Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Shaker Oval Boxes

Posts

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#26

Re: According to John Kassay, ...

Barry

This method might prove difficult on bands for the wider Shaker boxes.

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#27

Ellis Walentine

I would agree, Bob

Ellis Walentine

If you've ever riven an oak shingle, you know how cleanly a straight-grained log can be split. A single large log section from a good-sized maple or cherry tree, with the right froe arrangement, could yield hundreds of box sides (bands?) with no waste at all. Sounds pretty Shakeresque to me. Also, a very thin stop block would probably work pretty well for planing the pieces. I can even see a three sided arrangement, with 1/16" stops on both sides and one end, acting as depth gauges for the plane.

Ain't conjecture grand?

Ellis

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#28

Pam, how does it work and...

Kevin Adams

what are you going to use it for if you don't mind me asking? I've never seen that on Tomohito's site, did you special order?

Thanks for sharing.

Kevin

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#29

Re: Pam, how does it work and... *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I have a lot of shoji to build, thus a pile of kumiko, which are roughly 6mm thick. This plane will be used for those kumiko. Tomohito-san recently put it on his web site, see link below.

I had wanted to get the Inomoto-san version (http://japantool-iida.com/plane_others/2008/07/hikouki-kanna-by-inomoto.html), but it was too expensive for me at the time. This is the one that John Fox uses on the St. Roy episode. So Tomohito-san suggested that his friend Omichi-san had come up with a versiion that's a lot cheaper to make and it could be made from any basic smoother. I thought that the 48mm Meigo-Ryomo block plane would be more than wide enough for my project, at least to start with, so I commissioned Tomohito-san & Omichi-san to make me the cheaper version. Omichi-san said it was a great plane for kumiko (I know, he was probably just flattering me), and it does seem to be just what I need, has a much simpler spring mechanism.

If I need to plane thinner pieces (all to the same size, which is a key attribute of this method), I just cut some thinner rails and attach.

Pam


Tsunesaburo block plane based Hikouki

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#30

Why?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#31

Re: Pam, how does it work and...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I understand how that would work, and how very useful it would be. BUT, I hafta say, Pam, that if I had gone to the trouble to make a plane, it would nearly kill me to drive a screw into it, whether it was supposed to be there or not. :D

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#32

Re: Why?

Barry

Although no scale is given, the Hikouki appears to be about 4" wide. Some of the larger Shaker boxes have sides/bands that are much wider than that.

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#34

Re: Why?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Well, I'm not suggesting that the Shakers used a hikouki equivalent to plane the boxes, but they probably did something similar, such as Wilbur's suggestion above, for at least the bigger boxes.

Pam

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#35

Re: Pam, how does it work and...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Hmmm, maybe you use too many metal planes? Or you've never made a dai? Once you feel comfortable being able to make a replacement, you get a lot more casual about mucking about. Although, the reason I went the block plane route was because I didn't want to send one of my precious smoothers to Japan for mutilation. :)

Pam

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#36

Re: Why?

Barry

It's a shame there are no Shaker box makers on Wood Central so we could just ask them how they did it. :-)

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#37

Not a very good one, and then

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

you've got to use the noisy beast and breath the sawdust. I don't see going to 6mm with one of those beasts nor do I see putting up with the snipe.

Pam

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#38

Re: Why?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yeah, but while there are many ways to accomplish woodworking tasks, there aren't that many viable and available 100 years ago. We can make some educated guesses.

Pam

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#39

Re: Pam, how does it work and...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

"too many metal planes"

"never made a dai"

guilty as charged on both counts.

I know I need to wander further afield, but there are only so many hours. And what with summer too short and woodwork having to compete with motorcycle time...

Maybe it's time for a warmer clime

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#40

Thanks, Pam, very helpful.

Kevin Adams

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#41

scott grandstaff

Splitting wood

scott grandstaff

There has been some theory advanced about possibly splitting wood bouts up to 2 feet long, under 1/4" thick and ~6 or more inches wide.

I have a froe and a club. I've had several over the years.

