We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I recoil at much "modern" furniture that is designed to be different for the sake of being different. If someone walks up to a piece and the first thing they say(and see) is, "look, the drawer sizes don't progress from bottom to top" the design has failed to be most pleasing. It is simply different, and possibly repulsive.
It took me a bit to notice the irregular spacing on the Stickley piece- success. It was the first thing I noticed on the other-failure.
>I was recently able to see this article and I wish I had seen it in time to pen a letter to the editor(author). Maybe George sees this Forum and will respond.
The article begins with examples of classic furniture. I got to see the Philadelphia piece in detail and it is certainly deserving of the place it stands in the museum. Then the article goes on to detail a simple way to lay out one of the "formula" means of spacing drawers.
But these two sections were never tied together. Do the pieces described in the beginning use this formula for establishing their drawer spacing or was the spacing arrived at empirically so as to be most pleasing for the rest of the design? I was left wondering about the prevalence of this formula in classic furniture design.
Why do 2 pieces that have so much in common differ so that one passes easily and yet one fails obviously?
Most looking at them would just pass it off as attention to detail but would that really cover the design aspects such as the slight visual swell in the waist of the Stickley piece?What caused old Gus to incorporate that slight curve?Isn`t that curve a bit "outside the box" for his established style?
When I think Stickley or Greene&Greene I think Craftsman style and furniture that was very angular in profile.I know both dipped into curves with things like cloud lift details and curved inlays and glass work but a curved profile seems a real departure.Looking at the Ikea you realize that he did it to make the piece successful as the slab sided Ikea`s profile failed the "visually pleasing" test.
Would it be correct to say that ease of manufacture was what trimmed the difference away?If practicality and function is what brought that wide drawer up from the bottom then why don`t we see it on Shaker pieces?All things to think about when designing a piece we can be comfortable with,something that is both easy to live with and looks balanced and correct.
It`s not an easy task to design anything that needs to be functional on a day to day basis and yet remain bright.A piece that works in harmony with it`s surroundings,performs it`s duties well and still draws our attention in a subtle way.So many times we seem to miss it by just the width of a shaving and the piece says a little too loudly "Look at this wood", "isn`t he talented" or "Look how I fill this space".
I think whenever we sit down to design something we hope for the result to be like music that is barely heard from a distance yet catches your attention.We are caught up in it without really knowing why and we are drawn to the source.When the tune becomes more clear we recognize we were compelled to come over as opposed to just ignoring it and continuing what were were doing or finding that it intruded on our thoughts and we just wished it to stop.When we appreciate it`s balance,it`s presence,it`s perfectly modulated voice,when what it says speaks to us in words we feel instead of hear then that project is closest to what the designer had hoped,a piece that will stand the test of time.We find ourselves humming that tune long after the station has moved on to the next song,and it makes us appreciate it all the more.
>I like this Stickley piece for a number of reasons which have been well articulated in other posts. There's one feature I like that hasn't been mentioned, namely how the drawer layout gives each individual drawer a location that is easy to remember. Something like "small drawer, left side, middle" or "large drawer, bottom." Compare that to a highboy with five full-width drawers that don't differ much in height. I'd never remember which drawer something was in and would be continually pulling out one drawer after another looking for stuff.
My kitchen has a bank of four drawers and even after 20 years I sometimes get the two middle drawers mixed up, but never the top and bottom ones. I guess "upper middle" and "lower middle" are not quite distinct enough for my feeble brain.
I liked Bill's drawer layout because it broke up the top rows of drawers into twos and threes, so that a piece with many drawers still gave each drawer more of an individual identity.
On the topic of design systems, I have a file somewhere with articles on how the Golden Section or some other mathematical ratio is the reason this or that great building or painting is successful. Sometimes it's supposed to be the fact that this part is exactly twice or three times the size of that one, and sometimes it's the fact that the ratio between parts is an irrational number. I believe a better guide is to just look at something and notice "top heavy" or "too narrow" or "looks good." Art is seldom made or appreciated by the conscious, rational part of our minds alone.
I am lucky enough to have 2 18th century chests, one a Pennsylvania secretary, the other an English (I think) Butler's chest. The drawers on the secretary are 4", 5", 6", 7" high. The Butler's chest are the same - 4", 5", 6", 7", with a fifth drawer 8" high. On this chest the first two drawers are not actually drawers at all, but part of a front that pulls out and folds down to allow access to a desk-like area; the front is designed so that it appears to be two drawers, 4" and 5" in height. I agree with your observation that the 8" drawer is too high and not very useable if filled.
>George is an interesting guy, and quite approachable. We're tickled that he'll be writing for us at Popular Woodworking on a regular basis. If you enjoyed the article, you should also investigate his DVD available from Lie-Nielsen. Link below is to George's blog, also a great resource.
>I have that problem in my shop, because, thanks to years of accumulation and a tool inheritance from my uncle, I have enough tools to choke the 20-mule-team Borax team - mechanical, plumbing, electrical, leather and fabric (not much there), sheet metal, masonry/sheetrock/etc. - and, as a result, four rollaway toolboxes. Mostly I know what's where, but I have moments of standing paralyzed in the shop trying to remember, or opening a drawer, only to say bad words and try another.
I've slowly started to put those plastic label strips on, a workable solution in the shop, but unlikely to win approval from the kitchen god/goddess. For prettier locations than my shop, card holders might work, and be good for guests, too.
Not that I've done this, or even proposed it, for our kitchen - it's so far down the priorities list we'll probably move first.
>I like the arithmetic pogression linked-to by Ace Karner's msg - in distinct contrast to golden, fibonacci, or Hambridge progressions - all of which can lead to too much difference in drawer heights. An arithmetic progression can be as simple as adding or subtracting something like 1" (or increment of your choice) - to each successive drawer, so that it works between the largest and smallest drawer height you find useful (not always an integer)
A number of articles on furniture design repeat the myth that the golden section was used for the parthenon or pyramids - but researchers and writers who are not part of the golden cult have countered that there is no real evidence of its use in architecture, or in the associated literature -- until about the renaissance, and even then only in a very limited way (when Pythagorean integer ratios were used the most). The Greeks knew about it as a mathematical concept, but most probably did not use it in architecture.
Case furniture usually models architecture. Not the human body. So columnar stability issues are usually in effect. Most bodies are divided into 3's and 6's. At least that's how Da Vinci saw it.
Adam
PS Fat is not structure. Fat just sits on top of the structure underneath. That structure is fairly typical, and even on folks who are a bit heavy, is still evident.
>I said "So much furniture seems to have been designed using the human form as a model...", so no claims on "most;" however, I should perhaps have said "many furniture parts," which I think indisputable. All you have to do is look at the bottom shaped aprons of large chests to see the hint of genitals, whether it's a male or female case, look at the legs and feet, look at the arms and hands, it's everywhere; and I think it ingenious to also apply that design to the middle of a chest by giving it more weight.
Fat is not structure? Because I said hips instead of pelvis? Who are you anymore?
>I will agree that structure in furniture models(or should model) that in architecture,the same universal principles apply.
Where things branch off is in designing the total piece.
Architecture is bound by the shape we have commonly agreed on to be the most useful based on how we divide land,especially in built up areas.It is a slave to function,it needs to be as we have adapted most of the materials used to build it to accommodate that repeated shape or something close to it.
Furniture,on the other hand,occupies the interior of that shape.While it still must rely on the same principles for sound structure in order to be balanced and stable it allows us far more ability to express our own tastes in dressing that structure.Just because we live in a box doesn`t mean our furniture needs has be boxy.Furniture should compliment architecture in order to present a more balanced total picture within the room but it does not need to echo it.Our furniture gives us a chance to say what we feel about the space we make a home.When the house is sold we take that furniture to the next house and recreate that feeling of home.
Pam said that much furniture design stems from the human form.I`d like to expand on that and say most interior design (to include furniture) is trying to touch ORGANIC form and break away from the angular,ridgid constraints of the boxes we are led to live in.When I say organic I mean "of nature".Humans are only a small part of nature.Look at the over all feel of a piece taking in the balance,profile and especially the details and,with the possible exception of Shaker furniture(this too has it`s exceptions.Look at Shaker boxes),you see someone trying to reach out to something organic.Details especially tend toward taking inspiration from the natural world.
Your argument implies that architecture has been driven by how we have chosen to divide up land. I think the driving force may have been not that but physics.
Disclaimer: I am not a student of the history of architecture, so this might politely be considered speculation (there are less polite words for it).
Except for the occasional Mystery Spot, gravity works vertically at all times, and load paths* thus tend toward the vertical as a structure becomes larger. In small and simple structures, this isn't necessary - tepees or huts woven from saplings. But as the structures get larger, the need for a good load path becomes more important. Thus the Greco-Roman construction methods from which our buildings are descended; but there is parallel development of the same idea elsewhere, such as the Hopi pueblos.
Buildings with multiple stories require horizontal design elements, since a flat floor is more desirable than a humped or randomly slanted one.
All of this leads toward rectilinearity in core design.
I think there may be a similar logic in furniture. Large case furniture becomes far more complex if the load path isn't vertical.
I do agree with you that furniture details, and even (to some degree) the core design of small furniture, often references organic design elements. But even in pieces that could be far more organic without suffering failure, the load path seems to tend toward the vertical - I suspect because it is simplest from an engineering perspective. There's nothing that intrinsically requires that the pedestal on a piecrust table be in the center - but, if it weren't, a lot more engineering would be required to make it stable. Rustic furniture, which is often asymmetrical, is also often overbuilt as one engineering solution to this problem.
Now, I am no doubt culture-bound on this question - but I do think the argument can be made that verticality and symmetry may have been the simplest solutions to structural problems, rather than constraints stemming from the rectilinearity of past surveyors. After all, to my knowledge neither the Hopi nor the Kwakwaka'wakw (formerly known as the Kwakiutl) of the Pacific Northwest employed surveyors, but, for different logical reasons, they both came to the decision to make rectilinear houses.
*I believe this was originally an engineering term. It's in common use now in building to describe how the load from the upper elements of the building - roof, floors, etc. - are transmitted down to the foundation. I'm using it in that context.
>Nice treatise, but I think that people build human shaped furniture under the assumption that said furniture will fit people better. Kind of like why people build robots with human like features. That these furnitures make our houses more habitable is a nice byproduct. Maybe.
This is an excellent probe into the nature of things. Very thought provoking!
I agree with you that we humans do have an innate drive to ornament things (even if it doesn't need it--look at a screw-arm plough plane for example). And we do strive for some sort of connection in these ornaments--with human touch, or with organic forms.
>Here is a pic of a small jewelry chest I made with graduated drawers and graduated pulls. The height and width were determined by the size of the camphor boards I had for the case. I had intended to have 7 drawers but it ended up looking best with eight divisions.
I never design by drawing and prefer to just design as I build. I don't use any formulas, but I am aware of the principles of good design and when I get stuck I look to these for guidance. These would be things like rhythm, repetition balance, focal point, negative space....There is a an intuitiveness that as a designer you have or you don't but for these that don't relying on the principles of good design rather than a mathematical formula will lead you in the right direction.
For graduated drawers start with a full scale mock up and divide the drawers such that one drawer looks perfectly in between the one above and below, not between as in exactly half way but in a balanced way that if it was any larger it would be too close in size to the one below, or if it were any smaller it would look too close to the one above it. Chances are if you measure it will be a bit bigger than half way between the two, but resist the temptation to use your ruler for anything other than a straight edge until you are happy with the lay out and then only use your rule to transfer the measurements to the boards, don't think about the numbers just build it.
>While the concept of doing a mock up is straightforward , in fact the details of doing it for a chest of drawers 4 feet high is less obvious? What might the mock up be built from? How detailed does it need to be, for example does the thickness of the sides need to be represented? What elements are important to mock up? How would different sizes of drawers be readily tested in the mock up?
Your answer to the question of drawer sizing is exactly the same as what I got from conversations with others that I consider good designers. They don't use formulas. And in fact the idea of doing mock ups seemed to be a common practice each time I have visited College of Redwood, a place that excels in design.
However, I have never seen a discussion of mock up techniques- the tricks of the trade. Please share you insights and, magazine editors that might be prowling this site, this topic could be of general interest to your readers.
