Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Shaker Oval Boxes

Posts

Shaker Oval Boxes

#1

Shaker Oval Boxes

Barry

My wife and I went to Shakertown at Pleasant Hill, KY over the holiday. We watched a craftsman building Shaker Oval Boxes from very thin stock. He said that he used a thickness sander.

How did the Shakers prepare their stock? They didn't have thickness sanders.

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#2

As far as I know...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

They were planned to thickness. No real Shaker would use a thickness sander. That is unless it was driven by a river or some other natural power source.

I do want to make a few one day...

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#3

Re: As far as I know...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Maybe they pealed the logs, kind of like the veneer makers do today?

Pam

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#4

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

Catharine Kennedy

They used a surface planer- Hancock Shaker Village has a belt driven Daniels planer as well a a crank & gear driven one- the flat stock having been bandsawn to close from the billets first. Several of the boxes in their collection still show the planer marks on the insides!

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#5

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

Barry

Thanks. I had always wondered about that. I was ust afraid the planers of of the day were not accurate enough to produce thin stock that was consistent enough in thickness for bending box sides. I don't think I would attempt to plane stock to a 1/16" thickness with my planer. And I'm sure it's manufacturing tolerances are closer than the machines of the 1800's. I think the only reason the Shakers didn't use thickness sanders was that they hadn't been invented yet. I'm just a bit disappointed they didn't invent one.

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#6

Re: As far as I know...

Barry

If they had had a thickness sander, they would have used it. The Shakers did use water power and also steam, I believe. We're talking about Shakers here, not the Old Order Amish.

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#7

Re: As far as I know...

Barry

That's an idea, but I don't think so. I've read where they preferred quarter-sawn maple for the sides and you don't get quarter-sawn stocck by peeling logs.

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#8

Re: As far as I know...

bugbear

unlikely - have you seen what that process involves?!?!

BugBear

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#9

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

Paul M.

Don't know how the shakers did it. But I built a couple of oval boxes in a steam bending class at the local junior college.

We just used a bandsaw to cut thin slices (about 3/32 inch), and then a few swipes with a handplane got them down to a 1/16th. Then taper one end so that it feathers out to almost nothing over the last 3 inches. Steam for 30 minutes and bend very quickly around a plywood form that is the shape of the inside of the box (feathered edge on the inside). Ya gotta bend quickly to do this before the wood cools, but evenly so that the wood doesn't break. Then secure with adequate quantities of bicycle innertubes around and around the bent form to hold the wood in shape while it cools.

The thin band for the top rim gets bent around the outside of the lower box on the jig. This helps you get a lid that exactly fits the box.

Clenched copper nails will hold the final box form together once the wood has accepted the bend.

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#10

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

Catharine Kennedy

generally the boxes were boiled rather than steamed- you can overboil but if you oversteam the wood will crack- the steam drives the moisture out of the wood. Besides for 1/16th it's rather "overkill" to use steam- that's what we used for the bowstems of rowing boats- steam is real good for 1 1/2" and better stock!

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#11

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes *LINK*

wilbur

Maybe they could have used something like this, if it was set for a thicker shaving. ;)


Marunaka Supersurfacer

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#12

scott grandstaff

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

scott grandstaff

We just used a bandsaw to cut thin slices (about 3/32 inch), and then a few swipes with a handplane got them down to a 1/16th.

I expect this is exactly how the shakers did it.

The Shakers were one of the

"the end of the world is coming at the end of the century" (19th) cults.

There were many of these.

Some stuck around and became established religions

(um, well,.. maybe, ....they meant the end of the next century?? Yeah that's the ticket......)

Since the Shakers didn't believe in sex of any kind, well, no more Shakers were forthcoming! (If you weren't getting a guaranteed express ride to heaven, and right now, the lifestyle was sort of a tough sell.)

Anyway, it was well into the industrial age when they were working wood. So if they weren't using a bandsaw they were doing it with a power saw of some kind, better believe it.

Probably unfinished on the inside and the outside quickly cleaned up with a plane. Most all were painted, so a super smooth finish was unnecessary.

yours Scott

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#13

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

Barry

I took a weekend class about 20 years ago. Our instructor had already prepared our stock for us. I suspect he used a thickness planer.

