"Patriot" engineering
Adam Cherubini, NJ
>Everyone who dresses in colonial clothing and even stands next to any woodworking tools invariably gets asked about the scene from the movie "The Patriot" in which the main character weighs a newly finished sack back windosr before sitting in it to test it's strength.
My understanding is that many of the scenes in the movie are accurate including some of those that seem the most far fetched. The chairmaking scene is one that is not accurate. "Lightness" was indeed a design goal for early chair builders, but that lightness was usually in the spindles in the back and the bendings, not the structural undercarriage. And even 1/2" or 3/8" spindles when riven are surprisingly strong.
But turning saws DO seem to be a rare example of a colonial tool that is on the edge of structural integrity. The arms on these are often quite light. As you guys make these saws with Joel's kit, keep in mind a couple things:
1) Joel's patterns are none too forgiving. He copied a saw that was pretty close to the edge. I'm not suggesting beefing up the arms. But I can give you a couple tips that will help you stick to the plan and not crack your arms.
2) Start with riven stock. You CAN rive kiln dried material.
3) I don't think hickory, oak, or ash are good choices. These are strong woods when the grain is left intact. But when you cut away bits of it here and there, I think you are asking for it. These saws were almost always beech. The reason for this is probably that they were English tools and Englishmen used beech for tools. But I think the more isotropic nature of beech (it seems to have good cross grain properties which can make it difficult to rive) seems to facillitate the design. Maple might be a good choice as well.
4) Dominic's failure may have been caused by tight fitting tenons. The tenons have to allow some rotation or the upper arms will bend without tensioning the blade. I've made several saws like this. I tried the curved shoulders, just making loose joints, pegs, and fixing the near side tenon and making the far side loose. The issue is when the blade is rotated 90 degrees, if the near side tenon is sloppy the arm will roll disconcertingly about its centerline. So if you make the tenon loose, make it only so in the direction you want rotation in.
On an estehtic note, I prefer to see less contrast in the parts. Like a windsor chair, these items esthetically are all about line elements. The added colors (and I've seen alot of guys mixing in jungle woods) detract from the visual "swing" of these saws in my opinion. In this, I speak from experience. My saw is all maple with beautifully shaped arms based on an original saw in a family collection. But I added a curved center stretcher in poplar, painted it green and carved (poorly) ugly leaves into it. The saw works great so I haven't yet given myself the time to swap out the stretcher. But it's a hideous tool, that I'm ashamed of, and I actively try to keep it out of my column.
Adam
P.S. These saws make effective coping saws. The long skinny handle is actually better on the pull side of the saw. You may be better off with the same long skinny handle on either arm. I grip the arm where the pin comes thru, pointing my fore finger along the blade just as you would any other saw.