Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

tail vise vs. end vise

Posts

tail vise vs. end vise

#1

tail vise vs. end vise

Joe Shelton

>I'm at the 'head scratching' point in planning for a new bench.

Flying in the face of tradition and the experience of real woodworkers intimidates me, but I still have a question.

Why is a tail vise a better vise than an end vise?

Joe

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

#2

Re: tail vise vs. end vise *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Let me define the terms as I think you may have meant them, and then offer a thought; if I misunderstood you, then my response will be of no use, but you can correct the definitions.

Tail vise: block (usually wood) mounted on the bench in a way that it can slide back and forth along the front of the bench. Its main function is to carry bench dogs that, in combination with bench dogs on the fixed portion of the bench top, clamp boards on the bench top. Wow! that was harder than I thought; see link below, demonstrating that a picture is worth more than 53 words.

End vise: a vise like a Record, Wilton, Jorgensen, etc. face vise or a leg vise, mounted at the end of the bench and operating against the bench and/or bench dogs.

I think the biggest advantage of a tail vise (shared, even more so, by a wagon vise) is that the end of the wood clamped by the vise is resting on something; with an end vise, as you open the vise, the vise end of the wood is progressively less supported. This can be quite significant, in my experience, and is why I'm planning to replace by Record face vise, currently in use as an end vise, with something else at some point.

Bill, no experience with tail vises; only reading


An example of a tail vise, as I used the term

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

#3

Agree with your definitions

Joe Shelton

>Bill, I see the limitation WRT leaving a portion unsupported if one is clamping long work along the top surface of the bench.

Still, my current 'cobbled-up' end vise, in tandem with numerous dogs along the length of the bench, minimizes that concern. Unless I get a workpiece that is too long.

So, does the tail vise have intrinsic advantages when clamping work vetically to work on the end grain?

Thanks for your response.

JS

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

#4

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

David Cockey

>Isn't a "tail vise" less supported the further it's open?

(Disclaimer - no personal experience)

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

#5

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>It seems to me that the real reason a tail vise is better is because the dogs can be much closer to the front edge of a bench which facilitates using plows, rabbet planes, etc. and doing the necessary operations on wood that is not so wide. With an end vise (as defined) the dogs are about 3" from the edge. What if your board is 2 1/2" wide? You can't hang the end over the edge. But with a tail vise, the dogs can be 1" to 1 1/2" away from the edge. A clear advantage. Believe me, I know first-hand of what I speak.

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

#6

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Joe,

Truth in posting: I have a larger bench and a smaller bench, and they both have LV twin-screw end vises.

This topic comes up every few years. Lurking in the background, generally unspoken, is the fact that the 'cool factor' of the traditional Scandinavian bench is unbeatable. It's just too cool.

But the argument I recall goes something like this. When it comes to applying a line of force along the front edge of the bench, nothing does as well as a tail vise. This is because the vise is mechanically resistant (a) to racking laterally, (b) to racking vertically, and (c) to deflecting downward under planing pressure. This is of course assuming a perfect installation--don't know how difficult this is to achieve.

So if you don't have a tail vise, but want the equal, then you are going to have to take measures to ensure that your alternative vise is equally resistant to lateral racking, vertical racking, and deflecting downward under pressure. In the case of my twin-screw vises, there is no lateral racking through design of the vise. However, there is inherent vertical play, which has to be taken up by planing a taper into the front face of the vise so that the jaw will stand up vertical _under load_ (rather than leaning backward under load). turning to downward deflection, if you follow Lee Valley's instruction sheet, the vise will deflect downward a bit under load, because there is a 1/16" gap between the top of the main screws and the blocking one installs under the bench top. What I did to overcome this, and others have done the same, is install zero-clearance blocking under the bench top, so that the screws are constrained. In this case, the jaws can be opened about 5" before the cantilevering begins to cause deflection.

Incidentally, in regard to Patrick's caution about dog holes, the twin-screw doesn't present this problem, because you can place your dog holes outboard of the main screws with no ill effects. Mine dog holes are centered about 1-1/2" from the front edge of the bench. But that is a real concern, and one needs to have a solution or else deal with the problem that Patrick brought up.

So in like manner, whatever other vise one uses for an end vise, you have these 3 issues to address: horizontal racking, vertical racking, and downward deflection.

So the argument for the tail vise is simple: Why deal with problems? Use the vise that is designed not to have these problems. My personal answer to this is: Yeah, but I don't have the 10 feet or more of floor footprint required for that style bench. Or I would have one.

Now I am prepared to argue that there are practical advantages and huge flexibilities to a twin-screw end vise that a tail vise does not have. Maybe we'll get to that later in this thread. In other words, the basic argument for a tail vise is: Nothing does the job of a tail vise as well as a tail vise. To which I am ready to argue, yes, but there are other considerations which may make the end vise a better choice in a particular set of real-life circumstances.

