CPM 3V for bits?
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
Bill, et al, do you recommend using CPM 3V for making tools like shell or spoon bits? And, if so, how would you scoop out the recesses?
Also, how about for molding plane blades?
Thanks,
Pam
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
CPM 3V for bits?
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
Bill, et al, do you recommend using CPM 3V for making tools like shell or spoon bits? And, if so, how would you scoop out the recesses?
Also, how about for molding plane blades?
Thanks,
Pam
I'll take a stab at this
Steve Elliott
For cutting tools with edges that are not straight or cambered, I think 3V might not be worth the difficulties it would cause when sharpening. There are slipstones and other contoured abrasives that are intended for carbon steel, but relatively few diamond hones in those shapes, as far as I'm aware.
I know Bill Tindall has mentioned using a diamond-loaded cylinder mounted in a drill press for sharpening carving tools (I think it was) and I'm sure anyone with an inventive mind could develop methods to cope with almost any shape. But in general I'd say exotic alloys are better suited to plane blades and chisels which can be ground and honed using readily available equipment.
This evening I finished flattening the back of a 3V plane blade using a 5 x 24� plate of Blanchard ground cast iron and 60 micron diamond paste. The blade was slightly twisted and I had to remove a significant amount of hardened 3V, but the diamond worked well�much faster than the very coarse waterstone I�d used in the past.
lets us step back to begin an answer
Bill Tindall
To begin, what are the exceptional properties of 3V? The main advantage of 3 V is toughness. It is one of the few tool steels that can survive bending at full hardness. It is unlikely that a tool made from 3V will ever break. Also, it is exceptionally easy to work in its annealed state, more so than O1. Disadvantages are that it costs more than something like O1 and it must be heat treated by an experienced heat treatment facility (which are not hard to find). It has good, but not exceptional, abrasion resistance which can be an advantage if the tool to be made will get dull by abrasion, or a disadvantage when it comes time to sharpen it.
This steel was first selected by us to make mortise chisels. One can not imagine a better steel for home made mortise chisels- tough and easy for a woodworker to fabricate. While we were at it we made some bench chisels. Its properties make a lot of sense for a bench chisel, certainly more so than A2 which lacks sufficient toughness. Indeed its properties are well suited for home made bench chisels. While we were at it we made some lathe tools. The toughness of its burr and good wear resistance makes it exceptional for scrapers but it made nice skews too, especially pointy ones that would break in M2. For plane irons it has a bit better wear than the best commercial irons, but I don't find the advantage compelling. It is worlds better wear resistance than vintage Stanley irons, which are vastly easier to sharpen.
To decide whether it is "best for you" consider its inherent properties, plus, cost, availability in the sizes you want, how(who) it is going to be fabricated, and how it will be sharpened. Different people in different situations will come to different conclusions as to their preferred metal.
I agree on all points
Bill Tindall
PS
Bill Tindall
The utility of all these steels strongly depends on the details of the heat treatment, especially so for chisels. Toughness and rigidity are a trade-off. It is not well understood by many that abrasion resistance mostly depends on alloy composition.
Re: CPM 3V for bits?
TomD
Probably the easiest way to cut the hollow would be with a core bit in a mill with the head canted. Or with a detail wheel in a belt grinder. There are a lot of other ways to do it, but that would probably be the most likely method, with cost and likelyhood to find the tools. Like I have both those tools, though I don't have a core bit in any diameters at this point. I guess an end mill might do it. Another option would be a shaper, which is always cheap on tooling, but one would need a relief in the metal which would mean that the hollow would not be full length. With a steady hand a die grinder type tool would do it. I have Fred Emhof tools and they hold up pretty well without being super steel. But if the stuff is easy to work, I wonder if he would consider CPM.
Re: CPM 3V for bits?
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
I was thinking of small scrapers/sen, or maybe a quirk router type tool; but geesh, where would I find those. I have neither the money nor inclination, to say nothing of the space, to obtain milling machines. Maybe this whole project is beyond my depth.
The problem is I want some shell bits (see Follensbee's photos of the holes made with each bit type in Derek's thread on drawboring), and they don't seem to be available. I've searching the UK, so maybe I'll get lucky.
Thanks,
Pam
Re: I'll take a stab at this
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
I think shell bits are fairly regular, tapered toward the point. I'd thought that worst case I could do the old "stick the chisel in some mdf, add paste, sharpen by moving the blade in and out" trick. Guess that's totally inappropriate and naive.
Thanks,
Pam
Re: PS
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
Thanks, Bill. What do I want from 3V? First, I don't want to forge anything and really like it that a hacksaw can cut 3V to basic shapes. Also, bits are relatively fragile tools, so the strength of 3V appeals. As to heat treating, I'd send them out, of course.
