New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Let's Get Provocative

Posts

Let's Get Provocative

#1

Let's Get Provocative

David Miller from Iowa

I just had a debate with a guy in ran into, a retired machinist (not a woodworker) who has taken to buying junk planes and machining the sides and bottoms to within 1/1000 of an inch tolerance, and then he resells them. I respect this, there is certainly a market for this, and I think it is great all around.

It was a nice conversation until I asked him what he did with the cutters. He said the cutters didn�t matter that much, the buyers could hone them if they wanted, but the most important thing was that the soles were flat. I respectfully disagreed, saying that, in my opinion, cutter sharpness was the most critical, followed by quality of the wood stock, and that 1/1000 flatness tolerance was great, but somewhat irrelevant as long as the plane was decently flat around the mouth.

I think I would have gotten a better reaction if I had just punched him in the mouth. Things went pretty quickly downhill, culminating with him asking me if I knew how to run a machinist tool (no) and me asking if he had ever used a plane (no).

Anyway, hope this doesn�t get too out of hand, but I�m asking for challenges to my assertion that 1/1000 flatness tolerance is great, but not critical as long as the sole is decent, especially around the mouth.

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#2

I'm with you

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol,CA

I have yet even to test the soles of my planes for flatness; but I sure notice it when the irons aren't sharp.

Having said that: I did give away one plane (Craftsman No. 5, my very first ever plane) when I discovered the area in front of the mouth was sufficiently out of flat that it cut very badly. I didn't measure it, but feeler gauges would have fit.

But I think sharpness is probably the most important thing to pay attention to, hands down.

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#3

Stephen Shepherd

Re: I'm with you

Stephen Shepherd

Some of the finest furniture ever produced was made by people that couldn't nor didn't measure to those tolerances.

Stephen

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#4

I would also agree but . . .

steve mackay

Dad is a tool & die maker so I know whence you come'n from. I've been passed machinist tools that I use every day. Never as they were intended though. Two different vocabularies that, actually, work toward a similar goal. Perfect. "They" play their games, "we" play ours !

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#5

I'm with you too

wilbur

Japanese planes are set up so that the sole is out of flat on the sole by 1/64" or so, the plane blade is ridiculously sharp, and just the area in front of the sole and at the very front of the plane are flat and coplanar. And they work great, even if they are used backwards. ;)

David, where did you have this conversation? Was it in person, or via the internet?

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#6

Re: Let's Get Provocative

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Your debate reminds me of the first wooden plane I made. At that time I had only one plane, a Stanley. I carefully planed the sole of the new wooden plane so that I could see no light between the sole and a straight edge in any direction. The new plane worked well and I couldn't understand why it seemed to flatten stock more easily than the Stanley. Then for the first time I placed the straight edge on the iron plane. It touched both heel and toe, but in the middle there was more than 1/16 of daylight. I still can't believe I was able to use that thing. A little bit of skill and a very sharp iron go a long way. I flattened the iron sole, but after 37 years I still have no idea whether the sides are flat or square.

I would hand the fellow a rough piece of curly maple and ask him how flat his planes can make it.

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#7

Re: Let's Get Provocative

Terry in Denver

Your assertion should be easy to prove! Let him demo his Super-Flat with a dull blade and you can demo one of your planes with a sharp blade. You might not let him drive your plane though. No telling what he might do with his apparent temper!!

Terry

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#8

In person at a tool auction

David Miller from Iowa

I outbid the guy on a box with several large Stanley bench planes and the biggest Sargent jointer. I let him have the box full of Lakeside and Shelton bench planes, although had had to pay almost as much as I did due to other bidders.

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#9

Re: Let's Get Provocative

David Weaver

I had a couple of loud text back-and-forths with the same guy on WN when I used to be allowed on there (:b)

Mine was rather that the flatness of a plane that is lapped properly is easily enough for any work that needs to be done. Any lapped plane generally ends up a tiny bit proud at the toe and heel, but it's limited if you don't get carried away, and advantageous vs. being out of flat the other way.

At any rate, there was never any agreement, because agreeing that it didn't make a plane that effectively works better would've stopped his sales in their tracks.

It seems goofy because it's a big expense to pay to ship a plane twice and pay for the machining, and you're left with something that is still a fairly low-value plane in monetary terms.

I personally would rather keep the full thickness of the castings and lap only as much as I need to lap to clean up the mouth area of the plane and remove any significant twist, which I have only seen twice in metal planes. It takes me less time to lap a plane than it does to box it and take it to the PO.

All of this stuff about needing a vise that can stand up to a three hour attack from a timberman's axe, benches that weigh 800 pounds, and planes that are flat to within a ten thousandth can only be the result of never actually trying less. I'm not exactly innocent of buying tools I don't need, but I won't make goofy claims about whether or not they need to be what they are or that I can do better work than I would be able to if they were 2 thousandths less flat.

