Re: Carving tools-opinions please
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Hi Geoff,
First off, Welcome!!
I not a carver, but do use gouges to fashion ornaments sometime, such as cabinet pulls and the like. And also to use the gouges to make certain kinds of inlay and banding.
I have Pfeil (Pfeil = Swissmade, the terms are used interchangeably), Ashley Iles, plus a couple German brands (Two Cherries, same as Kirschen, and Dastra).
I like long, thin bevels, so prefer the Pfeil and Two Cherries.
For starting off, one of the things you will need to learn is how to sharpen these gouges. Do you have some way to do that? And in that regard, it really helps to know how a sharp gouge cuts and feels.
I think there is some benefit starting out, in getting gouges that come sharp enough from the factory to do real work. If you do that, you have an idea of what 'sharp' means, and therefore what you will need to shoot for when you resharpen yours. If you start out with gouges that require much sharpening to get started, then that will become the project, plus you still won't know what 'sharp' is, unless you have considerable experience in other edged tools.
In terms of initial sharpness, Pfeil stands out, followed by Ashley Iles (mainly requires a stropping), then Two Cherries (they're beveled well, but are not sharp).
I recommend Pfeil for you (Swiss made), based on the low bevel angle and initial sharpness. And the steel is fine. I should add perhaps: the Pfeil's are not the most beautiful--they have an internal ferrule, and a handle that looks like they got too good a deal on some wood. Plus they're not all lacquered and shiny like the Two Cherries. Never mind those things.
One other suggestion: Stay away from sets. Maybe someone can point their finger at a useful set, but I have never seen one that came close to what I needed. The sets tend to contain sizes they can't sell otherwise--in my estimation. Somewhere on these pages, Lee Grindinger has a short list of really useful sizes. Perhaps someone knows where that is.
Wiley