Wiley

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

#7

Re: tail vise vs. end vise------WebKitFormBoundary

Joe Shelton------WebKitFormBoundarybOK+uCyXOSa6ono

>Patrick, I don't contend with what you say. But I'm rebelling against the argument that I should "...believe (you); you know whereof you speak."

All I'm asking is why is the tail vise superior to a massive end vise.

My current old bench has a very heavy end vise that I don't like because it's clunky. It is the opposite of elegant.

But my dog holes are 3" off the edge, and I think any workpiece I'd clamp down that is less than 3 or 4 inches wide would probably bow under pressure. The tools I want to use on edge treatments won't run safely by a holdfast or batten on narrow stock like that. So, in my opinion, any difference between tail vises and end vises lie not in clamping long horizontal stock, but in the ability to also clamp work vertically.

Still, if you know something I'm missing, I'd really appreciate your telling me. Just articulate it. Don't ask me to trust your judgement. OK?

Thanks

JS

------WebKitFormBoundarybOK+uCyXOSa6onoe

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

#8

Use a wonder pup. *LINK*

Roy Anderson

>Ends and tails and vise, oh my! Just use a pup. Life is so simple.


Wonder Pup

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

#9

Re: tail vise vs. end vise------WebKitFormBoundary *LINK*

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>Joe, I said that I know of what I speak because I had an end vise on my bench which made the dogs about 3" from the edge and made many operations more difficult because of it. It has bugged me ever since I completed the bench and I took it off about a year ago. I'm not conceited just frustrated with the result. I'm going to build a new bench the first part of next year and plan on building a tail vise of my own design. I think that the ones available now are too complicated. I'd really like to find an old Oliver 221A end/tail vise that was bolted on just like my Record vise but functioned specifically as a tail vise. See the link below. This type of vise was made by others in the 19th and 20th centuries but has disappeared from commerce now. Too bad. Anyway, sorry if I sounded conceited. Didn't mean to come off that way.


http://www.mprime.com/Emmert/Images/Ads%20and%20Patents/ad1920-Oliver2.gif

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

#10

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

ThomD

>There are two areas to consider, one is the difference in use (covered well already), and the other is the overall environment. I have several benches also, my recent one has an end vise, and an earlier one a tail vise.

Environment for me mainly has to do with whether your bench is against the wall or standing free of the wall. I have a good sized shop, about 800 square feet, plus 450 square feet of storage, and the house has some stuff in it also. But the layout is narrow. I have never been able in any of my shops to get the bench off the wall. As I result I mostly use the front 8 inches. When I made the end vise I intended to fascilitate japanese and western plane use, and a bunch of other stuff. Against the wall this doesn't happen. I can't really use the end vise head on, and the end vise handle, wallsise, can even get caught up on the wall. It actually makes a pretty good tail vise, but despite my best efforts it isn't really living up to potential. By the way, if you can get to all sides of the bench (with enough space to really use them). Then you can consider other stuff like having different vises on 4 side...

One other thing that tail vises do well is that the jaw is very positive for taking square stock of the kind used in mortised parts of doors. I make all kinds of stuff. But if you break out traditional cabinet making tasks, dovetails, mortises, tenons, general planing, there isn't all that much of it that really needs anything other than a good face vise, tail vise, and square holes. One can come up with all kinds of scenarios, but in the real world a lot of that stuff doesn't happen all that much. Round table top? Don't fit with the wall, and I wouldn't round them then put them in dogs if I could get them on the table, and that kind of use often means you can't get support on cross grain areas. I normally do the roughing in the square and the final stuff on the base. Etc...

The LV end style vise is a great vise, so i would stick one wherever you can. Durability wise, though, the clutches are not super sturdy. I have had parts slip. There is just more stuff going on with a double screw, it isn't as simple to use. For instance, more often I want my jaw fixed parallel than capable of skew. With the double it is always a two part adjustment. I'm still very happy with it, and if I had enough space I would have more of them set up as face vises for chairs.

Tail vise is very rugged. I think one can supports an end vise against droop, but it still won't be as good. End vises tend to be attached to breadboard joints, when placed on the end. Double screw side mounting is a separate issue. What you really want with a vise is support at the start of the stroke so that one can have the plane engaged level. With the tail vise the board has the support of the main bench, or at worst the breadboard. With the end vise it is usually hanging out there on parts that will expand and contract aside from the movement patterns of the bench, and are not likely in line perfectly.

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

#11

Thanks, Patrick

Joe Shelton------WebKitFormBoundarybOK+uCyXOSa6ono

>Those Oliver vises indeed look good.

And I apologize for getting snippy. I'm in over my head, and I just don't understand the issues that contribute to the best decision.

Anyway, thanks for your responses, and good luck with your own bench.

Joe

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

#12

Choose neither - consider a Leg Vise instead...

John Aniano - in NJ...

>

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

#13

One other alternative -- wagon vise *LINK*

wilbur

>I'd explain this, but Chris Schwarz does a much better job than I could. Suffice it to say that it seems to satisfy all the issues of horizontal and vertical racking, and you can pound on the bench in that area without problems.