I have covered entire buildings and shed roofs in split shakes.

I have also split a lot of wood for many purposes, fine and rough woodworking, not to mention keeping my household warm on nothing but wood these past 40 years.

Anyway, it ain't happening. No way are you splitting off thousands or even hundreds of thin planks with any particle of regularity. Wood simply does not cooperate this well.

You will be super lucky to get as little as 1/2" deviation from one end of a 16" plank, to the other end.

Much less an accurate 1/4" plank straight from the 1/4 round.

Even when busting out turning sticks (from the very cream of the most perfect stick you can imagine) you still have to even them up with a broad hatchet to get them close enough to even mount on your lathe.

If wood could be split into planks this easy, everyone would be doing it and look around, nobody does. Barrel staves, turning billits and large timbers, these are the things people split out and there is extensive adze, ax and drawknife work to get them workable from there.

My friend Mike lives near the very top of the mountain. Its a rough life but he likes it. At high altitude, in this country, there are occasionally old growth Port Orford cedars. This the the cream de la creme of splitting wood. Like buttah and smells good too. But not even Port Orford would allow planks anywhere near this precise.

I honestly don't know how the shakers sawed their thin planks for oval boxes, but they didn't split them.

Believe me, I've tried.

yours Scott

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#42

Re: Splitting wood

Barry

I tend to agree. I've been woodworking for a long time and no way could I do this. I seriously doubt if the Shakers could have either.

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#43

Come on now!

Bob Hackett

Man if there was anybody out there who had wood that would rive out to finished sizes for shaker boxes I`d bet he could sell is for more than a book matched set of figured violin wood!

Unless I`ve had it all wrong for years the whole idea of splitting or riving any wood is to get a piece of wood of rough size(within realistic limits) that has minimal grain run out.Having the grain run the entire length of the rough piece adds the strength you need for bending or to help overcome shear forces(like in riven dowels and pins).

The old saying of "Split thick and shave thin" kind of explained the process I thought.

You guys are WAY to literal for me,I hope my mom doesn`t find out about this,she won`t let me hang out here no more if she does. :O

Split it then plane/hew/sand/adze/carve/etc,as needed till the desired effect is achieved,THEN bend it.

Next thing I know you`ll be complaining that a split surface doesn`t accept milk paint properly. :b

Oh,and another thing,Nobody I know has a saw in their shop that can cut 4+ rough plank from a good bolt of quarter sawn straight grained wood as quick as a noobie with a good froe and club after minimal instruction,and I know some folks with some big old whiz-bang saws sporting an assortment of bells and whistles. :D

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#44

scott grandstaff

Re: Splitting wood

scott grandstaff

This is actually very easy to prove. Anyone can do it and everyone should.

Try it yourself.

Take any plank you already have. The straightest creamiest 1/4 sawed wood scrap you own. Any species.

Cut off a real short piece of it. 3" is enough.

Now take a chisel and split it.

Not so bad, huh? Splits right off and not awful looking at first glance.

But take a closer look. Take a real close look.

Let your eye travel down the surface you just split.

Now lay your newly split surface down on any genuinely flat surface. Try to rock it and see how out of true it really is??

Slide it across a piece of coarse sandpaper a couple strokes.

Look again, real close.

The paper will flatten the highest parts but its the lowest parts you have to get all the way true for an actual surface.

Now, in your minds eye, magnify this up 200 times and imagine what you could ever hope to get straight from the froe.

Se what I mean?

yours Scott

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#45

Re: According to John Kassay, ...

ThomD

I made one of those japanese planes about 10 years ago and have planed a lot of 1/4" strips with it, Might work on the smallest shaker boxes, but not on the wide and thin stock in the larger ones.

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#46

Re: According to John Kassay, ... riving

ThomD

"It would make sense that the thin side pieces would be strongest and less likely to fail if they started out being riven rather than sawed."

This riv for strength thing is a myth. Riving can easily wander so that the parts aren't aligned to the grain, which is why there is all that tech about apply the bend on the side you want to run to, or spliting larger pieces down the middle.

