Re: Real answer
ThomD
I suppose to some extent it would help to disclose best for what in one of these threads, but here are the four factors, and let`s assume we are generally discussing finest shavings, though obviously that is only important on a small subset of planes used:
Cutter sharpness. If the cutter is not sharp it can`t pick up the size of shaving for which a sole prepped in the 10s would be necessary.
Sole flatness. Let`s say the blade is as perfect as possible, then the sole can be a limiting factor in the blade ability to pick up a shaving (a capability to cut a shaving of a few 10s is required to extend a few thou to get to the work. And if the sole was perfect except curves it would plane perfect curves.
Perfection in the tool. Flattening a sole to the 10s in a plane with hundreds of dollars of other problems to be fixed is not a full solution. The plane needs to be capable of holdingaccuracy when flexed, or possibly just adjusted in some way. Merely tightening the blade could cause deflection that would take the sole out of the tens. One has to question what is meant by machining a sole to the tens Did he just run it through a quality surface grinder, or maybe a used to be quality surface grinder. A tool with the capability to cut in the tens. Such a prep job might not survive release from the hold downs. It is relatively difficult to just measure something like a plane to the tens, let alone achieve that as a durable condition.
The work. Woodworkers do work down to the tens, but very little work requires this, and the conditions of the work probably don`t allow it.
There is no one preeminent factor. Machinists do spend a lot of time on their cutters, particularly old school machinists who used steel stock cutters, and ground them by hand, honed them on hard Arkansas, etc... In a similar way the newer tools that are mostly disposable are selected very carefully with a significant understanding of cutting dynamics. That said, they fall into the tool is king cutter is cheap mentality. For them a 5 thou hotley with a 100 dollar blade would be more comprehensible than a 5 thou artisan made blade in a 40 buck wood holder. The latter is probably the better choice for most work in wood. By the way, a lot of people here the word machinist and assume all kinds of competence and understanding. While it can be there, a lot of what was achieved took decades and the work of hundreds. Something like the modern target rifle where dedicated folks came up with all kinds of practices over decades to give us what we have today. Just going to any old oily shop and saying turn my Remington 700 into a tack driver, would not get you anywhere for the most part. With woodworking tools we have the additional problems that the clients aren't metal heads and for the most part aren't doing serious work (in the sense of competing on the weekend against their friends etc... where results are competitive, serious projects, of course).