We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Spurred by the post on chisel handle 'finishes' I would like to question whether or not Wax is really a finish. Or is it just a surface treatment?
In order to be a finish as generally accepted is that it dries and forms some kind of film coating. With drying oil it will be a thin finish, with varnish or shellac it will be a film finish.
Wax does not dry and is a huge sticky molecule that can't penetrate wood. If it doesn't dry and it doesn't penetrate then it is not a finish. It is a surface treatment.
Many finishes don't dry, some are catalysed, others harden like epoxies. Not all finishes are films, they may be integral to the part. I think it may be difficult to find the precise definition that would be required and then to get agreeement over it.
Many sources refer to wax as a finish so common usage seems also to support wax as a finish. By "common" I mean industry as well as lay usage. Krenov refers to wax as a finish.
There are hard wax finishes like carnuba, that I would have though shared the finish term when used on products like candies.
How would you catagorize finishing materials that use wax in them, like the various lacquer and wax products?
If the suggestion is that wax is somehow ephemeral, I would refer to the fact I have wax finishes that seem to have been successfully in place for years and years. Wax can be extremely resistant to pressure and heat, outperforming grease in certain applications. Not really germaine to the question but it goes to show what a versatile material it is. Also while we use wax as a finish Bees use it as a structural material, not merely a surface treatment.
According to dictionary.com finish is something you apply to an article when your done with it. You can easily do a search for "finish" at dictionary.com and read all the definitions yourself.
Definition #17 noun;
the manner in which an object is perfected or finished in its preparation, or an effect imparted in finishing.
Under this definition wax could be defined as a finish, because it can be the final step applied to wood before you put it in the tool cabient and start using it. I think James Krenov also talks about using just wax as a finish on some of his pieces. I always understood wood "finish" to be the final step you apply to a project, whether that's polyurethane or grape wine.
I think you're right...there's got to be quite a bit of gas in the tank for the trip we're about to take.
I expect a full argument - one that someone else is going to have to do the heavy work for, because I'm satisfied to stay at the level where it doesn't matter what they're called to me, more a personal understanding of how they work for me.
If someone starts calling Beeswax "nitrocellulose" then that's a bit far off, but aside from that....i'm giving the apathy tapout.
Definition of terms does matter. In much of science, the majority of coming up with an answer is defining the question. That's why there are theoretical physicists who never conduct experiments: they're just trying to figure out what the questions are.
You say that a finish must (a) dry and (b) form a film. As I understand what's going on with linseed oil, then, it doesn't qualify as a finish either, because it doesn't dry; rather, it undergoes a chemical reaction with oxygen that is completed when it's stabilized and as close to solid as linseed oil can get.
Waxes form a very, very thin film that, once the solvent used to facilitate their application evaporates, are stable on the wood. Yes, they can be rubbed off. But so can varnish - it just takes more effort to rub it off.
But, under your definition (modifying "dry" to include "cured"), it seems to me wax is as much a finish as any number of other things we normally consider finishes.
To some degree, as with so many other things in life, you'll need to find a line to draw. There are darned few actual lines in much of life; we wind up having to make them up*. I don't think of Lemon Pledge as a finish, for instance. And I would rank mineral oil on cutting boards with Lemon Pledge - not a finish, but a treatment. But if you're going to put wax with "treatment," you need to decide why you're putting it there - I don't think your current definition excludes it.
Saying, for instance, that a finish needs to demonstrate a certain level of water exclusion would probably put wax on the "treatment" side - but how do you then know how effective some of the more water-transparent finishes are relative to wax? Same thing if you decide "durability" is a requirement for a finish; how do you determine that?
Bill, providing no help at all, but interested in watching where this one goes
*I had a course in systems theory that made this VERY obvious. When you study a system, one of the first things you have to do is decide where your boundaries are - because everything's interconnected. If you're studying Lee Valley as a system, do you include the companies that supply raw materials to the companies that make the products LV sells, and the pulp lumber growers that grow the trees that get turned into the paper for the boxes that LV ships their products in? They're integral to LV selling their products, but casting your net that wide could make it impossible ever to complete your study of the LV system. Reading this explanation over before hitting "post" makes it clear to me why so many of my friends find me tedious.
Those of us who are not, must enjoy other people who are, because we can navigate to any other page.
I often get asked "which scenario is most cost-effective" or "which scenario is cheapest".
My answer is usually, which measure are you using, which set of rules or regulations or if it's a cash basis, is there risk adjustment? If so, how is it applied? What is the goal of the question?
