Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Hinge Morticing

Posts

Hinge Morticing

#1

Hinge Morticing

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>It is said that the devil lies in the details. That is, a project can be made or broken by the way small details are handled.

I was installing the hinges in the cabinet doors today and it occurred to me that my way of doing so may not be the best way. I think the method works OK, but I do wonder if others do it differently, and if so, how?

So I put together a detailed sequence of photos for the examination of the wise heads here, and await a critical review.

We begin with the doors adjacent to the side frame.


I mark the position on both frame and door with a small knife stroke. This lies in line with the lower edge of the bead.


The work proper begins with knifing both sides of the hinge ..



Then the baseline of the hinge is set on a marking gauge. This is the width of the leaf.



Now I set for the depth of the mortice. This is more critical since too shallow a mortice and the gap between door and frame is too large, and too deep a mortice and the door will not rotate. The full thickness of the hinge (including the joint) is 6mm. I have set the gauge for a depth of 2 � mm. That will leave a gap of 1 mm between the door and the frame.




Now chamfer the inside edges of the mortice. This is to move all chiselling inside the mortice and away from the sidewalls (which you want to preserve at all costs).


This is what it should look like �


Next, kerf the surface with a chisel (I aim to go about half the depth of the mortice).


I remove this � carefully! � with a paring chisel ..


It is possible to go directly to a router plane, which I use next, but the chisel is easy enough to use and the aim is to remove the kerfed surface. This defines the area to be cleared.

From here on I use a router plane. It is important that you set the depth at the start, and then work by taking thin shavings until you reach this level. A sharp blade makes this easy.


This is the completed mortice. Not my best work at the rear end � this Tasmanian Oak is interlocked and a bit crumbly.


With hinge in place and an awl for marking the screw holes. The holes are made slightly forward of centre to pull the hinge against the rear end.


Drilling the holes � I prefer to use a brace as this provides more control for angle and depth.


Here is a hinge with screws in place. Really awful hardware. The hinge is fine but the screws are nasty (slots are off centre).


The frame is joined to the door. This temporary (one screw) to see how it all works ..


Here is the full length temporary fit (the frame is still to be joined to the carcase) ..


Here are a few tests as to the quality of the fit ..

Firstly, the hinge is centred between the door and the frame, and the gap is the size I wanted ..


Secondly, the two pieces lie in the same plane ..


So this side is now complete ..


Last shot of WIP ...


So, what would you do differently?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Hinge Morticing

#2

Re: Hinge Morticing

GolfSteve in Calgary

>Things that I would have done differently...

First it would have taken me a month to get around to it,

Then I would have marked the hinge locations wrong,

Then I would have blown out the side of ,a hinge mortise with a careless chisel accident,

Then I would have drilled the holes off centre

Then I would have broken the heads off the screws,

Only after doing, and fixing, all of that, I would have ended up with the same thing you did.

Happy new year,

Steven

Re: Hinge Morticing

#3

Stephen Shepherd

I would use a router plane...

Stephen Shepherd

>to mark the depth of the mortise instead of the marking gauge, saves a step.

Stephen

Re: Hinge Morticing

#4

That the way my dad taught me

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>about *mumble* years ago.

Bruce, showing his age in MN

Re: Hinge Morticing

#5

scott grandstaff

Re: Hinge Morticing

scott grandstaff

>You got it Derek. That's the basic drill.

When you need high precision for elegant work, I don't think you took too many steps at all.

The main thing is work slow, at least for me.

Faster though.........slightly more casual....

I usually mark the hinge outline in pencil and use the chisel to outline it (leave that line!!), then remove most of the waste with the same chisel. Saves a step.

I like that you used a sharp awl to mark for screws, I do that too.

I have Vix bits and also the old Stanley self align-center punch, but you can't totally trust either to pull your hinge one way or another slightly when you want.

In a perfect world all screws should be in the dead center (and usually are in more casual work)

but for fine work.... we know different. :)

Where'd you get screws with crooked cut slots? I have done that myself by accident, (cutting slots by hand),

but never from factory stock.

yours Scott

Re: Hinge Morticing

#6

Re: Hinge Morticing

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I would cut the outline with a chisel, too, then would turn that puppy bevel down and clear out crosscut. It would never see a router plane, although real soon now it maybe would see the LN hinge mortise plane (I honestly don't feel comfortable using it yet). Never would I try the bevel up with the grain clearing, has always led me to grief, clearly not a constraint for you.

