New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Electric guitar bodies

Posts

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#26

Re: I prefer bolt on necks, too

bugbear

I agree that bolt ons provide a lot more flexibility.

And I think the evidence is in (to say the least :D ) that they're "strong enough" from a structural point of view.

BugBear

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#27

Re: I prefer bolt on necks, too

Patrick Gibbons

Ellis, with a guitar that looks that good, you almost don't even need to play very well.

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#28

Hey Pam...

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

While you're having fun and learning...snap some photos and post them!

I like to see the process done and hear about your experiences.

Joe

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#29

Re: Hey Pam...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Sure, be happy to; but I'm only ordering the wood now, will probably be at least a couple or three months before it's ready.

Pam

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#30

Re: I prefer bolt on necks, too

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yeah, they are strong enough, even if my soul isn't maximally satisfied. :)

Pam

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#31

Re: I prefer bolt on necks, too

bugbear

Your initial reasoning for a straight through neck was from an "engineering standpoint".

I have to say that over-building a feature at the cost of maintainability and versatility doesn't sound like good engineering to me!

Engineering design is all about balancing requirments against one another.

BugBear

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#32

Re: I prefer bolt on necks, too

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Look, this guitar will have a market value of about zero, so maintenance isn't an issue. It's for me and is as much an exercise/learning project as it is a musical instrument. I'm not fond of metal bolts holding wood pieces together. They work, but I don't like it. And I always say that the best joint is one that doesn't exist, can never break; so why not span the joint with a log?

Pam

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#33

Re: I prefer bolt on necks, too

bugbear

Look, this guitar will have a market value of about zero, so maintenance isn't an issue. It's for me and is as much an exercise/learning project as it is a musical instrument.

Guitarists often maintain (and adjust, and tweak) their own instrument, so it's not about value or resale.

Ultimately, it's your guitar, so build as you will. But you did ask for advice.

BugBear

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#34

Re: I prefer bolt on necks, too

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yes, I certainly did, and I appreciate every bit of it. One bit was to visit Ed Roman's site, which I did. Ed recommends a deep mortise approach with a mortised body on the back and a top (maybe mortised, maybe not, haven't worked it out yet) encasing the neck, and from tail to keyboard devices mounted to the through neck. I think this would be very strong structurally and would allow the sounds waves to resonate the wood.

Bolt on necks are good; but they do have the rep of loosening and needing repair more often. So, yes, they are more easily maintained; but perhaps they need that because they fail more often.

On the wood, I think koa for the body part, maple or spruce for the top, and mahogany for the neck. How does that sound?

Pam

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#35

Re: Direct coupling

David Weaver

What were the wild things that occurred? Did you get overtones on some notes, or resonance that you didn't want?

I have a telecaster that *isn't* hollow that growls at a couple of spots. It has overwound lindy fralin pickups in it that are pretty hot, so I kind of like the growlers, but I'm guessing that they're not supposed to be there. Those no fret ring or dead notes, so the growing is pretty much the guitar itself resonating at certain tones.

I can't imagine that hollowing a guitar for tonal qualities is an easy thing to knock out - probably a many body and pick the best experience?

I've seen a lot of ed's page, and I have had some neck through guitars, and one with direct coupling. I like it OK, but there are sometimes when I think the sustain and (i don't know for sure if this is attributable to the direct coupling) darkness of tone isn't always preferable. Certainly, on something like a jazzbox when you keep the sustain down with a spruce top and a lower mass bridge, you don't want something like that.

If you're playing soaring '80s guitar leads, then that sustain is nice.

It is offensive to the sensibilities when you take the top off of a stratocaster and see everything is just connected to plastic with huge routed cavities. It gives you the feeling that the guitar is not carefully made.

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#36

Re: I prefer bolt on necks, too

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

OOOh Koa! I vote yes on that! It's one of my favorite woods.

JR

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#37

Re: Through neck construction

David Weaver

A through-neck guitar was also my first good-quality guitar. An ibanez musician, one of the plain ones made entirely of maple with pearl/yellow paint and with passive pickups.

It was a fabulous guitar. I actually made a lot of money with it, getting paid to play. Since then, I got out of college, made money doing other things and bought lots of guitars that are much more expensive, sold the Ibanez before I left college only to have played guitar less, not for money since college, and realized that probably none of the guitars were better and most not even as good as the ibanez musician. It didn't have hot enough pickups for the sustain to be an issue, but it was clear as a bell.

Sure wish I had that guitar back. I guess I could buy it, but I wouldn't do that unless one showed up with the dings where I made them.

If I build an electric guitar, it'll be solid maple with an arch top and neck through. The access that guitar had is something les paul people would fight over (had a les paul, too, great sounding guitar, but not so great if you spend much time above the 12th fret and don't want to make a challenge of it). it also had a clean tone that a les paul couldn't dream of coming up with.

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#38

Re: I prefer bolt on necks, too

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Now I just have to see if the bank will finance a mortgage on the house so I can afford it. :)

Pam

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#39

Re: Through neck construction

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Nice looking guitars. There's one on ebay that shows the maple through neck clearly, with dark wings, a bass. A worthy goal.

Pam

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#40

scott grandstaff

Homemade guitar

scott grandstaff

This used to be a 3 legged table. No kidding.

