We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Siegel of California leathers has closed its doors
David Barnett
I received an email from Steven at Siegel of California, in the leather business for 84 years. They closed their doors for good as of yesterday, not in small part owing to Steven's recent hospitalization. Hope everyone got all the horse butts they'll ever need, because Siegel's was just about the last source in the US of A. They also were the last supplier that brought in the premium artisan leathers such as the small lot English tanneries oak and peat leathers, Italian sumac-tanned calf, and so on. They will be missed.
Re: Siegel of California leathers has closed its doors
Re: Siegel of California leathers has closed its d
David Weaver
Unfortunate that anyone is closing. I've never used horse butt, is it really that better than hard veggie tanned scraps an eighth or so thick that are really cheap otherwise?
I got about 3 square feet of veggie tanned 1/8th thick leather several years ago on ebay for $20, it's pretty hard and it has made great strops.
I'm sure what's on ebay rotates, but there's another seller on there (who i have never bought from) selling 10 square feet of scrap leather that looks by weight like it would be in the 1/8-3/16th thickness range for $21.
When it's that cheap, you can put it on anything - on a disc sander, etc, and make good use of it and not feel like you have to treat it like gold.
Re: Siegel of California leathers has closed its doors
Re: Siegel of California leathers has closed its d
TomD
Is that the place that provided all the leather for fine shoe and boot makers. I was on this shoe forum at one point and they were all confessing that half the comfort their clients attributed to them came from the soling leather that their supplier had. It can not be replaced by ebay vegi tan. There is a UK source, and a Manitoba supplier that also seems to be good. Part of the secret is the tanning, but another lost part is the way cattle are fattened and therefor what the hides that reach the tannery are like.
Re: Siegel of California leathers has closed its doors
"Is that the place that provided all the leather for fine shoe and boot makers. I was on this shoe forum at one point and they were all confessing that half the comfort their clients attributed to them came from the soling leather that their supplier had."
A lot of it, and affordable book leathers, as well. If you're speaking about The Crispin Colloquy, the terrific forum of The Honourable Cordwainers' Company for artisan cordwainers and bootmakers, Siegel was one of several ever-dwindling sources, yes.
"There is a UK source, and a Manitoba supplier that also seems to be good."
The UK source is the absolute best and only source for the thick insole leather used in the finest bespoke men's shoes. I have a huge side of this I haven't yet cut into that I got years back in a the forum group buy. The soles I have came from another group buy from a german source.
And you're absolutely right about the comfort. The deep-pit oak tans of Northamptonshire make the most comfortable insoles ever. There is no equivalent, no comparison. The fats are right and they breathe. Boy do they breathe. It's a huge difference. Throughout initial wearing, the insoles conform intimately to the contours and pressure points of the foot. As one whoppin' oversized diabetic, this is truly important to me, which is why I took up the craft years back.
As a previous binder and book arts worker, I've watched the smaller artisanal producers go the way of the dinosaur. Too bad.
"I've never used horse butt, is it really that better than hard veggie tanned scraps an eighth or so thick that are really cheap otherwise?"
Yes.
"When it's that cheap, you can put it on anything - on a disc sander, etc, and make good use of it and not feel like you have to treat it like gold."
Veg tanned whatever leather is excellent for belts, discs and wheels. I use it for gem polishing on rotating horizontal discs. As a substrate for polishing stone, ivory, metals with abrasive pastes and rouges, it's fine. I've made belts for my 1x42" sander that work beautifully for stropping and polishing blades, hammer heads, punches, stakes, and so on. And you've already discovered "it has made great strops."
But you asked if horse butt's "really better than hard veggie tanned scraps", and I'm tellin' you it damned sure is! Price just went way up, too! Seriously, it's not just lore, myth, or superstition. A luxury? Perhaps, but I'm not reverting. Try one of Joel's. It's the same leather as mine.
As for gold, it never was all that expensive, really -- just hard to come by.
Aha! That is dated today! I just got that one. Well, I'm just grateful they'll still be here in one form or other. Damn, it all seemed so abrupt. Thanks, Bob.
I'm blushing with embarrasment for jumping the gun. Head to toe. Imagine the Mary Kay blimp. Or maybe not. Too late.
Re: Siegel of California leathers has closed its doors
I few years ago when the Saltz tannery in Napa closed up shop there was a bit of a vacume in high quality latigo. Siegal eventually found a nice substitute that was nearly as good. I have a half hide of it in 10 oz but they had been out of the 2-3oz the last few times I stopped by.
Seems like there are a few here who are very knowlegable about leather. The last order I got from Siegal included some chestunt tanned french bridal leather. It was recomended to me for its consistency and its tendency not to stretch. I also liked that it was pretty afordabe. anyone use it beforre and do you know of a good source?
Since I am asking for recoendations on suppliers does anyone have a good source for kangaroo hides. Last time I stoped in at Siegel all he had was a white roo hide and some off the wall metalic thing. I prefer wattle taned drum stuffed but will entertain other options.
Robin
Re: Siegel of California leathers has closed its doors
Question I have, though, is if it is a lot harder than veggie tanned leather, but presumably softer than MDF, where would you put it between, and why not just use a strip of MDF?
I have used MDF before with good effect. It's a nice substrate (with a tiny bit of mineral oil slicked on the surface) for the LV green stuff.
I do kind of like the laziness of the leather belt, too. No matter how much camber, the iron gets sharp lazily fast. Maybe not so appropriate when perfect geometry is paramount, but for the coarse cutting planes that do the work with the dirty outside surface of the wood, it's great.
Re: Siegel of California leathers has closed its doors
... it seems like less a hardness than a texture issue.
"Question I have, though, is if it is a lot harder than veggie tanned leather, but presumably softer than MDF, where would you put it between, and why not just use a strip of MDF?"
To me, the horse butt exerts a strong, consistent, smooth, almost velvety pull (or draw, as they say in the straight razor community), unlike maple, MDF, and other leathers. On most other substrates, the stropping compound does most of the work, while leather, and especially horse, makes a pretty good strop with no compound at all. In my experience, ease of use and the edge from the horse butt strop is superior to MDF -- one pull to restrop an English skiving parer, several on MDF.
Green crayon compound on MDF, maple, cardboard, chrome green paint on Masonite -- all make fair strops, but with low to minimal draw. The truly dry compounds, though, such as Dunkel's Yellowstone, cerium oxide, tin oxide, whatever, excel on horse booty.
Consider, too, that horsehide shell has long been the cr�me de la cr�me for razor strops. Since the 1970s I've used a shell bench strop mounted to a block of mahogany, that came from a retiring barber. It's still going strong. Hard to believe there could be anything better.
"The other type of horsehide strop is called shell or Russian shell. This is a high quality strop taken from the rump area of the horse. Although it is quite expensive, it makes one of the best possible strops for professional use. It always remains smooth and requires very little, if any, breaking in."
Paraphrased from the Standard Textbook of Professional Barber-Styling, Classic Shaving - The Refined Edge.
"I do kind of like the laziness of the leather belt, too. No matter how much camber, the iron gets sharp lazily fast."
OK...i'm converted, even if it's just verbally....I will say (on public trans tonight)..
"I want to know what it's like to feel the feel of horse butt!!!!"
I get what you're saying about the pull. I have a nice razor hone, I just use it, and pretty much never thought about it. It wasn't terribly expensive, but not cheap - maybe like $50 or something.
Re: Siegel of California leathers has closed its doors