Pam

Re: Hinge Morticing

#7

Nice Brace...

McKay

>So did you make it? If so, where is the neat tutorial that you put together to show the rest of us smucks how it is done?

Re: Hinge Morticing

#8

One Important Question, Derek:

Tom Colligan

>Is that a Rolex watch we see on your wrist? :)

Happy New Year, everyone.

McKay (Steve?): Derek most certainly did make the brace himself and I'm pretty sure the tutorial is in the 'Tools' section of his site.

Re: Hinge Morticing

#10

Re: Hinge Morticing

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>It seems like a lot of extra work to use a router. Even with today's precision routers, you could finish the mortises in the time it takes to set up the router. You have a nice precise depth line made with the gauge. You can watch your line while you chisel out the bulk waste, then just stick the chisel in the gauge line for accurate clean up.

Re: Hinge Morticing

#12

Re: Hinge Morticing

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Never would I try the bevel up with the grain clearing, has always led me to grief..

Hi Pam

Don't forget I first kerfed the waste. That makes it an easy task with the bevel up. I have destroyed many a hinge mortice woithout following this step first.

Best for 2010!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Hinge Morticing

#14

Re: One Important Question, Derek:

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Good grief Tom, That is not important but, yes, it is a Rolex (Submariner). I've spent most of my life deeply involved in watersports. First surfing as a kid (and there are those that say I have not emerged from that state of mind!). For a little over 25 years I windsurfed quite seriously (competitively) - mostly State level but the occasional international level regatta. I only stopped competing about 5 years ago. This watch has taken a lot of abuse! Western Australia is famous for strong wind in summer.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Hinge Morticing

#15

Re: Hinge Morticing

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Warren

I was hoping you'd respond. You always find an efficient way of doings things.

I have tried just paring to a line. I don't feel I have the control to go all the way and retain an equal depth all round. It becomes more fiddly - in part this is my eye sight (I need more light), and in part I worry about the grain pulling the chisel off line. A sharp edge on the router plane is just like using a paring chisel, but it is more solid and stable.

I guess I need more practice with the chisel. Yes.

Best for 2010!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Hinge Morticing

#16

Re: Hinge Morticing *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I would probably use my handy butt mortise hinge plane. My protocol is outlined at the bottom of the article linked, which also describes the plane I made. It leaves out a couple of your steps, although I might well adopt some of your extra layout steps for a cabinet door (such precision is not usually necessary for architectural doors). Note that the paragraph on setting the cutting depth is intended for architectural hinges, which are customarily swaged so that the leaves meet with the hinge is closed. For non-swaged hinges, such as those you used in your tutorial, it would be necessary to measure the effective hinge thickness and set the plane with a ruler or other such method.

Pam: you mentioned not feeling comfortable using your LN version of the plane. I made my plane when I had to reverse the swing of a door in my uncle's bathroom (out instead of in) because he kept falling and getting trapped in it, and I had to do it quickly while he groused about it being unnecessary. I was amazed at the speed it added to the process, and that trial by grumbling uncle got me over my initial uncertainty about it. I don't recommend this method of learning how to use a tool; a little experimentation on some scrap should get you comfortable with it.

Somewhere deeeeeep on my round tuit list is making two fancier versions of this plane, in two sizes, one for architectural hardware and one for cabinet hardware. I'd like thinner sides (brass?), so that, for working in settings with existing stops (such as house remodels), I can get closer to the stop. Probably kind of silly; I'm close to done with remodeling our house - which is why it's way down on the list.


described here

Re: Hinge Morticing

#17

Re: Hinge Morticing

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>No, I didn't forget, but I'd most likely get tear out in the base regardless. Not a disaster usually, but certainly annoying, to me. Also, with the bevel down I get a much better angle when working a recess. I'm not really criticizing your method, there are many good ways to get the desired end; but like Warren, it seems a bit slower.

Pam

Re: Hinge Morticing

#18

Re: Hinge Morticing

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yes, and Larry Williams once said the LN version was one of his favorite planes, which is why I bought it; but whenever faced with a hinge mortise, I've resorted to my tried and true method, if you want to call it that. It's time now to either learn how to use it or sell it. I remember your woody version, very nice.

