Choosing a Pull Saw?
Tom MacGregoor
>I'm in the market for an entry level combo rip/crosscut (Ryoba?) pull saw for rapid cutting in 4/4 and 5/4 softwoods. Does anyone have a recommendation for a specific model or the TPI range I should look for?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Choosing a Pull Saw?
Tom MacGregoor
>I'm in the market for an entry level combo rip/crosscut (Ryoba?) pull saw for rapid cutting in 4/4 and 5/4 softwoods. Does anyone have a recommendation for a specific model or the TPI range I should look for?
Re: Choosing a Pull Saw?
Robin Corell in Atascadero CA
>Skip the $39 replaceable blade dozuki from Tools For Working Wood it is total garbage. Makes me wonder about the quality of anything else they sell when they promote such low quality stuff.
Clarification
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Tom,
Did you mean to say 'softwoods'? 4/4 and 5/4 are hardwood grades, is why I ask.
Wiley
Re: Choosing a Pull Saw?
wilbur
>Caveat: Although you didn't explicitly say this, I'm kind assuming that you want to make joinery-type cuts in your 4/4 and 5/4 stock, like dovetails or tenons.
Short answer: a Gyokucho ryoba for hardwoods is a good beginner saw. There are a lot of Gyokucho ryobas, but the hardwood ones are models 611 and 650, both available at Japan Woodworker, or 651, available from Hida Tool. They run about $30-35 each, and have replaceable blades. They will make decent joinery cuts, and they will also cut softwoods well, but as Wiley suggested maybe you are talking about hardwoods.
Long answer: I've been coming around to the idea that from a sawtooth standpoint, there isn't really too much difference between Japanese and western saws. From a rip tooth standpoint, which ryoba you get does make a difference. If you look at the typical western saws used to make rip cuts in 4/4 stock, they tend to be dovetail or tenon saws, with rip teeth typically in the 10-15 tpi range. The rip tooth side of a ryoba varies with the length of the saw, with smaller ryobas having higher tpi, and longer ryobas having smaller tpi. As it turns out, the ryobas that have a tpi that corresponds to the 10-15 tpi range are the 180-210 mm ryobas. Unfortunately, in the US these aren't as readily available as the 240 mm ryoba that everyone sells. I have a handmade 210 mm ryoba that was set up for hardwoods, and although I have gotten used to it, and it is my favorite saw, there are occasions that I wish that it had a finer tpi on the rip tooth side.
From a crosscut standpoint, any ryoba will do quite well for the most part. Crosscut teeth do vary with the length of the ryoba like the rip teeth do, but I don't find that the differences are as great.
So what I would really recommend for joinery cuts in 4/4 or 5/4 stock would be an 180 mm or a 210 mm ryoba, tuned for hardwoods. The ones that are most readily available are ones by Mitsukawa, available at Hida Tool for $80-85. Japan Woodworker also has ryobas in this size range for $50-100, but these are not specifically tuned for hardwoods, to my knowledge. Japanesetools.com and japan-tool.com also will have ryobas in this size, but the price (and quality) are above a beginner level.
Even though these saws are more expensive than the replaceable blade Gyokucho ryobas, one big thing that these saws will give you is a slight taper in the blade as you move from the teeth towards the center of the blade. The replaceable blade ryobas don't have this -- they are the same thickness throughout. This makes a huge difference in how these saws perform, just like a tapered blade makes a western saw perform better, and this is one area that it's really not worth cheaping out on.
By the way, the hardwood/softwood issue with Japanese saws is really a matter of degree, and I wouldn't get too hung up on it. You can saw any wood just fine with either type of saw.
Choosing a Pull Saw?
Gordon Thomas
>My thoughts on saw makers:1). Mike Wenzloff for western saws;2) Of the current japanese smiths still working I would say that Heiji is the best. I am happy to own a rip and crosscut dozuki and they are simply wonderful;3) the saws from Mitsukawa are disappointing. I have seven of these saws. One does not cut straight because it is bent and, for the other, the set is too much on one side. These are $600 saws.
