New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Let's Get Provocative

Posts

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#26

Aint no ultimate silver bullet.

Bob Hackett

Most people think if they just spend enough on something,be it time or money,they can get one single,ultimate,edged steel that will be capable of killing all bad beings with a single blow.

It ain`t happening outside of Hollywood folks!

Just like you need a silver bullet to kill the werewolf and a wooden stake to kill the vampire you have to have different things to vanquish each WWing demon.That means having to gear up for and have a different delivery system for each one too.

You don`t get to have an incredibly long lasting edge without having to give up your water stones and gear up with something like diamond.You don`t get an easily and quickly sharpened edge without having to learn to tap out a laminated and hollowed back.

You don`t get to do it all by hand unless you know how to sharpen your own tools in your own shop.

You don`t get to custom tailor your tools to absolutely fit your hand,the material you favor or the way you work unless make your tools yourself.

What you have to sacrifice is some of your WWing time in order learn and practice metalworking skills.

So put that gunbelt down and get to sharpening that stake there chummy!

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#27

Re: Had a similar conversation...

John in NM

Well, I guess that was his theory, that maximum hardness was better and that the lack of tensile strength wasn't important in a plane blade. All the reviews I'd seen at the time, and your experience as well, leads me to believe he was wrong about that. But hey, if all you have to do is bake one of his blades at 400 or so, then no problem :D

I've found that medium to soft blades are best for me, and that sharpness is the key - same as the original post. Much as I'd like to carefully sharpen everything with oil stones and get stellar results, I end up going straight from the grinder to a hard buffing wheel and get the results I want in a few seconds.

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#28

scott grandstaff

Re: Had a similar conversation...

scott grandstaff

I'm with you John. I don't want blades that are so hard its a chore to sharpen.

I don't mind resharpening at all if its...... easy.

oh and Tom,

My hand lapped plane soles probably wouldn't suit your own stroke, since they fit mine. But they have been my working tools over 35 years now and uncountable "shavings under the bench" in that time.

Blocks to infills and all others including my jointers.

I'm kind of careful persnickey about how I lap my shoulder planes n such, but still hand lapped.

Works for me.

yours Scott

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#30

Re: OF COURSE YOU ARE RIGHT !!

roninkokomo

I know all that friend, it just seems to me to be frivolous to talk about thousandths when toy material shrinks and swells eighths making all your work vain.

Again, I believe that if you have to ask "Is this close enough?" It isn't

But, I think it is important to keep it real.

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#31

Re: I'm with you

Gary Roberts

Yup, I side with Stephen on this one. The Gilbert & Townsend clans didn't use micrometers to measure their shavings or feeler gauges to check the soles of their planes. Personally, I think all this micro-tolerance stuff is foolish. It's wood. Wood compresses, expands, changes with humidity and temperature, etc. It's machinist level thinking to apply these tolerances to woodworking. Having worked with experimental lab machinists in the past, I can attest to the need for incredible tolerances in their realm. But not for wood.

But then, I have one sliding caliper and it's an old plastic one I picked up somewhere. I have no idea where it is now as I never use it.

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#32

Re: OF COURSE YOU ARE RIGHT !!

bugbear

But folks, wood moves. It shrinks and swells. 1/1000 th of an inch??? Get real.

But consider you're trying to take a 1 thou (smoothing type) shaving.

1 thou tolerances matter here - if the blade were retracted one more thou, you'd obviously take no shaving at all.

And, yeah, wood moves. But it doesn't move very much during a single stroke. Wood moves slowly!

So we can might up with a slightly warped board, but with a beautiful surface, cut by your to-a-thou smoothing plane.

BugBear

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#33

WE NEED STEPHEN THOMAS!

bugbear

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#34

Re: Let's Get Provocative

Michael Brady

I know who you are talking about. He sells some planes over on Woodnet. He's a standup guy and those who have had their planes ground or have bought his planes like his work. He is the only person I would trust the job to, but I have not felt the need to do it to any of my old Stanleys. I think he just retired and is just looking for a gig to pay some bills and practice his trade. Give him some slack. I have been known to sell a plane every now and then, and believe me it is a labor of love and not for profit; especially at the low prices that planes are bringing these days.

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#35

Re: Let's Get Provocative

Marv

Hi Michael,

Are you saying that the guy is doing it not for profit but for the labor of love? Or that the planes you have sold from time to time is a labor of love? I'm a little confused with your post.

I'm also a bit confused with those posting in this thread who say that a plane sole need not be flat to one or two thousands in order to perform properly. On the other hand, in discussions here in this forum, people have talked about making the top of their workbenches flat within a couple thousands or less. From a practical standpoint, I would think, if a bench top needs to be that flat, the sole of a plane should also be that flat. Am I missing something here?