What I don't know is how I'd scoop out the hollows.
Also, I want to make a bunch of molding planes, not just hollows and rounds, but also snipe bills; and it would be very nice to make custom type molding planes. All this is in the future, but not too far away. Again, the tops of these blades are fairly fragile. But these are readily available, at a cost.
I think the expense of 3V is so far below the cost of buying that it's not an issue.
Pam
Re: PS
TomD
I can probably make anything you want plane blade wise, and probably some of those other things. Unlike the US there aren't many heat treaters. I mean obviously there is all kinds of stuff in support of our industrial, base, but not anything terribly easy to get to for the oddball stuff at my level. Knifemakers have someone they use, but I know only too well that one needs these people pre-qualified for the exact task at hand. But if you have stock you need ground out, you can send it to me. Personally unless you have some really nasty use in mind I would get the Umhoff bits they work great out of the box, and while I pretty much expect to be able to make anything, that is one thing that is quite subtle and some pretty major makers have not measured up. Also, if you want the square ends, that is another thing that would be a major task in a one-off setting. Sen, as long as I know the pattern you want, I could probably do. But you would have to send it out for heat treating.
I guess the only other thing I would have to know is how well this stuff cuts under a bandsaw. My metal band saw is pretty rinky dink, but cutting O1 is no problem.
You might try some local knifemakers, if you don't want all the posting hassles. Texas has a strong contingent.
How spooned does a spoon bit need to be? *LINK*
David Barnett
Pipemakers use what they call spoon bits to bore the tobacco chambers in pipe stummels, however, their spoon bits have no concavity and no one seems to miss it whatsoever.
Why is the concave channel necessary? I've made bits that can horizontally bore into handheld briar using a lathe to spin the bit. This is fairly common practice among pipemakers and many make these bits themselves. What am I missing?
Straight bits (first picture)
http://www.downiepipes.com/tools.html
Tapered spoon bits for tobacco chambers
caution to fabricators
Bill Tindall
Some of the tools steels will spontaneously harden if they get hot during fabrication. For example 3V can be readily cut with a hack saw, about like cold rolled steel. I tried speeding up the operation with a saber saw with metal cutting blade. All went well until I increased the feed rate. The blade suddenly stopped cutting. It had no teeth left attached.
Re: How spooned does a spoon bit need to be?
TomD
Great, yet another name.
Those are often called D bits, C bits, U bits. And in this case spoon bits which ads to the confusion by using a name in common use elsewhere. Those bits, are least in cylindrical form are similar to gun drilling bits. In a locked in set-up like a lathe they are the straightest drilling bits around, and simple to make. Sometimes something like your pipe bits is used for one off chamber reamers for guns. The basic typical formula is something like the cut away level is 1 thou above CL per 100 thou of diameter. The cutting edge is offcenter with the cutting edge bluntish in normal metal cutting relief geometry. the long edge is heavily undercut. At least that kind of bit is not something one can start freehand, it would whirl offcenter. Don't know if that is true with the spoon/dbits.
Spoon bits are cut back such that when they are started, the point has to be offset from the center point, and the initial cutting will create a circle around the centerpoint, but less than full diameter, by maybe 25%, haven't measured it. The cutting action is such that the leading edge comes around and undercuts the the circle, such the a corkscrew like shaving forms above the burring point. There are at least three advantages to the spoon bit: 1) it can be adjusted in angle after the initial penetration, and steered onto line; 2) the hole bottom isn't overshot by a point, except that the bottom isn't full diameter; 3) the hole can be undercut if that is desired.
The point hollow is bowl like in that it is deeper as one retreats from the point. This compound curvature is what allows the point to cut the rising shaving. There is a relief angle from the leading to trailing edge. So the leading edge is slightly larger diameter than the trailing edge.
Re: PS
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
Thanks, Tom (why did you change from Thom?). I may take you up on that if you can handle the 3V. I think I'll go local if I have to commission the bits in O1; but I'd just as soon not, since I've been getting ready to do 3V for a few months now, bought a hack saw and all the sharpening stuff needed, including particulate masks.
What does cut 3V besides diamonds?
Pam
Re: How spooned does a spoon bit need to be?
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
I doubt I could cut with those by hand, but they sure look good. I already bought a set of spoon bits from LV, would buy the shell bits, too, but alas, they're not there. But your point that maybe I don't need to hollow out the bits is an interesting one. Perhaps I could just hollow as far as a grinder would allow?
