Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

dozuki broken teeth

Posts

dozuki broken teeth

#1

dozuki broken teeth

Jerry Gibbs

>I have a dozuki. I cannot tell the brand because its in Japanese. I think I bought it from Woodcraft. I have not used it much, and it has several broken teeth. Is it me, the saw or what. It still cuts well. It was not expensive, I think. I have a ryoba, but often prefer the stong back of the dozuki, especially to get started. Jerry Gibbs.

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#2

Re: dozuki broken teeth

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Jerry,

There are a number of things that can rip teeth off of crosscut dozukis, apart from hitting a staple imbedded in the wood (which I've done). Here are a few I have learned about the hard way. These can act separately or together with each other....

1. Softwood teeth cutting hardwood. Many Japanese saws, particularly dozukis, are designed for cutting softwood--in fact, they all are unless otherwise marked or ordered custom. So they will have a tall, narrow-base delicate tooth. If such a saw is used to cut hardwood, it is at risk unless a light touch is used. This is doubly so if the saw is used to cut into end grain, as in a dovetail cut.

2. Teeth getting dull. As the teeth get dull, you're beginning to muscle the saw through the cut. Puts more load on the teeth, and especially if you're cutting hardwood with a softwood saw which has taller, narrower-base teeth. Getting toothless is the eventual fate of all electrically-hardened, replaceable blade, crosscut saws--when you start yanking the teeth off of them, it's time to buy a new blade.

3. Muscling the saw (crowding the cut). Everyone will give the advice 'let the saw do the cutting'. And it's true. But taking this advice this doesn't come natural to us--we want to apply pressure and cut faster. This has the effect of putting more load on the teeth. And also--because the blade is thin and has little beam strength--crowding the cut will cause the saw to deflect slightly in the cut, putting additional strain on the teeth. All avoided by letting the saw do the cutting--you're guiding it.

4. Pulling the saw off line. Sometimes one can try to straighten a cut by 'pulling the saw around the corner'. This is hard on crosscut teeth especially.

Some useful mental exercises......As you saw, think about how the blade is running in the kerf. You are feeling for minimum-friction, where the blade is free-running and not being dragged against a sidewall or pulled around the corner. As you saw, think about helping the blade pull itself into the cut, but without applying pressure--think about feeding the teeth lightly into the cut.

Wiley

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#3

Re: dozuki broken teeth

Manny

>I'm sure not all dozuki are perfect but from what I've seen broken teeth are usually attributed to improper technique.

On a good quality Japanese saw just the weight of the saw is enough to get it cutting. Putting excessive pressure can cause teeth to catch and break. You also have to be very aware of this on porous hardwoods. You can catch in a pore and snap off a tooth if using excessive pressure. It's not a big deal once you learn how to use a Japanese saw and gain confidence.

Having said that I have tried some of the Woodcraft saws that look like tradition handmade (they're not) and they are dull as heck. I can see someone breaking teeth on them from pressing down hard to get them to cut.

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#4

Standing on the sidelines

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Standing on the sidelines reading warnings and instructions regarding a Japanese style DT saw.....the question begs to be asked...

Why?

Why rely on a saw that is so fragile and subject to damage and costly to maintain?..not to mention quite costly for the high end saws.

I hear none of these problems with a western style saw. Doesn't both type saws perform the same function? They cut wood, right?

Marv

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#5

Re: Standing on the sidelines

Manny

>Once I learned how to use them the "fragile" tag went away. It's just a different technique. I can pretty much cut any type of wood without worrying about fragility, every type I've encountered except petrified wood.

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#6

Re: Standing on the sidelines

wilbur

>Because in my hands, a Japanese saw will track straighter and leave a cleaner cut surface than any western saw I've used.

Marv, based on my experience, I could say similar things about western saws. Why use a saw that is harder to start a cut with, requires more force to make the cut proceed, and needs more frequent resharpenings than a Japanese saw? They both cut wood, no?

