New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Dovetails and drawer design

Posts

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#26

British dovetailed drawers

Steve Elliott

My first awareness of the British style of drawer construction came twenty-some years ago when I saw a British piece in an antique store and was blown away by the fine craftsmanship of the drawers. I'd been a professional cabinetmaker for about ten years and knew the typical American style, but this was something altogether different and, to my mind, better. I bought the antique and it's within sight of where I'm sitting right now.

What I liked about the drawers was the thinner sides and the expertly cut dovetails. Close examination suggests they were cut quickly by someone who had a great deal of practice. There are a few slight overcuts and they don't look fussed over, but there are no gaps. The joints at the front have tiny single-kerf pins, the joints at the back have somewhat wider pins, presumably for strength. All of the parts are mahogany.

Those finely-crafted dovetails at the front were ebonized along with the outside of the piece so they clearly weren't intended for show. When I retire I hope to learn to make drawers like that.

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#27

questions

Bill Tindall

the sides were mahogany, which would be unusual? were the drawers built with slips? How old do you think the piece is?

The back of a drawer suffers little stress and it is a common feature in Period furniture for the back dovetails to be fewer to reflect this lesser requirement. Hence, we would have to speculate on some other reason the dovetails in your piece where larger in the rear. Maybe they were larger because they were fewer and therefore needed to be stronger.?.

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#28

Re: Do you use any special dovetail chisels?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Thanks, Richard, I've tended to do the same. Lately, while on the prowl to possibly make my dovetailing somewhat more efficient, I've tended to have custom Japanese chisels made to address particular issues. I'm talking two or three chisels here, not whole sets and the like.

But, please don't tell Derek. :)

Pam

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#30

Answers

Steve Elliott

The style is Edwardian, according to the furniture history books I looked through, so it's about 100 years old. There's a small medallion inside a top drawer with the name of the store that sold it, James Phillips in Bristol. I'll add a scan of the front and back dovetails. The drawer fronts are curved so a little of the drawer front with its inlaid stringing is visible in the scan. The corner at the back has been chamfered, which also shows in the scan.

It does use slips. The drawer bottom is held by a single screw at the back. I don't know why mahogany was used throughout--I didn't realize that was unusual until I read your posts.


Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#31

Re: Derek note.....

Sgian Dubh

Bill, I was responding with what I felt was an appropriate level of craftsmanship to your description "building a nice but not extravagant chest of drawers to go in a bed room to store clothes in". For something posh and on show a lot, eg, in a living room cabinet, maybe very fine front dovetails would be more appropriate-- maybe you'd call them these mysterious "London Dovetails" you Americans go on about, ha, ha, a term I don't think I've ever heard used in a workshop over here in the UK.

Incidentally, mahogany is a common wood for drawer box parts in British antiques and old furniture. It's easy to work for one, and soft, which fits in with your soft slips/sides and hard runners/kickers comment in another post. Slainte.

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#32

Re: Derek note.....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The dovetails described by Sgian are not atypical for American drawers. They are much larger than what I think you are describing as London Dovetails. Comment please......

Hi Bill

Richard's description is very different from a "London" style dovetail. For the type he is reporting there is no need for a special dovetail chisel - although I did take on board his little tip, which I thought was excellent. This was to "nip" the front shoulders. In other words, make them look good from the show side.

The one article on Richard's website that deals with drawer-making does not use chisels, but a powered router ... :) http://curve.phpwebhosting.com/~luka/articles/drawers/rjones1.html

Is this more typical of the dovetail method you use Richard (no criticism implied, just that production dovetails made by machine are different in every way from those made by saw and chisel)?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#33

Intriguing, in many ways

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The (bamboo?) tapered pins reinforcing the glued rabbet front joint, and the rear single dovetail, are interesting, and seem likely to be much more durable than straight dowels. He sure works fast.

And I like the special fancy pink glue brush used on the hide glue for the cock beading (the video you linked to within the body of your message). Looks remarkably like a toothbrush ;)

Is that urushi being applied to the finished case? Given that he's wearing gloves when applying it, I thought it might be.

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#34

Re: Derek note.....

Sgian Dubh

That's funny Derek, because I didn't know that wee article on drawer making from about ten years ago was still being hosted-- I had assumed the site was long gone!

However, you did say, "The one article on Richard's website that deals with drawer-making does not use chisels, but a powered router ... http://curve.phpwebhosting.com/~luka/articles/drawers/rjones1.html"

The reality is that chisels are used in that method of making dovetails. The saw defines the lines, the router hogs out most of the waste between the tails and pins, and chisels are used to clean out the corners where the router won't reach.

You asked if that's a typical or normal method of dovetailing for me, and the answer is that it is quite often, but it depends on the spaces between either the tails or pins being wide enough to let a router cutter in. It's a useful method of shifting waste for quite a wide range of dovetailing tasks from through dovetails, to lap dovetails, and all the way up to secret mitre or secret lap dovetails.

However, for just one or two sets of dovetails it's sometimes not worth the bother of doing the router set up because you can have the waste cleared out as quickly, or quicker, just by using chisels and mallets. Slainte.

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#35

Re: Intriguing, in many ways

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I don't know for sure whether they're bamboo, but I think not. You can get piles of those wood nails (trenails in western parlance), something like $5 for a bag of 20; but I'd rather take a cut at making my own with a pencil sharpener, or even whittled.

Yeah, love the toothbrush.

I think it may be urushi, same consistency as that shown in the latest Nat'l Geo PBS show on the buried Chinese warriors (a couple of cuts above NG's usual fare, as was the Chinese bridge show). It's weird stuff, this weird non-color is painted on, it dries in brilliant color. Better living through chemicals. :)

The three things I found most impressive in those two segments are: 1) the way he cuts the dovetails, would love to know if he starts with a saw; 2) the sort of reverse rebate plane that he uses to make the 45� mitre, much cooler than trying to hold the angle manually and chiseling cleanup; and 3) cutting drawer back dovetails with a marking/cutting gauge, so very, very cool.

Pam

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#36

Yes, all that, too

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#37

Re: Derek note.....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Richard

I do understand the use of a router to remove the waste from the pins. A friend of mine in Perth, Neil Erasmus, who makes high end furniture, does the same. All dovetails are sawn by hand, the waste removed from the tails with fretsaw and chisel (he used LN), but the waste for the pins is roughed out with a small Elu router and a 1/8 carbide bit. I have one in my shop I got from Neil, but have not yet used it.

This is a good opportunity to link to some of his work ... with a focus on dovetails:






Link to Neil's website: http://www.erasmusdesigns.com/

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Dovetails and drawer design

#38

Re: Derek note.....

Sgian Dubh

Derek, your friend is evidently a skilled and neat or 'clean' woodworker with a bit of a perfectionist's attention to detail. I have to admit I'm not the world's biggest fan of through dovetails showing at the front of a stack of drawers, although I admire those qualities of crafstmanship I listed in my first sentence. My reservations about that form of drawer construction is because those tight joints can have a bit of tendency to open up a bit over the years when the furniture is in service-- and that can spoil the look a bit. I can always open a standard drawer (one where the ends of the tails aren't on show through use of the lap dovetail) and admire the fineness of them that way.

I'm a typical furniture designer and maker-- I not only look at the overall form of a piece, its functionality, fitness for purpose, etc, but I also cast my nitpicking eye over the joinery; of course, this means I'll always open a drawer, if there is one, to have a closer squint, ha, ha. Slainte.