Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Carving tools-opinions please

Posts

Carving tools-opinions please

#1

Carving tools-opinions please

Geoff (in Madison)

>I am making my first forays into carving (I need something quiet to do in my basement shop while the little kids are sleeping).

Therefore I need to buy some carving tools. I am planning mostly on low relief stuff for now.

The local Woodcraft store steered me to the Flexcut brand as a middle of the road, but still decent brand (and on sale 30% off until tomorrow). A few years ago Popular Woodworking had an article by David Calvo and in his opinion the Two Cherries brand was the gold standard, followed by British made ones (i.e. Henry Taylor).

Anyone have some opinions they would care to share with me?

Thanks,

Geoff

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

#2

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

R.J.Whelan - Sierras, California

>Geoff ... I don't do much carving, but I did buy some Flex Cut tools several years ago and found the edge holding to be pretty poor. I ended up buying a miss matched kit (one or two at a time): mostly Two Cherries and Ashley Iles - I've been pretty happy with both brands .. rj

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

#3

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

GolfSteve in Calgary

>My brand preferences are:

1. Pfiel (consistently excellent; maybe a bit lightweight if you do a lot of heavy mallet work),

2. Warren (I only own the Fishtail Gouge, but it is my favourite gouge),

2. Ashley Isles (I only own one, but am impressed),

3. Flexcut (I've only used their knives, which are excellent),

4. Two-cherries (I own a set of these; they are good but whatever they lacquer the tools with is a pain),

5. Henry Taylor (some are good tools; others don't hold an edge well).

Most of my carving tools are either Pfiel or Henry Taylor. Both are good, but I've found the Henry Taylor tool's edge holding ability to be inconsistent

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

#4

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I use mostly Henry Taylor tools. The two most common brands used by professional carvers in this area are Swiss Made and Henry Taylor. I have seen the Ashley Iles tools, but they seem awfully heavy, more the weight of firmer gouges. The Flexcut remind me of linoleum block tools.

I suggest that you get one or two each of at least three brands. That way you can decide what you like.

Don't get short "beginners" tools. Too hard to get both hands on for paring. A six year old can handle a full size tool.

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

#5

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I use Dastra, Stubai, Takahashi, Pfeil, and miscellaneous others; but I'm no expert carver, just follow along with the training tapes. Some of the Takahashi are very handy for regular woodworking tasks, like the skews for dovetailing and the small yarikanna for larger planing jobs.

Pam

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

#6

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

Bob Hackett

>I have afew Dastra that I`m impressed with,mostly spoon gouges.

The rest of my kit consists of old iron(what a surprise)and ranges from James Cam to Charles Buck.I picked these up one at a time as I found them or found need of them.

The only real set I own is a Miller`s Falls palm set I inherited from my father.They`re surprisingly good tools.

MB

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

#7

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

James Watriss

>I have Pfeil and Ashley Iles...

I think I like the durability of the Ashley Iles better. But the Pfeil is good once you sharpen em a few times and get past what I think is a pretty thin bevel.

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

#8

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Geoff,

First off, Welcome!!

I not a carver, but do use gouges to fashion ornaments sometime, such as cabinet pulls and the like. And also to use the gouges to make certain kinds of inlay and banding.

I have Pfeil (Pfeil = Swissmade, the terms are used interchangeably), Ashley Iles, plus a couple German brands (Two Cherries, same as Kirschen, and Dastra).

I like long, thin bevels, so prefer the Pfeil and Two Cherries.

For starting off, one of the things you will need to learn is how to sharpen these gouges. Do you have some way to do that? And in that regard, it really helps to know how a sharp gouge cuts and feels.

I think there is some benefit starting out, in getting gouges that come sharp enough from the factory to do real work. If you do that, you have an idea of what 'sharp' means, and therefore what you will need to shoot for when you resharpen yours. If you start out with gouges that require much sharpening to get started, then that will become the project, plus you still won't know what 'sharp' is, unless you have considerable experience in other edged tools.

In terms of initial sharpness, Pfeil stands out, followed by Ashley Iles (mainly requires a stropping), then Two Cherries (they're beveled well, but are not sharp).

I recommend Pfeil for you (Swiss made), based on the low bevel angle and initial sharpness. And the steel is fine. I should add perhaps: the Pfeil's are not the most beautiful--they have an internal ferrule, and a handle that looks like they got too good a deal on some wood. Plus they're not all lacquered and shiny like the Two Cherries. Never mind those things.

