New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

Posts

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#26

OK, and, of course, you're correct.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#27

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts

TomD

It is pretty hard to argue there is even a practical basis for making the determination. Who is really involved in making a living via hand tools today in the first world, now cut that back further to someone who is doing that but doesn't even grind tools. I can't actually think of anyone, not to say they don't exist. Now add the Bill part where they grind well enough to make tools, but don't grind to sharpen them. There is no practicality. What we have is just people who read the latest stuff online, and make a commercial argument about it, and other people who need an argument in order to justify buying stuff they have already decided to buy.

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#28

Re: Are we missing the point?

TomD

I think you are missing the point Bob, which is that for people embarking on making chisels there will be a variety of resources they can bring to bear. In some cases they will be the ones you describe, in other cases they may involve in-house heat treating and forging, etc... The steels you guys promote make sense in your scenario, but not in others, no universal solution.

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#29

Re: Impressive......questions?

TomD

Derek i would not normally hold a japanese chisel that way when striking it, one grabs the handle. Takes a while to get used to, can't wait until I develop a tremor.

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#30

Re: Impressive......questions?

TomD

Or possibly the hooped chisel was previously owned by Tage Frid if his saw is to be believed...

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#31

Re: I guess...

TomD

Makes you wonder what he is thinking.

One could refuse to sell to women because the whole idea of them being visible in the 9-5 world is an affront, but that would be pretty extreme.

Makes me wonder if he doesn't sell to women because he doesn't see them as real woodworkers, and can mostly only imagine men as such. That would be a legitimate concern at least as far as not wanting to deal with non-woodworkers, even if his filter is off. But if that were the reason, then he is really deluded about the market he is selling into...

If he doesn't care who buys his stuff and just wants to make money. Or if he has progressed to a post modern world where he is selling art, not tools. In either of those cases he should welcome clients of any stripe.

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#32

Thanks for pointing that out Tom

Bob Hackett

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#33

How do you hold a chisel to chop dovetails?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tom

Let's ask the question of everyone. Should be interesting enough. Probably get a 100 different ways.

How do you hold yours?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#34

chipping

Warren in Lancaster, PA

If you don't hold the chisel by the handle you have no angular control; it's no wonder you get chipping.

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#35

Re: I guess...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I don't think his brain was the main organic contributor.

Pam

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#36

Re: Impressive......questions?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

The one time I tried holding a Japanese chisel by the business end, I promptly sliced my finger on the arrises. I no longer do that. :)

Pam

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#38

Re: How do you hold a chisel to chop dovetails?

David Weaver

On a chisel that has good balance, I hold the chisel near the edge. It's easier for me to control it that way (as in get it in the mark or in front of the mark quickly and strike).

On one that's long, inevitably I will end up with a hand on the handle at some point. Due to some tool-pigginess, I don't have to use anything that isn't easily controlled holding the chisel blade.

I had just assumed a long time ago that the only chisel I'd like to hold on the handle all the time would be a mortise chisel or a firmer in heavy work.

I'm surprised by warren's comment. I've not had issues with chipping unless the chisel partnered to the work was not a good match (i.e., a fairly soft o1 chisel at 25 degrees chopping dovetails out of a medium hardwood like a good dense cherry or oak). Even then, it's more edge rolling and what looks like denting. I have not had chipping issues with decent japanese chisels (be they the "cheap" iyoroi mokumes or the k-ichi dovetails) regardless of the wood. I would rather solve the chipping issue with the tool than the hold.

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#39

Re: How do you hold a chisel to chop dovetails?

Dean J from MN

I hold my chisels (when removing DT waste) like a pencil. Near the cutting edge, with the side of my hand in contact with the board. Hand (and at times forearm) contact gives me control of the stock (I rarely clamp the case/drawer side down) as well as allows me to set the chisel right where I want it. My chisels are tanged, so are not top heavy. In the past I had top heavy chisels and found holding them low caused my to tire after a long stint of DTing.

I too was taken aback by Warren's comment -- I don't have any chipping issues holding my tools low. The very same tools chip like crazy in a beginners hands when I am out demoing. That chipping is the result of the beginner prying/twisting/scraping with the tool to remove waste.

-Dean

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#40

Step 1.....

Bill Tindall

Step 1 of removing dovetail waste is to engage the chisel edge in the scribe line. I have seen a lot of professional cabinet makers accomplish this task by holding the chisel near the bevel with hand resting on the work to guide it into position. This position, without question, offers more control than guiding the edge to the line with the guidance system(fingers) located farther away. Once positioned in the scribe line it is a simple matter to tap the chisel to remove the chip and move on to the next position.