Personally, I don't believe it is necessary for either to be that flat when working wood. In order to measure .001, requires some very sophisticated measuring equipment, not just a straight edge. Temperature changes during the coarse of a day will change wood more than that. That even happens with metal.

Just an opinion :)

Marv

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#36

Re: Let's Get Provocative

Michael Brady

Marv, I was speaking of my purpose in selling old planes being more about giving the plane new life and the joy in that process than it was about putting $25 and hours of work into a tool and selling it for $45. Along the way, I keep a couple for my own use. You may see that with saws too. Meanwhile dealers sell that same plane for $125., and don't even wipe the dirt off.

As far as the spec to which the sole of a plane may need to conform, I remember the WIA discussion between Rob Lee and Thomas Lie-Nielsen a couple of years ago:

Both gentlemen agreed that these specs are actually customer-driven. Customers demand them becasue they read forum threads like this one and return tools that don't meet them. Neither the manufacturing nor the use of the planes require that kind of precision. Basically, it makes the manufacturer have to charge for the degree of precision that the customer is demanding. Thats ironic, isn't it?

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#37

Moses Yoder

Re: Let's Get Provocative

Moses Yoder

I think a new plane should be flat to .001 because it can be. If we let manufacturers sell us crap, where will it end? I understand that a plane does not need to be flat if the toe, mouth, and heel are on the same plane but if we start letting the manufacturers build a plane that is .01 out of flat then that is what they will aim for in their product. A large number of old Stanley planes I purchase have a bump right behind the mouth that former owners never removed and they probably never knew what a properly adjusted and tuned plane was capable of doing.

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#38

Is this for real?

James Watriss

So, with all the sharpening conversations that fly through here on a regular basis, and you guys are going after someone for not doing it for you while he machined the rest of the plane? Really?

On shorter planes like 3's and 4's, sure, flatness is less of an issue. But I have a corrugated 5 1/2 that displays a pretty obvious taper in the corrugations from me hand-lapping the thing. (I hand lap while everything is strapped in and under tension.)

I have some planes where there's a mild hollow in the rear part of the sole, but I figure as long as the sides are in line, and the whole mouth is good I'm ok. But in the case of that 5 1/2, there was a pronounced bow along the length of the plane. Some planes don't really need the treatment. Some planes REALLY do.

I don't know much about machining. I'm not much of a turner, either. But I can say with a fair amount of confidence that the cutter use is going to be vastly different. Turning, and machining, the cutters are under constant use, mostly just hogging out material off of something that's constantly moving. It's the equivalent of dragging a plane behind your car at 30 MPH for a duration. The edge simply won't hold.

The best turners I know, and some of the few machinists I have talked to, will agree that a sharp tool leaves a better finish. But most of them won't require that level of sharpness until they make their final pass.

But for you guys to draw and start blazing on somebody in a different trade over something that's so obviously your job to do anyway... well, it just seems like you're looking for a fight to pick.

Lapping a sole plane isn't always necessary to that high a degree... but sometimes it helps. Thank the guy for his work, and sharpen your own damned iron.

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#39

Re: Let's Get Provocative

Marv

Moses,

There is no excuse for a plane manufacturer to machine the sole with anything more than .005 flatness. The process pretty much dictates they would have to actually put forth extra effort to do it with a sloppier tolerance. Generally speaking, from a machining standpoint, .005 tolerance is relatively easy to do. Below that, say .001 or .002 requires the machinist to use a different set of rules and attention to each and every step in the process. Even a speck of dirt will in a vise will effect the accuracy.

Marv

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#40

Let me try that again...

James Watriss

OK, so I think I misread the intent of the original post. Halfway through my first cup of coffee this morning, it sounded more like a complaint that he wasn't sharpening anything, and something about punching him in the mouth...

End of the day, and a little less cranky, I think I came off as a jerk.

Apologies to any who took offense.

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#41

Re: Let me try that again...

ThomD

"The best turners I know, and some of the few machinists I have talked to, will agree that a sharp tool leaves a better finish. But most of them won't require that level of sharpness until they make their final pass."

Sharpness is a different concept at times in machining. They sell some cutters with numbers that denote, among other things, The space between the edge and the first sign of a relief angle, at best these things are duuuull. But it is what they want. Sharpness is just a means to an end. With an immovable object spinning an irresistible force, the dynamics of the cutting can be whatever you want them to be. But on older machines, the bits were sharpened pretty sharp, for roughing and finish cuts, with a different bit for each.

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#42

Re: Let me try that again...

