Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

dozuki broken teeth

Posts

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#51

The link, the link, the....  *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>


LV Professional Dozuki

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#52

Re: Not boring...informative

James Watriss

>I don't know Manny too well, so I wouldn't presume to speak for him.

My guess, if I were to venture one, is that saws are like man other tools. Sure, we all sharpen our chisels, and our planes, but we use them, too, and a lot of the time the sharpening job is good enough, but it's not as good as it could be.

One of the Japanese traditions I heard about somewhere or other is that once a year, the craftsman will take out his tools and go over each one, clean it up, and get it sharpened the way it SHOULD be. Human nature being what it is, I really like this idea that once a year, we all set aside a day, or more, to do what we can to try to fight the natural entropic cycle of our tools and our lives. Like spring cleaning, but better, and more useful.

My guess is that Manny does a good job sharpening his saws. But once in a while, it's still worth sending it back to someone who does nothing but make or sharpen saws, to have it taken to a higher level than he normally does, or would.

I can do a fine job changing the oil in my truck. Brakes, if I have to, and belts. But I'm aware that this is maintenance for me, at my level, and that once in a while, it's really a very good idea to bring it in to someone who knows more than I do to make sure that the stuff that I don't normally do gets attended to.

As for me, I've been going through a similar process lately... going through all of my plane irons and chisels, and getting everything up to a full 100%. I'm on the other side of several months spent building up a new shop, and I figured that there were a bunch of tools where the grinding job was good enough, but not perfect, or the sharpening job was good, but there were a few odd spots... And it's been a lot of work. I have too much stuff to sharpen, I guess. But it's still been a very worthwhile process.

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#53

Just did some tests

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>From LV:

Small Rip Dozuki (SRD) (60T06.10)

Japanese Rip-Tooth Dozuki (JRTD) (60T04.04)

Steel-Backed Dozuki (SBD) (60T55.01)

Not from LV:

Z-Saw, rated as best buy by FWW a couple years ago in the "regular" (i.e. crosscut) dozuki category (and by far the fastest cutting of that category in the test) (Z):

http://www.woodcraft.com/product.aspx?ProductID=12F27&FamilyID=850

I don't have 4/4 walnut handy, so I used a piece of white birch (straight-grained), which should be similar in hardness and speed of cut to the walnut you're using (books rate them at the same density).

In order to get a 3/4" x 3/4" end-grain cut in that birch in three strokes, only the JRTD can make it, and that is with a lot of pressure on the saw. Letting it cut without weight on the saw, it takes almost 7 strokes. The SRD can do it in four strokes, again with a lot of pressure.

As for the two crosscut dozuki I have, both need a minimum of five strokes, and that is with a lot more pressure on the saws than I'd like to. In practice, I let the saw cut by itself without pressure, and it usually takes twice as many strokes as if I did put pressure on the saw.

I can therefore conclude that you put a lot of weight on the saw as you use them, and/or the walnut you were using was really soft (it happens, density for a given species is only an average).

DC

Just for fun I tried the JRTD on pine, and it will do the cut in under three strokes if one presses down on the cut. Also, the SRD cuts a lot faster when I put some pressure on it, good to know... The two crosscut saws do cut faster with extra pressure, but they get packed up with sawdust in the teeth, like I've been cutting Crunchies with them :-)

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#54

Re: Just did some tests

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I got the same results from the LV and LN, no teeth were broken, I stopped applying too much pressure when I broke a ryoba resawing several years before the above sawing test.

I honestly don't know why it apparently gauls [sic] you to admit that I might be a better sawyer than you. Why you feel you can accuse me of lying with impunity. If it were a man making my claims, you'd be all over him asking about his technique. But it's not, this is I and I'm a woman. Maybe I've got some natural zen thing when it comes to woodworking. Maybe it matters that Toshio Odate refined my technique.

But I do know that you guys seem to feel you can accuse me of whatever you please with impunity. You cast dispersions left and right. It can't be possible that "she" can do this stuff. It appears that you're like good little pit bulls: you grab on and you never let it go.

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#55

Re: Just did some tests

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Denis, maybe the saws you have are just dull as... Ah, nevermind.

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#56

Re: Just did some tests

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Pam and all,

Please don't play that card. Denis is arguing a point with you, using data. He is an arguer. He argues on many forums, and with guys in most every case.

You and Denis can just agree to disagree, or else keep talking from data.

But no personal invective.

Thank you,

Wiley, Moderator

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#57

Re: Just did some tests

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Denis,

In order to draw any kind of usefull conclusion from your tests, you would have to have all saws involved in the test, including Pam,s, freshly sharpened and sharpened by the same guy. The set in the teeth would all have to be the same and all tests done on the same piece of wood.

Way too many varibles to conclude anything. It's not even apples and oranges. It's like apples and oranges and plums and pears and marbles and, and, and,....