It started as a big heavy birch coffee table.

Then koa and mahogany.

The neck used to be an acoustic guitar somebody put a knee though around a campfire.

With electric guitars I think after you get a solid mounting its more about the electrics and hardware.

This bridge weighs over 1/4 pound of solid brass. The tuners are vintage Schaller. The pickups include an early double stacked Dimarzio and a hand would Bil Lawrence.

There is a control board hand wired by Dan Torres.

I built this over 25 years ago now. It has come down a very long road.

"Right as the mail" as they say. Its reliable and a powerful tone.

I wish I'd have used a bolt neck as it needs frets again, already, and swapping on another neck would just be so much easier.

yours Scott


img

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#41

Re: I prefer bolt on necks, too

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

Might as well try to get a trip to the Islands thrown in with the cost. At least you could hand pick the blank. :D :D

Joe

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#42

Re: I prefer bolt on necks, too

ThomD

" I'm not fond of metal bolts holding wood pieces together. They work, but I don't like it. And I always say that the best joint is one that doesn't exist, can never break; so why not span the joint with a log? "

I think a hardware prejudice has to be context specific. I appreciate the idea of wood joinery in many areas, but then there are whole other worlds. Metal and wood do belong together as in this case of guitars where they make beautiful music. We don't even work wood without metal, so it's all part of a single thing, not separate things.

That said, there are better ways of bridging the gap than others. I have mentioned hardware bonding, which seems a more organic way of doing things to me, though I could see how others would see a slug of metal in a lake of epoxy used to receive a machine screw as a rather tacky thing. What I like about it conceptually (it also works so well) is that it allows the joint to be made without harming the wood, over and over virtually for ever. While regular wood screws in repeat connections or under heavy loads damage the wood.

I'm not trying to convince anyone of anything, but there is a way of liking metal and wood together, rather than feeling bad about it. Obviously I guess with stuff like hardware on cabinets or architecture, or something like stocks on guns. I'm thinking more of the structural angle.

It is possible to add necks without bolts. The whole thing can be dovetailed in, but the wood needs to be pretty strong for that (talking about in-line dovetails, not the type one finds on acoustics).

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#43

Re: I prefer bolt on necks, too

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yeah, you can say that again, well over $300 for a 24" X 2" X 6" billet. Of course, it was billed as AAAA instrument grade. Argh! Definitely out of my league for a first guitar.

Pam

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#44

Re: I prefer bolt on necks, too

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I admit that metal inserts for bolt reception are inherently good things and they certainly work fine for bolt on necks, no question; but for this guitar I want to try the through neck. Found a lovely piece of mahogany for just such a purpose, enough for two necks when I screw up [pun intended].

Pam

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#45

Or, if you don't, you have material

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

for a second guitar - or a mid-stream course correction to one of those cool two-necked guitars.

Bill, used to drool over the Gibson catalog and always utterly fascinated by the two-necked guitars.

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#46

Re: Or, if you don't, you have material

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I have real problems visualizing how one hand can cover two sets of strings at once. How do they work?

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#47

Two-headed guitars *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

They were only ever offered in solid bodies, for obvious reasons; and the necks were always different. One, for instance, might be a six string, and the other a twelve-string (I think they had a regular-pitch/bass option, too, though it's been a loooong time now since I was sitting poring over the catalog). Linky below is one example; it doesn't appear that Gibson makes them anymore. So you'd play one neck at a time, but could switch back and forth as the song, or your muse, required. If I recall correctly, there was a toggle switch in some easy-to-reach location that switched power from one set of pickups to another.

They kind of reminded me of those reed players who would somehow dangle two saxophones from themselves, and switch back and forth - I never understood how they could concentrate, with the "off" sax banging around getting in the way. But I guess it's a matter of practice, as with everything in music.

In finding the link below, I even found evidence of a four-necked guitar, combining "...guitar, bass, mandolin and banjo..." Somehow, this begins to approach the realms of a Rubicon Trail-capable Cadillac - possible, but why?


http://www.kellyindustries.com/guitars/gibson_sg_double_neck.html

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#48

Re: Two-headed guitars *LINK*

wilbur

Here's an example of a guy, Michael Angelo Batio, playing a double neck guitar, although not the double necked Gibson that Bill referred to. This will take some will power, but it's worth watching to the end, where he shows how to combine double neck guitar playing with biceps curls.

I much prefer the original title of the webpage that led me to this video: "Play guitar like a superdork". ;)

This guy has a four-neck guitar as well. :O


Playing a double neck guitar

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#49

Re: Two-headed guitars *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Some of the stuff up high on the frets sounded so much like New Age Music that I expected him to suddenly show up in a leotard with his head shaved.

I agree - the original title is pretty accurate.

And, according to Wikipedia, Jimmy Page (Led Zeppelin) and Don Felder (Eagles), among others, play them - so I guess superdorkhood is not a requirement.

Even Pete Townshend played one, which raises the interesting question of what sound a double-necked guitar being smashed against a speaker makes.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_neck_guitar

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#50

Re: Two-headed guitars *LINK*

wilbur

I suppose I should make up for that last video by showing one where a double neck guitar is being used to good effect.


Stairway to Heaven live