Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Disappointed in Japan woodworker

Posts

Re: Disappointed in Japan woodworker

#26

Re: more information

Paul Kierstead

>Tell me, Todd, can you tell a LN at a glance from a Stanley? Some of the copies were are talking about are indistinguishable from what it is "based" on at a glance. *that* is a copy.

Gets me that people act like LN devoloped thier planes all on the own and it was a big surprise...

Do you know what the words "based on" mean? What, do you think it means original designed without knowledge of the the previous work?

I wasn't making excuses for LN, nor saying they introduced new features, and don't terribly appreciate being your staked goat.

Re: Disappointed in Japan woodworker

#27

Re: more information

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yep, the Stanley/Bedrock patents expired long ago; so anyone who wants to replicate/copy them is free to do so.

And a note on judgement: Judge not lest ye be judged.

Pam

Re: Disappointed in Japan woodworker

#28

Clarification of my objection, and why I'm unhappy

James Watriss

>This thread has turned into a pretty big exposition on what constitutes a copied tool, LN is just a stanley copy, etc. Some of the points made have been good and valid, including the point that many stores are now carrying knockoffs (in design, color scheme, or something else) and that that's just sort of how the game is played.

I never claimed that Lie-Nielsen was a wholly original concept, but they do take their tools to a higher level of fit and finish and overall quality than other tools. And the amount of work that's needed to get their planes to workable condition is minimal for my purposes, and they may work just fine out of the box for many people. It's not just that the Borg copy is designed to be built the same, it's that it's designed to look identical.

On facing pages they are being held up for comparison. And the implication, whether intentional or not, is that they are comparable tools. They look the same, made of the same materials... so who's to know? So the lasting impression to me is not a simple issue of what's a knock-off, it's that it feels to me like JW is trying to sell us on lesser quality, presented as if they were something else.

Knockoffs are typically pretty easy to spot. There are usually some subtle (or not so subtle) design differences that mark them as "looking like, but not really like" whatever it is they're roughly modeled on, but in this case, I didn't see any, or at least, nothing obvious. That's my issue. At the point of it, I don't think it's an issue of stealing design. I think it's an issue that both the design choices of the manufacturer, and the catalog placement on the part of the seller, would imply that this cheaper knockoff is just as good. Where do you draw the line between a knockoff, and a counterfeit?

I'm not sure. Maybe it's just a semantic point. To me, their offering looks a little too much like another object of known high quality and value, and then that they've tucked the lookalike in with those items of known high quality and value, thus adding to the confusion. I get that there's a market for knockoffs. But typically, I can pick one up and see right away that it's not the real deal. Not so this time.

When they list the L-N planes on the page, not all of them are actually headlines as L-N products. For example, "Jack Plane," versus "Lie-Nielsen Jack plane." At what point will they just tuck the Borg block plane in there as "Block plane?" And how many would notice that they'd been duped before it arrived in the mail?

Yes, I see the issue as disrespectful to Lie-Nielsen, but in general, it still seems like the top of the slippery slope. It's not the copying that bothers me. It's the pretense.

Re: Disappointed in Japan woodworker

#29

Re: Clarification of my objection, and why I'm unh

ThomD

>This whole thing reminds me of when I first had kids and for a while there we were never going to buy a Chinese toy. It was mostly a safety issue to me. There was and still are large amounts of lead even in name brand toys made in china, and probably elsewhere. But within a few years you would have been hard put to find any toys not made in China. Then the plush toy from china of apaprently decent quality and brand is like 5 bucks, and the original English teddy bear is 150, it starts to be unmanageable.

The LN planes being displayed on the same page as the Borg is odd. Maybe there is some infighting going on as some have suggested. But I have had the occasional JW catalog over the years, and they normally put all the chisels of a type on facing pages. What strikes me as odd is the idea that they are carrying these two identical lines. I largely expect JW to carry only the best, OK maybe that is out of sight these days, but dang good stuff. I don't know why they would waste space on knockoffs of any kind unless they are first rate. In which case why carry LN?