Pam
Re: PS
TomD
I changed because I accidentally finally created the identity they want one to have, but as a result didn't know what the password was. Kind too bad since it would have been a help. Not sure how that happened, and no, I don't drink. So I had to recreate the identity. And I am pretty much tapped out on additional semi-used email addresses, so I had to change the name. Incidentally, I go by Thomas, though recently I have been considering Tom, since it may be that Thomas ticks people off. That is what I see in their expressions. So I have so far been willing to drop the h in my online ID. 
Since we are getting up to date... What is happening with your woodworking. I hear you talking about all kinds of new tools, non-Japanese, what are you about making?
Re: caution to fabricators
TomD
That is what happens when your saw doesn't "go to 11". If you could have upped the speed you would have friction cut it like butter. I have a plasma and if I cut O1 it will be too hard to grind. No half measures.
Re: PS
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
I see, people must think you're being uppity masquerading as a Thomas. 
Projects are coming at me. I finally decided how I want to redo the kitchen, which requires adding a utility room, which is sort of too small a project, so may as well redo the shop to satisfy the zoners, all of which, when done, will require new dining room chairs, a new bed, new bath, and on and on. Still working on a guitar, and I can see a future that will require molding planes, and shell bits might be real nice.
Pam
Re: How spooned does a spoon bit need to be?
TomD
Unless David can assure you that the briar can be put in a vice and the bit spun freehand, then I am of the view it isn't going to work. With a lathe you can bore the best holes imaginable with just a tiny spec of toolsteel in space.
Spoonbits are the kind of thing where you can make something that really looks like a spoonbit, and it still won't cut, let alone making something that doesn't. Hey, but I am here to learn.
http://www.windsorchairresources.com/emhof.html
Those are the bits actually worth having, that actually work. I have tried quite a few commercial ones and the only ones worth having are the Emhof and where tapers are concerned, the John Alexander reamer, or metal working reamers. I have never found antique spoonbits. What is everyone else finding?
Freehanding the wily spoon bit
David Barnett
"Unless David can assure you that the briar can be put in a vice and the bit spun freehand, then I am of the view it isn't going to work."
You can only imagine how I'd like to try and convince you, but it'd involve a rope, a basket, someone to spin it, and a really talented grip. Or did you, by freehand, mean in a brace?
"Spoonbits are the kind of thing where you can make something that really looks like a spoonbit, and it still won't cut, let alone making something that doesn't. Hey, but I am here to learn."
I can attest to Thom-Tom's insight and acumen. While the most-suitable (for pipes) well-seasoned plateaux briar favors brittle and small chips, even so, pipemakers regard these bits as turning tools for the lathe rather than hand bores. While it arguably (and tentatively) can be done, it neither augurs nor augers well.
It requires a starting divot (no problem) but largely lacks the guidance advantages of the lathe used as a horizontal borer. By hand, it too easily jams, leaves nothing so smooth as a tobacco chamber, and if you could power through it to any real extent, it will surely tear out, or rather chunk out, when pockets are encountered, as they frequently are.
Now, if one prebores a pilot hole, one can with considerable effort and some risk, work the flat-faced spoon into briar with a beefy electric hand drill, but this further risks briar blowout and/or shatter, I'm told. I think for hand boring rotation speeds it's far more critical to have somewhere for the waste to go, even though briar somewhat excels in this respect.
The advantage of the concave spoon bit for starting a hole at any angle is not so important for pipemakers, although the ability to steer the hole at the beginning is. By the way, if the bit seizes in the stummel while you're holding it, it's uncomfortable if your grip is anything less than vise-like. I held the plateaux or ebauchon in a clamp to grip it securely and give my hands better leverage. If braced against one's stomach, it's generally fine, but blowout will be a shirt ripper, at best, and a naval reboring, at worst. I no longer have a lathe that supports this hold nor swings largish stummels, so I employ other means.
Re: I agree on all points
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
Bill and Steve, do you guys still stick with the following from Steve, May 2010:
Remove most of the metal by grinding. A standard Tormek wheel works, though somewhat slowly. A Norton 3X wheel works well too, and burning the edge is less of a danger because 3V is tempered at around 1000 deg. F. I like to establish the final edge shape (straight or cambered) on the grinder which takes a little finesse, but it's really not that hard to learn.
What do you think of my options for Makita wet grinder wheels: silicon carbide 120 or I-don't-know-what 60?
For a straight edge (jointer plane or chisel) I believe Bill uses a coarse diamond plate to take out any slight irregularities. Since the diamond isn't loose there's no problem with contamination due to larger particles sticking to the blade. I skip this step and just go to final honing.
Is that coarse diamond plate rectangular, like DMT, et al?
Thanks,
Pam
My method hasn't changed much
Steve Elliott
That's still a good summary of my current method. I've retired the Norton 3X grinding because I'm now doing all my sharpening at home and I like the way a wet grinder eliminates any dust. The swarf just goes down the drain.