Bob Hackett

What do you think all those slipstones you find in the OLD machinists` toolboxes were for?

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#43

Re: Let me try that again...

Marv

Hi James,

David's post is a little like one of those word math problems we used to get in junior-high. He's relating a conversation he had in order to lead up to the real question he wants to discuss and get some feedback on.

His question at the end of his post is....

Anyway, hope this doesn�t get too out of hand, but I�m asking for challenges to my assertion that 1/1000 flatness tolerance is great, but not critical as long as the sole is decent, especially around the mouth.

The issue is....does the sole of a plane need to be flat to .oo1 or 1/1000. Among all the responses in this thread the question has been pretty well answered.

As with so many threads, we tend to wander off the main subject. Now we are discussing how to grind and sharpen a cutting tool for turning metal as a machinist does as compared to a tool for turning wood. Oranges and apples and the only resemblance is that both an orange and an apple are eaten.

Marv

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#44

Soooo...

Bob Hackett

Who gets to eat the apple and who gets the orange?

Just to twist things just a little further off track and into the ditch. :D

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#45

Well...Bob,

Marv

Briefly, very briefly,

I'm not an experienced wood turner but have done a little of it. From what I have learned, it appears there are fewer variations when considering different type turning tools compared to tools for turning metal. With that in mind, I'd say that wood turners are the oranges and the metal turners are the apples. There are fewer different type oranges than there are apples. At least that's what I observe when I go to the grocery store. I'm sure there's some arguments in that statement somewhere.

Who eats the oranges and who eats the apples? Lets share. ;)

There's another factor involved with the machinist. In order for a machinist to accomplish what he does, he, in many situations needs to know how to operate a milling machine as well as a lathe. He is usually working from a blueprint with dimensions and tolerances. He is working with lots of different kinds of metals. His cutting tools and how they are ground is determined to some extent based on the type metal he is working. Speeds and feeds come into play. Coolants are used to keep the cutting edge of the tools cool. Heat is the cutting tools enemy.

Many similarities between the wood turner and the machinist, but there are more differences than similarities. It is impossible to cover all the similarities and differences here in a short post.

Marv

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#46

Thanks Marv.

Bob Hackett

I was just making light of the situation as we(meaning the folks here on this forum) DO have a decided tendency to either take something over the edge or off in a completely different direction.

I am a bowl turner and have been an instructor of general woodturning along with Steve Gleasner at the Center for Furniture Craftsmanship so I know about both turning and tools and I also have many years of machining experience on everything from lathes to milling machines to various types of grinders(no CNC training here though) so I completely understand what you`re saying and where you`re headed.

Thanks for the nickel tour though. :)

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#47

Re: Thanks Marv.

Marv

Bob,

I'm impressed that you are a turner instructor. Do you ever hang out over in the Turner's forum?

I have little or nothing to contribute to wood turning issues, but I sure enjoy going in there and clicking on the posts with pics. You guys sure do some fantastic work. I have spent too many hours on Youtube watching videos. I watch one, then can't stop until I've watched 15 of them.

I saw a guy in the turner's forum yesterday who is also a machinist who made some serious tooling for cutting large wooden rings. I watched his video. His cutters cut from both sides of a thick work piece and at an angle so when the rings are glued together they form a rough bowl. A very clever technique that saves a lot of wood waste and the turning of a large bowl from a big chunk of wood.

Some turners don't only turn wood as I'm sure you know, they are also tool makers. Very impressive!

I greatly admire those of you who are in the expert category. You guys are a joy to watch perform your craft.

Marv

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#48

Re: Let's Get Provocative

David Weaver

Good point. I don't so much mind paying the price that LN and LV want for their planes. 9 out of 10 parts of the planes might have precision that they don't need, but the parts that count also have it.

I also recall what Mike's referring to in print somewhere, but it was a conversation with leonard lee. I don't remember if it was in FWW or what, but he basically said that they have a lot of people calling saying this or that is out several thousandths, and most people have no way of measuring or telling. It was in reference to using the lapping machines that they make for the irons - because the customer wants it (which may not be necessary, but a side benefit is that it sure is nice and easy to prepare one of their irons - it can be done with a finish stone only).

One other thought, I don't know what way you can do a plane less accurately, but still have it work well every time. If the spec goes to 5 thou, then some of the planes are going to be out five thou hollow in their length, and that's a pain. If they follow another plane, then it's going to take a couple of passes for them to even be able to cut.

If they were five thou convex, I don't think I'd care, but there'd be no way to guarantee it. Same thing would happen with irons. If they weren't ground as precisely, we'd be spending more time with them on the stones.

I like them the way they are, even though I know I've made planes that are less precise and work as well.