Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically?

Posts

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically?

#26

Painful

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Charlie, you make these cuts sound painfully complicated and slow. If you are making cuts for four tails in a drawer side, how long does it take for the eight cuts?

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically?

#27

more on half blind pins?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Having neglected to do the detailed analysis that has proceeded I have blithely (and effortlessly) cut half blind pins just as you illustrate cutting tails(?) in your picture. Please provide more detail on the flat board approach. Are the pins facing you or away? Having yet to try it, what is better compared to a board standing upright?

I find that I can saw better than I can see. For me, way more than saw orientation cutting dovetails is a matter of getting optimum lighting. If one orientation or another enabled me to get better reflection off the lines I would learn to saw that way.

Occasionally I watch an inning or two of baseball. I am amazed at the different approach batters take to standing ready to hit a ball. No doubt some analysis of the situation would conclude that one stance offers better mechanics than another. But that isn't how it works out.

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically?

#28

Re: more on half blind pins?

Dean J in MN

>

Having neglected to do the detailed analysis that has proceeded I have blithely (and effortlessly) cut half blind pins just as you illustrate cutting tails(?) in your picture. Please provide more detail on the flat board approach. Are the pins facing you or away? Having yet to try it, what is better compared to a board standing upright?

Bill,

I think a photo would be simpler, but I'm no where near my shop at the moment so I'll try with words.

The board is flat on the bench, hanging over the edge a bit, pins facing me. For longer pieces sometimes it is angled across my bench, as my bench is against a wall, not an issue for those folks who have room behind their bench.

For small drawer fronts I often do them just as you do, cut the pins just like the tail board in the vise. But on case sides or large drawers it is sometimes hard to get the part low enough in the vise to have a comfortable angle to saw. I also cut out the sockets for dovetailed drawer dividers with the case sides just laying on my bench, so I am accustomed to sawing in that position. One other point -- I oversaw my baselines on half blind joints, and this flat on the bench approach makes that simpler.

There are downsides to the approach -- if you are tall you may have to crunch down a bit. I'm tall, and work on a low bench, but don't find it to be an issue, still this may vary depending on your height/build. The other downside -- you are actually starting the cut "uphill" to use the terms defined in this thread. However, I bias my start to have more saw on the inside face so don't find this difficult, again results may vary.

Give it a whirl. I just use a holdfast if the part is too light to stay still on its own. Quick and easy.

-Dean

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically?

#29

Re: more on half blind pins?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Bill,

Just a quick note. BTW, I'm cool with however anyone else wants to saw, so am not arguing any point here.

Anyway, on half-blinds I find it useful to have the board upright in the vise, as you describe, with the end grain right in my eyes. The reason is that I don't want to overcut the scribe line on the end grain. I can see that line better, and where the saw is relative to that line, if it is aimed up at my eyes.

I use a rip dozuki, and am therefore cutting into the straws in this orientation, but with a thin blade and 22ppi, it's not an issue. What is an issue with a dozuki is overcutting lines (if one cares). With your LN saw, you'd be cutting with the straws, unlike me. Regardless of push saw or pull saw, you'll be able to see your stopping point on the end grain better if the end grain is facing up. Not that you shouldn't try it Dean's way.....why not?...

WIley

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically?

#30

Re: Strongly disagree

charlie belden

>Pam:

I'm guessing that you're thinking in terms of the use of a Push Cut saw, where the power actually starts at your feet ( any boxer will tell you that ) and you HAVE to pivot at the shoulder AND elbow AND wrist to move the saw - and get it to cut. But that's three joints to keep aligned as they move, and each of those joints has a fairly wide possible range of motion.

With the vertical pull sawing cut it's movement from the elbow and at the wrist that provide the little bit of power needed, no shoulder joint or shoulder muscles involved.

If the attached animation works it should explain what I've been trying to describe with just text. The animation in Netscape 3.0 is really fast. Hopefully it will play a bit slower in other browsers.


img

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically?

#31

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically? (long)

charlie belden

>Dean:

If your wrist is in a neutral position when you start the cut - and the tip is "up", it would seem that your wrist would have to go out of "neutral" to continue the cut acrossed the top end grain. At some point you'd HAVE to come out of "neutral" at the wrist, unless a) the show face is away from you and b) you're OK with overcutting on the "inside" face.

Have I got that right or am I missing something?

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically?

#32

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically? (long)

charlie belden

>Pam:

Pistol grip or "stick grip, when you push the saw to cut it's like steering a car - with the "rear wheels". With a pull to cut saw you're steering with the "front wheels".

Rear steering cars - and there were some (see Buckminster Fuller's Dymaxion Car) - is VERY twitchy.

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically?

