Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Need drawer sizing advice

Posts

Need drawer sizing advice

#1

Need drawer sizing advice

Bill Tindall

>I need to make a chest of drawers about 4 ' high. The drawer pattern will be 3 drawers side by side at the top followed by 2 side by side and then 1,1,1- 5 ranks of drawers high for a total of 8 drawers. The question is how to size the drawer heights to be pleasing and not wind up with a ridiculously deep drawer at the bottom like many mathematical progressions lead to.

If you have such a unit in hand or picture in a book, or a flair for design, please advise.

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

#2

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>No experience with this, but I recall reading one article on a chest with dust frames in between each drawer that suggested adding the thickness of the dust frame to each drawer width - so, increasing from the top by 3/4" per drawer (1-1/2" for the third drawer, relative to the first, etc.). Even if your drawer has no divisions between drawers, you might try something like that.

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

#3

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Bill,

I got out a couple of Period furniture books, and began taking some measurements, just for scale. Turns out there were a lot of 4-drawer chests, while 5-drawer are quite hard to find.

The books I checked were Jeffrey Greene's "American Furniture of the 18th Century", and also "Connecticut Valley Furniture: Eliphalet Chapin and His Contemporaries, 1750-1800".

There were a couple of surprises for me. First surprise concerns Golden Section. My measuring (from book photographs) of numerous examples of Period furniture had led me to be skeptical of Golden Section claims. However, in measuring a number of examples of 4-drawer chests, I was amazed to find that if you measure from the floor to the top of the 2nd drawer from the bottom (but not including its divider; just to the top of the drawer), that distance is very close to 62% of the total height from floor to top of cornice or chest top. By the way, all these chests were roughly square in terms of height by width.

There was some variation in the drawer gradation. However, the most typical gradation was along the lines of 4-1/2, 5-1/2, 6-1/2, 7-1/2, with 1" dividers, meaning that the width of an upper drawer plus its divider equals the width of the next drawer down. Another typical sequence similar at 5-1/2, 6-1/2, 7-1/2, 8-1/2, again with 1" dividers.

In terms of variations, the most typical was that sometimes the uppermost drawer was a bit undersized compared to the remaining sequence--for example, 3-1/2, 5, 6, 7. However, in all cases the biggest percentage increase is width is from the first drawer to the second. Usually the percentage increases follow a consistent decline as you go down the stack. However, Jeffrey Greene's book, p. 229, has the biggest increase from 1st to 2nd drawer, which is typical, but the second largest increase is between the bottom two drawers. Greene's example does follow the Golden Section rule above, with the dividing line being the top of the 2nd drawer from the bottom.

I will send you a couple of typical scans from the Connecticut Valley book offline; I don't think it's OK to show them online without permission.

Don't know if the golden section thing will adapt to 5 drawers. However, the message from the Connecticut Valley in particular seems to be to start with a gradation where each drawer + its divider equals the width of the next drawer down.

Wiley

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

#4

George Walker on Design

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>That George Walker dvd from LN says, more or less, forget golden this and that, the proportions used represent some whole number factor. I've only watched this once a few months ago and am not home now, so I can't help you out for about two weeks; but probably several others here have studied it.

Pam

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

#5

what I have learned so far......

Bill Tindall

>1. There isn't any magic formula that "everyone" uses for determining drawer heights. It may be that there isn't a formula that any two people use! I have yet to encounter two progressions that are the same in my research so far. This discovery is a surprise.

2. The looks of the cabinet don't seem to be critically dependent on making this decision. This tentative hypothesis comes as a surprise to me. When I asked the question I presumed the progression of sizes seen in "quality work" would be constrained to but a few possibilities.

3. From what I have gleaned, in a 5 drawer high cabinet the first two ranks are(can be) the same height which reduces the problem to 4 heights to proportion.

4. The "book" formulas involving some mathematical progressions lead to ridiculously large bottom drawers in a 4 rank cabinet. An 8" drawer is acceptable but considered big in my mind. I don't know how anything bigger would be practically used.

5. I had never encountered the " depth of one above plus drawer divider thickness" approach for establishing the progression but it is certainly simple to use and leads to a practical progression of sizes. I will draw this progression up and see how it looks.

Thanks to all who offered assistance...........

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

#6

Re: Need drawer sizing advice *LINK*

Ace Karner

>Did a search and found this site maybe these one of these can help.


Woodbin

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

#7

Thoughts on The Golden this or that........

Bill Tindall

>I have never built anything from someone else's plans which has led to many hours at the drawing board drawing possibilities of cabinetry. From time to time I get reminded of the Golden Rectangle and try to incorporate it into something. Invariably these "book" proportions lead to something that is too narrow for its height ( or width and depth). For all the press it gets I too question its practical value in making practical stuff like table tops and chests of drawers.

Wily has discovered this rectangle incorporated in some handsome chests of drawers, but in these cases it is some subset of the overall size of the piece. Given enough degrees of freedom- drawer sub sets, moldings, feet, top etc. - maybe it is just fortuitous that a Golden Rectangle can be found in some part of handsome stuff. Or maybe not. I'm not yet ready to dismiss the concept for ever.

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

#8

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

Bob Hackett

>I understand that you enjoy making pieces that give more than a passing nod to history.I also know that you are a very accomplished woodworker with an impressive portfolio of fine work.That being said and in light of your research,here`s my suggestions.

1-Put your practiced eye to work and just throw the calculators in the drawer.When you come up with a drawing that pleases you then you can be sure the rest of us will be impressed by the design.

2-If you`re looking for a jumping off point,might I further suggest you try letting form follow function.Maybe let what you plan to store in the smaller top drawers set their size(within reason) and then build and balance from there.

All this is probably not much help in finding that secure footing to step off into a new project and I`m sure you`ve thought of both these things but when I saw the posts offering math solutions I just felt the calculated solutions would fall short of your talents and taste.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

#9

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Wiley

I find it interesting that you could discover a formula that binds those pieces together.

I must admit that I am a little skeptical that anyone actually set out with rule in hand to apply the Golden Sections. I just don;t believe that it occurs like this. On the other hand, I do accept that there is a Golden Section, and that this represents a balance of proportions. What I believe is that we can - and do - detect this instinctively, and that this is the reason why it is discovered in so much art and artistry.

When I design I do so without more than the roughest of sketches and a general idea of the dimensions. How these come together is a combination of intuition and mental imagery. In other words, because it looks right. Not ideal and not professional, and more art than science.

Bill, here is a chest of drawers I made several years ago with graduated drawers. No mathematics. I just played around with pieces of cardboard until it looked right to me.



Hope this helps.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

#10

you are correct.......

Bill Tindall

>I was looking for a place to start the design journey. I foolishly thought someone had decided in 1680 how to best lay out drawers and it only remained for me to discover it. I even feared that I would find that the numerous chests of drawers I have empirically built would, in retrospect, look poorly proportioned for having failed to follow the 1680 rule. I easily suffer delusions.

I was really surprised though at the variety I found- well, utter lack of any commonality.

As you suggest I do know the approximate desired depth of the top and bottom drawer and overall height to fulfill the function. I should not try to make it rocket science to fill in the rest.

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

#11

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

Hank Knight

>Bill,

Do you remember where that article was published? I read it too, lost track of it and I've been looking for it for several months.

Hank

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

#12

George Walker article *LINK*

Bob Lang

>George's article was in the June 2009 issue of Popular Woodworking, and he is now writing a regular column called "Design Matters" that started in the February 2010 issue. I'll see if I can pull some strings and get the article from June online.

Bob Lang


June 2009 Popular Woodworking

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

#13

linked to abstract

Bill Tindall

>Thanks for the try but I only got an abstract. I was sufficiently impressed with the content that I subscribed for 2 years.

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

#14

Thanks Bob

Hank Knight

>

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

#15

Re: Thoughts on The Golden this or that........

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I suspect the golden mean/rectangle was a very handy tool when building the Parthenon, not exactly something you could experiment with, tear down if it came out wrong. The column devices we've adapted for furniture, and usually we can come up with some ways of finding the gold in furniture measurements. I agree with several others here that while we can start with such devices, that's not where we want to end.

Pam

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

#16

Perhaps Some Illustrations Would Help *LINK*

charlie belden

>Don't know about you, but I have trouble visualizing what the results of formulas or text descriptions of a mathematical concept mean. But add an illustration and I Get It.

I've played with several of the Graduated Drawers Methods and eventually put together illustrations of several methods that SHOWED me how they work in a way I could understand - and visualize.

The illustrations with text on the attached page, and the next two pages, are GIF image files you can download and print for future reference if they seem useful. Though I put up a spreadsheet you can download that's for the first example (Single Increment Method), I've got spreadsheets for the Fibonacci Series Method and the Golden Mean Method - if they would be useful.

I've attached an illustration of the GM Concept applied to graduated drawers.

Hope this helps.


img

Some Graduated Drawer Methods Illustrations

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

#17

Art or Engineering?

Bill Tindall

>To illustrate the thought worrying my head, suppose an engineer designed columns for that Greek thing we all learned about (that I seem to have forgotten its name). It is doubtful that the columns would have been shaped as they are. Rather, I suspect some person with artistic talent drew or experimented with column shapes and empirically came up with something that was most pleasing to the eye that accounted for the physics and psychology of sight and that is not readily reduced to a mathematical function, or at least not one that readily comes to mind. The St. Louis arch, a pleasing form if ever there was one, turns out to be a hyperbolic trig function. It was arrived at empirically by hanging a flexible material from its ends until a pleasing shape resulted, not by outputting shapes to a plotter from variable parameter functions. The curve resulting from a flexed stick is similarly pleasing but it is not modeled by a simple mathematical function.

