Today's experience
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>I'm working on a small Krenov-style satinwood cabinet. Today, I focused on the bottom plate. I had previously finished the edges of this cabinet with a curved scraper, which had the right radius. This was done on both the long grain and end grain edges. The scraper had peeled off lacy shavings, so both the long grain and end grain edges were bright and clear. But when shellac was applied (~1 lb) all edges came up perfectly clear, but the end grain came up a shade darker than the face grain, which I take to mean that the shellac had penetrated just far enough into the end grain 'straws' to give it a slightly darker tone, though still clear and showing no scratches of course.
So I tried Bill's method this morning. With AlOx 150g, 220g, and 320g. As Bill recommended I spent most time with the 150, and much less with the 220 and 320. I did not burnish the edges: The paper was still cutting when I finished up. The wood is quartersawn, so I finished up the 220g and 320g with vertical rubbing strokes, to eliminate the shallow horizontal scratches that are left from cross-grain sanding on the vertical end grain.
I was prepared to quit after 220g, but found that the 320g made a difference. As I say, the grain was not burnished, because the paper was still cutting. However, after you work for a while, the end grain surface begins to get clear (like a photographic print coming up in the emulsion for those who have done that). When it's perfect, no tiny scratches, you're done.
I reapplied the shellac, and the end grain was a shade lighter than before, and now does match the face grain.
When I say burnishing, I mean a surface which has been glazed by pressure from a smooth rubbing device. Is that what we all mean? I don't know whether burnishing will get similar results; however, burnishing is not needed to do what Bill is talking about. And my results indicate that garnet is not magic; this was done with Klingspor AlOx PSA-backed 150g and 220g and a 320g AlOx PSA that MSC sells. I will say that the Klingspor is long-lasting, as was the 320g.
Also I continue to despise sanding, and this was no fun this morning, but I plan to continue following Bill's method on end grain, because cutting it clean with edge tools is not giving me the exact result I'm looking for. The edge tool is leaving a sheared, wide-open set of 'straws' in the end grain, which drink different than face grain. The sandpaper seems to perform some kind of a grain-filling function. Your mileage may vary; someone else may duplicate Bill's end grain results with edge tools, including the technique of burnishing.
But that's my story from this morning.....
Wiley