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#10

Perspective . . .

steve mackay

Called "up north" (IL) last night just to check in and remembered this subject while I was talking to Dad. The machinist perspective is kinda that the "cutter / tool" is more or less expendable. If it gets dull or worn it just gets thrown on the surface grinder or other machine and gets precision ground to sharpness. In "their" world it is the tool "holder" (read : plane body in this case) that requires precision and acuracy. A machinist doesn't spend hours tuning a tool (ie : cutter) but spends DAYS tuning the machine (tool holder) set-up. I suppose if every woodworker had a machine he could just drop his cutters into and have them perfect (to HIS standards) he might start getting all neurotic about perfect dimensions of the holder or plane body.

Now I'm gonna take hits from the machinists aren't I ?

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#11

Re: Perspective . . . expanded

Marv

Steve,

I consider myself more of a metal worker than a woodworker. However many of the skills used for working metal are consistent with working wood. When a machinist grinds his/her cutting tools there are some basic rules that must be observed, not much different than a woodworking cutting tool. While it is true that machine setup is very important, if the cutters aren't right, the quality of the machining will be effected. An experienced machinist will pay close attention to the quality of their cutting tools. Just like in woodworking, there are people who are in the apprentice stage and then there are the experienced journeymen. In a general sense, you have a full spectrum of machinists from the beginner to the so called expert. So it is with any endeavor that requires a learned and practiced skill. :)

Marv

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#12

Re: I'm with you too

ThomD

Japanese planes are an example of correct set-up, the sole relief is there to make it possible to get the sole super in plane and other things, and the blade is awesome sharp.

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#13

Re: Real answer

ThomD

I suppose to some extent it would help to disclose best for what in one of these threads, but here are the four factors, and let`s assume we are generally discussing finest shavings, though obviously that is only important on a small subset of planes used:

Cutter sharpness. If the cutter is not sharp it can`t pick up the size of shaving for which a sole prepped in the 10s would be necessary.

Sole flatness. Let`s say the blade is as perfect as possible, then the sole can be a limiting factor in the blade ability to pick up a shaving (a capability to cut a shaving of a few 10s is required to extend a few thou to get to the work. And if the sole was perfect except curves it would plane perfect curves.

Perfection in the tool. Flattening a sole to the 10s in a plane with hundreds of dollars of other problems to be fixed is not a full solution. The plane needs to be capable of holdingaccuracy when flexed, or possibly just adjusted in some way. Merely tightening the blade could cause deflection that would take the sole out of the tens. One has to question what is meant by machining a sole to the tens Did he just run it through a quality surface grinder, or maybe a used to be quality surface grinder. A tool with the capability to cut in the tens. Such a prep job might not survive release from the hold downs. It is relatively difficult to just measure something like a plane to the tens, let alone achieve that as a durable condition.

The work. Woodworkers do work down to the tens, but very little work requires this, and the conditions of the work probably don`t allow it.

There is no one preeminent factor. Machinists do spend a lot of time on their cutters, particularly old school machinists who used steel stock cutters, and ground them by hand, honed them on hard Arkansas, etc... In a similar way the newer tools that are mostly disposable are selected very carefully with a significant understanding of cutting dynamics. That said, they fall into the tool is king cutter is cheap mentality. For them a 5 thou hotley with a 100 dollar blade would be more comprehensible than a 5 thou artisan made blade in a 40 buck wood holder. The latter is probably the better choice for most work in wood. By the way, a lot of people here the word machinist and assume all kinds of competence and understanding. While it can be there, a lot of what was achieved took decades and the work of hundreds. Something like the modern target rifle where dedicated folks came up with all kinds of practices over decades to give us what we have today. Just going to any old oily shop and saying turn my Remington 700 into a tack driver, would not get you anywhere for the most part. With woodworking tools we have the additional problems that the clients aren't metal heads and for the most part aren't doing serious work (in the sense of competing on the weekend against their friends etc... where results are competitive, serious projects, of course).

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#14

I just had a similar conversation with a machinist

Bruce, a MN Galoot

friend, who remarked that his other machinist buddies couldn't believe how highly polished the surfaces of his bores were and asked how he achieved that. They asked if the feed rate was slower, or the angle of the cutter was different, or what?

My machinist friend told them that they needed to spend more time sharpening their bits and get the most refined edge possible. That would result in a finish that didn't need further refining or polishing. He said it's all about the edge.

This guy is a highly talented engine rebuilder. Sounds like a woodworker to me.

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#15

Old School I guess . . .

steve mackay

Dad just HEARS "CNC" and he tunes out of a conversation.

