Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Bowsaw Mark 1

Posts

Bowsaw Mark 1

#1

Bowsaw Mark 1

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Well, here it is. My 12" Bowsaw in Hickory and Coccobolo. It's probably the shortest lived of my projects in my wood working career!

Right after I took these photos I turned the toggle one too many times and snapped the left arm!

Photobucket

Photobucket

To be brutally honest, I wasn't thrilled with my work on the arms. I should have cut the mortises and curved shoulders BEFORE bandsawing and shaping the curves! I ended up eliminating the curved shoulders and then going with a flat face. This lead to me needing a new crosspiece and then turned out to be an uneven fit (from the mortise faces) that made the two arms not as coplanar as they should have been. In addition, I felt that I had made the tapered portion of the arms too thin (That's what happens when you get a nice wooden spoke shave and get all frisky with it!). This allowed for unequal stresses which, along with over-tightening, caused the one arm to fail.

I will say this, in the 1 minute and 20 seconds :>) I did get to use this I was surprised at how well it worked! I was cutting curves almost effortlessly. But sadly my enthusiasm was short lived.

So I learned a ton from this first effort and will reuse the toggle, knob, and handle in my next bowsaw project.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

#2

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

Greg B�tit, Crown Point, NY

>I have to admire your courage. Your saw looks great. The saw I made from the 12" Tools for Working Wood kit is so ugly I wouldn't dare share a picture of it. I used some "rosewood" crating that came protecting some furniture one of my sons had sent from Pakistan. But like you I find it is a marvelous saw that can turn on a dime. The knobs and handle turned out OK, but some day I'm going to make a nice looking frame for it...

greg

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

#3

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

Jesper, Denmark

>Hi Dom,

You may want to change the grain orientation next time. The arms are less prone to splitting if the grain is turned 90 degrees from the way you have it now.

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

#4

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

wilbur

>Oh, bowsaw, we hardly knew ye.

Dominic, would you care to post a picture of the bowsaw after it cracked? I'm curious to see where and how it broke.

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

#5

"Patriot" engineering

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>Everyone who dresses in colonial clothing and even stands next to any woodworking tools invariably gets asked about the scene from the movie "The Patriot" in which the main character weighs a newly finished sack back windosr before sitting in it to test it's strength.

My understanding is that many of the scenes in the movie are accurate including some of those that seem the most far fetched. The chairmaking scene is one that is not accurate. "Lightness" was indeed a design goal for early chair builders, but that lightness was usually in the spindles in the back and the bendings, not the structural undercarriage. And even 1/2" or 3/8" spindles when riven are surprisingly strong.

But turning saws DO seem to be a rare example of a colonial tool that is on the edge of structural integrity. The arms on these are often quite light. As you guys make these saws with Joel's kit, keep in mind a couple things:

1) Joel's patterns are none too forgiving. He copied a saw that was pretty close to the edge. I'm not suggesting beefing up the arms. But I can give you a couple tips that will help you stick to the plan and not crack your arms.

2) Start with riven stock. You CAN rive kiln dried material.

3) I don't think hickory, oak, or ash are good choices. These are strong woods when the grain is left intact. But when you cut away bits of it here and there, I think you are asking for it. These saws were almost always beech. The reason for this is probably that they were English tools and Englishmen used beech for tools. But I think the more isotropic nature of beech (it seems to have good cross grain properties which can make it difficult to rive) seems to facillitate the design. Maple might be a good choice as well.

4) Dominic's failure may have been caused by tight fitting tenons. The tenons have to allow some rotation or the upper arms will bend without tensioning the blade. I've made several saws like this. I tried the curved shoulders, just making loose joints, pegs, and fixing the near side tenon and making the far side loose. The issue is when the blade is rotated 90 degrees, if the near side tenon is sloppy the arm will roll disconcertingly about its centerline. So if you make the tenon loose, make it only so in the direction you want rotation in.

On an estehtic note, I prefer to see less contrast in the parts. Like a windsor chair, these items esthetically are all about line elements. The added colors (and I've seen alot of guys mixing in jungle woods) detract from the visual "swing" of these saws in my opinion. In this, I speak from experience. My saw is all maple with beautifully shaped arms based on an original saw in a family collection. But I added a curved center stretcher in poplar, painted it green and carved (poorly) ugly leaves into it. The saw works great so I haven't yet given myself the time to swap out the stretcher. But it's a hideous tool, that I'm ashamed of, and I actively try to keep it out of my column.

Adam

P.S. These saws make effective coping saws. The long skinny handle is actually better on the pull side of the saw. You may be better off with the same long skinny handle on either arm. I grip the arm where the pin comes thru, pointing my fore finger along the blade just as you would any other saw.

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

#6

thanks to all for the tips

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Some day I intend to make one of these, just after daughter's table ( which is coming along ok so far), a tray , desk, etc. The more assured of success the higher up the list it goes!

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

#7

Re: "Patriot" engineering

Joel

>Adam I would have to disagree strongly about Hickory. It works wonderfully well. As long as you pay attention to the grain orientation when making the saw It bends without breaking and works as well as you can possible desire.

Any work will break with too much tension and with the thin cables we recommend you get far more tension on the saw for the same number of turns than if you you a thick string.

We try on manufacture to pay attention to the cheek grain and of the thousands of saws we have sold I have heard of cheek cracking with less than a dozen. Even if you take that as a small number since a lot of people will just make a replacement themselves, it's not a high number at all.

Maple is brittle. tension it and if the grain is wrong it will crack too.

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

#8

Re: "Patriot" engineering

Joel

>while I am on the subject the lightest bowsaw I have ever seen was Chris Storb's - his is QSO - and is just wonderful. Again wood orientation being the critical factor.