Often the first question, while someone is expecting a simple answer, leads to a volley of questions because it is very important to understand the basis.
In this case, however, I don't think arguing whether it's a finish or a surface treatment has any effect on the discussion, and that is the way I like to choose whether or not something matters in the context of a discussion. It doesn't make someone think of beeswax differently, at least I would hope nobody here does - this isn't exactly a group of people who haven't done more than put some wipe-on poly on a piece of furniture they found at a flea market.
I enjoy the tedium a lot.
I also enjoy teasing about being "propellerheads" when they get far into the tedium.
That makes me think I have a future that is either torturing myself or attempting to torture other people. That's not a very bright future!
...was the easy answer to "Best finish for wooden screws?", but I showed some restraint, uncharacteristically. But here you go, gettin' all philosphical-like about nomenclature, taxonomy, the naming of things, with that ineludible pulsing artery to poetics, invocation, magick. Yeats, Crowley, Cagliostro taunt me, egg me on. Moses slyly chums the water for a wax fight. It's all I can do to hold back. I'm going to the other side. It's safer there.
Many finishes don't dry, some are catalysed, others harden like epoxies. Not all finishes are films, they may be integral to the part. I think it may be difficult to find the precise definition that would be required and then to get agreement over it.
Well then we are going to be determining what 'dry' means. Dry, cure, harden or in other way become not undry.
Many sources refer to wax as a finish so common usage seems also to support wax as a finish. By "common" I mean industry as well as lay usage. Krenov refers to wax as a finish.
Common usage may very well say that, that being said it is in a separate category from other things that dry, catalyze, harden, etc.
There are hard wax finishes like carnauba, that I would have though shared the finish term when used on products like candies.
It is a great wax, very hard and durable and wax can be the only thing put on a piece as David mentions, but I don't think it qualifies.
How would you catagorize finishing materials that use wax in them, like the various lacquer and wax products?
Well the parts that are not wax may or may not dry but the wax doesn't and will eventually wear away.
If the suggestion is that wax is somehow ephemeral, I would refer to the fact I have wax finishes that seem to have been successfully in place for years and years. Wax can be extremely resistant to pressure and heat, outperforming grease in certain applications. Not really germaine to the question but it goes to show what a versatile material it is. Also while we use wax as a finish Bees use it as a structural material, not merely a surface treatment.
I am not saying that it can't persist, there are archaic examples of beeswax used for many applications. And it is great for polishing and protecting objects, but it is not a permanent finish.
According to dictionary.com finish is something you apply to an article when your done with it. You can easily do a search for "finish" at dictionary.com and read all the definitions yourself.
I have read definitions in a number of dictionary and other sources and the descriptions vary dramatically.
Definition #17 noun;
the manner in which an object is perfected or finished in its preparation, or an effect imparted in finishing.
Under this definition wax could be defined as a finish, because it can be the final step applied to wood before you put it in the tool cabient and start using it. I think James Krenov also talks about using just wax as a finish on some of his pieces. I always understood wood "finish" to be the final step you apply to a project, whether that's polyurethane or grape wine.
If the last thing you did to the wood was sweat or bleed on it, then under varied definitions the piece would be finished. I am thinking of what would more commonly be considered a real finish.
Take your favorite large bowl briar pipe and fill it with a good charge of latakia and tamp it down. Now take a pine match stick with phosphorus/sulfur on the end and the wood impregnated with paraffin wax, strike it and let the chemicals cook away and and then carefully and gently light the tobacco in that pipe and puff and puff.
Smoke the entire bowl and tell me how much carnauba wax melts.
But what about the Nose Oil, that is another post.
Definition of terms does matter. In much of science, the majority of coming up with an answer is defining the question. That's why there are theoretical physicists who never conduct experiments: they're just trying to figure out what the questions are.
You say that a finish must (a) dry and (b) form a film. As I understand what's going on with linseed oil, then, it doesn't qualify as a finish either, because it doesn't dry; rather, it undergoes a chemical reaction with oxygen that is completed when it's stabilized and as close to solid as linseed oil can get.
Similar to glass, it is a semi liquid in that it slumps over time, so it can't qualify as a solid until a rock goes through it. Given enough time linseed oil will eventually dry, but most people consider it dry after a day or two.
Waxes form a very, very thin film that, once the solvent used to facilitate their application evaporates, are stable on the wood. Yes, they can be rubbed off. But so can varnish - it just takes more effort to rub it off.