With a saw, it is very easy to cut with the grain, one simply has to want to. If one starts with store bought lumber the waste can be massive, so people don't bother (other reasons beyond waste, such as optimizing figure, etc...).

Another problem area is imperfect wood. There is lots of that around, much of it just fine for loaded products, consider the run-out on aircraft graded wood in 1-30, which would be terrible quality for many traditional products, and not a good basis for riving, but is structurally fine for all kinds of stuff including bending. I have bent extremely short grain woods for guitars, one often can't tell at all that it is short grained, until a piece breaks, since tropical woods don't have "grain", no seasonal growth differences to show the way.

"Wood that will not split correctly is more prone to cracking/breaking when bent."

That is generally true with exceptions for stuff with rowed grain, and other splitting nightmares like curly or twist, that may not affect strength negatively. The extreme example being knees and crooks. Yeah, these are pretty picky examples, but this whole riving thing is wrong on so many counts, and has become received wisdom, so a few contrary examples might be tolerated.

"Riving the wood would also be a whole lot faster than sawing too."

Riving where possible is very fast, I sure prefer splitting wood for the fire to any alternative. That said, it is often a nightmare. For instance splitting curly wood is tougher than sawing, and leaves deep curls that need to be planed away at great effort/waste. Also, while my farm may be the exception, and all the others I have taken wood from, I is really difficult to find that John Alexander wood that just falls apart without any twist, or curl, etc... Just recently working on some balks for planes I had to re-split a lot of beech to appropriate sizes. Anyway, it was hard work. And these were mostly 16" in length and stiff, like firewood. So many pieces that would hang up at some point, a little bend somewhere, and some really nice curly beech also. In my Oak lot, I have never taken a piece of oak, and some of the trees looked perfect, that was John Alexander quality. These guys use veneer grade logs, which must be mutants, or like .001 percent.

While on the one hand the wood resources are declining, on the other you can get almost any wood of any quality you could possibly want today. If one looks at masterpiece guitars from the 19C, they had pretty dodgy wood you would not put in a discount store guitar these days. So what about the Shakers, were they sourcing wood like Spanish Guitar maker Tores, or like modern day John Alexander? If they were taking a lot of it off their own property they were probably sawing it.

And then there is the issue of the ease of splitting really long stuff. That gets a lot harder, and some of those boxes have a fair circumference.

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#47

Daniels planer and question for Catharine *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Stephen and all,

Attached is a litho and description of a Daniels planer, itself a simplification of an earlier English planer. Rotary cutting head.

In reading Catharine's post, I didn't assume that the Shakers were running superthin 1/16" stock through the planer. But rather than they would start with a larger stock; run the stock piece through the planer to get one face flat; then take the stock piece through a saw to shave off a 3/32" or 1/8" slice, sufficient for several boxes--rough thickness being whatever was required to finish out at 1/16".

The main stock could then be returned to the planer to true the face again. And repeat. I'm obviously speculating, but tend to give a lot of credibility to Catharine's report. She surely learned a lot of Shaker lore in her time as master carpenter at Hancock Village, and she saw the planing tracks herself.

Catharine, could you describe the planer tracks you saw on the wood?

Thanks, Wiley


OWWM on Daniels planer

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#48

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Daniels planer and question for Catharine

Stephen Shepherd

The Daniels planer will leave circular score marks similar to circular saw marks. I don't know who invented the circular saw but by 1814 you could buy a 36" diameter circular saw blade. That would mean you could cut up to about 15 inch thick wood, so rough sawn thin slabs of any length would be easily cut.

I don't know how the Shakers made their boxes. However I do know that it is possible to split hammered ash and oak to very thin strips of long lengths.

Stephen

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#49

Re: Pam, how does it work and... *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Aha, another biker. Well don't even think of starting to read the article below, it will eat a day of time. :)

Pam


Zambian adventure

Re: Shaker Oval Boxes

#50

Thom, I know you know how to make dai. 

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX