Question and comments
Bill Tindall
Maybe everyone else knows, but who are the people you refer to in your post?
I have been using CPM 3V chisels for the past 8 years. They were hardened at the recommended Rc58-60 but in fact they test at 58. They were heat treated by Paul Bos. At that time he would heat treat a single tool for a quite modest price and may still do so. Bos cryo treates everything, but there is some question whether it does anything useful, especially for 3V. He and mid South were the only heat treaters recommended by the CPM tech staff at the time. Bos was much cheaper for small lots but mid South better for a full load. Both places did a nice job of straightening the heat treated tool blanks so that the rest of the fabrication proceeded smoothly.
My chisels are hollow ground then sharpened at 26-27 degrees for domestic hardwoods. I don't work anything else.
My edge failure looks to be similar to Derek's pictures. The edge deforms under the stress of chopping dovetails. I have never seen a chip with 3V. In my hands one chisel sample of M2 micro chipped severely at the edge.
I was hoping 3V hardened at 60-62 would be a world beater, and M4 even better. It is difficult for me to imagine that M4 is deforming at the hardness you achieved. It would be nice to see some comparative data for 3V at 58-60 and 60-62 as well as M4 evaluated in some domestic wood. I had access to a well equipped microscopy lab for my pictures and even at that it is daunting to get a photo that reveals what one can easily see with the microscope. Derek's method of chop followed by pare would seem to provide the best comparative test. For our tests we chopped 10 dovetails in walnut and took a picture. The pictures shows a 3V chisel edge after 10 dovetails in walnut. 27 degree bevel. The performance was much better than what we observed on Sorby or Two Cherries chisels sharpened similarly.