Ultimately the real crash comes when someone offshores first rate product. It is coming. And frankly as much as I like all these guys and what they do, and like the fact all my stuff was made in Canada, NA, and of course Japan, 239 dollars for a run of the mill plane with a few bucks of tool steel some sewer pipe iron etc... Someone may do comparable versions for 75, then see where we are. We are talking about 19th century technology made by late 20th century tools in the manufacturing environment of the 21st century. Volvo may become a chinese brand. That's why the design content is so important, and important to protect. I just think this is for the most part the wrong example. LN is a wonderful company, but there isn't strong proprietary content. Manufacturing quality, the best you could house in a filling station, is their thing. And that is a fragile reed right now.

Re: Disappointed in Japan woodworker

#30

Re: Clarification of my objection, and why I'm unh

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I'm not a big metal plane user, mainly because of my first excursions with old Stanleys; but the first one that worked for me was the LN LA Jack, and that goes a long, long way with me. I've also bought a couple of LV metal planes, and they also work right out of the box. And both companies are a delight to deal with. There's no need to go chasing after brand x. I order directly from LN/LV for the very few metal planes I buy, and I don't worry about how the products will work.

Now if JW is your local tool store, it makes sense to buy these planes from them; but if not, then simply vote with your dollars, give them all to LN/LV, be happy.

As to Japanese tools, I don't think JW sells the top quality stuff in general, a few items here and there are great; but their prices fit their products.

Pam

Re: Disappointed in Japan woodworker

#31

I wonder if...

Todd Hughes

>back in 1910 wood workers were having these conversations about how Sargent [or others!] had ripped off Stanley designs and they are going to boycot buying them.

I just bought an old Sterns copy of a Stanley no. 80 plane and I guarantee no one here could tell it's not a Stanley unless you pick it up and look at the small name on it. I deal with lots of planes and I still have to look close to see if some are a Sargent or a Stanley. Lots of Millers Falls planes are so close a copy of a Stanley that unless you look close at the blade you can't tell the difference. All these were being made and sold at the same time.... Why is now I never hear anything about this? Today there is no stigma attached to owning a Sargent, Millers falls etc,....no one looks down from a high horse and asks how anybody could ever buy such a rip off and how bad these low life companys were to do such a thing. Never even comes up, today they are thought of as well respected companys...So what is the difference again between what they did and what it looks like these guys today are doing?...Other then today the people whose designs that are being "ripped off " for the most part didn't even devolop them thierselves but instead based it on others work. Sort of like complaining about Millers Falls ripping off Sargent on thier router plane design....which was in return an exact copy of the original Stanley

I guess in the end it doesn't really make any difference... Probably in a 100 years LN planes will be just a foot note as another small company that made Stanley type planes for a short period befor maybe being bought out by thier competition....who knows?.....Todd

Re: Disappointed in Japan woodworker

#32

Re: I wonder if...

Paul Kierstead

>Oh, I totally refuse to buy planes from any company that passes off miller falls as if they are stanelys. In fact, I boycotted Sargent, even sent them a letter, but for some reason it got returned.

Re: Disappointed in Japan woodworker

#33

Yup...

Todd Hughes

>..in the future this all will seem just as silly

I think a 100 years ago tool buyers had more to worry about and they justed wanted a good tool at a good price and didn't worry about where the design came from. It wasn't important....Actually probably ain't with most people today either.

I know when I buy something I want to get the best real quality at the cheapest price that I can and not much else comes into it. I have a girlfriend that won't shop in Walmart for various reasons so she pays lots more for the same item as me. What has she accomplished? ...just stupid...Todd

Re: Disappointed in Japan woodworker

#34

Re: Yup...

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Ever read Notes from Underground? It's important to her to deny the Waltons her money. That is not nothing. I also refuse to shop at Walmart, but then I don't buy Walmart type stuff, very satisfying all the way around.

Pam

Re: Disappointed in Japan woodworker

#35

Re: Yup...

Todd Hughes

>This girlfriend tells me how I should support local bussiness and all that instead of buying from those ruthless walmart guys

Though I just got an IPhone there normaly about the only thing I buy from them is food and Ammunition.

