Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Stain and dye question

Posts

Re: Stain and dye question

#26

End grain is amazing

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Bill,

What I am finding amazing, and it's true on other work you have shown, is the brilliance of all that surfacing end grain. You pointed us to the lambs tongue. And it's even, despite the surfacing end grain. But in addition, there are a zillion other places on those turnings, where end grain is surfacing and transitioning into face grain. But the tone does not vary across the curve, from full end grain to full face grain.

It would really be of great benefit if you would discuss how that is achieved on such a large scale. I mean, I can get that effect on details by careful sanding, but you have achieved it all over those spindles and other turnings.

I don't believe that evenness is achieved simply by making the end grain smooth. I can file end grain, and that gives it great clarity when shellacked. But the tone is slightly darker than the face grain on the same wood--I'm wrestling with this right now on some satinwood. It appears that what you are doing is filling the 'straws' of that end grain, so that the finish is not penetrating more than on face grain.

Whatever you can share would be most appreciated.

WIley

Re: Stain and dye question

#27

on maple

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have never successfully pigment stained ash or maple. In fact "gag a maggot" would often be associated with sentences involving pigment staining maple. I am convinced that maple must be dye stained. But even in this case I have seen more indeed crappy stained maple than any other wood. Until I learn to finish it I will continue to avoid using hard maple.

Tony posted a beautifully executed and finished maple tea table on the Main Forum last week. The color reminds one of the most buttery butterscotch one has ever eaten. I wanted to lick it. The steps involved left me exhausted. If you like looking at fine furniture it is worth seeking out his post.

Re: Stain and dye question

#28

the secret revealed.....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Refer to my earlier discussion on how surface preparation must consider what follows.

In the case of the turning, the profiles must be shear cut, not scrapped. Then they are lightly sanded with 220 grit.

The following applies to end grain on edges too. If when you sand with 220 grit the surface isn't bright, it will stain dark. Sanding particles are just like stain particles. If the end grain is rough, or if any grain is rough, it will catch the sanding particles and look dull. On end grain, like on a table, I spend 80% of the sanding time with 100 grit garnet paper. I sand until the surface looks bright. Every dull spot will stain dark, so they must be eliminated. My end grains always stain the same depth as flat grain. If you insist on only planing end grain then don't use pigment stains.

Re: Stain and dye question

#29

Got it,thanks Bill

Bob Hackett

>

Re: Stain and dye question

#30

Re: the secret revealed.....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thanks Bill!

"If you insist on only planing end grain then don't use pigment stains."

My gut preference is for planed or at most filed end grain. And I don't use pigment stain. However. Straight 1lb shellac (in my hands at least) will also take up differently between end grain and face grain. The end grain will be perfectly clear, but slightly darker, using only shellac (no oil). So I think I need to try the sanding thing that you are doing.

Wiley

Re: Stain and dye question

#31

Burnishing?

James Watriss

>Hi Bill...

Are you changing the paper frequently, or are you sanding until the paper smooths out, too? It sounds like the technique is doing as much to burnish the wood as smooth it out. And more so if you go on with the same piece of paper...?

I hereby renew my suggestion for a finishing forum. I think this is the kind of discussion that could really get detailed, and isn't strictly limited in usefulness to troglo-luddites like myself.

Re: Stain and dye question

#32

Burnishing? don't know

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Are you changing the paper frequently,.........Yes. Sandpaper is cheap, my time isn't. So if it isn't cutting its time to change. That said, is the end grain burnished? I don't know. I just know that on a table edge, for example, after I saw and/or plane it, I sand with 100 grit till there are no dull spots. I think this step removes damaged, even "micro-damaged, end grain fibers and once these are gone then the edge will accept stain like the flat grain. BTW, I never risk machine sanding end grain edges. I will machine sand flat surfaces when I need to remove a relatively large amount of wood ( a few thou,) but I always hand sand after 100 or 120 grit.

On turning, it is possible to burnish with the tool as you cut by rubbing the tool bevel on the cut. It leaves a shiny surface which I avoid if I intend to stain. These bevel-burnished surfaces just don't look right.

Re: Stain and dye question

#33

note shellaced example above.

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The Krenov style cabinet in the photo album is finished with shellac. One of the pictures shows some end grain and it will be noted that its luster is identical to the rest. This end grain was sanded like every thing else. On ash I may have quit at 180, can't remember. I usually don't go beyond 180 on porous woods like ash, walnut, oak. What is critical is to be rid of the dull paces that show up with the coarsest grit.

Re: Stain and dye question

#34

Re: Burnishing?