I would not put varnish and wax in the same category. You could put a sheet of metal over wood and given enough abrasion wear through.
But, under your definition (modifying "dry" to include "cured"), it seems to me wax is as much a finish as any number of other things we normally consider finishes.
Wax neither dries nor cures.
To some degree, as with so many other things in life, you'll need to find a line to draw. There are darned few actual lines in much of life; we wind up having to make them up*. I don't think of Lemon Pledge as a finish, for instance. And I would rank mineral oil on cutting boards with Lemon Pledge - not a finish, but a treatment. But if you're going to put wax with "treatment," you need to decide why you're putting it there - I don't think your current definition excludes it.
Saying, for instance, that a finish needs to demonstrate a certain level of water exclusion would probably put wax on the "treatment" side - but how do you then know how effective some of the more water-transparent finishes are relative to wax? Same thing if you decide "durability" is a requirement for a finish; how do you determine that?
There are many things that come into consideration when determining what finish I want to put on a particular piece. I choose a finish to highlight carvings and the finish needs to be brilliant and doesn't need to be terribly durable. But a varnish for a floor needs that characteristic of durability. And a varnish on leather or cloth it needs to be flexible. So there are a lot of things to consider for a finish.
If I want to protect a surface from water and or give it a nice shine, I use wax, I just do not consider it a finish.
Bill, providing no help at all, but interested in watching where this one goes
...that the carnauba freely flows, I'm smoking the wrong tobacco in the wrong pipe in the wrong manner.
Seriously, I do have a pipe where the bowl does get quite hot, although the smoke stays cool. This little 1934 Dunhill Amber Root Liverpool 2x is a gem. Most of my other pipes, Dunhills, Ashtons, and so on, many of them vintage, the wax gently warms and eventually rubs off (over several smokings) on the hand. Most of my pipes are thicker walled, of course.
No problem. Back to the buffing wheel if I really want that gloss, which I rarely do.
George Bernard Shaw once found himself at a dinner party, seated beside an attractive woman. "Madam," he asked, "would you go to bed with me for a thousand pounds?" The woman blushed and rather indignantly shook her head.
"For ten thousand pounds?" he asked. "No. I would not." "Then how about fifty thousand pounds?" he contined.
The colossal sum gave the woman pause, and after further reflection, she coyly replied: "Perhaps." "And if I were to offer you five pounds?" Shaw asked.
"Mr. Shaw!" the woman exclaimed. "What do you take me for!" "We have already established what you are," Shaw calmly replied. "Now we are merely haggling over the price."
Apocryphal, perhaps, but the point is not lost on you. We're not arguing over whether wax is good finish, nor even an adequate finish, nor a finish appropriate to one sort of wooden object over another, but simply whether or not it is a finish at all, which I say it is.
As for nose oil, it's a thoroughly accepted and acceptable briar finish. In fact, under the carnauba on every Ashton pipe, and even throughout the briar, a combination of three oils has been convected through the bowl by heated plugs and baths, carrying away bitter and harsh resins. A similar process once graced Dunhills and at least two other English smoking pipes of earlier vintage.
Of course, other oils besides huile de nez have been used to good effect, and I myself have favored the matte effect on more than one pipe of my own design and carving. In fact, I'm enjoying a bowl of Esoterica Tobacciana's Penzance in a oil-cured, oil-finished freehand original Vautrin le Mal Dublin of my own creation.
You didn't say whether Cypriot or Syrian latakia, Stephen, but I'm saving the rest of my Balkan Sobranie for special occasions.
This is an interesting topic and it seems like before we can come up with an answer for "is wax a finish" we need to address what exactly a finish is.
Few would argue that BLO is not a finish, so let�s start here. Now what about paint, surface treatment or finish? let�s go back to that BLO and add some whiting and some pigment and now it becomes paint, but it is still penetrating the same as before and it is protecting even better than before in exterior applications.
In terms of protection and permanence as qualifiers for a finish I can think of nothing that performs better than urushi. Our modern lacquers all share their origins as an attempt to mimic the look and performance or urushi with a simplified and safer application. Lacquer is generally lumped in with all the other film finishes for wood and very little distinction is made about it being a finish or a paint regardless of whether it is clear or tinted. To the Japanese the urushi artist is held in higher estem than the craftsman that made the article decorated by the usushi artist. With some of the decorative techniques of urushi precious metals are used in the finish to mimic the look of chased and inlaid metal techniques. In this sence I would have to say that urushi is both a finish and a surface treatment.