Usually every time when I go into a Walmart I like to pick up 500 rounds of .22s every week. With these they are almost half the price as what I would pay in the local small business sporting good store for the exact same bullets. So even though my girl tells me I should surport the local small guy I don't

Anyway I go into Walmart the other day and there is the guy from the local gunshop ,who I know from doing a show next to him, at the counter buying up a big load of ammo. He gets packed up and I go up and clerk told me he is out of the stuff I want because that guy just bought every box.Clerk tells me that guy sure much shoot alot because he is in all the time buying up the Ammo..One guess what he was going to do with it , eh? .....Todd

Re: Disappointed in Japan woodworker

#36

Re: Yup...

Paul Kierstead

>This is not a situation of buying the same thing, just at a cheaper price. And, in fact, it isn't about the availability of copies; it is about a company which appears to be willfully misleading its customers. Now I'm not one to assign morals to such things, but I'm also not one to shop at companies which are dishonest. So, I doubt I'll shop there.

As to Walmart; well, ours don't sell Ammo. And what they do sell is, in most cases, sure as hell not the same quality as *local* goods (note local goods, not chinese crap sold by local companies). If I want to buy crap at a low price (happens occasionally), I go to Walmart, cause it pisses me off even more to go to a local "home" chain and pay a lot more for the same crap. In many ways, Walmart is vastly more honest then most stores around here, who think you can stamp "Kitchen Aid" on a crap spatula made without care, or standards, and sell it for $15. At least Walmart charges what it is worth.

But if I have my druthers, I actually buy something that *isn't* crap. Which means I don't shop at Walmart for that.

I don't live life just to have the most stuff for the cheapest price. It isn't fulfilling, for me at least.

Re: Disappointed in Japan woodworker

#37

Re: Clarification of my objection, and why I'm unh

ThomD

>I agree on the Japanese stuff, though they used to sell the top end of what was available, the market seems to have shifted to personal contacts directly in Japan and other smaller resellers. That is a bit like saying LN doesn't sell the top of the line because there is a Hotley.

I agree on the quality of LN and LV. I bought most of my LN at LV, best of both worlds. It's just that at one time you could say that about bikes, yet everything is now made in Asia, pretty much, with the exception of custom frame makerts, and a few parts like hub gears that cost 2K. You look at what a bike part costs and the quality of machining and design and inovation in it, and it planes pale in comparison. The only thing that is saving the domestic tools business is that it is too small. But that is changing. Over the last 20 years hand tools are getting more and more mainstream, and the market is increasing in size. It is supporting small guys working out of their garages making 300 dollar saws. At some point someone will notice and the party will be over. Or maybe not.

Re: Disappointed in Japan woodworker

#38

Re: Yup...

ThomD

>"it is about a company which appears to be willfully misleading its customers."

Where is there any evidence of that? Those of us without a catalog are at a disadvantage, but what is the language in their ads that implies whatever it is that has one angry? If one puts two pictures on a page of the same product how is one being mislead into believeing they are both original? My 3 year old could spot the copy. Every kid who shops at the dollar store knows the difference. And who is uniformed enough not to have heard of LN? I think people in this thread are guilty of impuning motives to JW that are not in any way obvious.

Todd, I think the difference today is that the tools thing has virtually nothing to do with practicality, it is one of those lifestyle definition things where people choose certain objects in order to define their personal style. In that war, knockoffs don't speak the same language as originally made products, because few people want to define themselves as unimaginative knock off artists, they want to associate with higher values. One might point out that anyone who identifies with a bunch of consumer goods, and slavishly copies their bench out of Chris Schwartz' books is hardly all that original either. Most people have a button somewhere like this. Like with your 22s do you feel as good pouring them through a Rossi lever, or norinco, or would you prefer a Winchester or Ruger?

Re: Disappointed in Japan woodworker

#39

Re: Yup...

Paul Kierstead

> ... because few people want to define themselves as unimaginative knock off artists

I think you are guilty of impuning motives to people in this thread that are not in any way obvious.