Bob Hackett

>I`m also surprised to find out that the sanding only goes to 220.

I`m sure that,given Bills always thorough nature,he`s found thru experimentation that this is all that`s required.

There has to be a correlation between the final grit and the size of the pigment grain doesn`t there?I mean,if you don`t sand to a fine enough grit then the pigment will lodge in the scratches and instead of accentuating the grain it will accentuate the sanding scratches.

Perhaps I`m thinking too much.

For those who sand,how many have been going beyond 220?

I know on my turnings I need to go to microfine scotchbrite if I want to get the depth and 3D effect I`m looking for on figured wood.

Bill`s turning is superb and the level of finish only enchances that.It just blows me away to think I`ve wasted all that time sanding and sanding thru all those grits when I could have stopped at 220 and been good.

In his e-mail to me Bill once again stressed that finishing needs to be looked at as a holistic process.He also said looking at furniture should be like looking at a painting,alittle distance is needed to get the full effect.I take this to mean everything must work together in tone,color and level of technique in order for nothing to distract and to get the effect the craftsman is trying to convey.

The first thing a woodworker will do is zoom in and scrutinize the details and look for flaws,especially in the finish.The camera has an even more unforgiving eye as the piece is usually flooded by the amount and type of light that will highlite any flaw.

Bill`s work obviously withstands the camera`s critical eye and more than pleases the folks he`s making it for so I for one am going to start sanding some of my more difficult wood instead of stressing the planeing and scraping and see what happens.I also will experiment more with pigmented stain.

If I can get to a position in the pack where I can see Bill up ahead then I,and my customers,will benefit I`m sure.

Mainely,Bob-Going down to the shop to pull out the sandpaper(everything between 100 and 220 at least.The rest will go into a box for now).

Re: Stain and dye question

#35

Sanding and turnings

wilbur

>"But in addition, there are a zillion other places on those turnings, where end grain is surfacing and transitioning into face grain. But the tone does not vary across the curve, from full end grain to full face grain."

After my experiences making bowls and spindle projects on a lathe, I can say that sanding a turned piece is really pretty easy to do compared to sanding a flat board on a workbench, at least for me. The fact that with a lathe the piece is spinning and the sandpaper is relatively stationary allows for a much quicker sanding process.

On that lamb's tongue detail, since presumably that would be sitting on the bench while I went at it with a piece of 120 grit, I would have to do a ridiculous amount of hand sanding to match the amount of sanding that I could achieve in a minute with any workpiece on my lathe turning at 800-1000 RPM or so.

This isn't even considering the fact that most turners will sand their pieces to much higher grits than furniture makers, with 400 grit seeming to be a consensus minimum level of sanding, and going up to above 1000 grit isn't uncommon at all.

In learning how to turn, I've found that turners have lots of things that they gripe about in their field. For some reason, uneven uptake of dyes and stains is not one of them, even though on any turned piece there are always transitions from face to end grain and back. If my assumption about the amount of sanding that can be applied to a turned piece compared to a furniture piece is true, and my reading of Bill's experience with sanding and stain uptake is correct in that he spends a lot of time making sure his surfaces are evenly sanded, which leads to success, then a lot of this is starting to click in my little brain.

Re: Stain and dye question

#36

Finishing Forum

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>James, I think this is the best place for such discussions. I think if there is a general forum, it will be muddied by those who have no idea how to use a smoothing plane, and scuffed up by those who cannot imagine turning without sanding. We have many people in this forum who are eager to learn and who do not shy away from refined techniques that require practice and experience.

You may recall there was a WC carving forum at one time. Discussions there often centered on Dremel and reciprocating machines. For discussions of gouges and chisels, there was more on this forum.

Re: Stain and dye question

#37

Re: the secret revealed.....

darin

>No one has picked up on the use of "Garnet sandpaper". Is this part of Bill's formula that makes him suceed where others have had less sucess?

Re: Stain and dye question

#38

Can`t see why it would be

Bob Hackett

>220 grit is pretty much the same size no matter who makes it or what it`s made of.

What makes a difference is the type of backing,what bonds the grit to the backing and the durability of the grit.

That`s my .o2.

MB

Re: Stain and dye question

#39

Re: Can`t see why it would be

Frank D. in Montreal

>True garnet lasts about 2 seconds compared to aluminum oxide (i.e. it breaks down very quickly). That could explain some burnishing or what amounts to using a finer grit.

I learned that end grain takes a finer grit to get similar finishing results as face grain, so when you'd use 220 for face grain, for example, you'd go to 360 on end grain.