Now to muddle things up a bit. Some of the best preserved and oldest paintings are encaustic, basically bees wax with a small percentage of dammar resin and some pigment. Not sure I would choose it as a finish for a chair but it is hard to deny that encaustic as a finish will protect and it is durable in the since that it will hold up to time even if it won't hold up to abrasion.
So back to 'what is a finish' and I think part of that definition has to include what you want in terms of function specific to your exact application at hand; Then keeping the door ajar to allow some things to be finishes, but not be suitable to your application at hand.
In oil painting it is common to varnish a painting as the last step. The varnish does serve an aesthetic function to even out the gloss and add depth but its real function is to serve as a protective layer that can be removed after many years of darkening by oxidation and degradation and replaced with fresh varnish to restore the painting to its original color and luminosity. It is my feeling that wax can best be used in this same role as a wood finish. To be a sacrificial barrier to oxidation degrade of the oil/varnish/lacquer/paint.
So is wax a finish? I suppose if it functions in the same way as varnish on an oil painting I would have to advocate for wax being classified as a finish.
"Similar to glass, it is a semi liquid in that it slumps over time, so it can't qualify as a solid until a rock goes through it. Given enough time linseed oil will eventually dry, but most people consider it dry after a day or two."
Firstly, let me disabuse you of this notion that glass flows in the manner you ascribe to it, at less than slumping temperatures, that is.
Glass as either a semi-liquid (at normal temperatures) or a super-cooled liquid is no longer scientifically accepted. Amorphous, yes. Liguid below slumping, melting or batching temperatures, no.
"Examples of Roman glassware and calculations based on measurements of glass visco-properties indicate that these claims cannot be true. The observed features are more easily explained as a result of the imperfect methods used to make glass window panes before the float glass process was invented."
Beyond the glass thing, at what point is wax no longer a wax should be asked, as well. For example, I paint in encaustic and use encaustic as a finish on wood, paper, parchment/leather and other materials. The encaustic base and coatings I make incorporate varying percentages of damar resin with the beeswax, and sometimes with other waxes and resins, too. This significantly raises the softening temperature and characteristic of the beeswax, making it harder and more durable, more resistant to heat. It must be applied with heat, not solvents nor friction through rubbing. I use heat guns, melting pots, hot wire filament brushes, hot palettes and irons. Now considering that well over 80% of the mixture is beeswax, it's hard not to think of it as wax or call it wax.
Now I don't apply this wax through rubbing, not where the waxy molecules are being drawn out, stretched and thinned in the usual manner. I'm coating, spreading, sometimes scraping, ironing, smoothing, melting and flowing the wax over the substrate. When the wax cools, I may buff it to a higher gloss, but that's it. Is it a finish? I say it is.
The Yerkes observatory is the largest refractory telescope ever built. They could not build them any larger because even this one the glass lens does distort from gravity in real time. The research on glass goes on.
"They could not build them any larger because even this one the glass lens does distort from gravity in real time. The research on glass goes on."
Ah... but while the Yerkes glass does distort, bends, even sags, it does not, however flow -- not as a liquid. I really don't think the research "goes on" any longer on this issue. Maybe ten years or so back there were still a few holdouts, but I think it's generally understood now. They no longer claim this on the Yerkes tour, do they?
From the Corning research articles:
Glass Is a Liquid, and Naturally Flows, Right?
It is easy to understand why the myth persists. It does have a certain appeal. Glass and the glassy state are often described by noting their similarities with liquids. So good teachers, such as Mr. Hoke was, like to quote the story about the windows. As is the case with liquids, the atoms making up a glass are not arranged in any regular order�and that is where the analogy arises. Liquids flow because there are no strong forces holding their molecules together. Their molecules can move freely past one another, so that liquids can be poured, splashed around, and spilled. But, unlike the molecules in conventional liquids, the atoms in glasses are all held together tightly by strong chemical bonds. It is as if the glass were one giant molecule. This makes glasses rigid so they cannot flow at room temperatures. Thus, the analogy fails in the case of fluidity and flow.
I will say, this doesn't concern me too much, not when I'm actually making glass from scratch, or batching. I'm just glad to get sand hot enough to melt and flow.
How can the general public just come up with definitions for words with no authority to confirm them? If we define a finish, don't we need a dictionary or something as a resource to back our definition? Kind of like the general publics use of the word "seen" as the past tense of "see". You can say "I seen my friend yesterday" 100 times in a row fast and it still won't be proper english. We can define terms all we want to, doesn't mean we are correct.