New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Dovetails and drawer design

Posts

Dovetails and drawer design

#1

Dovetails and drawer design

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

In conversation with Bill Tindall we both felt that the post I made in an earlier thread ("Observations and Questions") is likely to get lost, and both of us find it an interesting topic. So I will ask the question again ..

Question: How many forum members routinely make London-style dovetails for drawers? And the corollary is, If you do, what strategy do you use to remove the waste from the slim tails?

In the background to these questions is the impression I get from some of the replies in this thread (and others) that there is a fundamental difference in the way that the "British/Australian" school go about designing and building drawers compared to the "American" school (if I may be that reductionistic about these groups). I posed a similar question on a UK forum and no one there used the term "London dovetail". The respondents however all considered that slim style of dovetail to be the norm (as examplified in the work of Alan Peters).

Link to an article I wrote on London dovetails: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/Londonhalf-blinddovetaileddrawer.html


Another area of design difference is the thickness of the boards used. Typically the British/Oz school will use 1/4" or maximum 3/8" thick side boards. As a result, it is not practical to hold the baseboard within a groove, and this gave rise to the use of slips. Bill raised this topic with me, and I raise it here, and I have no doubt that Bill will expand on his experiences further in this thread. In the meantime I offer a link to an article and pictorial I wrote, with references and highlights from previous thread at WC (with wonderful quotes of Richard Jones - are these in the archive on WC? They deserve to be!) ...

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/DrawerDesignandDrawerBottoms.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#2

Ooops! Freudian Slip?

Bill Tindall

" the post I made in an earlier threat "

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#3

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

David Weaver

I don't do that style of dovetails - there's always enough room (between the tails) for a chisel to release the cut in at the corners. Makes the pins easier to mark, too.

Waste is coped - always, because of fairly thick sides. Never did a drawer less than 1/2" thick sides. Have used fretsaws from time to time, but a coping saw blade is much stronger and I have one break only once in a blue moon (and usually when roughing out tool handles in something really hard). I think it's just as fast for me to cut straight down the tail and then make a second cut across with a coarse tooth coping saw as it is to use a fret saw to make one cut across, but that is probably due to thick drawer sides and carcases (but we are not talking about carcases, I guess).

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#5

LOL ... my eyes might be wrong but ...

roger lance

it seems you wrote "thread" with a "d" .... and wrote it with a "d" the three times you used the word .... I wonder what Dr. Freud would make of this ??

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#7

Since he was often photographed smoking one...

roger lance

it was a good thing for him to have written.

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#8

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

Bill Tindall

What I know about "English" drawers is gleaned from poking about in the two Antique shops here that specialized in English furniture. Astonishingly they import it by the shipping container full. English drawers have very thin quartered white oak sides, mahogany fronts, very skinny dovetails and slips, as judged from my sampling.

What I know about American drawers is gleaned from a similar process, plus visits to galleries and professional shops. I never miss a chance to inspect a drawer's construction. I suppose I may have a drawer fetish.

I have never seen a white oak side, a 1/4" thick side, or a drawer slip on an American made cabinet drawer. So, for sure, the traditional English drawer never gained popularity in this country in Period furniture. I would speculate that the wood used in this country-pine and poplar and regionally white cedar- had a lot to do with differences in drawer engineering details.

The features of Period furniture have largely carried over to furniture built today. There is a large contingent of Period furniture makers more or less faithfully reproducing Period furniture along with its traditional drawer construction- pine or poplar sides, modest sized dovetails, about 1/2" sides, panel bottom. Many more recent styles approximate these same drawer details.

I only see very skinny dovetails in studio furniture, often in a primary wood drawer side , and there it is a design statement of the maker, something that sets him or her apart from local tradition.

Personally, I don't consider dovetails something to flaunt, or a place to expend undo effort. They hold stuff together, are seldom seen and purposely hidden when I can hide them. A poor design, or a poorly executed design as seen from the outside, is not going to be rescued by a drawer dovetail. I judge drawers by how they work.