Re: Stain and dye question

#40

AH HA!!

Bob Hackett

>The old used 220 `cause I don`t know where the 300 is trick!

I KNEW there was a secret to it.

I actually suspected there was some burnishing going on.

Let me say this about that.I tried Bill`s technique on an old red oak apothecary chest my wife wanted me to refinish.I picked it up at the dump awhile back and it was in SAD shape.

Everything had to be reglued and the single board back had warped till it split so bad the former owner patched it with plaster B4 painting the inside.The top looked like a banana sandwich.The old exterior paint was removed with 80 grit and a very random orbit sander.The only plus was that the antique door glass was intact till I opened the door and the wood fell apart and dropped it slightly chipping a corner(it didn`t fall far).

Long story short,I made a new back and nailed it on(used a wood skew rabbet plane to ship-lap the old pumpkin pine boards and a Stanley 35 to bevel the edges back to match the case rebate)Ripped the top into smaller boards(used a pull saw) so it`d lay flat,jointed with a 606 and reglued then nailed it back on(most of the old nails had rusted almost in two)Sanded the door parts then reglued after inserting the old glass(yes,it came out square).

I then sanded the case and top with a good orbital sander to 180(I know I cheated) then hand sanded to 220,the end grain got hit with Either 260 or 280 (whatever it was in the box that sat under the 220)till it shined up like the rest.

I pulled out all the old pigment stains my father owned and mixed them up till most of the pigment was suspended then using a piece of red oak ply preped like the case I mixed till I had a close match to the trim and old wood of the top and bottom.I applied the mix like Bill suggested and controlling the color was NOT a problem.I matched the newly sanded wood to the old just like I knew what I was doing,even end grain.I usually just get a gel stain that was in the ballpark and then dub around with glazes and tinted wax till it matches but those days seem to be over.I was so excited I even tried my hand at mixing and applying stain to the back to match the newly planed pine on the bevels to the old orange shellaced pumpkin pine with great success.

The wife was amazed both by the finished product and that I did it so quick.She didn`t even complain about all the shavings in the kitchen(it was cold in the basement).

The only problem is that while the old and new woods match color wise the newly sanded wood isn`t near as beat as the old.But I know how to fix that.;^)

Thanks Bill,for cutting my time and saving my hair.I gotta say,I`m a convert.The pigment stain is staying in my shop rather than my mom`s basement.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Stain and dye question

#41

Re: Burnishing? don't know *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I accidentally burnished the very first project I made, some book shelves when I was 11. The ends of the shelves took up too much finish (probably oil of some sort) for my liking, so I sanded them smooth and hard, then applied no finish because the ends wouldn't take any. Of course, I doubt that the sandpaper was anything near 200, probably 40 or 80, whatever was on hand (oh, yeah, zero cost shelves, my allowance was spent on books).

Since then I've been able to occasionally burnish the end grain with a chisel or plane, they shine all by themselves. There's even a Japanese chisel with a point just for this that I haven't tried yet. Go to the link below to about half way down the page.

At any rate, nothing I do is called finished until the end grain is appropriately finished.

Pam, who loves your work


Daishin Brand Kensaki Chisel(Kensakinomi)

Re: Stain and dye question

#42

Link doesn't go directly there

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Pam,

Hida, it seems, doesn't reveal its navigation in its links - I had to click on Woodworking, then Chisels, to get to the page you meant.

No big deal; just thought I'd mention it.

Re: Stain and dye question

#43

Re: Link doesn't go directly there

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Thanks, Bill, here's a photo instead.

Pam


img

Re: Stain and dye question

#44

The man to speak to about burnishing...

Bob Hackett

>Would be David Barnett.

I`d say he`s the closest thing we have to a resident guru,or SME(subject matter expert,in Army jargon)on the nature of purposeful burnishing and proper burnishing tools.

Jewelers/goldsmiths are great to hang around with if you have more time and money than a normal human.Time to run down the numerous tangents they will spin you off on.Money for the tools(most require diamond tooling)and raw materials(you`re lucky if it`s just semi-precious stone sold by the gram)needed to chase the current tangent.

If you search the archives to see a pic of just some of Dave`s gear you you`ll see that even well heeled woodworkers and mechanics are slackers by comparison.

You have been warned.

Mainely,Bob-Who is shaking his head thinking of how much he paid for the Snap-on toolbox he thought was a deal at the time.

Re: Stain and dye question

#45

Those years of "purposeful burnishing", and now...

