We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>They carry good tools and all, but their recent introduction of borg products really bothers me. (in the paper catalogs, haven't seen them yet on the website) They're basically open copies of Lie-Nielsen designs. Boggs spoke shaves, block planes, etc... I don't think this is very good business on their part, especially when they still carry L-N products, too.
I dunno... I wrote them a letter already, I've spent about $1000 there in the last few months, but I'm not giving them any more. I like a lot of the other stuff that they carry, but I think they should treat their vendors a lot more respectfully than that. Not cool, not good business.
Felt the need to say something publicly, so I figured I'd vent about it here.
>The first Boggs shave I ever bought was the one manufactured by Veritas. Then next thing you know a Boggs shave is being made by LN, then the next thing you know Veritas has their similar somewhat more complex design (bought all of those). The original Veritas is the nicest one I have ever seen. So far though I am pretty confused about who did what to whom from among three of my favorite makers, before Borg got into the deal. Seems like a strange test case of style infringement. If it's a legal copy then one might as well complain about the people who came late to the Japanese tool party on the backs of 30 plus years of promotion from Japan Woodworker. Ultimately, if one comes up with something that can't be patented or trademarked, one should probably just smile sweatly in the knowlege that one's contribution to the copies will be more strongly noted than what one copied in the first place.
I have the means of knowing that LN and JW have had a growing animosity for some time involving marketing by each company. I don't have enough information to pick sides.
JW is both a retail and a wholesale operation. I suspect JW needed a source of some kinds of tools to wholesale that LN was not satisfying.
We don't have enough information to judge the morality of this or most business decisions.
>Some of the LN tools are copies of Stanleys, but some aren't (The Boggs shave is the most obvious of the 'copies'). There are also some copies of LV items that are original showing up there.
There may or may not be legal infringement, but that's not the issue to me. The issue to me is that there are a few products they're selling that I am quite convinced are copies of current, original LN and LV designs. There are other retailers who've already pulled some of those products because of the possible infringements.
Legal or not, I consider it sleazy business practice. I won't subsidize such practices.
>I spoke too soon. I just checked the JW site, and in the last week or so they've pulled the designs I'm referring to (at least one of them was front and center on their home page until recently).
>Not at all equivalent. Lapsed patents are not the same thing - which is why LN gets the blessing of the law (and me) for its bedrock designs. Patent length gives the company time to recoup its R&D investments with exclusivity - then, in public interest, it opens the design up to competition. To allow generics to hit the market a year after the initial medication, for instance, would wipe out any incentive for development, originality, and pushing the science forward.
These designs are not about providing similar capabilities in a less expensive package. They are about capitalizing on the marketing, R&D, and reputation of another company to sell a product that they essentially reproduced without any concomitant capital investment in development.
I'm not trying to tell you how to spend your money, but I would ask that you try to refrain from undue snark in your reply.
>Vocationally, I am an independant design consulatant for the consumer electronics industry. Frequently knock-off designs of unknown origin hit the shelves before the origninals are released. Some are okay product, others are trash. Usually price is a reliable indicator of the quality. At least in our industry, the bargins in this world are gone. You get what you pay for.
It seems to me that this is probably the case regarding the Lie-Nielsen and Veritas tools. They cost more than the imported clones flatly because they are a better tool. Some people don't need or can't justify Lie-Nielsen's or Lee Valley's quality. I think most of us would agree on that.
Japan Woodworker is simply filling what they see as an unaddressed niche in the market. It's not uncommon for a Mercedes or BMW dealership to sell a lesser brand in an effort to capture more of the market; I see this as akin to that marketing.
I have seen a recent review of the new product and the result was that, for the price, it seems to be a good tool. It is not a Lie-Nielsen nor a Veritas. But for some people it is the perfect fit.
I am not privledged of any information regarding any conflict between Lie-Nielsen and this vendor. But I don't believe that the vendor is trying to steal market share away.