His saiku nokogiri kataba (another $600 saw) has traversed the Pacific 6 times for Mitsukawa to address.
The final instalment in this chapter is a rip dozuki had so little set that I need to forcibly pull between thumb and forefinger to remove the blade from the kerf. I sent this back to Tomohito Iida with a request that mitsukawa examine the saw. The dozuki was returned to me this week with the back partly removed from the blade. When I raised my concern with Tomohito the reply was that I should take a small hammer and very gently attach the back to the blade! Bear in mind the back was separated form the blade while in the custody of Tomohito/ Mitsukawa.
As always please do your own due diligence.
happy sawing,
Gordon
Re: Choosing a Pull Saw?
wilbur
>Hi Gordon,
Just out of curiosity, what other active Japanese saw makers do you know of? I only can name Heiji and Mitsukawa, and the various unnamed saw makers that supply Japanese saws to the Japan Woodworker.
Tasks?
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Tom,
Wilbur discussed joinery type saws, and I agree with most everything he said. However, when you say 'rapid cutting', that suggests you might be looking for a saw to break wood down to rough size prior to doing joinery.
Some random thoughts.....A very good utility saw for doing a whole bunch of tasks (but not joinery) is a 300mm Gyokucho ryoba. I use mine for rough crosscutting to length, and also recently trimmed back my magnolia tree with it. It's really handy.
I much prefer the 300mm to the 240mm in the same brand. Here's why. The 240mm ryobas I have seen of the 'entry level' variety are like fly swatters. There is so little beam strength in the blade, and the connection to the shank is so flimsy, that you need to be a very good sawyer to keep it from being captured in the wood and taken wherever the grain wants it to go, particularly in 2x or better softwood, or 5/4 or better hardwood. Maybe Wilbur's experience is different, but that's my take on it. If you look at a hand crafted Japanese 240 ryoba, a primary functional difference between that saw and the Gyokucho 240 is that the handmade saw has a much heavier connection of the blade into the shank, plus the blade tapers up more thickly into the shank so that it is a much stouter saw and will hold its own against what the grain is trying to make it do. The 300mm Gyokucho is 9.5ppi crosscut and 6.5ppi rip.
If you want a saw that will make long distance rips or crosscuts, I would suggest something other than a ryoba. The ryoba will track well until the opposite-side teeth get into the kerf, and then typically the saw will start wandering off course. To make a long cut, you need a single edge saw that is tapered from teeth to back. And ideally the saw should be double-tapered, like a Disston or like a hand crafted Japanese saw.
Be glad to discuss any of this in greater depth. Also, I only mentioned Gyokucho in replaceable blade saws because that is what I have experience with--there are many others.
Wiley
Re: Choosing a Pull Saw? *LINK*
John Aniano - in central NJ...
>Tom,
Consider the Zeta brand saws. They are wonderful and don't cost all that much. I use mine all the time.
Re: Choosing a Pull Saw?
Gordon Thomas
>Wilbur:
I am not aware of any active sawsmiths other than the two you mentioned. There are others who regularly post on this forum who are in a better postion than I to comment.
best wishes,
Gordon
Re: Choosing a Pull Saw? *LINK*
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>There are Kaneharu and Minemitsu, both of which Hiraide sells. I've got a Kaneharu dovetail saw that's very, very nice, tests well at the magazines. Also, So sells Shigesaburou, Shindo, Nakaya (also sold at Hida, I like mine), Kanesada, Kanni, Nizaemon, Mitsuo, Kojirou, and Kanemitsu. I think there are lots of these guys; but you have to have the courage to try something without much knowledge.
Re: Choosing a Pull Saw?
wilbur
>Thanks, Pam. For some reason I thought Kaneharu was a brand name, and not an individual saw maker.
As far as the other saw makers that So carries, they all seem to be NOS saws, and the makers themselves are no longer currently active. At least that's what So told me when I was talking with him about buying my Heiji ryoba. I'm sure they are all nice saws -- I just wanted to get a Japanese saw from someone that was still in the business.
