New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Electric guitar bodies

Posts

Electric guitar bodies

#1

Electric guitar bodies

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I'm at the wood ordering stage for a very special (to me) electric guitar. I think I want to make the body of claro walnut; but the best I've found so far is two pieces, each 7/8" thick, glued to 1-3/4" thick and sanded. It seems that this glue may distort the sound waves, perhaps bouncing them back for a different sound than a solid 1-piece 1-3/4" would. Anybody have experience with this?

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#2

Re: Electric guitar bodies

wilbur

No experience in making electric guitars, but over the years I've played plenty of electric guitars made of two pieces of wood glued together like you describe that sounded great. In fact, a Les Paul is made by gluing a piece of maple onto a piece of mahogany, much in the manner that you describe.

At most, the glue lines might change the characteristic of the sound. It doesn't necessarily mean that it will be a bad sound, and part of the charm of an electric guitar is how the sound distorts as you turn up the volume.

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#3

Re: Electric guitar bodies

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Thanks, Wilbur. I think, thanks to George at Sawmill, that claro walnut is ineffective overkill for solid bodies; so I'm leaning to a much cheaper solution, can save my money for claro on an acoustic I want to make next year.

Pam

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#4

scott grandstaff

Re: Electric guitar bodies

scott grandstaff

Consider cherry, Pam

Bonnie Raitt sounds pretty good on occasion. :)

She's been playing a cherry strat for some years.

I used it for my mini. I like the sound very much. Its not a solid 1 piece, far from it. Still sounds pretty nice for a miniature.



yours Scott

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#5

Re: Electric guitar bodies

ThomD

A base wood is often used, and then a top can be glued over that for wood preferences like curly maple etc... These guys sell a lot of that kind of thing though this is just a blank:

http://www.warmoth.com/Guitar-Sized-Body-Blank-Swamp-Ash-P1577C212.aspx

Wood is wood though, and that's a lot of money for a piece of wood. Just be sure whatever you are building with is strong enough to mount the neck to with confidence.

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#6

Re: Electric guitar bodies

bugbear

Whilst the neck of an electric guitar has strong effects on the sound, all the reading I've ever done indicates that the effect of the body is minimal, which is why you see so many "interesting" body shapes.

BugBear

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#7

Direct coupling *LINK*

David Miller from Iowa

I used to make electric guitars some time ago when I thought I was going to be the next Paul Reed Smith (I didn't acheive this - but I did learn a lot about make electric guitars). As others have indicated, a glued body has little or no effect on the sound. However, the technique of direct coupling the 3 main elements directly to the guitar make an amazing difference, and almost no mass produced guitars use these strategies. However, all the custom shops do this - when you see your favorite rocker playing a name brand guitar, it was custom made by the factory using these strategies and resembles the guitar store version only on the outside.

These are:

proper seating of the pickups (very important)

proper seating of the neck into the body (medium important)

bridge structurally secured (less important)

The link is to Ed Roman guitar in Las Vegas - he's a bit pompous, but there is some great technical info there.

The only sound difference I was able to achieve by doing anything with the body itself was hollowing out cavities - I made a prototype with a sinuous channel in it like a bose wave radio resonance chamber and it really did some wild things, but I never was able to work out the bugs and moved on.

Good luck


Ed Roman Guitars

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#8

Re: Electric guitar bodies

R.J. Whelan

Pam,

I'm not a professional (or even close), but I have built several acoustic and solid bodied guitars and a close friend has been building instruments for 40 years.

The one test I know of is to cut the blank to rough dimension - strike the blank (lightly) with a hammer (in several spots and on both faces) and listen for the tone - if it sounds dull at any point of contact you may have a resonance problem.

My friend says that a solid piece is a better option, but a lamination can work. The number of laminations should by an odd number (3,5,7,9, etc).

Hope these comments help ......... rj

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#9

Re: Electric guitar bodies

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

A cherry strat? Cool, and hard to argue with Bonnie. What's more, I've got a pile of cherry pieces that are looking for a project. A miniature strat? You actually play it?

Pam

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#10

scott grandstaff

Re: Electric guitar bodies

scott grandstaff

Oh sure, it plays like a dream.

Its a bit over 1/2 size. So its tuned 5 notes up but basically, the same.

My favorite thing is to play it through a harmonizer/gain effects patch.

Then it sounds like this huge deep powerful rip-the-rafters-loose instrument while I have this little ukulele sized thing on a leather strap around my neck.

I love it.

Yeah consider cherry, its a great choice and its beautiful. Terrific sustain.

When I started the cherry was practically white, as it often is.

So I roughed it out very close to finished and then would schlep it out into the sun every morning until it got hot about noon, bringing it back in.

Then do it again next day. Alternating sides facing the sun.

In 2 weeks of this, it was the color of 50 year old work, so I finished it.

In another 2 years just sitting around, it came to the color of 100 year old cherry.

I guess I have to wait for the 200 year old color.

But I'm a patient guy. :)

yours Scott

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#11

Re: Electric guitar bodies

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yeah, the neck. From an engineering standpoint I want to make a solid neck from top to bottom and add a couple of wings for the body; but I haven't been able to find a long enough suitable piece of mahogany and the neck would probably be susceptible to bending unless I somehow insert a full length truss rod.

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#12

Re: Electric guitar bodies

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Cool. My cherry (actually several piles of rails and stiles from someone else's undone kitchen) is beautiful if you like saddle shoes, a mix of white and reddish, very melodramatic. I'll try your sunlight treatment on a piece of it.