So it might be reasonable to be skeptical that any basic mathematical progression or series would lead to the most pleasing drawer spacing for every situation, or maybe any situation. The "best" spacing could depend on every variable in the piece- how may drawers, how high the piece, how high the top or bottom drawer, moldings, etc.

A ruler and access to the world's best furniture would answer the question of whether drawer spacing is art or engineering. (I suspect there is a PhD thesis on this topic hidden away in some library.) In my limited search I have not found a simple formula that fits drawer spacing, which leads me to the tentative conclusion that either "best" spacing depends on the details of the piece or it doesn't matter much to the aesthetics of the piece.

As an example, a friend has a chest of drawers of exceptional form. The spacing between two of the drawers is way more than the others. This "oddity" was not even noticed until we started measuring these things.

Data: Does anyone have data to share on drawer spacing in classic furniture judged to be exceptional in form? My curiosity is kindled to dig deeper into this topic.

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

#18

Re: Art or Engineering? *LINK*

Bob Lang

>I think the whole idea of mathematical formulas was never considered until colleges were established and design and architecture became professions in the years between World War I and World War II. Before that common sense and a good eye were used. Academics without practical experience needed some theories to establish their credibility and authors and publishers were ready and willing to repeat this stuff. Enough ink has been used by now to establish these things as facts.

It's usually far more work to stretch some formula to fit than it is to accept that what looks good isn't easily quantifiable. Good art can't be reduced to paint by numbers. You'll be a lot happier with your chest of drawers if the top drawer is shallow enough to hold your socks without rooting through a deep pile and the bottom drawer will fit a couple sweaters. The ones in between should be sized in between and there are numerous ways to do it.

One of the nicest looking pieces of furniture to my eye is the Harvey Ellis designed #913 dresser made by Gus Stickley. Contrary to almost every other piece of furniture ever made, the widest drawer is one up from the bottom. I think we want something we can trust to help us with these things, and many people want to find that in numbers. I think there's a 98% chance the answers are somewhere else.

Bob Lang


Stickley/Ellis Rulebreaker

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

#20

Re: Art or Engineering?

Chris Friesen

>Not as nice as the Stickley (although the tapered legs a bit funny to my eye), but I own a couple of the Ikea chests pictured below.

For those with lots of commonly used items (socks for my wife, shirts for me) the fact that the largest drawer is up higher can be handy as it puts the contents at a convenient height.


img

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

#21

There it is!

Bob Hackett

>The form following function thing.More handy to have the bigger drawer up higher.

Anybody know why the Stickley chest was done that way?This isn`t another bent 16 penny nail in the front of the fine art cabinet thing ala Gary K B is it?

I`d REALLY like to know the true reasoning behind the departure from the accepted norm.

BTW-it really does look more pleasing that way,to me at least.

MB

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

#22

Stickley

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Why the drawer arrangement at bottom? Dunno, but the case profile does recurve and narrow at the bottom, so the drawers could be thought to be following, with the tallest drawer at the widest case expanse, and a slightly less tall one where the case narrows at the bottom.

I don't recall bombe chests doing any such thing, but it seems a possible explanation.

Wiley

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

#23

Not sure but...

Bob Hackett

>When I look at the pic the widest point seems to fall between the tallest drawer and the one above it.Just about dead on the divider between.

Strange that Ikea would echo the layout,although their furniture seems to follow function more than most "furniture for the masses" companies.

When I suggested to Bill that he design the chest with function in mind I pictured him coming up with a design that broke with tradition but still looked like it was a piece with history,something that the old masters would build because it made sense.

I was thinking of shorter than normal drawers in one of the top pairs but the taller middle drawer conveys the same feel of breaking the established rules.

MB

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

#24

Re: Art or Engineering?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>So much furniture seems to have been designed using the human form as a model that having the tallest drawer in a middle position (or thereabouts) would mimic the human hips. Therefore, those two examples of Stickley and Ikea look so right because they more closely mimic humans.

Pam

Re: Need drawer sizing advice

#25

Ah, an example of the point I was trying to make

Bill Tindall

>Recall I pondered that all the elements of the cabinetry could influence what drawer spacing would be pleasing. I think this piece confirms this hypothesis. Something about its height and the curve at the bottom and the curves on the sides that makes putting the largest drawer above the base a pleasing presentation. On the other hand the rectilinear piece in the other picture looks just strange.