Re: Tasks?
wilbur
>I do agree with Wiley that a handmade Japanese ryoba, properly tapered, will perform much better than a replaceable blade ryoba. That Gyokucho that I mentioned is a good inexpensive way to get started with Japanese saws, but there are better options, which involves more of an upfront expenditure.
The other half of my current thinking about Japanese saws is exactly what Wiley had nicely stated. Besides joinery saws, the other western saws that are usually recommended are a pair of crosscut and rip handsaws, used for quickly breaking down stock. These typically have tpi of 5-9 tpi. The teeth on the ubiquitous 240 mm ryoba are finer than this, which makes this size ryoba less than ideal for breaking down lumber quickly. The size of ryoba that come closest to the tooth configuration of western handsaws would be in the 300-330 mm range. Again, it's harder to come by ryobas of this size.
So my current thinking is that the best set of Japanese saws to start with would be a 210 mm ryoba for joinery cuts, and a 300 mm ryoba for breaking down stock. Probably like everyone else in the world, I started with a 240 mm ryoba. Knowing what I know now, if I had to do it all over again, I'd search out a set of 210 mm and 300 mm ryobas, handmade. Having said that, I wouldn't fault anyone for just starting with a 240 mm Gyokucho. That saw is still a decent all around saw, and it's an easy, inexpensive way of getting into Japanese saws.
There is one mainstream woodworking supplier that sells ryobas in these sizes -- Woodcraft (!). They offer a 210 mm and a 300 mm ryoba for about $115 total. I don't want to say that I recommend these, since I haven't tried those saws myself. I've seen them in the store, and they appear to be tapered. I'm sure they are of beginner quality -- kind of like getting a Groz plane instead of a Lie-Nielsen. But my bet is that you'll get more use out of this pair of saws than a single 240 mm ryoba.
Hida Tool, Japan Woodworker, japan-tool.com, and japanesetools.com also have handmade ryobas in 210 and 300 mm sizes, but they would be more money -- anywhere from $200-$500 for the pair. Still, if you consider that you're really getting two saws for the price of one in a ryoba, which would be four saws for a pair of ryobas, it's really not a bad deal at all.
a side note to Wiley
VT_Andy
>Hi Wiley,
In my neck of the woods at least, the lumberyards I know also label and price softwoods as 4/4, 5/4, 8/4 -- the only places where they are labels as "2 by" "4 by" etc are building supply places, as opposed to places selling rough lumber.
-Andy
Re: Choosing a Pull Saw?
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>The Kaneharu might be just a brand name, really don't know.
As for So, thanks for the correction.
Pam
Re: Choosing a Pull Saw?
Raney
>Interesting - I have two saws from Mistukawa, a 240 ryoba and a 240 dozuki, both of which I'm extremely pleased with. I don't mean this to be disrespectful whatsoever, but I have to ask why you've bought seven if you find them disappointing? Did you purchase them all at the same time?
Wilbur - Kaneharu is indeed a brand name, not a single maker. I have wondered a bit about who makes these, as Mitsukawa and Heiji are the only currently active sawmakers I've been able to find anything about either. Perhaps they are even made by one of the other two... who knows?
What about sharpening?
Frank D. in Montreal
>Hi guys,
Don't want to hijack this thread, but my question might interest Tom and others. The main factor that has been preventing me from buying hand-made Japanese saws is the sharpening. Disposable blades are cheap, readily available, easy to change, and most of them are impulse-hardened so they last a long time before getting dull. Handmade saws, on the other hand, don't stay sharp as long (from what I understand), and you have to send them to Japan to get them sharpened. This seems to me like a major inconvenience and a good reason to stay with disposable blades. Am I missing something?
Re: What about sharpening?
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>Hi Frank, long time no see!
Mark Grable in the US sharpens Japanese saws (he actually does the whole metate thing), he studied under Yataiki, and has a very good reputation (never heard anything negative about his work), however I haven't used his services yet (at the rate I use my saws, meaning no shop time these days, it's gonna take a while before I will need his services...
