Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Shaker Oval Boxes

Posts

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#51

Re: Splitting wood

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Scott, no one has suggested that anyone can get straight wood from a froe, much less consistent thickness off the froe; but you can get to a reasonable starting point to apply spokeshaves and/or planes.

Pam

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#53

Re: Thanks, and

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I tried, but none of the links went to found pages. Oh, well.

Pam

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#54

further OT, sorry Pam

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Carla King's delightful story was originally produced as a series of dispatches as she rode her new Ural with sidecar around the USA boundary. It seems to have been converted to a book, maybe available at a library. She spent a long time in North Dakota, my home state, and really captured the spirit of the people there and most of the places she rode through. Part of the charm of the book is that her bike didn't work very well, and she details the work she put forth to trouble shoot the various electrical and fuel problems. She subsequently wrote another tome about her travels through India.

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#55

Re: Pam, how does it work and...

Fred Peake

I'm not sure why you would need a specially prepared plane. I just use an old smoother purchased off E-bay. A couple of scrap pieces of kumiko serve as the guides. I drilled the guides for mounting screws in both directions (thickness and width). I screw the guides to the sole of the plane to thickness the stock to 16mm, saw off the kumiko strips, then flip and remount the guides to thickness to 8mm.

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#56

Re: Pam, how does it work and...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I'm not saying anyone needs a hikouki, but the spring loaded wood compressor seems pretty handy.

Pam


Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#57

Clever

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

An interesting idea for thin and small-section stock, to keep it aligned on the benchtop.

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#58

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

Tim

And if they didn't use sliced veneer, they probably started with a quarter log and resawed the log into the bands. Then you get the lack of run out (because they'd use the logs that didn't split into straight quarter sections for something else) from being split and can make thin bands by resawing. It wouldn't surprise me if they took a log that was split into quarters and then further split on tangential lines to approximately the band width they wanted. I'm guessing a bit of the heartwood was tossed into the firewood pile or was used for bands for the tops since those are narrow.

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#59

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

Tim

I buy (because resawing and planing or sanding a quantity of bands is not worth it....) my bands from Wilson. They are sliced off a log just the same as they have been for a couple hundred years. It wouldn't surprise me if the Shakers used a knife-based veneer slicer to make their bands, same as they are made today.

Here is an internet reference where they state that sliced veneer was started in the 19th century.

http://www.davidrwebb.com/A-History-of-Veneer.405.0.html

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#60

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Interesting, Tim. What do the knives look like?

Pam

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#61

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

Barry

And, I'll buy your description of how the Shakers may have used sliced veneer for oval box sides.

I don't buy the Shakers hand planing box sides to as thin as 1/16". It would have taken too long and they made these boxes not just for their own use, but for sale. The profit margin would have been too narrow.

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#62

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

Tim

They look like great big thickness planer knives.

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#63

Stephen Shepherd

I am dubious

Stephen Shepherd

as to the date on that web site. I am sure that they were not introduced until the last quarter of the nineteenth century.

Stephen

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#64

Thanks.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#65

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I would think the Shaker economy was quite different from the US as a whole, and that while they had to reach a certain level of productivity for the community to survive, it probably wasn't necessary that every endeavor made a huge profit. After all, I doubt (as in I don't know for sure) that they paid wages to their workers; so all they'd have to do is sell things for a profit, but it could have been slight and the only costs were tools and supplies.

Pam

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#66

Re: Pam, how does it work and...

ThomD

OK missed that. Mine didn`t have a spring, not sure what it is good for, but I want it!

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#67

Re: Pam, how does it work and...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

You get just a bit more compression just before the edge does its thing. Same with Inomoto-san's version, but his (and the standard) mechanism is more complicated.

Pam

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#68

Re: I would agree, Bob

ThomD

Shingles are short, and they choose their woods carefully as to type. Back in that general period (and running on up to the 70s). There were many crates and baskets that used various veneers in their constructions, clearly banged out by machines, don`t know what type... Today the remaining versions I see use mostly plywood which means even thinner veneers. There are venner cutting machines that are non-rotary.

This guy says rived:

http://www.shakerovalbox.com/articles/building/

Gotta saunter over there and see him rive the wood for that box on the bottom:

http://www.shakerovalbox.com/

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#69

Moses Yoder

Re: Shaker personal property

Moses Yoder

The Shakers had very little personal property, I think actually their clothes was the only thing that was considered their property and any personal property was actually frowned upon. So they had no need to be paid wages; if I remember correctly everything was communal property, and all the money went into a community fund.

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#70

Re: Pam, how does it work and...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I would think it would also keep small pieces of stock from wiggling around quite so much.

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#71

Yeah, that, too.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#72

"Shingles are short..."

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

This is a regional thing. I've never seen them, but I've seen pictures of American colonial and later Appalachian shakes that were four feet long. I suspect this practice was adopted because they didn't have nails much, so the shakes would be held down with poles, held down, in turn, by rope; not something you'd want to do any more often than you had to.

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#73

Re: Pam, how does it work and...

ThomD

Makes sense. For the initial cuts the plane is pressing hard down on the strips. but just as the runners come in contact the blade is projecting from the sole, and there could be a lack of support on the top of the strip. I have never had a problem, but I mostly use mine for planing strips for canoes etc... and the wood is about as nice as can be. Normally I would put that kind of thing through the planer, as I am not looking for extra work, but it seems a pity to not handle such beautiful wood to plane.

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#74

Plus, I don't do tailed planers.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX