New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Chisel Blade Testing - 5 Steels

Posts

Re: Chisel Blade Testing - 5 Steels

#26

Question and comments

Bill Tindall

Maybe everyone else knows, but who are the people you refer to in your post?

I have been using CPM 3V chisels for the past 8 years. They were hardened at the recommended Rc58-60 but in fact they test at 58. They were heat treated by Paul Bos. At that time he would heat treat a single tool for a quite modest price and may still do so. Bos cryo treates everything, but there is some question whether it does anything useful, especially for 3V. He and mid South were the only heat treaters recommended by the CPM tech staff at the time. Bos was much cheaper for small lots but mid South better for a full load. Both places did a nice job of straightening the heat treated tool blanks so that the rest of the fabrication proceeded smoothly.

My chisels are hollow ground then sharpened at 26-27 degrees for domestic hardwoods. I don't work anything else.

My edge failure looks to be similar to Derek's pictures. The edge deforms under the stress of chopping dovetails. I have never seen a chip with 3V. In my hands one chisel sample of M2 micro chipped severely at the edge.

I was hoping 3V hardened at 60-62 would be a world beater, and M4 even better. It is difficult for me to imagine that M4 is deforming at the hardness you achieved. It would be nice to see some comparative data for 3V at 58-60 and 60-62 as well as M4 evaluated in some domestic wood. I had access to a well equipped microscopy lab for my pictures and even at that it is daunting to get a photo that reveals what one can easily see with the microscope. Derek's method of chop followed by pare would seem to provide the best comparative test. For our tests we chopped 10 dovetails in walnut and took a picture. The pictures shows a 3V chisel edge after 10 dovetails in walnut. 27 degree bevel. The performance was much better than what we observed on Sorby or Two Cherries chisels sharpened similarly.


Re: Chisel Blade Testing - 5 Steels

#27

plane irons

Bill Tindall

there are a lot of them out there at 58-60. I have been using one for 8+ years.

Re: Chisel Blade Testing - 5 Steels

#28

Re: Question and comments

wilbur

"Maybe everyone else knows, but who are the people you refer to in your post?"

People on the Woodnet hand tools forum who have been trying out some of John's chisels.

Re: Chisel Blade Testing - 5 Steels

#29

Re: Chisel Blade Testing - 5 Steels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

...The RC hardness for each steel was based on recommendations from Crucible and from custom knife makers who have been using these steels for many years. Neither of these sources had experience in making wood working tools so I made an educated guess based on their inputs.

Hi John

Based on the current evidence of the edges folding, rather than chipping, I would assume that the steels were actually too soft and we should be trying them in higher ranges if they are to be used for paring after chopping. I think that the ideal edge is one that gets as close to chipping but does not do so (too much work to repair), perhaps shows just micro-fractures. These PM edges instead folded (which ensures the edge will be dull), with the M4 the closest to the "ideal".

This appears especially the case with the 10V, certainly with the 3V and least with the M4.

Of course I do plan to redo the test, grinding back each edge by 1/8" before hand. I doubt that this will make any difference however.

What I want to first do is test these chisels in a test of paring. There have been a few comments about PM steels, especially 3V and M4, potentially being excellent choices for plane blades. Paring and planing ... both are about abrasion resistance ... for which these steels are expected to best suited.

So let me do the paring test, and it is likely that we shall see the results reversed.

Choosing steel for blades is always a compromise of strengths and weaknesses in regard to the target. Assessments like these, while quite amateurish, are real world and hopefully provide a window into their potential.

Note to self: must get an A2 chisel into this battery of steels.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel Blade Testing - 5 Steels

#30

Re: Chisel Blade Testing - 5 Steels

bugbear

Whilst we're talking about steels from the "world of knives", I'll relay a comment often seen on knife forums; the forging and heat treatment matters at least as much as the steel composition.

Since the use of these steels for chisels is (to say the least) in its early stages, I suspect that the best way to make such a chisel from these new steels is still to be found.

If the excellence of the Koyamaichi came purely from the steel, all white steel chisels would have the same performance, which is certainly not the case. Ditto for O1 and W1.

BugBear

Re: Chisel Blade Testing - 5 Steels

#31

on grinding back 1/8"

Bill Tindall

The damage from heat treating extends only a few thousandths of an inch into the metal, according to tech staff at CPM. The place to worry about this fact is the back of the chisel. If enough material has not been removed from the back of the chisel during fabrication then material degraded during heat treating is forming the working edge. Hence, the place to worry about removing potentially defective metal is the back of the chisel, not its end.

Knives, with their double bevel, do not suffer this potential problem. Their working edge is the middle of the metal mass.

Re: Chisel Blade Testing - 5 Steels

#32

I would like to add a 3rd critical variable

Bill Tindall

Whilst we're talking about steels from the "world of knives", I'll relay a comment often seen on knife forums; the forging and heat treatment matters at least as much as the steel composition.

I would like to add sharpening technique as a third leg of the performance picture. Note the huge difference in performance of 3V between 25 and 30 degrees.

