Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*
wilbur
This is more of a user report than a engineering-style tool test, but Jameel Abraham recently wrote on his blog about his experience with a Fujihiro chisel made by Imai in making dovetail joints for a chest:
"I'm building a small chest for a friend using some of the hardest, densest, gnarliest maple I've ever come across. It's like working a tropical exotic....I purchased a 12mm Fujihiro bench chisel from Hida Tool a couple months ago. I chopped all the joints for this chest with this chisel. And I didn't go back to my stones once. That's right. The edge retention simply blew me away. That's about 5 running feet of continuous rock-hard, abrasive birdseye maple end grain work. And for fun I took some wispy thin end grain basswood shavings after I finished the last socket. Simply amazing."
This is the same maker and brand of most of the chisels that I use in my shop. These chisels are made with white steel, which is basically high carbon steel, without much in the way of added alloys. I'm not sure if they are white steel #1 or #2, but they probably are white steel #2. I find these quite easy to sharpen. It usually takes me only about 30-60 seconds with a high grit waterstone to refresh the edge for my 1/2" chisel. If I'm lazy, and have to go back to a 1000 grit waterstone because I let the edge go too long, that's a 2-3 minute process to get back to the sharpest edge that I can manage.
With the recent discussions on looking for improved steels for chisels and plane blades, I've said before that from a practical standpoint, I thought this might be trying to solve a problem that may not exist. I'm sure that there is a steel that will have better edge retention than these chisels, and that this could be demonstrated in a torture test. But if this high carbon steel chisel can chop 4 dovetail joints in hard maple for a chest without needing to be resharpened in the middle, and still stay sharp, I don't think that added edge retention will save much in the way of efficiency.
Quick back of the envelope calculation: If I am making a chest of drawers with 6 chests, with dovetails on the drawers, my experience is that my chisels should be able to chop all the dovetails for a drawer without resharpening. Suppose that I do have to resharpen my chisel between each drawer. That would be a total of 12-18 minutes at most of sharpening time spent on this project. (More likely, it would be less as I probably would only have to do the 30 second honing.) If I had a chisel with better edge retention that could take me through all 6 drawers without resharpening, I'll save that 12-18 minutes. I have no idea how long it should take to make a chest of drawers, but if it takes 60 hours, that works out to a 0.5% increase in efficiency.
Now, I'm not knocking the process of seeing how the CPM steels and so on will work in tool making. I just think that the practical gains from this are going to be less than what we may think.
The Economaki-Brese-Imai-Lie-Nielsen Melange