One other suggestion: Stay away from sets. Maybe someone can point their finger at a useful set, but I have never seen one that came close to what I needed. The sets tend to contain sizes they can't sell otherwise--in my estimation. Somewhere on these pages, Lee Grindinger has a short list of really useful sizes. Perhaps someone knows where that is.

Wiley

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

#9

Re: Carving tools-opinions please *LINK*

woodburnbob

>I was going to mention SJ Addis and others of vintage, but better no one thinks of them. 40 years ago my dad scored a large number of Addis' for a few bucks at a the garage sale of a very old fellow in a retirement place and offered them to me as a gift. Took me 30 years to learn what I'd actually been given, some years after Dad died.

Wiley, you reminded me of Lee Grindinger. It hasn't been that long since I read something like you mention. Here's your comment at the time:

I found Lee's recommendations to be perfect. *NM* (views: 6) -- Wiley Horne--Glendora CA -- Saturday, 4 October 2003, at 5:07 p.m.

I had to do an archive search on Grindinger as a keyword to hit the payload. Searching his name turns up little.

I googled him too, as that is where the links to his list lead. Too bad. Seems www.furnituremaker.com no longer exists. There are mirror image sites on the WWW that record all that was on the WWW at some particular time. I messed around with that service at one time. So, even if somebody shut down their site in 2005, say, one might be able to find a mirror image of everything that had been there stored on some huge Big Brother server.

Occasionally there were presumably juicy blow-outs on this very site in past years that I'd miss seeing but know something happened by the telltale message for a moderator that, say, 9 posts had been summarily delete because of uncivil discourse. No problem. I'd go looking for it on a mirror and sometimes find it. I'm a curious guy.


Old thread from 2003

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

#10

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

John Aniano in NJ...

>Geoff,

I like the Pfeil brand best in new chisels, and Henry Taylor least (the latter had steel that was annealed too soft...). In old chisels, Addis, Butcher, Buck Brothers, Charles Buck.. all can be excellent if you can find them.

John

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

#11

Lee Grindinger's list *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hello Bob,

I can't get to Lee's original recommendations either ("Safari can't find the server, blah blah").

Anyway, in a previous go-round on this same matter, Dan Donaldson transcribed Lee's comments. See here:

http://woodcentral.com.ldh0138.uslec.net/cgi-bin/archives_handtools.pl?read=31302&v1=e2vrt43&v2=circular+saw&v4=spray+gun&v5=dfrwq67

This is not to suggest there is a 'magic set' of gouges that is good for everyone. But I would say selecting from these is better than buying a pre-selected set from a vendor.

Note in the link that the continental numbering of gouge sweeps (think Pfeil, Two Cherries, Stubai) differs from the Sheffield system (Ashley Iles) by 1 unit. For example, a Pfeil 6-sweep will be about the same as a Sheffield 5-sweep.

Here is a useful comparison chart published by Joel (Tools for Working Wood) on differences between Ashley Iles and Two Cherries gouges:

http://www.toolsforworkingwood.com/Merchant/merchant.mvc?Screen=NEXT&StoreCode=toolstore&nextpage=/extra/carvecompare.html

Wiley


Lee Grindinger (per Dan Donaldson)

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

#12

The good brands

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>There is an easy way to tell if you are looking at a good brand. They will be 9 or 10 inches long and will have well over a hundred different tools available. Straight gouges, bent, spoon, back bent, veiners, v tools, skews and more. You need to have serious carvers using your tools to maintain this kind of variety. Of the brands that meet these criteria, all are good, but individual carvers will have preferences.

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

#13

scott grandstaff

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

scott grandstaff

>I like a fairly shallow, around 3/8-1/2 wide and slight fishtail shape gouge. I have several.

I can get more from this basic shape than from 22 other shapes.

A mid sized V gouge and a deeper gouge or three.

These are my most used basics.

From my own experience, I think everyone who ever made carving tools made good ones and made some duds.

Nobody bats 1000 and just because I got a bad Sorby once (and I did) doesn't mean many thousands weren't excellent (have some of those too)

Every brand is good, most of the time.

I'd say pick the handle style and blade length/weight you suspect might be comfortable. Give it a go.

Try another.

I never let a good carving tool get away if it is offered reasonable (which for me you can read extremely reasonable hhee hhe),

whatever brand.

I look for the size, shape and weight much more than brand.

I have never been able to pick the completely perfect universal chisel handle, so after 1 or 200 I have made, I am still looking.

Oh yeah, the best wood carver I ever knew uses tools I wouldn't pick up out of the gutter, for free.

Determined man, our Matthew.

yours Scott

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

#14

Forgot to mention Addis, but ...