Re: Chisel Blade Testing - 5 Steels

#33

I question your conclusion

Bill Tindall

"These PM edges instead folded (which ensures the edge will be dull), with the M4 the closest to the "ideal"."

It appears from the photographs that the 30 degree edge for 3V is better than the 30 degree edge for M4. This observation is at odds with hardness of these two metals. I would have predicted that M4 should be significantly more resistant to deformation at the edge.

Re: Chisel Blade Testing - 5 Steels

#34

Re: I question your conclusion

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

Rather than posting tables of information, I simplified it into a summary. The actual data I recorded did show better pine end grain paring with the M4 blade, which it why I placed it above the 3V.

I took a few images of each blade. Keep in mind that the lense can only capture a section of each blade, and that the higher the magnification, the smaller the blade section captured. So I presented an image of a section of the blade that I believed was most representative of the full length. There was less folding on the M4 compared with the 3V, but that is not as apparent in the images selected here.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel Blade Testing - 5 Steels

#35

Adding some additional perspective to this work

Bill Tindall

There will always be many "best" chisel steels, best depending on practicality of fabrication, cost, durability of edge, ease of maintenance, commercial availability, etc. The data provided is valuable to those needing to make a chisel obtaining decision.

I don't know anything about John Payne but reading between the lines perhaps he is someone in the boutique business of making chisels for sale, or like me someone that was too cheap to buy a set, or somewhere in between. For this situation the "best" chisel is one that MUST be made with the equipment at hand. Anyone with a hacksaw(to cut the annealed steel) grinder, and a mail box (to ship to heat treater) can make chisels from commercially available metal sheets. Hence it follows that the best chisel in this situation will be limited to one of these steels readily available in annealed sheet form, that can be sawed with the equipment at hand (3V is the clear winner in this fabrication category). Optimizing best among the choices will involve selecting the steel, bevel angle and the heat treating regime. In this realm, the comparison will be limited to O1, A2, M4 etc. Data on Stanley, or other, is a useful benchmark, but a benchmark only. Here the conclusion is that a home shop can make a chisel as durable as Stanley made and maybe not quite as durable as the Japanese smith can make, at least not yet. John can be proud of this accomplishment.

The data provided in this thread offers some valuable guidance for others in this situation. The substantial difference in cost and ease of fabrication would lead me to using O1 or 3V if I was to make additional chisels. Adding some data on the ever popular A2 would be especially valuable.

In a different realm "best" might be what can be sold on a commercial basis for less than $XX. We saw a huge difference between Sorby and Two Cherries when used for chopping. Presumably both are some variant of O1. Or best may be extended to the best ever made without regard for availability, cost, fabrication requirements, etc.

So, the data provided will mean different things to different people. For the persons that were comfortable spending whatever for the "K" chisels these data should add comfort that they got what may be the most durable chisel for dovetail chopping. For someone making their own chisels, there is useful guidance. For someone that by some means already has a set of vintage Stanleys there would seem to be little need to worry that someone will be able to buy something substantially better. For someone that needs to make a living chopping dovetails and needs to buy a set of chisels tomorrow there is less useful guidance.

Re: Chisel Blade Testing - 5 Steels

#36

thanks for clarification, and an added emphasis

Bill Tindall

So, it would seem that edge durability, as determined by resistance to deformation, is highly correlated with hardness, i.e. the harder the metal the less prone it is to deform/fold on impact? I believe this is the result one would predict from material science but it is of great relevance to see it confirmed in a "real world" test. In my mind this conclusion is the most important product of this effort for it provides guidance toward future optimization. The best metal will be one that can be made very hard while preserving toughness, either through metal composition(3V) or fabrication (the K chisels) or some combination of these variables.

The hope for an inexpensive chisel is that a composition can be found to achieve this optimum with out having to resort to expensive processing (K chisels).

Re: Chisel Blade Testing - 5 Steels

#38

another question

Bill Tindall

Could you get Chuck and Dave to post here some information about their experience with 3V? Ideally in a new thread. You all have data at higher hardness, something I have long been curious about, by was too lazy to make more chisels to investigate.

At the time we made stuff from 3V the conventional wisdom was to harden to maximum toughness- Rc58-60. Some years later the knife makers found that 3V performed better at higher hardness, such as you have been requesting.

I know my chisels at Rc 58 would not have a durable edge at 25 degrees in domestic hardwoods. At about 27 degrees edge life is acceptable but I certainly can't chop dovetails all day with my chisels without edge touch-up. I am surprised that someone would tolerate the need for a 35 degree bevel because penetration is so much poorer than at a steeper angle. But maybe the additional robustness of the 35 degree edge is worth this trade-off. In any case, would like to share more experience.

Re: Chisel Blade Testing - 5 Steels

#39

Starting my own, limited test

Steve Elliott

Bill,

This thread has motivated me to do a test of my own similar to Derek's, using a piece of satinwood (slightly less hard than jarrah), chopping end grain the way Derek did. This afternoon I've been flattening the back of a James Swan chisel I will use as a good sample of older carbon steel, and for 3V I'll use a plane blade hardened to Rc61. My sample of satinwood is 3/4" wide so the chopping will be similar to Derek's use of 3/4" chisels.

