Re: Pull Stroke Sawing - Vertically? (long)
charlie belden
>snip
> With practice I find that one doesn't need
> (and, I think, shouldn'T need) as much visual
> feedback to make a critical cut. Of course
> some visual feedback is important,
The more sense you engage, the more info the brain
gets to use.
In engraving, there's a "walking Z cut" usually done with
a line graver. You engage the left corner of the graver
with the metal being engraved, rock the rest of the
cutting edge into the cut, then pivot off the other edge
of the graver's edge and make the next cut rotating in
the other direction. It's called "wriggling" - sort of like
"walking a board" on end. Getting the spacing of the
patten uniform is tricky.
My engraving teacher would sing "doodle-doodle-doodle"
as he made this type of cut - and "rocked" on each
"doodle". For small fine patterns he'd "doodle" faster,
and for longer patterns he'd "doodle" slower. It was all
about establishing a rythm - and singing helps do that.
Of course, you had to be close to hear him - close
enough to invade his "personal space" to hear him. He
laughed when I aksed him about his "doodling". He
wasn't even aware he was doing it - having been taught
that little trick many many year earlier.
> but I'm not sure having one's face in the cut
> is ideal with either style of saw.
For photo purposes I was holding a dozuki cause it was
handy. For dovetails, the Odate Dovetail saw is much
shorter - and the stroke is only maybe three inches at
the most. And since this is a finesse/control cut, not
a power cut, there's very little force involved - if you
let the teeth do the cutting - on the PULL stroke.
>I also use the old trick that Charlesworth
> taught me of using a mirror (behind the
> piece being cut) to saw dovetails or tenons,
> and I find it useful for both types of saws.
Tage Frid used that trick too. Problem with mirrors is
that you're seeing a mirror image. When you're looking
at things directly, the brain doesn't need to make any
adjustments.
> I think the muscling through the cut is more
> due to blade thickness than style. Some
> western saws just breeze through a cut, no
> tenseness necessary.
Well there's another difference between western push
saws and japanese push saws - the teeth - what kinds
and how they're ground/filed. The teeth on a japanee
saw are a mix, one tooth does one thing, the next
another and and the next one does another before the
pattern repeats. And each tooth has several "facets".
So the japenese saw cuts wood in a very different way
than a "western" saw.
> The real question is how to start the cut. If
> you don't need to muscle through a cut, and
> if you don't need to apply rotational forces,
> that means that you've started the cut
> perfectly vertical or in line with your mark.
> What allows one to start a cut perfectly
> with a Japanese saw, compared to a
> Western saw? I'm not sure one style is
> easier to line up than the other; both take
> practice to line up at the begonning of a cut.
Ah - there's another difference. You want to align the
cut to TWO straight lines - one on the end grain and one
on the face grain, the two lines falling in planes that
are square to each other.
With a push cut saw, the part is usually held vertically
and you're seeing the end grain horizontal line best,
standing looking down towards the part. If you cut
straight down on the end grain line you'll have a problem
when cutting tails because their sides slant outward
away from the end grain line.
But with the part horizontal you can see the entire
scribe line on the face grain. If you rest the saw blade
on the juncture of the face grain and edge grain line -
and pivot off that point to align the far end of the
blade to the face grain line - left thumb nail ON THAT
LINE - blade against that thumbnail, you can make a
slanting initial cut - that's about half the desired cut
length - AND - down the line on the end grain - just a
little.
NOW, when you rock the saw to vertical you've got a
notch at the top of the line to register the saw blade to
and can make the first light vertical cut in the end
grain - TO the end grain line.
For both cuts, you want to LEAVE THE LINE, or, if
you're really good - SPLIT THE LINE. You DO NOT want
to TAKE THE LINE since it's the only thing to tell you
where you are relative to where you want to be.
> Another argument you seem to make is that
> the possibility of applying rotational forces
> is a disadvantage. I'm not sure I see why. Of
> course ideally you shouldn'T need to, but I've
> found myself, even with my Japanese saws,
> either backing up to re-establish a kerf gone
> astray, or trying to correct a cut.
There's a LOT more to using a handsaw, pull or push to
cut, than just PUSHING or PULLING it through the wood.
Starting the cut is the critical part. If you blow that -
trying to STEER the cut to correct the intial problem -
or once you're into the cut - usually make for more
problems than it might solve.
And this points up another difference between the two
types of saw, and how they're used.
The "pistol grip" push saw encourages / allows you to
do things you shouldn't do.
Let's start with the intial face grain/end grain corner
cut. With a push saw the teeth are cutting "uphill" -
into the end grain. Nora Hall, a euro trained carver, and
excellent teacher (DVD only for me unfortunatley) uses
a "Broom Bristles Analogy". If you try and cut a
broom's bristles from their ends (UPHILL) - the
bristles are separate/spread (tear out) rather than
being severed. BUT - if you cut TOWARDS the end of
the bristles (DOWNHILL) - you can sever them.
So - with a push to cut saw, and the part vertical, you
have to drop your "saw hand" and point the tip of the
saw UP - AND - have the saw at an angle - to start a
Pin Cut - IF you don't want to cut "UPHILL". That's
pretty awkward. If you start the cut down the "back
side" of the part you're sawing into the "end of the
bristles" AND it's also awkward.
With a "pull saw", starting the cut - while standing - is
a LOT less awkward - and avoids the "cutting uphill"
problem.
> The oval handle allows one to correct a cut by
> rotation if necessary, although the best way to
> correct a cut for both styles of saw is to lower the
> angle and bend the blade slightly towards the traced
> line.
That's true - but - unlike a push saw, the pull cut saw
handle discourages "muscling it" to correct a cut gone
awry because it's more delicate, unlike its push cut
cousin.
> But either style of saw is never inherently more
> accurate than the person cutting.
THAT we absolutely agree on. It's usually the Loose
Nut on the handle end that's the source of most
problems - regardles of the tool being used.
> I think that on the push cut, western style handles
> are the most appropriate shape. It's not surprising
> that they are still being made.
Well I'm not so sure about that.
You must remember that european woodworking comes
from a tradition of "do it yourself" - or maybe relying
on a blacksmith or tool maker to make your tools. And
since sophisticaled metallurgy came to europe - and the
americas - late in the game relative to Japan this is
notsurprising. So once you had the saw, YOU had to
keep it sharp. A flat file and a triangular file were all
you needed to do that - and something to hold the blade
while you filed of course.
Japan had much more sophisticated metallurgist/tool
makers - namely sword makers. When Samurai fell
from favor they shifted that edge tool making
knowledge and skills to other things - knives - and
woodworking tools - like the saw. And the clients of
the people who bought their tools were a select few -
who were very powerful folk. So a woodworker with
clients like that could spend some money on great
tools, and that supported great tool makers who had
the knowledge and skills to make great tools - one at a
time - and maintain them when they became dull.
SO - one group of woodworkers went about things with
a Make Do With What You've Got, and a Fix It Yourself
approach. If that meant you needed more muscle to do
the job - well handles were not that hard to make - and
there was plenty of hardwood available. . .
> A western style handle on the pull cut, in my opinion,
> is not appropriate, other than for very rough-cutting
> saws which require a lot of brute force, just as
> straight handles are less apropriate in most cases on
> the push cut (gents saws notwithstanding).
I wasn't suggesting putting a push to cut saw handle on
a pull to cut saw, though there are pull cut saws like
that available today. Those saws may turn out to be
similar to "transition planes" as more american
woodworkers get access to and become familiar with
pull to cut saws, with "stick" handles.