This is not to say that one is better than the other. They just are different tools.

And I have used Japanese saws in hardwoods without breaking teeth (yet). I also think that both types of saws require different technique. Everyone that is used to western saws that I've seen try a Japanese saw uniformly puts too much downward pressure during the cut. I have the reverse problem when using western saws.

Oh, and about the maintenance: I've been practicing resharpening Japanese saws, and I don't think that it is as difficult as it's made out to be. At least not the resharpening part. Resetting the teeth is a much different issue.

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#7

Why use Japanese saws?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I like the straight handles and the cutting speed relative to western saws. The only comparable western saw I know of is the LN straight handled dovetail, which also cuts very, very quickly. For normal sized dovetails, it literally takes me three or four strokes to get the job done and no particular strength.

The straight handles allow me to use a two-handed stance when necessary, which I find very natural.

Pam

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#8

Re: Why use Japanese saws?

ThomD

>I think this is the point, it's true that the average Japanese saw is better than the average Western saw. But if even one Western saw proves outstanding, shows the potential, it's a major exception, as you know. I learned on Japanese saws, when they were all we had in the 70s, and I they remain mostly what I use, but my work wouldn't suffer if they weren't available today.

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#9

Re: Standing on the sidelines

ThomD

>I don't think there is that much difference when it comes to western saws:

- It won't be a costless experience to run a dovetail saw into a staple, or even hit a really nasty knot.

- I have only lost teeth with a Japanese saw once when I was triming a door, and I ran into a packing staple.

- Nobody I am aware of has ever posted any work on this board that required a high end Japanese saw to achieve. I am not really aware of what such work would be. I greatly admire Japanese woodwork, but in the main it is not better than Western work. It can be quite different, with aspects to admire like say lacquerwork, that we don't have where possibly they don't have French polish.

When people talk about these Uber saws, the language changes from what the saw does, to how it feels to the user. The best Japanese tools are a very high standard of craft and a pleasure to own and use. That is a self-justifying thing to those who find the pleasure, but surely nobody is actually suggesting that these saws are required for the work. It may be the case that there is some arcane Japanese joinery that requires these saws. I'm skeptical because I often see a lot of chisel or plane work being done to get the final surfaces. There is little call for Japanese temple carpentry over here. I hear a lot of talk about dovetails, which don't really seem to show up in much Japanese of Japansese inspired cabinet work. Western dovetail work does not require Japanese saws, it just requires saws that work.

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#10

Re: Standing on the sidelines--Long, boring

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Marv.

You were responding to my post, so let me attempt an answer....All those issues I mentioned were things I did or experienced when starting out a couple decades ago (can't believe I'm that old!). All with Gyokucho replaceable blade saws. All done with no instruction whatever--just pick up the saw and start sawing. There was no internet then. No forums. The only background in hand sawing I had was 26" saws from the hardware store, also used with zero instruction.

Well, that's a hell of a way to start any endeavor, but I suspect that there are plenty of people right now tuned in to this forum who are in the same situation, except that they have forums like this one to read and try to sift something useful from.

Now. Japanese carpenters and tradesmen do not tear up their saws. They are trained--they apprenticed. They had the master get up side their head with a steel rule when they weren't doing it right. I haven't torn a tooth either or had other mishaps for at least 10 years, because I learned. Except for one idiot time back about 2000 when I had a Chuyemon ryoba and some 2x boards sitting on a freaking workmate. Bumped into the workmate and knocked the whole shooting match to the ground. Snap. Dead $160 saw. Ended up with some really nice scrapers, which I still have.

Anyway, what I was going to say is that screwing up Japanese saws is not inevitable. It's a result of lack of training and instruction and reasonable care. Hopefully by relating my own mishaps I can help someone avoid their own.