Pam

Re: Hinge Morticing

#19

Using the BM plane versus the Router plane.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Bill

I do remember your plane. I looked up the details of the LN. Yours has a blade 5/8" wide and the LN is 3/4" wide.

According to the LN website, the butt mortice plane is used with and against the grain. How do you use yours?

By contrast, I use the router plane across the grain. I find that this helps me control the depth of cut better.

The other point I should make is that when using the router plane, I push it (as if I was using a paring chisel), then wiggle it side-to-side to (getting a slicing action). With the depth stop set, it is a quick procedure to take off thin, controlled slices. Incidentally Pam, this is how I use the wide slick as well - push in, wiggle side-to-side, clean up with straight strokes. Also, if I am cleaning up, I prefer the chisel bevel down (one of the reasons I don;t like secondary bevels on chisels).

It would make sense to me to use the BM plane like a router plane. It would lose a little in the adjustablity department, but it would gain in blade support. And then a narrower blade makes sense. I just cannot get my head around using it with/against the grain. I think Tear Out City!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Hinge Morticing

#20

Re: Excellent ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi again Stephen

I tried it your way today. Works a treat! In fact, the router plane makes a better marking gauge - easier to push and get some depth on the cuts.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Hinge Morticing

#21

Mortising of hinges *LINK*

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Derek,

Rather than link to another forum directly, I'll cut and paste my comments.

------------------------------------------------------

Hi Derek,

REally quick reply here - sorry - up to my neck in alligators. I'd agree with Col's comments.

The method on one side looked fine.

It's rare in cabinetry to set both hinge plates into the carcase - the door,most defininely yes, it's mortised in. The hinge is just screwed onto the inside of the cabinet side for light doors. The centreline of the hinge pin is mounted in the centre of the door gap.

If the door is heavier, it's feathered in. A google search on feathered hinge mounting should show detail.

The hinge is mortised in IF it's a very heavy door such as a household doo. It's rarely done in cabinetmaking.

CHeers,

eddie.


Feathered hinges

Re: Hinge Morticing

#22

Re: Mortising of hinges

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Andrew

I wonder how many cabinetmakers were trained in this method, and/or whether it is associated with a British (and Australian) training?

Why do I ask this? Because there clearly are different methods of hinge morticing. No one here (or elsewhere) has questioned the essential methodology I posted.

Further, just one more reference (I could cite others but this one is easiest), when I look at the images on the LN website (for the butt mortice plane), the method there is for a uniform depth mortice ..



Note, I am not discounting the method you present at all, just looking for more information and understanding (why I make these posts in the first place).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Hinge Morticing

#23

Re: Using the BM plane versus the Router plane.

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Disclaimer: I haven't used this plane on Australian woods, nor on, say, rock maple or similar tearout-prone woods.

That said, I've been surprised at how little tearout I've encountered. I use it with and against the grain, planing more or less from the center of the mortise toward both ends, adjusting my starting point as needed. If I'm working on a mortise on wood with the grain diving pretty dramatically, I'll find myself starting very close to one end of the mortise, planing with the rising grain, and finishing off the remainder.

I should comment that it's not a perfect tool; it sometimes needs supplementation with a chisel. But I've found it speeds up the mortising process considerably.

It's hard for me to imagine how I might use it cross-grain - the design is optimal for long-grain planing on a hinge or hardware (example: strike plate) mortise, with the sole of the plane supported on both sides of the mortise along the grain. For hinge mortises particularly, using it cross-grain would leave one end of the sole out in space, and, I suspect, would lead to a lot more diving of the cutter into the wood. Cross-grain work would more appropriately be done with a router plane or by hand with a chisel.

Re: Hinge Morticing

#24

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Hinge Morticing

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I was right where you are now a little over a year ago.I put it in the classifieds and noone showed any interest so I tried to use it again. It actually works pretty nice once you get the feel for it.I still don't drag it out much though.It's a fiddly tool. A router is much quicker.If you have alot of hinges to do it would make more sense.---Jack

Re: Hinge Morticing

#25

Re: Hinge Morticing

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yes, I bought it for my house renovation, including kitchen, and we're getting ready to restart that job, thus... :)

Pam