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>they're only available used. The variety and quality is wonderful.

Pam

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

#15

translating sweeps

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>The number system used for Addis tools corresponds to the number of segments of that profile to complete a full circle. Thus a 1/2" wide #5 is 1/5 of a circle and a 7/8� wide #5 is also 1/5 of a circle yet they are completely different shaped sweeps. In the Pfeil numbering system all #5 tools have the same shaped sweep regardless of their width. Their is no correlation to the two systems or any way to convert by adding or subtracting anything. Once you understand that it all makes sense.

Robin

Ps. There is a very good reason why a half used up Addis in need of a new handle will often exceed the cost of a new Pfeil and it isn't for their collector value.

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

#16

I have an opinion, for what it's worth

Roy Anderson

>I'm not an expert carver, but I do some carving. Like me, you started out at the local Woodcraft store and they steered you to the Flex cut. Don't bite. Let me have that experience for you.

First, why does it make sense for a cutting tool to flex? It should be rigid so it is controllable, predictable and all your force is directed toward cutting the wood fibers. This line about it flexing around the profile of what you are trying to cut just doesn't add up. They are also short. This is occasionally handy, but not frequently. Most often, you need to get two hands on the tool for controlability.

Note the passionate opinions of a rank amateur.

Still, I prefer Swiss made. They have a hexagonal handle, so the tools are less likely to roll off your workbench. I have a few Ashley Isles, a Two Cherries and a couple of strangers I got off E-Bay, and they work just fine, also.

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

#17

Much thanks for the help...------WebKitFormBoundar

Geoff (in Madison)------WebKitFormBoundary+lGVXr1g

>I have several of the suggested books on order from the library and will start to price out the starter tools mentioned ---working up to Lee's list. As for sharpening, I have a full set of waterstones and hand sharpen all my chisels and plane irons, but may look at getting something motorized.

------WebKitFormBoundary+lGVXr1ge8lmXeVA

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

#18

Re: Much thanks for the help...------WebKitFormBou

Tony - Memphis

>I use Pfeil and have been very happy with them. They replaced the orignal taylor tools I got (would not hold an edge). I would steer away from a "set" of tools. Pick a project and buy what you need for that project. As expensive as they are, yo don't need to buy tools you won't use. Also, water stones aren't realyl a good choice for sharpening carving tools. You really need something more durable like an oil stone. Carving tools will wear ruts in your water stones in short order. You might look at Chris Pye's book on sharpening carving tools. Its rare that a motorized sharpener will really be needed for a carving tool. Its one of those things that is probably quicker by hand. Once in a while, you will need to regrind, but no often. You might also look at Chris Pye's DVD on sharpening (maybe it a carving dvd that covers sharpening?). Anyway, good luck with your carving. It is a lot of fun and a great way to take your woodworking to the next level.

Tony

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

#19

Source for sharpening slips

Bob Hackett

>A good place to look is in old machinist tool lots or boxes.Or ask an old machinist for that matter.

Be aware that some can be very coarse grit but for the price(Like 3 for $1 up here) you can afford alot of them.Reshape as needed on diamond stones.

MB

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

#20

Re: translating sweeps

Don McConnell

>Robin et al,

I agree that one can't simply add or subtract a number to get an accurate comparison of the Sheffield List (London Pattern) and European sweep charts. (More on this in a moment.) But, the rest of what you say contains so many inaccuracies that I feel the record needs to be set straight in order to avoid unnecessarily confusing people.

First, the Sheffield List numbering system does not indicate a given segment/portion of the circumference of a circle as you suggest - i.e., that a # 5 is 1/5th of a circle of that radius. If that were true, the #9 should be 1/9th of a circle, and it is actually one-half of a circle. And the same holds true for the rest of the sweeps.

What is true of BOTH the Sheffield and European sweep charts is that the gouges of each sweep have the same proportions. In other words, the width and depth of the arc of each gouge of a sweep have the same ratio to each other (not the same radius). This holds true whether one expresses this in terms of degrees of arc, as Michel Auriou does, or in terms of the radius of each size gouge, based on its width. Some time back, I worked out a method for arriving at the latter for the London Pattern/Sheffield List charts:

http://www.planemaker.com/articles_gouges.html

And, one can arrive at the same values for the European charts using exactly the same approach. (Actually, upon some reflection, it becomes clear that there is no other logical approach to creating a system of sweeps for carving gouges.) For purposes of this discussion, I've compared the two systems (using a chart from Two Cherries), and am attaching a pdf file with the basic results. Hopefully, it will be of some value.