From what I understand his availability is kind of "random", so getting hold of him is probably the most difficult part.
DC
Thanks Andy!
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Another addition to the list of things I thought I knew that aren't so.
Wiley
Re: Choosing a Pull Saw?
Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio
>Another vote for the Tashiro Zeta� system. I've had several of his saws for several years, and like them a lot.
My 2c (about what it's worth)
Paul M.
>I have a couple Ryoba, none of which are name brand or particularly noteworthy. But they are all frequently used.
I haven't counted, but it seems like there are similar number of teeth on the rip side of each Ryoba and also on the crosscut side. So the 240mm has small teeth and the 300mm has larger teeth.
I use the small 240mm sometimes at the bench for small hardwood joinery. I use exclusively the 300mm on softwoods, mainly because the joinery is larger and the larger teeth seem to work much better on softwood than the smaller Ryoba. You also want your saw to be at least 3X longer than the board you are cutting to make sure that your teeth are clearing the debris. 4X is even better.
For your softwood work, I would not get a Ryoba smaller than 300mm. The brand or maker doesn't matter so much, as all of them will work just fine in softwood.
Re: What about sharpening?
wilbur
>As far as longevity, handmade Japanese saws can stay sharp for a very long time. I can't say if they stay sharp more or less than machine made Japanese saws, and it may be that they don't. But a handmade Japanese saw still can go a long time between sharpenings. I've heard reports of heavily used (read: near daily usage) Japanese saws going a year or more between sharpenings, and lasting a few years between sharpenings for a hobbyist. Maybe Wiley or Pam can weigh in with their experiences -- they've been using Japanese saws longer than I have.
The other issue is sharpening. I think that method of sharpening a Japanese saw is much more like sharpening a western saw than different. Filing rip teeth is pretty much identical to filing the rip teeth on a western saw, except that the tooth profile has a little different geometry. But it's still just shaping the rip tooth.
The cross cut side is a little more complicated, but it's still just filing the front bevel, then the back bevel of every other tooth, and then going back to get the teeth that you skipped, much like sharpening a western crosscut saw. There's the added step of filing the bevel at the tip of the teeth, which is still basically using the same technique, just at a different angle and position on the tooth.
I've tried sharpening the teeth of old rusty 270 and 300 mm ryobas that I found on eBay, with decent results -- much better than I thought I would get. Certainly, the large teeth on these saws helped to make things easier, and the super fine crosscut teeth on smaller ryoba would take more practice to do, but I don't think that the practice of sharpening teeth on a Japanese saw is nearly as mysterious and esoteric as one might believe. If you have the skills to sharpen a western saw, you should be able to sharpen a Japanese saw.
Adjusting the set of the teeth on a Japanese saw is a completely different matter, and that isn't something I've tried to do yet.
Re: Choosing a Pull Saw?
Gordon Thomas
>Raney:
The first saws I purchased were a dozuki and three katabas.These are just fine. Subsequently, I purchased a second dozuki and 2 more katabas. It is the latter 3 saws which proved to be a disappointment. Two did not cut straight (bent blade and uneven set) and the dozuki binds in the kerf (too little set). I sent the dozuki back to Mitsukawa to examine the set. It was returned with the back partially removed from the blade. After the dealer suggested that I attempt the repair myself, that came as a total surprise. Hope that helps clarify my earlier post.
best wishes,
Gordon
Re: What about sharpening?
Gordon Thomas
>I have spoken with Mark twice in the last three days. So no problem I can see making contact.
I have also had the opportunity to use a ryoba and kataba that he sharpened for a friend. The original price on these saws were in the $150 range. Both performed very nicely.
hope that helps,
Gordon
Re: What about sharpening?
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>What you said, Wilbur; but the machine made dozuki from LV stays sharp a long, long, long time.
Pam
Hmmmm, In my neck of the woods...
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA
>Both Lumberyards and home centers sell 1 by, 2 by etc...
The exception is hardwoods.