The picture shows a typical American Period drawer in a "country furniture" piece from New York State. Hardly flauntable, but it has held well for about 200 years of use. Sides are typical, about 1/2" poplar. Note over sawed cuts to speed up waste removal. In the 40 years I have owned this piece nobody has commented on the perfection or style of the dovetails, only on its design.

Note to beginning woodworkers My motto is: any successfully dovetailed drawer is better than the one not made for fear of it not looking perfect.

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#9

Re: Since he was often photographed smoking one...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I don't know, but would be suspect that it's straightforward hypocrisy. Freud didn't want his actions analyzed.

Pam

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#10

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

David Weaver

I agree with that - any is better than one assumed to not be perfect.

I only ever heard my parents say "dovetailed", never "dovetailed well" etc, and in our old furniture (all of it before 1900) as a kid, I don't think I ever looked.

I do remember a lot of the drawers being held together by small nails, and in some of the furniture they are dried out and probably 150 years old.

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#11

Maybe sometimes you just want...

roger lance

to enjoy smoking a cigar...or making a piece of furniture....without a lot of symbolism being attached to the act.

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#12

I wouldn't say that ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Freud was known - famous - for his self-analyses in his books. For his era his openness in self-examination was pretty amazing.

Regards from Perth

Derek (psychoanalytically trained)

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#13

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

Mark Salomon

I usually make my dovetail pins a bit wider than London pattern but still thinner than the typical American practice because the American pins tend to look like they were made by machine. For the same reason I usually don't use drawer slips (hence sides about 1/2in) but slips are a nice touch for fine work. I assume that you are asking how we clean the tails (not the pins like you said) for the thin pinned DTs? I have chisels that are small for chopping/cleaning at the baseline and I have a Blue Spruce marking gauge that is squared off and sharpened to clean the sides of even very narrow tails. Since this blade is thinner than my DT saw kerf I'm ok. I tried using various knives but it was difficult to control them because they had nothing to register against--the squared marking gauge fits the bill by laying against the tail. FWIW, Dave Jenske of Blue Spruce tools told me that he also uses a squared off marking gauge for cleaning up his narrow tails as well.

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#14

By the way, the amish...

David Weaver

... and mennonites and amish near home get their drawers custom made by a guy (another amishman) with a pneumatic dovetailer - one where you put the drawers in, step on the pedal, and the drawer side or front is dovetailed.

So if the amish aren't doing the dovetails by hand, then who is? In terms of affordable furniture intended to be purchased by the masses, I don't know of anyone.

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#15

You have to admit, the cigar line is a great line

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#16

Sure, but you only know that after analysis 

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#17

Re: I wouldn't say that ...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Maybe, but it sounds more like a line to cut off analysis by everybody else. That's how you meant it, right? :) :)

Pam

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#18

If I have to. 

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#19

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

Sgian Dubh

"I posed a similar question on a UK forum and no one there used the term "London dovetail"."

I am one of those Brits that doesn't recognise the "London Dovetail" nomenclature Derek, and I don't think I got involved in any thread you may have started in UKWorkshop, or wherever it was. The only place I seem to see these so called London Dovetails discussed is in American woodworking forums. Fine dovetails in drawers with slender sides and drawer slips just look like typical high quality drawers to me-- they are nearly always made that way in high grade work. Fat sides, chunky dovetails, and grooves worked in the fat sides are generally reckoned to be suitable for lesser work, eg, country furniture, mass produced items, kitchen drawers, tool cabinets, etc.

In my book, there are only four types of drawer dovetail, ie, fine, coarse, rough, and dogs breakfast, ha, ha.

Incidentally, the link in your opening message doesn't seem to work-- it may just be a temporary thing and not the coding-- I can't tell. Slainte.

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#20

Do you use any special dovetail chisels?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#21

quantitative description please

Bill Tindall

How thick is your ideal drawer side for a 7" high by 30" wide drawer, and what material will it be made from? (presume you are building a nice but not extravagant chest of drawers to go in a bed room to store clothes in). Do you vary side thickness depending on drawer size?

