Re: Question for Adam
Adam Cherubini, NJ
>Sloane was wrong about a great many things, Patrick. His books are beautiful works of art, inspired by old tools and their products. But I don't get the sense he had much personal experience with tools. The turning saw he refers to as hickory looks a lot like Dominic's. Can't imagine it would survive real use for the same reason Dom's failed. That's simple physics. Who knows if the saw that inspired the drawing was actually hickory. It looks a lot like the saw in Sturbridges's collection today depicted in Jay Gaynor's book "Tools:...".
Don't tell Bugbear, but Joel's saw is a beautiful copy of Duncan Phyfe's (regardless of what his ad copy says). Joel loves the Phyfe chest. His Gramercy saws are very good copies of the Phyfe saws. And the Phyfe chest is in New York. I believe Joel has seen it. There aren't that many of these saws over here. I could probably point to a half dozen of these, mostly pictures in books.
As for Americans using hickory to make their turning saws, there's this sense that there were lots of colonial (pre 1776) cabinetmakers working on the frontier. I don't think that's quite true. I'm sure there were some (like the Dominys). I also think there's a sense that American cabinetmakers were making their own tools. Or that frontiersmen and farmers all had English turning saws, or knew what they were, or wanted them. This is a specialized tool.
My guess is the overwhelming percentage of English style turning saws on North America were made in England of beech.
I guess if there's a teachable moment here it's that sometimes the form is connected to the material. Be careful how you substitute.
Now I'm going to say it here clearly so we can end this discussion. Joel is a friend of mine, He's very smart. One can, and I'm sure he has, tweaked his design and the orientation of his stock to produce a nice light strong tool. For those of you making your own, use maple or beech if you don't want to carefully align your stock.
Better yet, recognize that as simple as this tool seems, it's actually a bit more complex than that. Just buy it from Joel complete and forget about it. I got to use one in Berea and I really liked it. I had trouble giving it back. I've seen Chirs Storb's. He bought Joel's kit and made the saw carefully to Joel's designs. That saw hangs in the conservation lab at the Philadelphia Museum of Art and is no nicer than Joel's production version.
Peace?
Adam