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

#9

Hickory

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>There are about five species of hickory just here in Pennsylvania. When I was in school there were six, but two are now lumped into one "variable species". There are minor differences among these, but more significant is the difference in strength between slow growth and fast growth timbers.

It could be that Dominic used some hickory that was on the weaker side, but in looking at pictures of the Gramercy saw and Dominic's saw, there are also some subtle differences in shaping that make the Gramercy look stronger in my eyes. Despite its curves, the Gramercy has a good core of continuous straight grain from handle to cord, Dominic's saw does not.

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

#10

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

V ictor Parisian

>Nice job on the saw. Sorry to hear that it was so short lived.

Lots of good information coming at you from the forum. Better luck next time. Thanks for sharing.

Victor

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

#11

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Bowsaw Mark zero........

Jesper, Denmark

>Here is the standard hardware store European version.

Notice that verticals are formed as through tenons and are not reduced in size through the mortices in the stretcher. The blade is 20".

The stretcher is pine, the verticals are European beech. One vertical is flat sawn, the other quartesawn. Beech is not known for its resistance to splitting.

Just some food for thought for your Mark 3.


img

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

#12

"standard hardware store European version"

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Jesper,

You realize that you've just turned the American members of this forum Kelly green with envy: it's been more than a few years since American hardware stores carried anything like bowsaws.

Bill

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

#13

Re: Eric Sloane

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>In Sloane's A Museum of Early American Tools he shows a bow saw on p.68 with hickory arms, an oak strecher, maple handles and a paddle of walnut with a piece of yew that the string wraps around. Bernard Jones has a stouter looking design that is made of beech.

Since pecan and hickory are not separated at the mill, is there a difference between these two species that would cause problems if the arms were pecan and not hickory?

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

#14

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>I think your joint at the stretcher should be rounded to allow movement of the arms as you tighten. From the picture it appears your joint allows no such movement.

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

#16

interesting data on strength vs grain orientation

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Taking the saw as an example, if the grain in the leg runs out with a slope of 1 in 10 the piece looses 20% or its strength (modulus to rupture) while a slope of 1 in 5 suffers a 45% loss in strength.

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

#17

data..strength vs species

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Strength (modulus of rupture) AKA how tight can you make the string till the leg snaps

Hickory 11,000 to 20,000 psi all the hickories are about the same

Pecan 10,000 to 14,000

Maple, hard 9000 to 16000

Beech American 9,000 to 15,000

Ash, white 10,000 to 15,000

Walnut 10,000 to 15,000

Locust 14,000 to 19,000

Oak white 8,000 to 15,000

I asked someone who makes saws what to make a saw from and he said "about anything you want to". These data would confirm his opinion/experience.

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

#18

Re: please clarify "cheek grain"

Joel

>the cheek of a bowsaw is like a bow. If the grain in the cheek runs out, especially in the thinner upper portion above the stretcher the saw is going to crack. The mitigating factor is how prominent and how strong are the (I don't know the proper name for it) wood layers and the bonds between the wood. MY sense is the easier the wood is riven the easier it will crack under stress IF THE GRAIN RUNS OUT. Otherwise you get a nicely strong and flexible bow saw.

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

#19

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Well........

Jesper, Denmark

>If Y'all wanted a few, I could make a deal and ship some. Folks over here, though, are just as enamoured with the copper tailed monsters as you are over there in the New World.

Induction hardened teeth on "Fuchswantzes" are unfortunately the more common variety bought these days.

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

#20

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Dave Anderson, NH solved the....

Jesper, Denmark

>problem in a different way:

http://www.chestertoolworks.com/bowsaws.htm

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

#21

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

Dominic Greco in Bucks County Pa

>Jesper,

I'm not sure if I understand your comment about the grain orientation. On the arms I have it running "up & down" the arm. How else could you have it?

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

#22

Re: data..strength vs species

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>So the hickories are all about the same, but some have only 55 percent of the strength of others? The modulus of rupture chart that I use has average values. In average values hickory exceeds the others in your chart, except for black locust which is close. In my experience I have seen just an occasional hickory board which is considerably lighter than most and presumably weaker. Using just your chart, it seems that one could get superior performance out of hickory if he knew how to choose his wood. Hickory also has higher modulus of elasticity values than the others on your chart. And we also have to keep in mind that the charts compare straight grain and straight cut timbers. As mentioned by others, pieces with curves or runout would have other values.

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

#23

Re: data..strength vs species

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>These data, taken from a Forest Products Lab publication give the range of values measured for numerous samples. I would presume that in the case of the ring porous or semi- ring porous woods that samples with a greater portion of late wood (fast growth, more dense) would be at the stronger end of the range.

There is a good correlation between species strength and density. Makes sense that more stuff yields a stronger material.

It is not without reason that sledge hammer and cant hook handles are invariably hickory.

(The ranges for the 4 hickories listed was essentially the same)

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

#24

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I'm not sure exactly what Jesper is proposing as to grain orientation, but I think the distinction he's making is between the rings running parallel to the long axis of the saw or across it - putting it another way, flat sawn vs. quarter sawn.

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

#25

Re: Bowsaw Mark 1

ThomD

>Dominic, did it just pop on you, or did you have it reall cranked down hard?

Grain orientation is a big issue if you could find some wood with a cooperative curve in it, it would be a better bet.

Hickory bows have set a lot of flight records, but the grain the whole back of hte bow would be in the same ring.

I am surprised the 10-1 slash looses 20 percent, that is pretty high grade wood. Good to know.

Wood doesn't care wither you riv it or bandsaw it as long as the end result is the same. Riven wood can be steared well across the grain.