And: what will be the major and minor size of the pin hole in this drawer side?

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#22

Re: Do you use any special dovetail chisels?

Sgian Dubh

No Pam. My dovetail chisels are a bit of a mixed bag. They're mostly a black handled Stanley type-- I don't think the pattern was available in the US when I bought most of them. I have a Record or two with yellow/red shatterproof handles, although why shatterproof was identified as a good quality in a dovetail chisel I can't tell. Apart from that I have a wooden handled Kirby (I think) and a no-name 2 mm dovetail chisel. That's about it.

I don't generally get very excited by the tools of the trade, and just tend to make whatever tool I've got to hand do the job. I suppose my main exception to that are my planes where even there I've got a mixed bag of mostly nonentities, mostly Stanley or Record, a nice Spiers coffin smoother, and two examples of sad and near useless Norris planes, but I do like the odd Clifton I've got and my Lie-Nielsen block plane. I do also like a good saw, and enjoy using my Independence dovetail saw for cutting between tails and pins, and for other smaller rip cuts. Slainte.

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#23

Re: quantitative description please

Sgian Dubh

"How thick is your ideal drawer side for a 7" high by 30" wide drawer, and what material will it be made from? (presume you are building a nice but not extravagant chest of drawers to go in a bed room to store clothes in)."

Probably about 8- 10 mm (5/16- 3/8") thick Bill. I'm quite fond of pale woods for drawer sides, backs and slips, so hard maple or European sycamore are prime candidates. I don't generally like using poplar-- it always looks a bit 'muddy' and grey, although it is very forgiving if you want to whack out dovetails in a hurry. I'm not averse to using all sorts of wood types really, but I generally ten to avoid dark woods. I rarely use softwood for drawer sides and slips, and I don't think I've ever used a softwood for better quality work.

"Do you vary side thickness depending on drawer size?

Yes, as thin as about 4 mm (~5/32") for tiny drawers up to perhaps 12- 13 mm (1/2"+)for very large drawers carrying a heavy load. I always use 12- 13 mm thick stuff if I'm mounting drawers on metal slides, which is almost certainly irrelevant to your quesry. On a side note I almost always use 12 mm drawer sides if I'm attaching them to either undermount or side mount metal slides because the 15 mm (5/8") or 18 mm (3/4") thick material recommended by the slide suppliers looks a bit too thick, ungainly, and heavy for my taste.

"And: what will be the major and minor size of the pin hole in this drawer side?

For the narrow gap between the dovetails at the front end of the drawer side (the lap dovetails) I'd probably go for about a 3.5 to 4 mm space, and the gap at the root (shoulder line) a slightly sloppy 6 mm (or 1/4"), to suit whichever chisel is available. I generally use the most convenient chisel width as the guide to dovetail socket size: this is because I like to do the final paring to the shoulder line between the tails in one pass, and maybe just take a final little nip out at one corner because the chisel doesn't quite span all across the gap.

The through dovetails at the back are generally a little coarser, ie, wider gaps between the tails. I hope that all made sense. Slainte.

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#24

thank you and a comment

Bill Tindall

"I hope that all made sense. Slainte."

Yes indeed, and thank you.

One practical reason to use a softer wood for a drawer side is that the easily repaired drawer wears and not the potentially harder to repair runner and blade. I have seen some wicked grooves worn into mahogany blades by the white oak sides in English antiques.

PS...some shellac on poplar sides and they stay bright. Indeed unfinished poplar looks dead after some years. I have never seen anything but a softer wood used in even the highest quality American Period furniture. One oculd argue that if it was good enough for Goddard and Townsend then.........

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#25

Derek note.....

Bill Tindall

The dovetails described by Sgian are not atypical for American drawers. They are much larger than what I think you are describing as London Dovetails. Comment please......

Next time I am in an English antique shop I will do some measuring.