Stain and dye question
Stephen Shepherd
>I was under the impression that a stain had a pigment that imparted color and a dye changed the color of the wood chemically?
Stephen
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Stain and dye question
Stephen Shepherd
>I was under the impression that a stain had a pigment that imparted color and a dye changed the color of the wood chemically?
Stephen
My understanding too.
Bob Hackett
>
Dyes and stains
David Barnett - SW FL Gulf Coast
>As a rule, dyes are classified by their solubilities in various media, substrate affinities and fixing properties and methods, whereas stains are insoluble pigments with enhancements for substrate deposition, penetration and adhesion. Stains may include dyes.
Re: Stain and dye question
Warren in Lancaster, PA
>I think the word stain has been used for every change of color except paint. In a pigment stain, finely ground pieces of pigment are suspended in the vehicle. They are not dissolved in a solvent and that is why they often settle to the bottom of a can. An example would be burnt umber suspended in oil.
Dye stains are colors that are dissolved in a solvent (water, alcohol, oil etc.). The "particles" in a dye stain are at the molecular level. The do not settle. Examples would be logwood and aniline dyes.
Chemical stains do not have color in themselves, but react with the wood or chemicals in the wood to alter the color. Examples are ammonia and nitric acid. Some preparations include more than one of these types, like a Minwax stain that has both dye and pigment.
Hi David.
Bob Hackett
>"Enhancements for substrate deposition"?
Can you translate that into Mainer please?
It hurt my head just to type it.
Thanks,
MB
What`d you use to finish your anvil stand?I liked whatever that was.
I'll try! I'll try!
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>Additives that help the pigments stick to the wood.
How'd I do, David?
Re: Stain and dye question
James Watriss
>All of the above are correct, but there's probably a word or two that should be mentioned about "who cares?"
Because stains are thicker, they're better suited for more open, porous woods, like oak. They'll deposit in the open pores, and highlight the grain of the wood. On something with a tighter grain, like maple or cherry, or birch, they really won't penetrate as well, and will simply smear around on the surface, and look like crap.
Dyes are thinner, and won't generally leave a perceptible build-up, so with woods like oak and ash, they'll simply change the color of the wood, without really doing much to enhance the wood's appearance. They will change the color of maple and cherry, too, but they don't do as much, usually, to enhance the grain. The sole exception that I've come across, and care about, is on figured woods. Because the planed surface of something like curly maple is actually made up of alternating patterns of face grain and end grain, as the fibers undulate through the wood, the sections with end grain will absorb more dye. It highlights the grain a little bit. If you sand back far enough, you can get an alternating pattern of white face grain, where the dye didn't soak in too deeply, and thus can be planed or sanded off, and dyed end grain, where the dye was able to sink in more deeply.
On cherry, one of my favorite finishes is to dye it lightly with honey amber, and finish up with amber shellac. Nice, warm finish, and still darkens up well over time.
Close, Bill... very close.
David Barnett - SW FL Gulf Coast
>In pigment stains (insoluble colorant) the main deposition goal is even colorant distribution. How well the colorant/pigment hugs the surface (surface isomorphism and penetration) and chemical adhesion at the molecular level follow, of course. Fineness and concentration of pigment particles, vehicle viscosity and substrate condition, such as static electrical charges, are some of the other factors.
For example, I've been using Brian Boggs' quebrocha powder presoak before applying iron acetate ebonizing solution. Boggs' 'wet blend' approach is right on target here. Too-dry RH or my favorite heat gun deaffinitizes colorant to substrate. My improvement is to add surfactants to both aqueous components.
Hi, Bob
David Barnett - SW FL Gulf Coast
>["Enhancements for substrate deposition"?]
Stuff that lowers viscosity, makes water wetter in aqueous solutions, and lets stuff spread and settle more evenly. This may involve aligning and dealigning molecules and particles (not one at a time, Bob).
[Can you translate that into Mainer please?]
Ayyup! Soap 'n' watah.
[It hurt my head just to type it.]
We just use our fingers down here in Florida.
[What`d you use to finish your anvil stand?]
Tried & True varnish oil on the anvil stand, T&T original finish (w/beeswax) on the repousse bench, and Sutherland Welles polymerized tung oil (low lustre) on my workbench base.
Perhaps I should have said...
Bob Hackett
>it hurt my horns to type it.
The horns are connected(loosely)to my head so I guess I`m still close enough.
Glad you took the bait,got a big laugh off the Maine-ah translation.
Can you expand upon the Brian Bogg`s ebonizing thing.It doesn`t have to be in Mainespeak just talk slowly.;^)
MB
Oooo,Jimmy gonna get a whuppin'
Bob Hackett
>I`m picturing multiple fingers poised above send buttons with pics of less than crappy stained cherry and maple under those fingers.
Don`t have to be psychic to see THAT coming.
That and he used the P word(planed)in conjunction with finishing.
MB-Still waiting for the how behind the pics
hmmm.........
Dan Donaldson
>Could you translate that into English ;-)
(ducking and running) ;-)
Please vote on whether cherry looks crappy
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>A friend is learning to photograph furniture. He came by to practice on some of my stuff which he posted at the link below. I don't know how to extract a picture from this place but it opens promptly so there will be no problem viewing it.
BTW, until you can prepare end grain for pigment staining like the lambs tongues on the spool bed don't conclude that pigment staining will look like carp.
http://redboston.com/pics/Tindall_20091122/
Re: Please vote on whether cherry looks crappy
Marv
>That is gorgeous work, Bill,
One way to easily grab only one image is to right click on it and then save it to your picture files on your computer, then you can open it in here in the Optional Graphic Upload box from your computer.