Incidentally, for what it's worth, amongst former manufacturers of carving gouges, I've become pretty fond of the Herring Bros. gouges out of London. And the few D. R. Barton gouges I've encountered have been high quality, as well. Regarding contemporary makers, I've not used enough Pfeil gouges to have anything meaningful to say about their steel, but am frustrated by the fact that most of the other major current makers are producing carving gouges which are so heavy/clunky as to impair their utility.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR

------WebKitFormBoundaryKDS9xRai7xiy+BT8


img

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

#21

Is a Two Cherries column missing?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Don,

Your derivation of gouge sweep radii is a wonderful example of observation and analysis and deduction.

In the graphic you posted, I believe the Two Cherries radius column got lost somewhere. I am very eager to see what you have discovered.

Wiley

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

#22

Re: Is a Two Cherries column missing?

Don McConnell

>Hi Wiley,

Nothing is missing - the column down the center relates to both the Sheffield and Two Cherries sweep charts. It shows that the Sheffield sweep numbers 3, 4, 8 & 9 are essentially equal to the same numbered sweeps in the Two Cherries chart; while the remaining sweeps differ by one, or don't correspond at all.

Though, upon reflection, I can see that I confused things by the wording in my message. When I agreed that one can't correlate one system to another by simply adding or subtracting a number, my intent was to indicate that the correlations isn't as simple as each sweep number being "off" by one.

Since we're discussing, this, though, it may be helpful to point out that there is some leeway in determining the actual value of the multiplier - especially in the slower sweeps. But, the values I arrived at, especially for the Sheffield List, were those which gave me the most consistent results when working with a variety of early sweep charts.

It might be possible to "massage" these values to give results more consistent with the "degrees of circumference" figures supplied by Michel Auriou, but I really don't think that would gain us anything meaningful. Meanwhile, I think the radius values generated by my approach are potentially more useful.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

#23

Most helpful!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Don,

Thank you. Now I look at it and it's perfectly clear. It's an interesting thing--a little while ago, I went to my bench and picked out two pairs of gouges (upon which my earlier statement was based):

First pair......... Ashley Iles 5sweep/19mm and Two Cherries 6 sweep/20mm

Second pair.... Ashley Iles 6sweep/26mm and Dastra (Germ.) 7 sweep/20mm

These pairs overlay virtually exactly on each other, as predicted by your chart. I was going to post the comparative gouge strikes to demonstrate--that won't be necessary now.

Little did I realize that these were the ONLY two combinations of sweeps that the "difference of one" rule applies to, and is incorrect for any other combinations.

In citing the 'difference of one' rule, I was trying to be helpful, because when I bought the first pair of gouges above, I didn't realize they were functionally the same tool!

However, your chart shows the total relationship between the two systems, and I hope the chart gets some notice, because it provides good guidance to any newbie (or maybe not so newbie) who is buying mix and match gouges from the two systems.

Wiley

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

#24

Make it an article

Dan Donaldson

>It might be good to take the table along with a bit of explanation and add it to the articles. That way it would always be available.

Re: Carving tools-opinions please

#25

best advice is to join a carving club

Bob Demers

>Carving is a very personal thing, as in style, wood favored, tools used, sharpening angles and methods, but there is always one constant.

You MUST use sharp tools. The first thing that a carver notice on a piece is the quality of the cuts.

I had been sharpening by hands my chisels and plane irons for years before i joined a club (Annapolis Valley Woodcarvers) and thought I was doing a decent job. well, let me tell you that i did not knew sharp before I joined them....Carvers are fanatic about their edges and rightly so, a so so edge is dangerous.

The advantage of joining a carver clubs are numerous, but above all it will shorten your learning curve and steer you in all the right choices.

The biggest obstacle a beginner face is the lack of sharpness on his tools. Carving tools, especially the V gouge can be tricky to sharpen.

Hence why you should learn to maintain your edge by hand before going to motorised helpers or you run the risk of ruining your tools in a hurry.

A carver choice of woods and style affect the bevel angle best suited, hence why traditionally, English tools such as Henry Taylor are supplied with only a basic grind, the final sharpening is left to the carvers. That is true to various degrees with most with one glaring exception: Pfiel or Swiss made tools.

They come users sharp from the manufacture, hence why they are the best reccomendation for a beginner. (truth be know I still hone them first, its the fanatical part in me :-)

They also hold an edge and are well balanced. Now you know why they are often seen in magazine and favored by most.

Join a club, get helpful advices, get to use hands on various brands, learn to sharpen, strop your edges often, have fun, enjoy the camaraderie among carvers

Bob, carving since 1998