BTW, at least 85% of the woodworkers I have met that are not a forum or woodworking web junkie does not know who LN is. That is from a pretty good sample too. Perhaps

Re: Disappointed in Japan woodworker

#40

Re: Yup...

Paul Kierstead

>Your 3 yr old would have to be really really good to spot the differences between:

http://www.japanwoodworker.com/product.asp?pf_id=98.084

and

http://www.leevalley.com/wood/page.aspx?c=1&p=54886&cat=1,310

Just as an example I pulled up in under 30 seconds. Now you are going to tell me that the scraper there is not intended to confuse buyers? What, it just happens to be essentially indistinguishable in all ways?

Re: Disappointed in Japan woodworker

#41

Re: Yup...

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>A lot of our small retailers, like convenience stores, buy their stock at Sam's Club; and it's not like you need your guy's expertise or advice. But the Waltons are such major a**holes, I just can't stomach it. Censoring all media, which causes film makers to censor themselves, foisting their employees' health care on us, not paying their fair share of state/local sales taxes, abandoning stores when those special arrangements end, and the like.

I'm with your girlfriend on buying local, to a point; but I'm by no means golden on this. I spend an enormous amount at Amazon, seldom buy anything at Woodcraft )to be fair, when I was accumulating stuff, they were so power tool bound, but still...). And before the internet, I was big on catalog shopping. I haven't bought an American vehicle since my Harley debacle in 1978; although I wouldn't go out of town to buy a vehicle if I were in the market. I refuse to buy anything Microsoft, but do buy Apple. This last is a software quality issue, MS doesn't have it.

So, have at it, I'm not going to condemn you. But I hate it that you're supporting such pigs. I would think that simply walking into one of their crummy buildings in one of our crummy malls would be enough to dissuade.

Pam

Re: Disappointed in Japan woodworker

#42

Re: Yup...

Brent Smith, Montreal

>A timely tale here........My fridge conked out yesterday. Early this morning I went to one of the local giant warehouse furniture and appliance places because the message on the machine at the local small retail store said they open at 10. Not 1, but 3 sales people came at me. It took me all of 5 minutes to decide on which fridge I wanted. During the course of the invoice being done on the computer the question of delivery came up. $60 for delivery and because I was in dire need they were going to squeeze me in for an afternoon delivery on May 2nd. I looked at the guy, laughed and walked out. I got home phoned that small business and he delivered the same fridge 3 hours later and even carted off my old one. Yea, it cost me $100 more, but service!!!!!!

I don't shop at the giants unless forced by circumstance to. Today just reminded me why!!!!

Re: Disappointed in Japan woodworker

#43

Actually there is...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>"As such there is no international legal venue to pursue an infringement claim"

When a company like I use to work for that HAD a mfg. plant in china, all you had to do was threaten them. They backed off quick.

Re: Disappointed in Japan woodworker

#44

Forgot to say...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>It's all about the company that tries to import such copied products that gets in trouble.

Re: Disappointed in Japan woodworker

#45

Just bought a IPhone

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Ahhh man, you should have got one sooner. You could have downloaded the shake the baby game before they pulled it.

Re: Disappointed in Japan woodworker

#46

Re: Yup...

Joe Shelton

>These arguments (on all three sides) are valid, and none of them is enough for a legitimate moral, exclusionary vote.

For me, Todd's right. The .22 cal is a lot cheaper there. Think I'll leave work early and pick up a brick...

Re: Disappointed in Japan woodworker

#47

85%?

wilbur

>"BTW, at least 85% of the woodworkers I have met that are not a forum or woodworking web junkie does not know who LN is."

Just wondering -- how much of that 85% like to use hand tools?

Re: Disappointed in Japan woodworker

#48

Re: Yup...

James Watriss

>That's more or less where I was trying to go with this. They can build a plane of equivalent quality, I'm sure, for less, just by using a cheaper material than bronze. Why make it look so exactly like a more reputable tool, if you're not trying to gouge the other tool maker's sales, or confuse people about why the other one is so much more?

A knockoff, IMHO, shouldn't be such a dead ringer lookalike.