Woodworking Magazine blog post on wagon vises

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

#14

Metal or wood?

Bob Hackett

>When you say leg vise I think of an old blacksmith`s vise bolted to the bench with a steel leg running down to the floor.

Pretty sure you meant the wood type that you have to fiddle with the thing at the bottom to keep the jaws parallel though who knows.

I`ve seen several hundred versions of the wood type,each with it`s own good and bad quirks.The adjustment required at the bottom seems like the most common complaint though.

MB

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

#15

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

Dean J in MN

>Or, how about neither?

I've been tail/end vise free for nearly 5 years now. I've not looked back.

-Dean

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

#16

Re: tail vise vs. end vise------WebKitFormBoundary

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Those Olivers look pretty good, but they're not replacements for tail vises, whose screws don't interfere with clamping a piece vertically.

Pam

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

#17

scott grandstaff

Re: tail vise vs. end vise-PIX

scott grandstaff

>I say both, and thensome!!

I need all the help I can get. I use the tail vise and the end vise and several other kinds of vises and

I never had "too many vices", whatever you heard elsewhere.

You would believe that good for nothing deputy??? heehehehe

In my little life I have to figure out what will genuinely work, that I can build or scrounge. If not for free then really really close. Time I have, money? never much.

I'd have taken a twinscrew. I like that concept. One didn't show up in time.

I'd have taken a heavy carriage end vise. But nobody was giving away any.

Well, come to think of it I did that. It just wasn't instant.

An old apple press screw ($5) and about 50 more pounds of iron concealed inside what looks like an all wood vise. (Some 1/4" plate steel and heavy angle iron with one leg removed, along with steel pipe spacers, etc.) Sheeza no rock. I can jump up and down on it all day.

Some walnut and quilted maple, regular maple, a bit of madrone and black oak. Oh and some homemade rosewood plugs to cover the big bolt holes.


Here's my face vise. The newest addition. Its a fair sized vise but no Emmert. I got it for really cheap though. Had to wait a few years from one to show up, but the price was right.


Notice the pipe legs? These are very heavy (schedule 80) pipe. Not as picturesque as 6" square rosewood with big through mortise stretchers (sniff),

but I could park my truck on it with no worry.

(Free shorts from the mine boneyard along with the 2X4" heavy square tube stretchers, that came from a busted sludge dryer.)


yours Scott

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

#18

Re: tail vise vs. end vise-PIX

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I didn't for a minute understand Free shorts from the mine boneyard along with the 2X4" heavy square tube stretchers, that came from a busted sludge dryer. But I love your bench and the double duty tail/shoulder vise.

Pam

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

#19

scott grandstaff

Re: boneyard

scott grandstaff

>Oh sorry

OK you know those huge piles of old nasty looking metal that accumulate behind industrial plants of any kind??

That's the boneyard.

1/2 my life came from some boneyard or other.

yours and thanks for the kind words

Scott

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

#20

Aha, thanks.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

#21

Thanks, Scott, and...

Joe Shelton

>...what do you do with the 'L' shaped return on the end of the tail vise?

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

#22

OK, so what do you use, and...

Joe Shelton

>...is it better, or just the way you ended up doing things?

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

#23

scott grandstaff

Re: OK, so what do you use, and...

scott grandstaff

>The big L shaped jaw I use for clamping wide pieces vertically.

Dovetailing and such.

Its not the strongest part of the vise and so I baby it.

It'll hold for a drawer side though, easy.

But at the other side?

Between the tail vise opening and the bench corner?? Near where the dogs do their business?

There is a massive strong pinch point there, that I use constantly.

You could crush a bowling ball!

Well almost seems like it. :-)

yours Scott

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

#24

Re: OK, so what do you use, and...

Dean J in MN

>My bench top has a planing stop on the top and some holdfast holes. Think Roubo or Nicholson. I've used a Nicholson, and am equally at home on that bench as on my bench. I left the tail vise off my bench, well, I'm not sure why aside from the times I did use a tail vise I didn't see a big advantage compared to the way I currently work.

I'm not saying one way is "better" than another. It is your bench after all, build it and get to woodworking. I'm just saying one can work without a tail/end vise, just keep the option open.

-Dean


img

Re: tail vise vs. end vise

#25

scott grandstaff

Re: OK, so what do you use, and...

scott grandstaff

>Sharp molding Dean!! Yum!!

And a good lookin pile of curls too!

Yup, with a bench you need to float your own boat as much as anything. You can use to a whole lot of different ways to work.

Each as good as each other, just slightly different.

Anything you can like and be comfortable with? Is more important than almost anything else.

When you feel good about your tools it makes it easier to work every day.

I was always a sucker for the old style end vise and square dogs.

They aren't any better than good stops or another type vise and round dog configuration. Just another style.

They're all just styles you get to chose from.

You pick the horse that appeals, and you ride.

yours Scott