By the way, nothing wrong with applying a little pressure when using a saw as long as it isn't grabbing. It's the old grab factor, when determing how much pressure to use, plus other varibles.

Marv

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#58

Re: Just did some tests

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>In order to draw any kind of useful conclusion from your tests, you would have to have all saws involved in the test, including Pam,s, freshly sharpened and sharpened by the same guy. The set in the teeth would all have to be the same and all tests done on the same piece of wood.

I used to have the saw Pam relates to, and in my hands it cut quite slowly for dovetails. I never thought to put weight on the saw because I've been following the advice of "letting the saw do the work". More on that later. As for having the same set and having the saws sharpened by the same person, it won't happen because some of the saws are impulse-hardened at the factory, making them unsharpenable by hand. With Japanese saws, you rely on a machine (lower priced manufactured saws) or the experience of a top-notch sharpener on hand-made saws. Bottom line, you take the saws as they come, unlike with western saws, which by construction allow for more flexibility in sharpening (at a price?).

Way too many variables to conclude anything. It's not even apples and oranges. It's like apples and oranges and plums and pears and marbles and, and, and,....

I beg to differ here, Japanese saws are usually made to fit a specific cutting requirement. With the machine-made ones, compromises are made to provide the best performance in many situations. How good the compromise is depends on the tasks at hand, speed vs. quality of cut. Rip dozuki saws are a fairly recent offering in NA, I assume that manufacturers and retailers realized that a rip dozuki was ideal for end grain cuts, and was enough of an improvement to warrant offering them for sale. I have both types (rip and crosscut), in both machine- and hand-made offerings, and I would not consider getting rid of any of those saws, they all have their place.

By the way, nothing wrong with applying a little pressure when using a saw as long as it isn't grabbing. It's the old grab factor, when determing how much pressure to use, plus other varibles.

No argument in principle, except that IME putting more pressure reduces one's control over the cut. The tests I did yesterday strongly suggest to me that pushing a saw beyond its natural cutting characteristics end up making the saw less controllable, with packed teeth and a wider kerf. BTW, all of the saws I tested, once started in the cut, do not grab at all.

Cheers,

DC

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#59

I thought you did about as good as possible...

Alan DuBoff

>Denis,

I thought your test was about as good as possible.

If each saw was sharpened by the same person, and the set all done the same on the saws, at some point you will end up with similar saws.

The idea is to test how these various saws perform in the real world, which your test did.

Denis wrote:

"No argument in principle, except that IME putting more pressure reduces one's control over the cut."

I agree, and this holds true with my experience in using western saws also. Most people have a very delicate touch when cutting dovetails. The harder one pushed the saw, the less control they have, and the less time to correct/respond to a cut which starts heading away from the line. Japanese saws are almost impossible to bring back once they start to drift, and trying to do so will often result in a broken tooth.

While there will never be a test that is equal across the saws you tested, it is what it is and I do find it of some use to know myself.

The other factor not mentioned is the length of the plate, and/or how many teeth, but it's not a big deal...the saws are what they are, as-is the test is what it is...it's not rocket science, you were only testing a few saws and how they cut.

I find your test better than just stating that you tried a test some years ago, and this is how you recall the results. You did give a good effort to evaluate the cutting. Thanks for that.

Cheers,

Alan

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#60

Re: Just did some tests

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Bottom line is...comparing a sharp saw to a saw that is less sharp to determine which one cuts faster, is just plain illogical. I cannot see an argument here.

Marv

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#61

Dull as what, Scott. Got a twin?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#62

Re: I thought you did about as good as possible...

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Perhaps some of us don't spend all our time testing sawing speeds. It was my instructor at Homestead Heritage first brought my attention to the speed, then we tested his new saw (the LN straight handled) and my saw (the LV Pro dozuki). In both cases, in 3/4" walnut, I sawed about 3/4" down in 3 strokes. What exactly bothers you about that, Alan? That's both recall and specific and true. Do you actually work wood?

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#63

Re: Just did some tests

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>You know, I started to send you a private email, but decided to keep it in the open. Why exactly do you think so many men, at least 5 or 6, have come here for short periods and immediately attack me? They hang around harassing for a few months or weeks making as much fuss as they can, then disappear. And they do this with impunity, there is never any punishment for them. This didn't happen on Badger Pond. Why do you suppose that is, Wiley?

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#64

No, but...

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>...I have a brother I haven't seen in a few years. He's a mechanical engineer in Texas. Puts his career too far in front of his family for my tastes - emulating what we grew up with, and I just don't see going there. But it works for him.

One of his daughters is a very fine figure skater. The other is quite the non-ice athlete. His wife's abrasive and obstinate. Don't much care for her.

But, no, we're not twins. Thanks for asking about my family, Pam. How's yours?

Oprah's still dull, FWIW. YMMV. No attack. Just throwing bait out to see what hits. Lookit that.