>Personaly I don't worry at all about things like this...I figure it is up to the companys that make these things that are being copied to look out for thier own welfare and go to court if they can. If it was / is illegle then the courts will stop it. If it isn't illeagle then it is the same as LN ripping off the old Stanley designs to copy today...no difference
I think there is a LONG history of tool makers...uhmm..."using" others tool makers designs in thier tools. Stanley lawyers imagine were kept plenty busy going after other makers who used it's designs.
Don't know if you have copy righted that "undue Snark" remark but have to tell you I liked it and plan on using it myself in day to day conversation !....Todd
>A lot of my opinions are colored by doing marketing as a day job - and working for a number of manufacturers who face this sort of thing on a regular basis.
The way it works is that you make something that has a high degree of recognizability and 'cache'. I then make as close a copy as I can for a very low price, and I sell it for a much much lower cost than you. My copy is almost always an infringement if your design is at all original, but that's fine with me. In nine out of ten cases, I'll make a good deal of money from the practice before you ever manage to stop me.
But it's not. It's fantastically expensive for the original manufacturer to get me to stop. It generally costs them well into six figures to bring me to court, and takes on the order of years, not weeks. In the, say, two years that the manufacturer is gathering its defense of its patent, I'm selling at almost pure profit (after all, I have no budget for research, marketing, or planning). By the time it gets near a court, I say 'oops - my bad' and withdraw the product. If it still has life in it, I make some small changes and bring it back out - often resetting the whole clock. Meantime, I've made lots of money on your design.
The original manufacturer, by the way, really doesn't have much choice about whether or not to spend the money it takes to sue me. If they don't, they've effectively relinquished any claim to their original patent. If they let me get away with it without vigorous defense, they have no leg to stand on in any future claims against anyone else who may copy the design.
For some strange reason, I find that most people are under the (grossly mistaken) impression that if you sue me and win, I'll end up paying your legal costs. That's almost never even partly true. And if you're not a very large multinational who has an intellectual property legal team on staff, you're going to be forced by costs to stop your suit the moment I say 'OK - My bad. I'll stop now.'
It's very easy to say 'the courts will settle it', but anyone who ever had to deal with manufacturing at this level will tell you it's an absolute nightmare. This sort of 'strategy' has killed a lot of otherwise very healthy, and good, small companies.
Again - you don't NEED to be concerned about it - and you can spend your money wherever and however you like. Me? I don't support that sort of business practice.
And Todd - I'll give you full run of the 'snark' comment. Consider it a gift :)
>excellent post but you forgot the part about if chinese manufacturer is involved all bets are off since China has never signed ANY treaty respecting or honoring intellectual property rights. As such there is no international leagal venue to puruse an infringement claim.
>Why would anyone here buy LN or LV tools from JW anyhow? I've bought a few things, one of which (chisel for clearing mortises, was not cheap) broke, was replaced, broke, was not replaced, no more chisel purchases to JW for me. And sometimes they'll have pretty cool stuff, like kalaban that no one else does: but to buy LN/LV or even Stanley from them? I don't think so.
>Yeah but the point is these aren't patentable designs in the first place. The Boggs spokeshave is a style change, there aren't any patentable features. I would not personally choose to be a manufacturer of a style rip-off product, and so far haven't bought them either. Without a patent there is never any issue of recouping your R&D expenses etc....
If you go back before LN, LV was making a very good quality imitation of Stanley, and a Bronze corner plane. Then along comes LN (possibly the original supplier). LV sells LN, then they tear off in their own direction. It is all pretty murky to me. I pointed out the spiral on the spokeshaves.
I think you have an issues with Borg potentially, it is a whole other thing to have an issues with JW, when even LN is still for the time being selling to them. JW has been around for a long time and has pumped a ton of money into the woodworking business to bring us stuff that was missing from other catalogs for decades, and to be one of the few high quality supplies. The reality is that making 19th century tools on CNC machines is not a business just one company owns, and as hand tools gain popularity there is going to be a lot of knock-off competition from the kinds of places that buy more CNC machines than any other contries in the world. The popularity of hand tools is starting to outstep the original base.
