New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Is Wax a Finish?

Posts

Re: Is Wax a Finish?

#26

David Barnett

Terms & their Definitions...

David Barnett

...Definitions & their Terms.

Moses, you're right. One does well to find established definitions and there are plenty from which to choose, and yes, those definitions of what a wood finish is and standards for what wood finishes can or should be, from architectural to interior trades, conservational, historical, and so on, will vary. There are specification guides such as the Code of Federal Regulations of the United States of America for nearly every type, style, period and of architecture and architectural details. There are specifications for conservators and restoration specialists, for national collections, auction houses, involved professional organizations and associations, and specifications for individual museums.

Without going too deeply into it, one definition that recurs is that a 'finish' can be considered as that which is applied to wood to either protect and/or to visually enhance, but need not be so. That is, it need not protect to be considered a finish. In fact, a wood's finish needn't refer to any enhancement at all but to the actual condition of the wood, such as it's patina through use, weathering, oxidation and so on -- its condition, so to speak. In that sense, all wood has a finish.

Okay, I know that's not what we mean by a wood finish. What we mean is whatever you put on wood after you've made something from it -- nothing more, nothing less. If you read about furniture from antiquity through the middle ages, you'll often see that wax was used. No one's trying to convince anyone that wax was a great finish, not even a good finish, but it was used. They put it on wood. Presumably for a reason. And remember, these were not solvent-based evaporative wax finishes, mind you, but were often dry-rubbed or applied with heat. That takes intention and effort.

I like the look of dry-rubbed wax. It looks different than evaporative paste waxes. But I'm having a hard time imagining why anyone would go to the effort unless they thought it would (perhaps mistakenly) protect or beautify. And either of those purposes would, to me, constitute a wood finish.

Standards vary throughout the world. The Brit and the Museum of Egyptian Antiquities (Cairo) consider wax a finish, and I suppose that's good enough for me.

Writers of woodworking articles on finishing, not too surprisingly, describe and consider finishes to protect and beautify. Those more concerned with historical conservation and restoration have other concerns, not the least of which is authenticity.

One very famous wood finisher, George Frank, considered wax a finish, and preferred dry-rubbed wax and water-emulsive waxes to solvent evaporative waxes. I moved back to Florida to the town where he retired, too late, unfortunately, to make his acquaintance, but gleaned much from his local legacy. His European perspective on finishing included wax, not only as a final protectorant-beautifier, but as a standalone finish -- in rare instances, to be sure, but a finish nevertheless.

So while there may be a truly broad range of definitions, if there are experts, organizations, governments, and institutions that accept that wax is a finish -- not the best finish, not necessarily a good finish, nor even an acceptable finish -- but a finish, then it's a finish. Even if it's a bad finish, it's still a finish.

If you're going to define a wood finish as that which protects, and to a specific standard of protection, then I suppose you can run it up the flagpole and see who salutes it. Is mineral oil a finish? Is tung oil a finish? I have to puzzle, why does someone needs wax not to be a finish? Why go to the trouble?

Let's say wax is instead a surface treatment. Can't varnish be a surface treatment, too?

It all starts to get a little tortuous and more than a little silly when you purpose to exclude wax as a finish, per se.

Let me put it this way:

Is wax a durable finish?

No, wax is a non-durable finish.



Is wax a penetrating finish?



No, wax is a non-penetrating finish.



Is wax a cross-linking polymerizing oxidative finish?



No, wax is a non-cross-linking non-polymerizing non-oxidative finish.


____________________________________

"Sir, you in the ditch. Yes, you with the shovel. The ditch digger. Could I have a word with you?"

"Sure, but I'm not a ditch digger. I'm a brain surgeon."

"Then why the hell are you digging that ditch?"

"Well... I'm not a very good brain surgeon."

See what I mean?