We cut the finger joints andfethered the opposite end of the side on a stationary belt sander. He had a copper box with a lid sitting on top of a double hot plate that we boiled the sides in. We bent them around a wooden form. Then, we slipped them off the form, held them with wooden clothespins (another Shaker invention) and went ahead and put in the copper nails. Then we forced wooden "former" into the top and bottom to hold their shape while they dried.

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#14

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

Barry

That's really cool. I saw a machine like this about 20 years ago. Same principle anyway.

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#15

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

Barry

It just seems like it would be really hard to hold a 1/16" piece of wood for handplaning and hard to get a consistent thickness. If there was technology available, the Shakers would have used it. Heck, they invented some pretty marvelous machines for that day and time. They had to do something with all of their spare time. There was no TV and no sex. What's a man (or woman) to do?

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#16

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

Stephen Shepherd

I have seen a lot of bent wood boxes and a few have shown signs of being split then planed or scraped. All worked green and as such can be bent without steaming or boiling. Or if dried can be boiled or steamed and bent, but I would bet they went for the easiest method.

As for the Daniel Planer being used to cut such thin stock for oval boxes, I would have to see the circular tool marks made by that planer. It was made to machine mine and bridge timbers and I would doubt it planed anything as thin as the sides of very thin oval boxes. The Daniel planer is a big piece of equipment.

Stephen

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#17

Ellis Walentine

According to John Kassay, ...

Ellis Walentine

... the earliest boxes were made entirely with hand tools. Later, they cut the sides, tops and bottoms using powered circular saws. I found no mention of bandsaws or planers or surfacers of any kind.

Ellis

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#18

Re: According to John Kassay, ...

Bob Hackett

It would make sense that the thin side pieces would be strongest and less likely to fail if they started out being riven rather than sawed.

Wood that will not split correctly is more prone to cracking/breaking when bent.

Riving the wood would also be a whole lot faster than sawing too.

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#19

Re: According to John Kassay, ...

Barry

Of course, the Shakers had to invent the circular saw first.......... :-)

If that is the case, the Shakers had to work to some very close tolerances to make box sides that were thin enough and consistent enough to bend properly. When I think about how they may have done it, all sorts of questions come to mind. How did they hold wood that was planed to 1/16"? They turned these boxes out by the hundreds and thousands. How did they produce thin stock in sufficient quantities, using only hand tools? I took a class about 20 years ago and actually made five of these boxes. It's a tough task even with an array of modern tools available. What the Shakers did in the early to mid-1800's is nothing short of amazing.

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#20

Some debate about the Shaker invention *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

of the circular saw.

Wikipedia's got a nice summary, but plenty of other websites have theories too.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circular_saw

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#21

Re: According to John Kassay, ...

Jim Crammond in Monroe, Mi.

Barry,

I've made quite a few Shaker oval boxes and most of them were planed. I cut the bands on a band saw, then clamped the bands to the bench at the rear of the band and planed away from the clamp so that the band is in tension, not compression. With a sharp iron, a fine set plane and some care, it is fairly easy to do. All you are really trying to do is remove the saw marks. Also, when sawing the bands, care is taken to follow the grain closely, if not with even a small amount of run out in the grain, it won't bend well.

Jim Crammond

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#22

Re: According to John Kassay, ...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

One really neat way to plane to very thin thicknesses is to use a Hikouki. Here's one (this is actually an alternative type) I just bought from Iida-san.

Pam


Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#23

Planing a 1/16" thick board

wilbur

It seems to me that it would be relatively easy to tack 1/16" strips to a known flat surface to form a rectangular U-shaped channel the width of the side of the Shaker box that you want to make. Then the 1/16" strips can serve as a depth stop of sorts for the plane. Resaw a Shaker box side about 3/32" thick, lay it down in the rectangular U-shaped channel, and plane down until you hit the tacked down 1/16" strips.

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#24

Re: Some debate about the Shaker invention

Barry

My wife and I were at Pleasant Hill earlier this week. They had no hesitation about claiming credit for the invention of the circular saw, flat broom, wooden clothspins and many other things. Of course they could be a little biased.

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#25

Re: According to John Kassay, ...

Barry

I have made a few Shaker boxes, but the stock was already prepared by someone else. Maybe it's not as hard as I imagined. I don't do a lot of hand planing but your explanation sounds logical.