>They are a 20 minute drive, a walk-in vendor, with a brazillion edge tools on display, and a staff that will answer any question you can ask about those tools, but otherwise, not talk your ear off. I LIKE them!
I've started buying carving gouges as I need them, and being able to select from 5 or more lines of product, at all price ranges, is a very good thing.
>I'm not trying to judge the long-term morality. I get that there are sketchy business practices all over, but this one really stood out to me. I don't know the whole history, or the relationship between the two companies. But it's like any other kind of history... just because it's in the context of a long string of bad blood or insulting exchanges, doesn't mean I have to say "oh, ok, that's cool then."
There's always a rationale for bad or obnoxious business practices. But just because it's profitable or in some other way satisfying to them, doesn't mean I have to take part by offering my support.
I'm sure there are other companies I've sponsored in some way or other over the years, without knowing what I was contributing to. But I try to do the right thing once I'm aware of the consequences. I won't shop at Wal-mart anymore, either.
>You make a good point, Thom. And I do recognize that JW is a vendor of quality stuff, and that this is something to value. And CNC has made it very easy to 'carbon copy' just about anything. But that, to me, is all the more reason to start insisting as consumers that businesses start to play fair. When anyone can knock off anything, it can start a race to the bottom, which benefits no one.
Had they placed these products elsewhere in the catalog, I might have reacted differently. Or, had the two products been visually distinct, I'd have seen it differently. But they're mixed into the L-N spread in the catalog, and that struck me as obnoxious.
"Here you go... I'll offer you these two different things, on facing pages. They're basically the same, and they look absolutely identical, except this one is a lot cheaper."
It came across as an attempt to undermine L-N. I'm not such a L-N fanatic, but I've seen this country undersold on crap, using similar tactics, for too long. So this just didn't sit right.
They certainly aren't copies of currently shipping Stanley's, for sure. The current staneleys are cell phone camera reproductions o the mona lisa. Outside of that, they are certainly based on Stanley's, though copy might be a bit strong.
We don't have enough information to judge the morality of this or most business decisions.
I've grown tired of this cop out. We are asked, over and over again, not to judge because we don't have enough information. Judgment is, in fact, the thing we do when the situation is not cut and dried. Judgement is required constantly, day in and day out, to keep our lives going. Every single time you meet someone, you make a snap judgment of whether or not they are a threat to you. Companies deserve to be judged, and should be judged, on their actions. If the respective companies feel incorrectly judged, they can provide facts. If they don't want to provide facts, they will have to live with the judgement they get.
>Although I agree that I would rather not buy a copy of a tool when you can have the original, what puzzles me is why single out Japan Woodworker for this issue? Lee Valley sells cheap clamps that look like Bessey F-clamps, Woodcraft also carries Lie-Nielsen-like bench planes, as does Woodworker's Supply, Grizzly, etc.
>I see your well stated point. To look at one part of it, by putting the objects side by side in the catalog, aren't they being forthright about it?
I distinguish between the legal violations, the copying of an unpatentable thing that is none the less a worthy variant, and the stuff that is just no problem. We are really only concerned with the middle area (and I suppose rampant violation of the law that goes unchecked if not so much in our world).
One thing that used to be common was manufacturers sharing their patents with other makers in the interest of the broader industry, and industry standards. I think the Boggs shave (whatever part he played in that aside from Veritas and others) is a worthy innovation in style, but typically stuff like that gets copied instantly and rolled into the market for the good of all. His reward is a few years out in front, and the respect that comes from innovations. More prominent examples of the public good are spreadsheets which is the extreme of a scientist giving his product to the world, or Fred Bear giving linear glass technology to the archery business among many patents he shared. But when there isn't even a novel feature, really everyone else should copy it immediately and get on with it.
