New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Electric guitar bodies

Posts

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#51

I'm not sure it's possible...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

to make up for that first video; but your effort is appreciated.

This counts as the first time I've heard "Stairway to Heaven," to my knowledge.

Digressing, and demonstrating that I'm old and out of it...Amazing how many of the important events of my generation I missed. Couldn't afford Woodstock; decided not to go down to Chicago (one day away, at the time) for the 1968 Democratic convention and thereby, probably, missed getting my head bashed.

On the other hand, I saw Eugene McCarthy announce his candidacy for President (my college gymnasium was one of the four locations at which he announced it Nov. 30, 1967). And we (my sweetie and I, not Gene McCarthy and I) were at Altamont, until we got too disgusted by all the people on dope, disrupting the event, and left.

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#52

Thanks much

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Thanks for all the info, guys, very interesting. I especially liked Wilbur's guitar dork, really great stuff.

However, just in case there's any doubt, I bought the mahogany (4X4X40) double neck to make two necks instead. :)

Pam

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#53

Sigh

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

and here I was looking forward to the Youtube video of you, Pam, playing your very own arcanely shaped two-neck device, combining, perhaps, guitar and koto.

Still, it'll be interesting to hear how your simpler but no doubt satisfying build goes.

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#54

Re: Electric guitar bodies

charlie belden

Les Paul, the inventor of the electric guitar pickup made his first electric guitar with a traditional neck, but a section of 2x4 to hold the pickups and potentiometers for adjusting the volume. Oddly, though musicians are free thinkers, his new guitar was not well received - because it didn't LOOK like a guitar. So he doweled on two more guitar shaped pieces to his 2x4 - and the rest is history.

As long as you have a strap you don't need a big rounded figure 8 guitar shape. For aesthetics - ok. But I doubt it has much affect on the sound of a solid body.

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#55

Re: Electric guitar bodies

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Thanks, Charlie. I suspect there are some ergonomic issues with trying to use a 4X4 instead of a traditionally shaped body, among other things the wings can brace the instrument so the playing area stays in the same plane with the player's body. A 4X4 would more easily tip. That said, I agree with you, that the wood doesn't make a huge difference; but it clearly makes some difference.

Pam

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#56

Other stringed instruments

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

A while back, someone was making a stick-shaped electric cello, called the Travielo or something along that line, for cello players who traveled a lot and needed a practice instrument while on the road. This would not, I gather, be a performance instrument; just something to keep the practice skills up while traveling on non-musical business.

I never heard if there was a traviel-bass, for contrabass players with the same issue.

Which reminds me that, unlike the acoustic instruments, where the size of the body is proportional to the pitch of the strings (lower = larger), electric basses seem by and large to be sized identically to regular-pitch guitars (even, in some cases like, say, Paul McCartney's H�fner bass, rather smaller than typical solid-body guitars). This leads me to think that the critical issue is the effect of the strings on the pickups, rather than resonance in the body.

Bill, absolutely no knowledge of solid-body guitars other than having a son who owns one

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#57

Re: Other stringed instruments

Howard Pollack

I think that the key elements are the length and diameter of the string. -Howard

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#58

Re: Other stringed instruments

ThomD

Soloette guitar is an electric practice guitar, started as a classical. It's just a stick of wood. Basically the string is in tune and there are vibrations in the body, but how they can affect they string I don't know, it wouldn't seem all that a vibration entering the pickup from the body would be a good thing. Then there are the hollow body electrics like the 335, but the part behind the strings is solid.

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#59

Re: Two-headed guitars, Jimmy Page, etc

James Watriss

I watched a documentary recently, titled It Might Get Loud that brought together Jimmy Page, The Edge, and Jack White, to talk about life, music, and their own histories... Enjoyed it a lot.

At one point, Jimmy Page was talking about how Stairway to Heaven was pretty much the reason for him to use the double neck (6 string and 12 string)... so that he could switch to (I think I'm remembering this right) the 12 string for the solo, and play the 6 for the rest of the song. They showed some footage, it was all very impressive. I've always been a Led Zep fan, but not a super-fan, gotta know everything type music geek.

Anyway... worth watching, for those who are interested.

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#60

Re: Two-headed guitars

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Thanks, Wilbur, brings back some old times. In '75 Jack and I had just moved in together and were preparing for a 1.5 year very early retirement, the theory being that we could always work but wouldn't always enjoy traveling about on motorcycles.

Pam

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#61

Re: Two-headed guitars *LINK*

L. Hanson

Linda Manzer made a 4-necked, 42 string acoustic for Pat Metheny, about 25 years ago... I've seen few like it... There's a video of him playing it on the link.

You can read more about it at Linda Manzer's web site

Manzer.com


img

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wp1wHZfZz9s

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#62

Re: Two-headed guitars, Jimmy Page, etc

wilbur

It was the other way around for the live version of Stairway to Heaven: 12 string neck for the main part of the song, 6 string for the solo.

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#63

Re: Other stringed instruments

wilbur

For the most part, electric bass guitars have longer necks than electric guitars, and the bodies are usually sized larger. I think that the main reason for the larger body size in an electric bass guitar is for balance, not tone. The Steinberger electric bass had quite a small body. Paul McCartney's Hofner bass was smaller, but it's neck was on the shorter side for electric basses.

There are many electric guitars where it's pretty clear that the body shape was more for aesthetics than for tone.








Re: Electric guitar bodies

#64

Re: Two-headed guitars, Jimmy Page, etc

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Whew, thanks, was beginning to think I'd entered a mirror image world.

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#65

Re: Two-headed guitars, Jimmy Page, etc

James Watriss

My mistake... I'm not a guitar player, and it's been a while since I'd watched It Might Get Loud.

Clearly this isn't one of those topics where I have anything to add. :)

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#66

Re: Other stringed instruments

ThomD

It also is very much a mater of what the audience wants to see. Your guitar has to meet their expectations. One of the problems of selling novel designs to artist is that even if they get it, use them on their recordings, they sometimes won't play them in public. The Matheney guitar being kinda an example of a guitar that probably fits people's sense of the sort of instrument a guy like him would play. Same reason why musicians wear guitars at uncomfortable heights, and play them standing rather than seated.

Here is a song where the guitar body gets used:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nLmWcRBzzAc&feature=related