I sometimes use a fixed diamond plate to check for edge straightness. My Tormek tends to take a little more off the middle of the blade than from the edges, no matter how I vary my technique. A couple of passes over a flat diamond plate let me know how much more to remove from the edges.
After I've ground right down to the cutting edge I taper the corners back by about .010" over 1/8" of edge length. That way I can take a thicker shaving without leaving tracks at the edges, and also take a VERY thin shaving if I want to and still have it be almost full width. With a little experience it's pretty easy to judge the right amount of taper. Since it takes a little fiddling to get the tool rest for the Tormek adjusted to the same angle I've ground at, I sometimes add some extra taper so that the next time I grind I won't have to do that step.
With the bevel and the edge shape established on the grinder I go to a 2-1/2 x 8" cast iron plate charged with 1 micron diamond. I charge the plate every time (very quick, much faster than soaking a waterstone) because it increases the cutting speed and costs next to nothing. I'm using a shop-made jig that hones about 2 degrees steeper than the bevel angle and allows me to follow the shape of the tapered blade edges. I've also freehand honed effectively, not resting on the bevel but feeling the angle where the bevel rests on the plate and then lifting the back of the blade a little. It's not quite as accurate but it's plenty good enough for useful woodworking, as opposed to blade testing where the variables must be controlled.
For chisels I grind down to the edge and then hone on waterstones, freehand. On a freshly ground edge I go straight to a Norton 8000x or Shapton 15000x. It only takes a few strokes to get a small microbevel that cuts great, and if it's at an appropriate angle for the task it won't chip or fold. The backs of the chisels never touch anything other than a flat stone of the finest grit, and usually even that isn't necessary if I've ground the edge back enough to remove the entire worn edge. Fine honing on the bevel removes any wire edge I can detect unless I use the microscope. To renew an edge without grinding I use an intermediate grit stone resting on the entire bevel to remove the worn edge, then do final honing of the microbevel. I don't check my working tools under magnification, that's just for exploring what methods work best and how far to go with each step. All the important aspects of sharpening can be determined by the usual techniques woodworkers have used for centuries: looking closely at the surface produced and at the edge itself when it's sharpened and as it wears, and learning from those with more experience. Nothing motivates me more to get better at something than seeing someone else do it better and faster.
Since I don't do carving I'm not sure these methods should be applied to carefully shaped edges like gouges. I think leaving a little bit of the existing edge when grinding is a good way to ensure that a carving tool doesn't change shape every time it's ground.
It�s been about a decade since I used a Makita flat grinder so I can�t advise on that. I remember making the edge of my best Japanese dovetail chisel off-square faster than I thought could happen, and returning to methods I knew better. I haven�t tried 3V on a Makita. About a year ago I bought a new silicon carbide wheel for my Tormek and it�s better mostly because it is the full 10� diameter, which increases surface speed. I�d go for the coarsest grit for the Makita unless you will be using it for some kind of final honing.
The fixed diamond plate I�m currently using is a DMT which is either fine or extra fine. For determining whether an edge is straight it�s not necessary to remove much steel at all on the fixed plate�just look for the high points that the plate scratches.
I hope I�m not steering you wrong on any of this. I�m sure there are many techniques that work, these are just the ones I�ve found to be the quickest and best for the kind of edge I�m after.
Re: I agree on all points
Phil Smith
"What do you think of my options for Makita wet grinder wheels: silicon carbide 120 or I-don't-know-what 60?"
I've used the Makita wet grinder with both the 120 grit green wheel and the standard 1000 grit wheel to good effect when making tools out of CPM 3V. When I made Mortise chisels I had a piece of 1/2 thick 3V that I cut length wise with a hacksaw. Took the saw marks out in the annealed state with green wheel. I have also use the 1000 grit wheel to do most of the work flattening the backs of heat treated chisels. You need a flat wheel and good touch but it works.
For aspiring tool makers
Bob Hackett
I would recommend getting a good quality 6" angle grinder.
You can use one of these for everything from cutting up rough stock with a cut off wheel to rough grinding with a stone to finishing with sand paper discs and then Scotchbrite (or equivalent) pads.
A relatively cheap and extremely versatile work horse of a tool that will help you get going and do a ton of work in both wood and metal.
Re: For aspiring tool makers
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
Thanks, Bob, I was looking at angle grinders a couple of months ago. Haven't been able to come to a purchasing decision; but I did put a DeWalt 4-1/2 in my shopping cart. Do you use a diamond edged blade for 3V cutting?
And thanks for all your tips from last year, especially about shielding the grinder lamp.
Pam