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#16

OF COURSE YOU ARE RIGHT !!

roninkokomo

This comes around every so often, and before I get thumped, let me say that I believe a true craftsman has an obligation to all the accuracy that he can achieve. OK???

But folks, wood moves. It shrinks and swells. 1/1000 th of an inch??? Get real.\

Especially revealing is the fact that the guy had never used a hand plane.

Ron ,,, a Kokomo Galoot... hoping to get back in the shop soon.

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#17

Re: OF COURSE YOU ARE RIGHT !!

ThomD

Metal shrinks and swells, machinists don't normally work below the thous, it is a lot harder than it sounds. They may do a set up indicated in to the tens, but the overall job won't be. But woodworkers do take polishing cuts in the tens, 3-4 tens is easily achieved with a wooden hand plane.

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#18

Re: Let's Get Provocative

BrianA from Monument

I wonder if this isn't a "taste great vs less filling" type question.

To me at least the taste is the most important part.

I think both sole and blade shape and trueness are important.

But for this thread, I would say that blade shape and sharpness are most important and the

trueness of the sole is somewhat less important.

Yet what I hear here and experienced is that if the sole of the plane is bad it wont work.

I have had that happen to me with a wooden jointer plane with a untrue sole.

It wasn't until I reevaluated the sole and put it back into what I considered spec (flat and true) that I could make some real progress on my surface planing.

I doubt many woodworkers really want to attempt to make the sole of a metal plane flat and true enough to do the job. I think that this is true because most woodworkers are not machinists.

I do expect a higher percentage of woodworkers on this website to do it though.

So I think some of the what I perceive as machinist bashing here is a lack of appreciation and understanding of their trade.

Personally I am somewhat more of a hybrid being a 2nd career gunsmith having recently attended gunsmith school (graduated 4 years ago) where I learned some things that machinists do (self deprecating humor - I am not a journeyman machinist). Yet I spent nearly 2 decades learning how to work wood as a hobby. I anticipate that learning about both woodworking and gunsmithing will be a continuing activity.

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#19

Re: Perspective . . .

wilbur

I see what you're saying about the machinist's perspective on the tool holder. But if the machinists were really thinking hard about the plane, based on this approach they should be more concerned about the frog/blade mating surface than the sole of the plane.

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#20

Had a similar conversation...

John in NM

Once, with the guy who ran St. James Bay tool.... asked him what temperature he tempered to, as I was buying a hardened but un-drawn blade for a bullnose kit. He said he didn't draw them at all, they didn't need it! :0 Machinists do not always get woodworking and have almost never done any research in the tool use unless they're interested in both trades.

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#21

it would be interesting

Bruce, a MN Galoot

to have this conversation with machinists who truly understood both worlds, like Wayne Anderson, Karl Holtey, Stephen Thomas, and I'm sure a host of others. Imagine how illuminating that would be for the great unwashed, like me.

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#22

Re: Perspective . . .

steve mackay

OK

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#23

scott grandstaff

Re: Let's Get Provocative

scott grandstaff

How about the third choice??

Personally I am happiest with a hand lapped plane, whether metal or wood.

Any machinist will tell you a hand lapped sole is not very accurate. No its not.

But honestly, neither is my arm.

I'm not using a machine when I plane, unless you are calling -me- an imprecise wood milling machine. :D

When I lap a plane I am basically approximating my own stroke across the workpiece. I use other movements to clear waste as I go and change positions, but by and large most of it is the same stroke I use to plane wood.

About 3 grits will do it for me most times.

I like mine soft as an old worn in house slipper. Lapped to my own regular stroke.

I just need to get some work done and would rather spare my old bones whatever I can.

I love my tools. I build tools. I spend time on tools.

But really, the look on my mama's face or whatever I am really going after?

That tops anything.

yours Scott

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#24

Re: Let's Get Provocative

ThomD

That's an interesting perspective Scott, about the hand lapped. I kinda doubt it works that way. Wouldn't that be like wearing your own hand worn groove in a stone and believing it gave you great results because of it. Krenov had more or less said something of the sort...

It is one thing to discuss where the excellence in plane prep really pays off, and another to say neither maters. I wouldn't go that far. All else being equal I would take a sole that was prepped to the tens over one that wasn't I just wouldn't make it out to be a big deal in all cases.

I'm just about winding up this year's work at the cottage. 2 months of, to put it kindly, making do. It is amazing how one can leverage relatively modest features in a tool. The plane where the blade stays square to the sole. The chisel with the broken handle but the easily sharpened blade. Quite a cast of characters here. I generally get a lot done just because there are few distractions compared to the big shop in the city.

Re: Let's Get Provocative

#25

Re: Had a similar conversation...

ThomD

I got one of their blades and it wasn't that great, but on the other hand, you want 62 out of 01, how far wrong was he?