BTW, lovely jewelry case. Pleasant to look- a natural consequence of good design.
>I also like both the approach and the piece in the pic.
I`ve probably already mentioned it but for those looking for books on design,I found Stephen Hogbin`s Appearance & Reality to be an excellent resource.
I think it was an article in Woodwork magazine I read awhile back that went thru the full scale mock up process using corrugated cardboard and hot glue as materials.IIRC the author went from small scale models made from popsicle sticks or wire models to the cardboard.
My question is;I hear a lot of craftspeople say that they come across a concept they want to develope and only make the most basic drawings to set it in their minds.
Those folks felt the same way I used to feel.Once you make a full scale drawing or especially a full mock up then it`s almost as if the project has been completed and you`re anxious to move on to the next.
For them once the idea has a life in 3D the enthusiasm fades and the real piece just becomes making a duplicate,something that someone who builds "one off" furniture tend to shy away from.
What are some of the things you do to keep from settling into that mindset while the mock up is nearing completion?
>Making some thing out of cardboard would not satisfy any of my primal urges to build and create. I always suspected people with a talent for design were wired different.
>We (Popular Woodworking) had a two-part article in October and November 2007 that covered this to some extent. The author was Ted Brown, a COR graduate and founder of a COR type school.
I think the methods of mocking-up in cardboard or whatever of limited value. I think it's more about appearing artistic (composing instead of designing) and putting off the actual work of making something. To go back to your drawer-sizing question that started all of this, you can get a perfectly good idea of what works and what doesn't with a scale drawing, or full-size marks on a story board. The design process and drawing skills are all about getting the vision in your head into a buildable form in an efficient way. If I need to build it to envision it, or communicate what I envision, I need to back up a few steps and practice my sketching and drawing. Life is short and I doubt I'll live long enough to make every piece I'd like to make. I don't have time for setting cardboard boxes on the bench and spending an hour or so staring at them, even though that might make me appear to be an artist rather than a cabinetmaker.
>For the jewelry box in the picture I used the walnut board that all the drawers were cut from for the mock up. I drew pencil lines and erased them until I had want I wanted. For other mockups I never do a full 3d build out of another material such as cardboard. I guess what I do is more of a story board vs. a story stick. For drawer divisions it is important to be able to see the full size of the entire drawer front. This is where those design principles come in. I need to see them full size to be able to determine the balance and rhythm. I suppose balance is easy enough to understand, in this case it refers to the overall balance and not too top heavy or bottom heavy. Rhythm is probably a new term to most on this board. It refers to the rate of change or cadence you develop with the graduations. You don�t want one of the drawers to be too close in size to one of its neighbors or you will create a pause in the rhythm. While this can be a desired effect in most cases of graduated drawers it is not desirable to have a break in the rhythm. I prefer 1/8" MDF for doing full size drawings. I can sand off an old drawing or cut it up and make templates out of it.
For a commissioned piece I usually do a scale model. It allows me to design in real 3d. I have a rather extensive background in figurative drawing as well as drafting and auto-cad but I do my best design work in actual 3 dimensions. Perhaps it is partly due to my extensive use of curves which don't always translate well to paper.
For scale models I don't do any joinery but rely on butt joints and super glue, there are no drawers but rather solid blocks of wood with pencil lines to indicate the drawers. The intent of the model is to show the overall shape of the piece and the scale of the legs in relation to the case. I use bass wood because it lacks a prominent grain pattern to detract from the design. Many edge profiles do not translate well at scale so sometimes I leave edges square for this reason sometimes I leave them square because this is a detail I decide on as I am building. I photograph the models using a point of view with the camera that would mimic if the piece were full size. It takes me about the same amount of time to make a model as it does to come up with a design on paper.
The picture is of a model for a silver chest. I think you can see the pencil lines on the front to indicate the drawers. The overall height of the model is 17".
>Here is a picture of the silver chest as built from the model in the prevois post. AS you can see the general shaps is the same as the model. Details such as the pulls and the lorge shallow bevle around the band of drawers were decided on as I was building the chest. The overall heoght of the chest is 68"