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#13

Re: Electric guitar bodies

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yes, I've read those things, too. My claro walnut idea was a test of sorts, both of my ear and accepted wisdom; but it might be too expensive.

Pam

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#14

Re: Direct coupling

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Very interesting, David, I'll read what Ed Roman has to say, also looks informative.

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#15

Re: Electric guitar bodies

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Thanks, R.J., for some reason an odd number (of laminated layers or glue layers?) sounds rational, and certainly tapping is good advice. I saw a news segment a few years ago with a maker tapping a piece of thick, red wood. Boy did it sing.

Pam

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#16

Re: Electric guitar bodies

bugbear

From an engineering standpoint I want to make a solid neck from top to bottom and add a couple of wings for the body;

In case you don't know, that approach is known as a "straight through neck".

BugBear

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#17

Re: Electric guitar bodies

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Thanks, thought it might be something like that. I've now seen a couple of examples with truss rods, looks like a piece of cake.

Pam

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#18

Question for Pam

Patrick Gibbons

What literature can you recommend reading for an aspiring electric guitar maker?

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#19

scott grandstaff

Re: Electric guitar bodies

scott grandstaff

I haven't been able to find a long enough suitable piece of mahogany and the neck would probably be susceptible to bending unless I somehow insert a full length truss rod.

Pam

Frets wear

The neck through idea has been well explored and done. Same as the glued in, or set neck. Carvin guitars made a pretty good run with neck though. They will sell you a though neck to use. If you can find an older one, it'll not just have a truss rod but 2 strips of carbon fiber reinforcement besides.

Very stable, but honestly, necks move anyway. Its what they do.

And even Carvin has relented lately.

Gibson is still clinging to the set neck but they offer bolted necks as well.

The trouble isn't with the initial guitar. The neck though or set neck is just dandy, and for some time.

The trouble comes after a few years when the frets wear.

If you are rich you simply replace the whole guitar and hang the old on the wall, but for the rest of us...........

Fret jobs on solid attached guitars are much harder (read scandalously expensive) on one piece guitars where you can't just take the neck off.

Only a few places will even take on the job of refretting a Les Paul Standard or topline Carvin.

5 to 800 dollars is the usual ask for a full bound ebony board inlaid in pearl, and a waiting list!

Bolted necks are 1/2 that, at worst.

Besides, with bolt on necks you can simply pull the neck off and install another in an hour or less.

You can buy a whole new neck for much less than having frets redone. There are any number of neck companies out there making nothing but necks. Many of them fine companies.

Warmouth, mentioned earlier, makes necks in 11 kinds of wood and 21 different shapes/setups!

The genius of Leo Fender strikes again.

Lately stainless frets are being used on a few guitars. I look for more and more of these to be made.

Hopefully, eventually, someday, with hardened stainless.

Its my own view that frets should harder than string wire. Strings you can get for 2 bucks!!

yours

Hell on frets (ya see that black smeary looking stuff all over your left hand after a couple of hot jams??.... Yeah that's your frets.)

Scott

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#20

Ellis Walentine

I prefer bolt on necks, too

Ellis Walentine

In fact, if my '65 Tele hadn't had a bolt-on neck, I couldn't have made this replacement body for it. Pickups were hand-wound (while I waited) by Bill Lawrence about 15 years ago. The only thing I am not crazy about is the density of this tiger maple compared to the original swamp ash, but it sure has a solid tone.

Seems like we've got a lot of pickers here. Maybe we can start a virtual band. :)

Ellis


img

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#21

Through neck construction

wilbur

My very first electric guitar was a Washburn Falcon. It had a through neck construction, with a mahogany body and maple top, much like a Les Paul. The through neck construction gave it a ton of sustain -- almost too much at times. As a player, as I got better at playing guitar, I learned that you sometimes want the note to decay in a manner that you would expect from a guitar. Not that it's a bad thing overall, as for the punk band that I was in during med school that guitar was great, but it might be something to consider depending on how you want your guitar to play.

I think that's one of the things that gives archtop guitars their unique sound -- a relative lack of sustain compared to regular flattop acoustics.

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#22

Re: Question for Pam *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I'd recommend Martin Koch's two books: It's easy to Build Your Own Lap Steel Guitar and Building Electric Guitars

He also has a video for each of these; but you have to order either from him in Euros or from StewMac for the guitar (note, I was ready to order this today, but their $8.50 fee for mailing a CD/DVD was just too outrageous for me).

Pam


Koch on Amazon

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#23

Re: Through neck construction

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Good point, which is why I said the through neck was my preference for structural reasons. I don't know which way I'll go yet.

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#24

Re: Electric guitar bodies

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Thanks, Scott. I don't understand why I couldn't do my own refretting if I've done the original fretting. I don't think it would matter that I couldn't detach the through neck, assuming I use a separate fret board. I do understand why a vendor/manufacturer selling to end users might suffer sales of through neck guitars if a large number of their customers had to pay to refret.

I've read about carbon fiber neck reinforcement, sounds useful. As to Carvin necks, there's no way I'll pay $269 (on sale from $399!) for a fretted neck. Part of this exercise is to learn a lot about guitar construction and have some fun.

Pam

Re: Electric guitar bodies

#25

Re: I prefer bolt on necks, too

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Beautiful job, Ellis. I agree that bolt ons provide a lot more flexibility. :)

Pam

PS Haven't forgotten you dai, have just been swamped, should have some time free up in mid-December for a month.