#33

Re: Strongly disagree

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>No, Charlie, I'm talking about using both push and pull saws, vertical and horizontal sawing.

Pam

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically?

#35

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically? (long)

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>But in practice, there doesn't appear to be much difference in effect. I currently use and love my Japanese saws, but in the past I was just as effective with western saws. In a side by side test, the small straight handled LN matched up stroke for stroke, smooth cut for smooth cut, accuracy intact, with my LV pro dozuki. Both were very fast.

Pam

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically?

#36

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically? (long)

Dean J in MN

>Yes, my wrist will come out of neutral, but by that point I've crossed the end grain and have followed two lines quite far into the cut. The existing kerf guides the saw, I just let the saw's toe weight drop it flat to the baselines, more or less autopilot at that point, too late to correct anyway.

-Dean

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically?

#37

"Bench Pin" for cutting pins with Pull Saw

charlie belden

>Bill:

Again, borrowing from the jewelry making trade, here's a "bench pin" for cutting dovetail pins using a pull saw, sawing straight up and down while seated. Works using a bandsaw as well, though for that use you'd want to put UMHW on the underside so it will slide rather than stick.


img

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically?

#38

Wasn't suggesting using a push saw vertically

charlie belden

>

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically?

#39

Re: Painful

charlie belden

>If I WERE in a hurry - I'd use the bandsaw - same idea - part horizontal (ok so the pins would be slanted 7 or 15 degrees on a sloped sled") - or it there were a lot of dovetails to cut - the AKEDA DT jig and a router - or the router table with the JoinTech Cabinet Maker precision fence system.

But if I'm after Zen Moments and being One With The Wood - and hand cut them - it's with a pull saw - seated or kneeling - part laying on the bench top.

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically?

#40

Re: Wasn't suggesting using a push saw vertically

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>OK, but why not? Let's say you have to resaw a board. Why not put it above you, like in a pit, and saw away?

Pam

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically?

#41

Didn't know this was going to go this long

charlie belden

>It's funny how much we do without thinking about it once we've learned a process or procedure. So it's really easy to assume that some of the critical details are common knowledge and not worth mentioning - until someone asks "but how do you . . .?"

With a half dozen or so eyes on something, and with a range of knowledge and experience, gaps get filled in and understanding follows. Agreement? Well that may be asking for too much. I'm learning some things I didn't know before.

This "seated pull cut sawing" thing might be something useful to get into at the Disabled Woodworking Symposium since there are a fair number of folks in wheel chairs, or with limited movement without "discomfort" issues.

Thanks to the participants in this discussion.

And newbies - lurking is ok - unless you have a question and want an answer. If you don't ask, no one can help you.

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically?

#42

Pit sawing - and veneer saws

charlie belden

>You want to be the person "in the pit"? And who is going to be on top, pulling the damn saw up?

Actually, the french came up with a Veneer Sawing System - the saw having a frame - with the blade in the middle. IIRC, the saw cuts on the downstroke, powered by your legs and a counterweight lifts it up on the return stroke, your hands guiding the cut.

I've also seen a video of Tage Frid resawing - with a pretty big bow saw. Amazing thing to see.

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically?

#43

Don`t give up yet ,Charlie

Bob Hackett

>Please don`t let the naysayers shout you down.

Some people just love to argue,they really don`t want to see anything new or different survive.

You bring up a very valid point about this being an important and useful technique for people with mobility issues who must work from a sitting position.Let me speak for a minute for those of us who have limited range of motion and chronic pain issues in our upper extremities.This technique is important stuff for me and those like me(there`s more of us that you think)and I for one would hate to see it fade because a few people refuse to see it`s merits.

You are a rare and talented guy,Charlie.Rare because you feel the need to post a different and now contested technique.You also have the ability to wade thru the questions with clear and concise discussion and you can create well thought out illustrations and even animation when needed.For folks like me it doesn`t get any better than this.

Your approach to holding a saw seemed foreign to me till I understood that the work needed to be held flat on the bench(or in your "bench pin").Once I asked questions your answers led to a completely new approach that will not only help me work more effectively with my injury but I can also see where it could be applicable to other tasks that have been painful for me,saw filing for one.

I (re)learned a lesson from the finishing thread and Bill T.`s and Richard`s responses.

That thread and this one bring to mind advice I got from one of my old 1st Sargents.He advised me there were 3 types of people in the world;

People who watch things happen

People who make things happen

People who wonder what the hell happened

He also advised me to "Endeavor to be the second type".

I`ve since discovered that there are actually 4 types of people.I added to the list;

People who stand in the way of things happening

I`m sure if Top were here he`d advise you to"Endeavor to avoid and ignore the 4th type at all costs".

Thanks,Charlie

Mainely,Bob

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically?

