Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Safety Week

Posts

Re: Safety Week

#26

Re: What does a big, pricey lathe provide?

wilbur

>A few things:

1. Stability when turning large, heavy, out of balance blanks. Woodturners often use green wood, which is heavier than dry wood because of the water content. In general, this means a well designed base and a lot of mass (read: cast iron or steel). Eccentric turning is also done by advanced woodturners, which means that the blank is always out of balance.

2. A high quality motor with enough power so that it can supply good torque at low RPM, and the electronics to be able to vary the speed.

3. Machining so that the headstock and the tailstock align nicely, the bed is straight, the bearings run true, and that the lathe can turn a blank without vibration. Speaking of bearings, they also need to be heavy duty enough so that they can support the weight of a large, heavy, out of balance blank mentioned above.

4. Many high end lathes have sliding headstocks, so that you can position the headstock at various points along the bed of the lathe. This adds to the amount of machining needed.

Re: Safety Week

#27

Re: What does a big, pricey lathe provide?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Thanks, Wilbur. In videos I've seen a couple of big lathes used by tree/burl segment turners that seem to be huge grinding wheels at an angle with the piece mounted at the wheel axle and no tail. They look impressive, the weight seems to provide balance.

I assume the purpose of head movement is to get closer to the center of gravity?

Pam

Re: Safety Week

#28

Re: What does a big, pricey lathe provide?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>For practical reasons a large diameter piece will not work on a pole lathe. On the pole lathe the motion is reciprocal, the stock is constantly changing direction. This is no problem for small diameters. But the angular momentum for a solid cylinder is proportional to the radius to the fourth power. An 18 inch diameter piece has more than 6000 times the momentum that a 2 inch diameter piece has. It just does not want to change direction.

On the other hand, I can't see a problem doing this on a treadle lathe. One of the heaviest lathes I ever worked on was a two hundred year old treadle lathe. The whole thing was made of white oak,the bed was something like 5X6's ten feet long or more. It is hard to imagine that someone with experience on a treadle lathe would question its safety vis a vis an electric lathe.

Re: Safety Week

#29

Re: What does a big, pricey lathe provide? *LINK*

wilbur

>Hi Pam,

By sliding the headstock to the middle of the lathe you definitely would change the center of gravity of the lathe as a whole, and that could add stability as compared to having the headstock at the end of the lathe.

A more practical advantage of the sliding headstock is that if you are working on a large piece, and you slide the headstock down towards the tail end, you can put the piece in a position so that you can stand at the tail end of the lathe while working on it, instead of leaning over the lathe bed, which saves your back. It sort of converts the traditional headstock/tailstock lathe into a bowl lathe, which I think is what you were describing.

Finally, you can slide the headstock all the way down to the end so you can do outboard turning if you have a piece that is too big to fit over the lathe bed.

Fine Woodworking has a video demonstrating big lathes used for bowl turning. You may need a subscription to see this, but if you have access to the video, at about 2:30 into it you'll see the sliding headstock being used to provide outboard turning. Although this video doesn't show it, hopefully you can also see that if you were turning a blank that fit over the lathe bed, and you slid the headstock most of the way to the tail end, you wouldn't have to lean over the bed to get to the center of the turning blank.


FWW video on big lathes

Re: Safety Week

#30

Re: Safety Week

David

>While typically associated with power tools, I always preach the 3 inch rule to my son. Even follow it myself! What I really think works the best is thinking. As others have said, where will your hand or conversely the blade be if the wood is removed.

Hand tools often foster complacency. Table saws, jointers, routers, now those are scary, but a plane? I was reminded, twice (!) about just how sharp planes can be. Was giving the blade of my Sargent 507 a final wipe down after sharpening. Cut right through four layers of paper towel and my thumb before I knew it had happened. This was no blade nick either. Couple of weeks later I was using the same plane and went to pull some shavings out from the sole side. Did it again, this time just a forefinger nick but enough blood that I contemplated leaving some on the plane as a reminder!

Re: Safety Week

#31

Re: What does a big, pricey lathe provide?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Thanks for that, Wilbur. That spinning burl looked like an accident waiting to happen, to say nothing of the imminent tool destruction. :)

Pam

Re: Safety Week

#32

Re: What does a big, pricey lathe provide?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Warren, sounds like a huge lathe to turn with foot power, but I guess once you get it going everything falls into place. I was thinking of making a pole lathe from white oak, have a stack of it just sitting there for the moment.

Pam

Re: Safety Week

#33

Re: What does a big, pricey lathe provide?

Victor P

>A little more advanced turning than I do with my jet bench top model.

Wouldn't want that big piece coming apart in my shop. Ouch.

Victor - in hot and humid Houston

Re: Safety Week

#34

Re: What does a big, pricey lathe provide?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>I have a friend who I hope isn't reading this who decided to become a bowl turner. He set about selling a bunch of his stuff to get enough money to buy a new Jet lathe, a really neat chuck and turning chisels, stuff to seal the green wood, bought videos that demonstrated methods and techniques, cut down a tree in his yard for a chunk of Maple. Then, there it set in his garage for about a month or so while he got up the nerve to turn it on. He finally chucked up that chunk of Maple and managed to rough out a bowl, put it in a paper bag for curing and never turned the machine on again. He said it scared him too much. A month later he had it all sold on eBay and now he's learning to play the flute.

Marv

Re: Safety Week

#35

:)

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Safety Week

#36

I hope he realizes the danger he's in now *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>of playing rock and roll while standing on one leg (see link), losing the high end of his hearing, and developing a lip that looks like he's been kissed by a rhinoceros.


flute while standing on one leg

Re: Safety Week

#37

Re: The best safety tip I know

ThomD

>Probably mostly to protect from the workpiece, when the worpiece cuts loose from the vice it can really hurt. Could never get close to cutting myself with the knife.

Re: Safety Week

#38

Re: What does a big, pricey lathe provide?

wilbur

>I'll say. The largest blank I've tried turning so far was about 12" in diameter, and when I first turned the lathe on I had no idea how fast the outside would seem to be going. I almost pooped my pants.

On the plus side, those little 6" blanks look like toys in comparison.

Re: Safety Week

#39

Re: What does a big, pricey lathe provide?

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>Now that we're REALLY off topic...

The best part of a big, pricey lathe is the SLOOOOOOOWWWW speed at which it will run. Because slow at the center is still quick at the edge of large bowls and platters.

But, that said, I'm not spending $4k+ any time soon on a new one.

Re: Safety Week

#40

Steve Kubien

Re: What does a big, pricey lathe provide?

Steve Kubien

>Not sure about big and pricey (relative terms there) but a modern FAST lathe will allow a smoother cut and more control. Quite simply, it is easier to turn fast if you can. Oh ya, when things go wrong on the lathe, they go wrong very quickly and, often, violently. The trick is to learn proper tool control and to stay out of the firing line. Hmmm, sounds a lot like Mr. Shepherd's safety tip above.

Great thread.

Steve