I'm a computer outsider, but have followed with amusement Bill Gates' attempts to get paid for the changing of streetlights and such. He must have nightmares over having missed the motherload on Google, which was obvious, if obviously not so obvious. He had "rocket scientists" trying to break the payments riddle. But in the end there is a lot of stuff you can get paid for, and a lot of equally valuable stuff you can't.
There seems an assumption these days that every invention should allow someone to cash checks in Tahiti for the rest of their natural lives. The long run history of patents was not to make millionaires except to the extent that it was in the public interest in promoting innovation. Ok that is old fashioned thinking, but I see little reason to shift even further to the gold standard by driving out of business companies that have the temerity to do legal business that is clearly in the public good, in the hopes of providing disproportionate rewards for marginal enhancements of existing art.
That said, it is just life that the upper classes that are the target market for expensive hand tools are going to be defenders/extenders of the intelectual property model we now live with, so tool sellers need to be sensitive to that reality. Take the Ottawa valley from which Lee Valley takes part of it's name, a tech hub in Canada, where my brother in law is an IP lawyer. So what JW has wadded into may be far less wrong than stupid.
>I agree two wrongs don't make a right, but they tend to dampen down public outrage a lot. There is also the issue of any wrong. I can go through endless areas where there is something someone invented that an industry pounced on and adopted across the board. Bike parts come to mind. The Joe Breezer weldable dropout. Stuff strengthens the bread and on we go. The patents model is useful but it is also toxic, and I think the thiking shouldn't be applied on reflex. LV has been smart about his by combining marginal enhancements that are patentable with stuff that isn't, so a complete rip-off of their stuff is harder to do.
>This particualr discussion in in regard to JW. There have been similar discussions about other vendors ad nauseum. To my mind there is a difference between planes that are very similar to LN, which are themselves upgraded copies of an older design, and the wholesale copy of current designs being a manufacturer's whole raison d'etre.
Have a look at the Borg 5-piece scraper set, then look and the Veritas chair scraper and tell me this is comparable to a Grizzly clamp looking somewhat similar in form to a Bessey...
It's a matter of judgement, and there's a difference between expanding the market down, and wiping the top of a market out. One is useful from a competition standpoint because it pushes the high end to continue to develop and progress. The other signals the starting whistle of the race to the bottom which most of us have seen the results of in any number of areas. Bought any 80's bench planes lately?
This is a matter of degree, and a matter of judgement. The combination of the aforementioned scraper, along with the variety of other products, ticks enough of the 'sleaze' boxes for me that I find the company distasteful, and that distaste (for me) also in this case extends to the retailer that is advancing the manuacfturer's balance sheet. I don't think anyone else is wrong for buying from JW, but I find this one egregious enough that I won't. It's my wallet, and I feel quite comfortable with my right to vote with it. JW is not the only company I prefer not to do business with any longer, but they're the topic of this particular thread.
".... they are certainly based on Stanley's, though copy might be a bit strong"
So do you really think that LN planes are just "based" on the original stanleys and not really a copy?....You are joking right?
Name ONE design feature that is different from the original stanley. ...Now I'm talking about how LN ones are painted and not jappaned or that they use lesser quality wood or are made out of a different type of metal or anything like that but a design feature that is a distinctive feature of a LN. The bodies are the same design, so are the frog, , blade adjuster, laterial lever, blade assembly, lever cap, front knob, and the tote....Doesn't leave much does it? Other then putting Stanley on the lever cap and Bailey on the body I don't see how they could have made a closer copy.
Gets me that people act like LN devoloped thier planes all on the own and it was a big surprise when they just happend to see about thier entire lines of tools in a 1935 Stanley catalog one day....Man talk about a weird just by chance happening devoloping identical tools independent of each other,...even got the same numbering system!
If these other current tool makers are making tools that are "based" on LN and others and if they are doing it in a legal way I don't see any difference between that and if LN is making tools "based" on ones devoloped by others and doing it in a legal way....Todd