Marv
Re: Please vote on whether cherry looks crappy
Warren in Lancaster, PA
>Yes, it certainly does look like pigment stain. I think it is inviting trouble to post pictures of one's work and ask people to declare it poor.
Outstanding work as usual.
Bob Hackett
>I am especially impressed by the turning on the cherry bed.
May I ask some specific questions in relation to the finishing?
Starting with the ash wall cabinet.How old is it?What is it finished with and are there any added UV inhibitors involved in the finish?
Next,the cherry bed.You mentioned the prep work on the lamb`s tongue,a tough transition from end grain to side grain and yet the staining is even and reveals no blotching(something cherry is famous for)even in the transition.Care to share the secret?Does it involve shellac as a prep before the stain?
Finally the mahogany piece.What made you go with minimum pore filling?
Did you elect to not completely fill the pores in the top surface too?
If not,why not?It`s my understanding that a filled and french polished(or equivalent)top would be the traditional finish on a piece of this type and caliber.Please feel free to correct me if this is a false assumption.
You also have mentioned that you use a technique to apply pigment stain using a rubber similar to the ones used in french polishing.Would you care to reveal the materials and construction of the rubber if it is at all different from a french polishing rubber?
If you use a rubber to apply the stain then what is the vehicle that the pigment is suspended in and how does the pigment transfer thru the cloth and not get filtered out of suspension by the cloth used?
Thanks in advance Bill.I will further ask you to bear with me as your answers will no doubt spark further question from my end.
I say in all sincerity that the finishes you achieve are the types of finishes any craftsman aspires to,I know I do.
Mainely,Bob
BTW-Your friend appears to be doing a fine job of learning to take excellent photos of furniture.
Nah, it all looks great.
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>
Boggs' quebrocha bark tea ebonizing trick *LINK*
David Barnett - SW FL Gulf Coast
>If you've ever tried ebonizing oaks with iron dissolved in vinegar, you know there's a fair amount of variability in the intensity, depth, and warmth of color, largely dependent on the resident tannins in your wood sample. For greater uniformity and depth, some have added tannins to the wood, whether by strong tea or chemical grade tannic acid. Tea can help, although it's not terribly predictable and too often falls short in my experience, and plain tannic acid leaves both me and the wood cold -- a cold blue in the wood's case. It seems natural tannins are more complex than pure tannic acid, which is only one component. It's also expensive.
So Brian Boggs learned about quebrocha bark from his father, gave it a try, and came up with a viable dying schedule producing a rich warm and deep black on the usual suspects such as oaks and walnuts, but extends to low tannin species, as well. It's reasonably predictable, reproducible, safe, and produces the prettiest ebony coloring without obscuring the grain on the widest range of woods. Although Moser's and Lockwood's ebony dyes are fine on walnut, nothing beats this improvement on an old-fashioned method on oaks and fruitwoods and mahoganies -- even BB plywood glue-ups (a light solution can yield a gray and black pinstripe).
It's also just the thing for cerused finishes; ash, oak, whatever, and there are neat things to do with quebrocha if you're into leatherwork or papermaking. As a colorant, quebrocha is a gorgeous russet.
The source for the quebrocha bark powder is:
Van Dykes Taxidermy
www.vandykestaxidermy.com
Catalog no: 108025
Item no: 01347179
2lbs. @ $9.99
I guess this much be catching on. They upped their price since I recently ordered, but it's still cheap. I bought 5lbs. for 15 dollars.
As for the original article, the PWW website was down at this posting, but here's the link to Brian Bogg's article.
Ebonizing wood
I suppose I could try...
David Barnett - SW FL Gulf Coast
>...but Esperanto is my native language.
;-)
Dan Donaldson
>
Thanks David.
Bob Hackett
>I`ve been looking for something with less of a purple undertone.
Hate to go thru all that trouble of making and filtering the vinegar only to have to hit it with dilute india ink after.
How light fast is this new stuff?
MB
Re: Boggs' quebrocha bark tea ebonizing trick
Larry Barrett
>David - I was trying Brian Boggs' technique just last night and read your post in the middle of things. You mentioned in a note above that your "improvement is to add surfactants to both aqueous components". I assume you are talking about making it easier for the solutions (the bark tea and the vinegar/iron solutions) to soak into the wood; could you expand on what you are using here to aid in the process? - Larry Barrett (no relation, as far as I know).
Lightfastness? According to Boggs, very much so.
David Barnett - SW FL Gulf Coast
>
Yep...
James Watriss
>I sure did.
Thankfully, the flogging and flaming I'll get in here will still (I think) be of a more congenial nature than the 'pleasant' conversations I had with various extended family members over the holiday weekend. I start to think that people rush out to take part in black Friday to get away from their families at any cost.
I'm big enough (especially after Thanksgiving) to say that clearly my experience level with pigment stains is not up to Bill's level. That bed is gorgeous. Open mouth, insert foot.
I'll revise and say that my experiences with pigment stains on cherry have been both limited, and uninspiring. And even worse with Maple.
On a separate note, I start to think sometimes that WC should have a finishing board. It's a common need for most folks, and it's a pretty critical skill... a good finish can really help out a piece that didn't come together as well as expected. And a bad finish would really do a lot of damage to a great piece of work.
Then again, there's a lot of potential for such a board to devolve into a small civil war, as the varied opinions and experience levels start butting heads. It'll be even worse than the ongoing fights between the dinosaurs with their oil stones, the mouth breathers with their water stones, and the uppity geeks with their diamond paste.
(I actually use all three, depending on need. Suffice to say I'm feeling a little punchy after the third cup of coffee, and too many days involving too much family.)
(ducking and running for cover...)
Happy Sunday, all. Hope your long weekend has been a good one.
-J
answered by email
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>