomed to the same extent, but I can understand if other people don't like paring with a Japanese bench chisel. A Japanese paring chisel is nicer, of course, but I can make either one work for me without much problem.

I have more written up on setting up a Japanese chisel at the link below.

For the record, the Imai chisels that I have are the plain ones, and go for about $65-70 apiece today in the usual sizes one would have (1/4"-1"). Judging form the photo from Jameel's blog, he has the same one. Back when I bought them, they were about $15 cheaper, making them price competitive with Lie-Nielsen's chisel offerings at the time. The change in price over the years is pretty much completely due to the falling dollar/yen exchange rate over the past few years. If I remember correctly, CPM chisels made by John Payne are going to be in that price range, or maybe just $10 cheaper at most.

You also don't need a $1000 natural waterstone to sharpen them. Any high grit (8000 or higher) waterstone will be just fine.


Japanese chisel set up articles

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#14

Re: Impressive......questions?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Sometimes the Japanese handle makes little sense to me. I have just received a sokozari-nomi (mortice cleaning chisel), a Koyamaichi from Stu in Japan. This comes with a hooped handle. Go figure ... ?

This is because the chisel is supposed to be hit to grab fibers, then pulled up. This particular bottom cleaning chisel is the only one of the three to have a hooped handle.

Pam

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#15

Re: Impressive......questions?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

The one Imai I have is a 15mm shinogi of the cheap variety without hoop. It works great, holds its edge nicely. I prefer the Tasai ultra thin for paring, but probably this is shinogi vs ultra thin rather than Imai vs Tasai. I keep looking for an Imai ut, but no luck; nor have I found other than Tasai ut, although Koyamaichi has thin chisels, as 8mm of which I recently ordered, have yet to receive. Apparently Koyamaichi's process involves a lot of time.

Pam

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#16

Re: I guess...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

It was pretty bad, Denis. I only know because I tried to buy one of his dozuki; but, alas, he's a male pig who refused to sell it to me. Between him and Odate I think I really dislike Japanese men. The only saving grace so far is Inomoto-san.

Pam

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#17

Re: Impressive......questions?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Pam

I believe you ... but just do not see how this can be done. Obviously I am missing something. My plan was to use it in a scraping action.

How would you do it?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#18

Re: Impressive......questions?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

If you have Odate's JJapanese Woodworking Tools, check out page 69 of the paperback version. But if you don't:

The mori nomi is used to clean the faces of mortises, and along with the mortise chisel, the idea being that the blind mortise depth that defines a very thin membrane can be approached. So the face (what one may call the back, the part opposite the bevel) is placed along the mortise face/end and hit downward, then pulled up to snag the offending wood.

It's misleading that all three of these chisel types are called "bottom cleaning."

Pam

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#19

Turning to Odate's book now ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Pam

Thanks for pointing me in the right direction .. (sound of my head being slapped)...

Ok, on page 69 in my paperback copy of Japanese Woodworking Tools:

".... The remaining wood on the bottomis scored with the mortise chisel, and the last of the wood fibers are removed from the bottom of the mortise with the sokazarai-nomi, a thin goose-necked tool with a small spade-like bend at its end. This chisel, which is pushed with one or two hands (never tapped with a hammer) ....". (my emphasis)

Aside from the fact that Toshio Odate cannot spell "mortice" and "fibre", I must must have the last say on using this chisel ... which is how I expected to use it. Pam, you are confusing the sokazarai-nomi (Stu referred to it as a sokozari-nomi) with the mori-nomi. Of this, Odate writes, " Unlike Western woodworkers, who lever out the waste with the mortise chisel, the tategu-shi uses a mori-nomi to hook out the chips. To use the tool, press its face flush against the walls or end of the mortise; the chisel is tapped down, then quickly jerked up to catch the chips".

The sokozari-nomi has an L-shaped cutting edge (looks and is used like a router plane blade), while the mori-nomi is shaped like a harpoon or arrow head (drive it down and hook up waste).

So we are back to my observation that the sokazarai-nomi or sokozari-nomi does not need a hoop since it is pulled and not struck, and therefore the hoop is not only incorrect, but gets in the way. Interestingly, in Odate's book, the sokozari-nomi is drawn without a hoop, while the mori-nomi is drawn with one.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#20

once again....helpful information, thanks

Bill Tindall

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#21

Re: Turning to Odate's book now ...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I really don't think I'm confused about anything discussed here, Derek. It's quite clear to me that you've misnamed your hooped chisel, or Stu has, or the blacksmith has put a hoop on the wrong chisel, or something like that. :) I'll admit that when I first got a set of these chisels I was confused about why one had a hoop; so I naturally went into "Oh, same confusion" mode and didn't even look at your photograph, which clearly demonstrates what you said. Stu?

So, to put this straight, it's the harpoon shaped chisel that's the mori nomi and should be hooped. Neither of the other two benefit from being hooped.

Pam

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#22

Re: Turning to Odate's book now ...

Bob Hackett

It`s my understanding that a chisel only needs to be hooped if it is meant to be struck.

If it is hooped then the hoop needs to be placed so as to eliminate any splitting and that means the hoop needs to have it`s diameter is at a 90 degree angle to the direction the cutting is taking place.

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#23

And? Did I say otherwise?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#24

Re: Impressive......questions?

Raney

If you look closely at the photo, it is (as Derek has said) a sokozarai-nomi. Pam is talking about Mori-nomi, which are used exactly the way she describes. However, Derek is quite correct in his understanding. This is the first time I've ever seen a sokozarai with a hoop. Normally, the Mori is the only one of the three 'typical' doormaking specialty mortise cleaning chisels that is hooped.

Looks to me like there was some confusion between the chisel maker and the handle maker. I'd remove the hoop if it were mine, as well.

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#25

No you didn`t. Just stating my understanding of it

Bob Hackett