Fiddliness of the mortise plane
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>I have seen pictures of the LN plane, but never held one in my hand, much less used one. I am struck by the difference between the cutting iron width (3/4") and body width (1-1/2"). Granted, mine is 3/4" wider than the cutting iron, too; but it's almost all sidewall. I doubt the LN plane has 3/8" thick sides, so there seems to be a lot of room for cutting iron wiggle. I can see that getting the iron set to the right depth AND straight when you've got nothing to assist you would be hard. A good application for some lateral-motion-limiting setscrews.
I don't find mine particularly fiddly to set; I think the limited lateral motion available helps in that.
Were I making another one, I'd probably grind down a 4" powered jointer blade, or a cutoff from a planer blade, or similar, rather than cutting up a Stanley-type iron - given how much the cutting iron hangs out beyond the body, extra stiffness would be good.
Another comment: LN recommends creeping up on the final depth with successively deeper settings. I don't find this necessary; I set to full depth, and use the sole of the plane as a "fence." When the iron stops cutting, I know I've reached full depth, but, in the meantime, the heel of the plane isn't in contact with the wood during much of the cutting.





