Photomicrographs
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Bill,
Once you find out the magnification which works best, please let me know. if it's within 1000X, I'd like to make an amateur effort.
Wiley
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Photomicrographs
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Bill,
Once you find out the magnification which works best, please let me know. if it's within 1000X, I'd like to make an amateur effort.
Wiley
Re: These points I do agree with
Warren in Lancaster, PA
>Bill, I did not say that your planing was flawed. I have never seen it.
Here is the exchange: On 11/12 you said "On a hand planed surface this [pigment] stain is unacceptably dark, and its hard to control uniformity."
On 11/13 I wrote "When you said that a planed surface stained too dark it was really quite shocking to me. It makes me wonder about the quality of your planing." If you were talking specifically about end grain at the time, I was not aware of it.
Wiley I don't know why end grain should be not be slightly darker than face grain, stained or not. Do you want it to look like edge banding or veneer or real wood?
Re: These points I do agree with
Frank D. in Montreal
>Thans fgor the additional info Bill. My knowledge of sandpaper is still a bit rough (even though I'm an enthusiast when it comes to using it).
I'd certainly be interested in any micrographs you (or others) have to show. Even though I don't use stain much, end grain is still a concern with finish.
I don't turn, so can't comment on that kind of burnishing, but as far as I know any process that compresses the grain or makes it lay flat is called burnishing. When I use a molding plane, for example, I always grab some shavings and rub them along the profile to burnish it (becomes visibly shinier) to flatten any fuzz and make finish go on more evenly. I think planed surfaces don't accept finish as evenly because they don't leave a burnished surface, but cut more cleanly than sandpaper and leave pores exposed.
We agree!
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Thanks Frank,
"as far as I know any process that compresses the grain or makes it lay flat is called burnishing."
It is that idea of compression that I was getting at. And I agree that typically the plane is not burnishing end grain, but rather leaving open straws.
I'm still not sure whether planes burnish face grain though. We're all familiar with planing a board and observing a glossy result. Some woods take a deeper gloss than others--sugar maple (including birdseye) comes to mind in particular. Is that burnishing? And if so, is it sole pressure, or the cutting pressure of the iron, that is doing it? And if it is not burnishing, is that simply what well-sheared wood does? I have to think there is at least a component of burnishing to it.
Wiley
Re: These points I do agree with
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Hi Warren,
"Wiley I don't know why end grain should be not be slightly darker than face grain, stained or not. Do you want it to look like edge banding or veneer or real wood?"
You know, I've never really asked myself that question. On this particular project (I'll have pictures one day), I think it looks better if the top and bottom plates _do_ look like banding. But aren't.
And as I think about it, I am impressed by the look of Chinese and Japanese and Federal (to take a western example) furniture, which eschews end graind, and other period furniture which covers it with moldings. I like breadboard ends over bare ends--many will disagree with that statement. So as a general preference, I like either covered end grain, or else end grain that looks finished.
But here's the caveat, Warren. My opinion doesn't have much value, because I haven't studied older furniture. I've never looked hard at a piece of museum furniture, for example. And in particular, those pieces that have unmolded, unbanded end grain. Like many tea tables I have seen in books: What is the look of the end grain on those tables?
Finally, I am stating a personal preference, but not casting a normative judgment on what others may prefer. There are hills I am ready to die on, but how end grain looks is not one of them.
Wiley
Why don't plane heels "burnish"
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>It would seem that rubbing some shavings on wood would not be materially different from the heel of the hand plane passing over the freshly cut surface. I am not questioning your observation that it isn't, just wondering why.
Re: Why don't plane heels "burnish"
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Hi Bill and all,
I should clarify, I'm raising the question of whether the gloss on wood from planing is burnishing, or if it is something else. Don't claim to know.
Your thought about the heel (of a western plane) performing the same function as rubbed shavings is sensible.
But here are two observations that indicate to me something else is going on:
OBS #1.....The highest gloss I can on wood get is from a Japanese plane, tuned just so. On a Japanese smooth plane, the last thing that touches the wood is the iron, because the tail is in the air. You get compression from the ramp in front of the blade, but then the blade takes the shaving, and nothing follows the blade.
So the primary 'gloss effect' from a Japanese plane must be coming from the blade's
action. But even if you accept that, the question remains whether the blade has left a compressed (burnished) surface, or simply a cleanly sheared surface. Related to this is the fact that the Japanese plane is bedded lower, like in the low 40s usually--this would seem to argue against compression and in favor of a clean-sheared surface.
OBS #2......Notwithstanding OBS#1, the most important variable affecting gloss is the sharpness of the blade (assuming the plane is otherwise well tuned). As the blade dulls, even if it is still cutting just fine, the gloss perceptibly falls off. Again, this argues for the blade as the glossing agent, and it argues against burnishing as the mechanism and in favor of the notion that it is the quality of the sheared surface that gives rise to the gloss. My assumption is that as the blade dulls, burnishing by the iron (if it is happening) should actually increase. But there are imponderables, such as the fact that a truly sharp plane is pulling itself into the work--at the micro level, I can't visualize exactly the forces at the blade edge in that situation.
I think my observations above are more sound than the tentative conclusions I am drawing. However, there are undoubtedly other relevant observations that hopefully others will make, and plenty of room for argument over the conclusions.
Wiley
pure speculation
Frank D. in Montreal
>I've always checked for possible burnishing by plane soles, and have sometimes seen slight tracks that appear slightly less shiny than the planes surface (or simply different), but I think that in general plane soles don't burnish because the surface area is too large in relation to the pressure applied to the surface of the wood. When I burnish a surface with shavings, it's only specific points of a handful of crumpled shavings that come into contact with the wood, and considerable downward pressure has to be applied, as well as multiple passes ("brushing" the shavings back and forth).
I also thin kthat's why machines like a planer with rotary cutterheads burnish wood quite easily, because there is a lot of force applied to a small area, which smashes the wood fibers together. Same with burnishing metal on a scraper with a burnisher, a relatively elevated force applied to a small contact area.
I've thought about this before and that's my take.
Re: Why don't plane heels "burnish"
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>But in the context of end grain, most use flat soles on Japanese jointers, not stepped like smoothing planes. Therefore, when using shooting boards, there may be some burnishing.
Also, Inomoto-san recommends planing very quickly, and the wood surfaces seem to be more highly polished as a result of doing so.
Perhaps the compression done by the toe just prior to cutting has some lasting effect on how much the wood shines.
Pam
Low Bedding Angles & Surface Gloss
Steve Elliott
>When planing softwoods a plane with a steep bed angle will often cause the surface to be cloudy even with a very sharp blade. The reason is the increased forward force of the blade and the fact that softwoods deform ahead of the cutting edge. Even after a thin shaving has been removed the wood below the cut line looks cloudy because of the disturbance to the wood fibers.
Japanese planes made for cutting softwoods have lower bed angles and are less likely to significantly distort the wood. I've found that different softwood species can vary greatly in the amount of cloudiness they show.
As for burnishing by the blade, a dull blade has an area behind the cutting edge that compresses the wood surface just behind the cut. I've never noticed that surface gloss increases as a blade dulls, so I'd guess that burnishing by the blade is not a factor in producing a glossy surface.
I'm convinced
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>