David Barnett - SW FL Gulf Coast

>...my failing eyesight. If only I'd listened!

Re: Stain and dye question

#46

I don't agree with either statement

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Indeed garnet wears different from other abrasives but it doesn't fracture to doodle dust like silicon carbide. Garnet paper can be found in a cheap, inferior, bond to the paper and that stuff has no life because the grits fall off.

I sand flat and end grain to the same grit size. If anything the end grain brightens up one grit coarser.

Re: Stain and dye question

#48

Today's experience

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>I'm working on a small Krenov-style satinwood cabinet. Today, I focused on the bottom plate. I had previously finished the edges of this cabinet with a curved scraper, which had the right radius. This was done on both the long grain and end grain edges. The scraper had peeled off lacy shavings, so both the long grain and end grain edges were bright and clear. But when shellac was applied (~1 lb) all edges came up perfectly clear, but the end grain came up a shade darker than the face grain, which I take to mean that the shellac had penetrated just far enough into the end grain 'straws' to give it a slightly darker tone, though still clear and showing no scratches of course.

So I tried Bill's method this morning. With AlOx 150g, 220g, and 320g. As Bill recommended I spent most time with the 150, and much less with the 220 and 320. I did not burnish the edges: The paper was still cutting when I finished up. The wood is quartersawn, so I finished up the 220g and 320g with vertical rubbing strokes, to eliminate the shallow horizontal scratches that are left from cross-grain sanding on the vertical end grain.

I was prepared to quit after 220g, but found that the 320g made a difference. As I say, the grain was not burnished, because the paper was still cutting. However, after you work for a while, the end grain surface begins to get clear (like a photographic print coming up in the emulsion for those who have done that). When it's perfect, no tiny scratches, you're done.

I reapplied the shellac, and the end grain was a shade lighter than before, and now does match the face grain.

When I say burnishing, I mean a surface which has been glazed by pressure from a smooth rubbing device. Is that what we all mean? I don't know whether burnishing will get similar results; however, burnishing is not needed to do what Bill is talking about. And my results indicate that garnet is not magic; this was done with Klingspor AlOx PSA-backed 150g and 220g and a 320g AlOx PSA that MSC sells. I will say that the Klingspor is long-lasting, as was the 320g.

Also I continue to despise sanding, and this was no fun this morning, but I plan to continue following Bill's method on end grain, because cutting it clean with edge tools is not giving me the exact result I'm looking for. The edge tool is leaving a sheared, wide-open set of 'straws' in the end grain, which drink different than face grain. The sandpaper seems to perform some kind of a grain-filling function. Your mileage may vary; someone else may duplicate Bill's end grain results with edge tools, including the technique of burnishing.

But that's my story from this morning.....

Wiley

Re: Stain and dye question

#49

Re: I don't agree with either statement

Frank D. in Montreal

>Hi Bill,

My own experience and everything I've heard about garnet sandpaper indicates that it indeed does burnish surfaces. It may not be too friable, but this might be what causes the burnishing. One link I found among many others confirms my impression about garnet (woodzone.com):

Garnet is a natural abrasive that is still commonly used in woodworking. It is not friable like Aluminum Oxide and tends to wear out a lot faster. This is not necessarily a detriment since garnet will produce a smoother surface than aluminum oxide of the same grit number. It will however cut slower than its stronger cousin will. Garnet is also an excellent choice for a final sanding paper. It has the tendency to burnish, or seal off a wood�s grain. This allows pigmented stains to penetrate woods such as birch, pine, or lauan, more evenly.

This said, I almost never use stain, other than for carpentry work. I do think that pigment stains are good when trying to obtain a tone, but this is always to the detriment of depth and chatoyance. I've never seen a contrary example, as beautiful as some pieces stained with pigment stains are. Just my opinion...

Re: Stain and dye question

#50

These points I do agree with

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Garnet's prickly edges wear off faster than aluminum oxide and I suppose for this reason it historically has been preferred for production machine edge sanding. So, slightly used garnet will leave a different scratch pattern from slightly used aluminum oxide. I don't see much difference in somewhat used, but not used up, aluminum oxide and garnet. As far as I know the particle size does not change (100 grit doesn't become 180 grit ) with use as silicon carbide does.

I made arrangements today to get some photo micrographs of end grain I have sanded to my satisfaction vs one hand planed to the best of my ability which Warren says is flawed. So I challenge him to send me a properly planned end grain for the control, or settle for my best efforts. I can saw with certainty that the sanded end grain is not equivalent to the burnished end grain one gets by rubbing the tool bevel when turning end grain.