#44

Re: Don`t give up yet ,Charlie

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Look, Bob, when I advocate a technique it's because it works and works well. Toshio Odate taught me how to saw in a few minutes, with the shoulder as a pivot; but I didn't take his word for it, I practiced and practiced some more and found out that he was right. So the next time we have someone claim that his/her new saw is great, it only takes 10 strokes to cut a single tail and I respond that that's slow, it only takes me 3 cuts, you know why. Everyone poo-pooed me and expressed disbelief, but it was not a lie, it was truth. You are free to disbelieve at your loss (ignoring your shoulder problems for the moment), but you can't claim with any credence that I am merely opposing Charlie for the sake of argument or other debased motive. I expect better from you, and Charlie for that matter.

Pam

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically?

#45

Grandma knew it all

Marv

>My Dad's Mother knew it all, at least she thought so. When I was six years old she was showing me how to hoe weeds in her veggie patch. She told me if I do it any other way, it will be wrong. She was of that mind with everything. As I grew older I learned that she was wrong. I got so no matter what she told me, I'd make every effort to come up with a different way of doing whatever it was she was saying was the right way. At first I did it out of spite and indifference. Later in life I concluded that she did me a great favor. What works well for one person might not be what works well for someone else. Many times, that "someone else" will actually discover a new way of doing it. Might even be a better way. If we were all closed minded like my Grandma was, progress would stagnate. Sharing of our knowledge is a gift to whomever is open to new or different ideas and methods.

Marv

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically?

#46

OK, I quit.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically?

#47

{Blows Whistle} time out, gang!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>This has been a very productive conversation, with passionate arguments for one or another method of holding a saw, sawing position, body mechanics, etc.; and an important theme of learning how to accommodate for physical limitations and still enjoy the shop.

But some of the passion is edging over into attack, subtle or overt. I ask participants to take a deep breath, remember that there are many ways to skin a cat or use a saw, and focus on the learning that can grow out of passionate discussion.

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically?

#48

Pam's Right - Discussions are NOT Arguements

charlie belden

>Pam ain't no Nay Sayer. She brought her knowledge, skills and experience to this discussion and makes valuable contributions to the discussion.

Discussions are an exchange of ideas where the participants come to it with an open mind to share ideas, perhaps challenge assumptions and learn something new to think about.

Arguements are a bunch of folks saying things TO or AT each other, with no intent to listen and think about what others are saying.

This has definitely been a lively DISCUSSION with interesting ideas and experiences to share and good questions asked. Challenging assumptions, our own and other folks' assumptions constructively that all participants come away with more knowledge and thinkgs to think about than they had before is always a good thing.

One of the things I've learned - so far - is that we all have biases and preferences resulting from our own experiences. Sometimes that keeps us from considering other things.

This saw thing is a great example. If you come from a european tradition of woodworking it's easy to have a bias towards a lot of what goes with that tradition. The same is true if you come from a japanese tradition of woodworking. In both traditions, the tools and techniques were developed for the materials available and a need to make things, and the societal context of each tradition.

European woodworkers had lots of hardwoods to work with but comparatively so-so tools to use. So they adapted their tools and techniques to their situation.

The Japanese woodworker had softwoods to work with mostly and access to more sophisticated cutting tools, the tools MADE specifically to meet a specific need - and refined to a very high level over time.

The european woodworker brought the wood to his working space. The Japanese woodworker typcially brought his tools TO the wood. The former typcially have a big heavy solid workbench that had a lot of built in ways to hold the wood. The latter went for portable - using what was available at the site - and their feet or knees or hand to hold the wood so they could work it.

I introduced a sawing technique developed for a completely different discipline from woodworking - the use of a jeweler's saw. For cutting dovetails, the pull saw works like a jeweler's saw. Sitting or kneeling to saw seemed logical, and probably familiar to a Japanese woodworker, though unfamiliar to anyone from the european tradition.

The technique might not be the fastest most efficient way of cutting dovetails but I believe it has its merits. Others may see it differently - and that's fine with me. If the technique enables someone to do something they could not do otherwise - I'm a happy camper.

Thanks Pam. Thanks Bob. And thanks to the rest of the participants. Discussions are useful and constructive and provide things to think about - or not.

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically?

#49

As someone with a rotator cuff injury

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>which is, so far, thank goodness, about 1% of what Bob reports, I think I can say confidently that it's impossible for Bob to ignore his shoulder problems - and his contributions here have been about how to saw more efficiently given his body with its limitations.

Another demonstration of how threads on this forum start out on one subject and diverge or expand, often usefully.

Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically?

#50

Re: As someone with a rotator cuff injury

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>It's not that I was ignoring his physical problems, but that I wasn't speaking to them.

Pam