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#65

Re: Just did some tests

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Pam,

I disagree with each and every premise you have just put forward. I spend a fair amount of time watching this forum, and you are not a forum victim. Your continuing assertions that you are, create a tense atmosphere on this forum.

Here are two choices for you to consider. The first choice is, my door is always open offline. I will discuss any issues you have. The second choice is, if you persist with this further online, your ISP will be added to the banned list.

Wiley Horne, Moderator

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#66

Western saw mindset?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Western saws are highly adaptable, that's their best quality. I once used a $10 gent's saw that had been sharpened by Tom Law, and was duly impressed that such a cheap saw could cut so well, in relative terms.

The fact remains that Japanese saws come in many different ways, the inexpensive ones are built on a compromise basis, soft vs. hardwood tooth geometry (and set), rip/crosscut/combination, etc. They for the most part work very well given the compromise set used. Given the complexity of Japanese saw teeth, it makes sense to impulse-harden the inexpensive ones, no point in sending a $40 saw to Japan or Mark Grable for metate at $200 a pop (assumption here, haven't sent any saw for sharpening yet).

Bottom line, on manufactured saws, it's the choices/compromises made by the manufacturer, and the amount of work put in the saw, that dictate how the saw works in a given situation. The end user can't change that, as impulse-hardening makes re-sharpening impossible through standard methods (never mind the tooth complexity for now). So there is value in investigating how well these saws perform relative to each other.

On man-made saws, all parameters are adjustable if the sharpener is good enough at metate. When I ordered my two Yataiki saws, I specified the kind of wood I was intending the saw for (hard maple being the baseline), and the teeth were shaped and sharpened according to my specifications (I don't know if blade tensioning and shaping is also specific to the expected species used, Dave B. or Wiley could shed some light on this).

The western saw world is in fact not that much different from the Japanese world, other than being more user-modifiable (at the expense of requiring more frequent sharpenings). Compare a LN variable-pitch saw against a Wenzloff against a Gramercy against a Andrew Lunn against a Veritas DT saw against a Rob Cosman saw (still in the prototype phase I assume, there's no mention of it on his site), and you will see that they all use different parameters in their saws. But in the end, if one should be so lucky and have all the saws at his/her disposition, what would come out is how each saw compares to the others in terms of speed, cut quality, ease of start in a cut, for different wood species, etc. The Japanese saws mentioned in this thread are compared roughly in the same way. I have tried over 20 different types of dozuki (most of them machine made), and can attest that some are worth the asking price, others, not really...

I have the feeling, based on comments you've made in the past, that in your opinion there's much ado about nothing when it comes to Japanese saws. You should try to use them for a while, if you ever come up to the Slowly Thawing North, bring your saws and we'll play with both yours and my saws. I think you'll get a better appreciation for Japanese saws then.

Cheers,

DC

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#67

Gee Scott, I think she's...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>She's harassing the males here!?! Or was she talking about all the Scotts here on WC. Seems to be a lot of us...

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#68

Re: Gee Scott, I think she's...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hello Scott and Scott,

Do not taunt Pam.

Thank you,

Wiley

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#69

I completely agree wtih you

Alan DuBoff

>Pat wrote:

"It does not appear in a lot of Japanese dictionaries. Unless exposed to it somehow, I would guess (and this is just a guess) that most Japanese high school kids wouldn't even be able to tell you what it meant.

That is not all that odd though given that most American kids would not have any idea what the "set" of a saw is."

This is spot on, I agree with you on this completely. However, it is worth noting that most high school kids would not know what nokogiri, kanna, or nomi are for that matter. These are specialty words that are used mostly amongst woodworkers, and there are not very many woodworkers in Japan as a whole, these days.

That said, my Father-In-Law has a few tools, like kannas and nomi. I have never seen him use them, although he has a nice Bonsai garden that he prides himself in, and he may have built the stands and shelves that host those plants.

Pat wrote:

"An actual definition is fine and good, but sometimes hard to translate perfectly. Especially when it is an obscure word. In reality I think it refers more to the 'tune' of the tool in general."

This is the case with many words, which are derived from kanji, since many of them have hidden meanings, or the kanji paints a picture.

Some of the tool names could have come from remote areas of Japan which have different dialects. I often visit Kagoshima, as my Father-In-Law's family is down there and where he's from. They have their own dialect and set of words that are unique to them. As an example, in Tokyo (kanto) people would say, "kyo wa atsui desu yo?", but in Kagoshima they will say, "Atsuka desu ne?". I don't think you'll find atsuka in the dictionary, it's Kagoshima ben. You have to know. Even folks from Tokyo will have a hard time understanding the folks in Kagoshima in many cases. Another example is a game they have called nanko, it's a drinking game that is played in Kagoshima, and most people from Tokyo have never heard of it.

I suspect some of the tool names could have come from similar remote areas of Japan. One might need to be from those areas to totally understand why some of the tools and/or processes are called what they are (i.e., metate).

Cheers,

Alan