More power to anyone that has the skills to guide the chisel to the line by holding the chisel far removed from the target, ie by the handle. I don't see that this more demanding alternative offers any advantage, or disadvantage if you can do it.

My advice to someone would be to guide the chisel edge to the line by what ever means you find quick and reliable for it doesn't make any difference in the final result.

If you choose to hold near the bevel you will find that a shorter lighter handled chisel will be easier to control than one with a long heavy handle. No doubt for this reason I see inexpensive Japanese style chisels used in may professional shops for this operation for they are balanced nearer the bevel. The "Blue Handles" are exceptionally poor for this approach.

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#41

Re: I guess...

Raney

That's surprising, given his reputation as such a kindly fellow.

Pam, was he explicit about his reasons for refusing? Given that he had such a close business and personal relationship with Kayoko, I wouldn't have guessed him for such a barefoot-n-pregnant type. Not that I haven't seen such things before...

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#42

Re: chipping

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Chipping is caused by shear forces. When you hold the chisel like a pencil the chisel can flop around damaging the edge, especially in woods like your jarrah, as you have shown.

You won't see drawings of 18th century workers holding their chisels near the edge. Not sure if you will see traditional Japanese workers with the floppy grip either. Of course several have suggested getting new steel and new sharpening methods as an alternative.

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#43

Re: chipping

David Weaver

I haven't seen the flopping around that you're talking about warren. What kind of mallet are you using? I use either a flat faced wooden mallet (wooden handled chisels) or a steel hammer, and i've not had, and i'm pretty sure of this, any material shearing or twisting force at the edge of the chisel.

I think you could easily see the flopping you're talking about if you found a classroom full of beginners and asked them to hold the chisel near the cutting edge. It's a skill like anything else.

The only chisels I've had trouble with the edges on are chisels where the edges are troubled no matter where you hold them, either because the chisels are just junk/soft or because they aren't quite up to handling the angles they're ground to.

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#44

Re: chipping

David Weaver

>floppy grip<

This is similar to how I grip japanese chisels. It occurs to me that you are assuming that everyone who doesn't hold the handle is holding only at the bleeding edge of the chisel?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9dtqG_wdHDY&feature=related

False dilemma, warren.

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#45

Re: chipping

Warren in Lancaster, PA

David, your video is not nearly as extreme as what I was thinking, but still I don't know if that is a traditional Japanese grip. This is what I was referring to:


img

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#46

Re: chipping

David Weaver

Likely not, but I don't see how else you can grip a chisel.

I have seen (granted i am a user of japanese tools, and not a follower of traditional japanese woodworking) the grip of people using japanese tools go from that (shown in that video) to holding the handle pretty much anywhere.

Because the chisels are short and the shank is round, you can comfortably grab the chisel by the handle and part of the shank and still have good control at angles and cutting depths where holding the end of the chisel isn't practical.

I don't think anything should be written off where you can hold the chisel firmly, strike in line with the chisel's edge with a hammer, and get the chisel to the mark quickly.

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#47

Re: chipping

David Weaver

I guess it's up to everyone to decide what they want to do, maybe dereks grip is a little different on chisels a bit wider than that one.

Certainly the grip you're thinking of (where someone has their hand around the handle of the chisel somewhere) is used in videos on youtube, it's just hard to find those videos when the written language is different and they're not searchable with english text.

The one that was on here a while ago with the craftsman making a hidden miter dovetail joint showed the grip you're talking about, but I think it's unlikely that most amateurs are going to develop that level of control to work at speed.

Maybe it's an experience issue, I still prefer the finger grip like in the first video i linked, because cutting dovetails is something I do a few times a year, not a few times a day.

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#48

Re: I guess...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Kayoko was ordered at the start of a blacksmithing seminar in San Francisco to tell me that he was only being courteous while in the US by allowing me in his class at all. This after I'd spent $1000 or so getting there and paying for the class. Of course, my reply was less courteous, on the order of his ass can be sued.

Kayoko did sell me an azebiki he made that she had on hand, with the handle by him as well, sort of a little "stick it to him" move as far as I was concerned.

Pam

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#49

Stephen Shepherd

Exactly

Stephen Shepherd

Why do the chisels have handles? One may hold the chisel that way for a light tap to define the scribe line but then the handle gives much better control and as Warren says reduces chipping. Misuse is the cause of chipping, or running into a nail or bullet or other non wood object.

But I do believe Warren is using the same type of chisels that I do, which are laminated and by their very nature much harder tools. This point seems to have been missed.

Stephen

Re: Chisel edge retention test report, of sorts *LINK*

#50

Re: I guess...

Raney

I always find this sort of thing so... sad. Someone so deserving of admiration in one way, yet with such an egregious flaw that I simply cannot respect them at all.