My real interest is in the mode of edge failure: deformation, chipping, or abrasion. I have the capability to take 540x microscope images now, and I'm hoping that will be informative.

I don't have chisels in any of the newer alloys. With chisels I'm quite satisfied with what I can get in current Japanese tools and older vintage ones. It's mostly size and ergonomics that matter to me--edge retention is already very good with high quality carbon steel.

Re: Chisel Blade Testing - 5 Steels

#40

Great, one suggestion

Bill Tindall

Anxious for your results. They are always thorough. I would rather see a domestic hardwood used, maple for example. The results would be more relevant.

One hardly needs 540X to see the failure of the chisel edges. The chips (seen in M2) or deformation (seen in 3V and carbon steel) have been obvious at 10X. It is getting a representative picture that is the hard part.

In my hands our 3V chisels are some better than the one Swan I have. But the differences are not enough better to trump the ergonomic issues you pointed out. I wish someone would send Steve an A2 to compare.

(I suspect you will prefer the ergonomics of the Swan chisel over the plane iron for typical dovetail chopping. )

Re: Chisel Blade Testing - 5 Steels

#41

Re: Great, one suggestion

Steve Elliott

Good suggestion, Bill. I'll probably start with the satinwood and then compare the species I'm more interested in working, maple and cherry. I'd like to have at least a little experience that would compare to the test Derek conducted, though.

As I thought more about the test I realized I could use any of the large assortment of plane blades I've accumulated, which includes A2 and M2. I'll be putting together a simple fixture to guide the plane blade while I tap it through the end grain. In addition to testing the various alloys I'd like to compare the effect of using different types of mallet. Derek's pictures show a mallet with a steel head, which would deliver the sharpest sort of blow. A softer head, whether wood, plastic or rubber, would spread the impact out over a slightly longer period of time. I know it's easier to make fine adjustments to a plane iron using a sharp tap from a metal hammer and I'd guess it's also easier to chip or deform a chisel edge with a sharper tap.

When I started on the back of the Swan chisel I was using a worn DMT extra coarse diamond stone, and it was so slow I got out my cast iron and 60 micron diamond paste. That was WAY faster. I wish I�d known that years ago.

Re: Chisel Blade Testing - 5 Steels

#42

sounds good

Bill Tindall

I still wish you would start on a domestic hardwood. I am way more interested in a comparison of these blades on woods most people work than any other consideration. If we arranged on a vote for the wood to first use would you consider the results?

Re: Chisel Blade Testing - 5 Steels

#43

Let's keep this simple

Steve Elliott

My first quick look through my scraps didn't turn up a suitable piece of maple but I can make one if I need to. I agree the most interesting results are the ones that reflect the typical conditions, not the ones out on the fringe.

That said, I find it useful to have more than one person testing a certain set of conditions, hence my interest in reproducing Derek's test.

Re: Chisel Blade Testing - 5 Steels

#44

Re: another question

John Payne

Bill

I will ask them. Dave is a young guy that puts out high quality furniture at a rate I've never seen. I'm not a wood worker like that so he cuts more dovetails in a weekend than I do in a year. I know no one who can equal his volume of wood work, so he was the one I wanted to test steels first. Chuck Bender is a regular writer in Popular Woodworking and has a wood working school so his chisels see a lot of use there. They are both regulars on Woodnet, I'll ask them to post here too.

John

Re: Chisel Blade Testing - 5 Steels

#45

thanks

Bill Tindall

It is curious that they each settled on such hugely different bevel angles. Would like to know why.

Re: Chisel Blade Testing - 5 Steels

#46

Bob Strawn

Re: another question

Bob Strawn

I have been using the M4 blade for a lot of very bad things. As a result I have had to remove a few dings. The M4, once you get the soft steel off, is a pain to grind. Very resistant to grinding. Since M4 is one of the top end metals designed to take heat and cut steel, one would expect it to take a bit of time to grind, and one would be right.

After about the third large ding, and my getting real tired of grinding the same poor abused blade, I decided to save some time and get sloppy. So after I got silly and used the plane blade by itself, with a mallet to flush cut a steel screw point, I got lazy and just used a slightly worn belt and high pressure to grind the ding out, ignoring color change. I even got a touch of glow on one edge. I did not dip it to cool it, I set it aside on my anvil to equalize temperature.

Apparently that is the correct way to sharpen this thing. The edge is now, tougher than ever, and holding up to my horrid abuse and testing.

Seems my careful wet grinding, honing and stropping, that does such magic on my O1 tools, is not the correct method for M4. Next time I have to take a ding out, I plan to use a stock grey wheel on a grinder. That may just be what M4 was designed for. Sure makes sharpening it easier.

Bob

Re: Chisel Blade Testing - 5 Steels

#47

that's why its called "high speed steel"

Bill Tindall

Many of these tool steels are tempered at around 1000 degrees. So as long as you don't get over that temperature you won't change the hardness any during grinding. Lost in the discussion is the fact that these steels are forgiving to sharpen. There is no risk of destroying their temper on a grinder.