Oh, while I'm talking about it, let me relate one I haven't done, but which is easy to do. Everybody's first plane is a block plane right? And everybody's first Japanese saw is a 210 or 240 replaceable blade ryoba, right? It's 50:50 that at some point, that person will walk over to a green 3" limb on a tree that needs trimming, or else a green dripping wet 2x4 from the Borg, and take their 210 or 240 ryoba to it. Won't be long before that saw hangs up on a back stroke and bends into a double-recurved bow. If it's a Gyokucho, you'll probably get away with it, with maybe just a bent blade. But if it's a nice expensive Rc58 smithed saw, it's gone. Right now. Before you can say 'jack robinson' or even think 'jack robinson'. Snapped in two. You now own some really nice scrapers.

Now you could still argue: OK it's all avoidable, but why put yourself in a risk position?

And you could also ask in the same vein: Why in the world would anyone buy a high-dollar Japanese plane that looks like a piece of steel stuck into an oak block, with a blade that has to be 'tapped out', which means you the amateur are going to take a steel hammer to the bevel of a $300 blade set, hit it freehand with no jigging whatever, and try to miss the hagane, and land your hammer blows in the middle of the soft backing, with no more than + or - 1/16" between you and a deeply chipped or cracked-in-two blade? How crazy is that?

Here's my answer to that....Because it's there. Why do people ride down a mountainside on a 17-lb bike with 1" tires inflated to 95 psi? These tools are made for craftsmen who know what they're doing, and the makers don't compromise. They're not dumbed down and idiot-proofed--the real tools I'm talking about now. They're optimized for purpose, and the assumption of the maker is that the tool is for a real tradesman. The saws are unforgiving of foolishness, as are the plane blades and the chisels. If they are abused, used incorrectly, or given a torture test--crosscut teeth will come right off; saw blades will snap in two; chisels will chip; plane blades will be cracked in the cutting steel never to be fixed. And then well-meaning and sensible people will say--Japanese steel is too hard for purpose. Japanese saws are too fragile.

However, these tools repay proper use. Which has to be learned. You have to humble yourself. You have to start out, just as Wilbur or Larry did at Med. school, with the realization 'I don't know anything.' Get macho with a Japanese tool, and you'll have an expensive accident to talk about on a forum. 'My new saw just fell off a workmate, a 4x4 landed on it, and it's dead now.' Duh.

Well, you're right about this. And Thom said this too. Nobody needs to own japanese tools. However, if you're of a mind, getting some instruction is the way to go, and bad things can be mostly avoided.

Wiley

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#11

Re: Standing on the sidelines--Long, boring

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>The first time I got serious about using hand tools was 28 years ago. At that time I used a Tyzack back saw for dovetails, and it worked fine. I moved it with me a couple or three times, even though I didn't have a workshop for 9 of those years. But when I picked it up again, it didn't cut so well as I remembered and there was a lot of discussion on the net about Japanese saws.

So I got Toshio Odate to teach me how to saw with them (in a class on making shoji), I fell in love in that class with all the tools. I bought a dozuki from Rob, fell more in love. Attended Inomoto-san's plane making class an got my first look at hundreds of Japanese tools in Harrelson's shop, bought several of them. It was all so easy and comfortable.

Sure, I broke a few teeth on a couple of ryoba, but the love was not diminished. Maybe I'm some sort of sucker for tools that are elegent in behavior, that cut smoothly and easily, that seem to know the job they're to do and do it. My '76 BMW R90S behaves that way, too. You just think about where you want it to go and it goes there.

Could I do woodwork without the Japanese tools? Sure, obviously, hundreds of thousands have done so before me. But I don't want to.

Pam

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#12

Re: dozuki broken teeth/crosscut

Jerry Gibbs

>If the dozuki is designed for crosscutting softwoods, what good is it in a cabinet shop? Jerry Gibbs

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#13

Not boring...informative *LINK*

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Thanks Wiley for taking the time to describe what owning and using a Japanese saw is all about.

Have you read Chris' latest review on Andrew Lunn's DT saw? He compares it to a Japanese saw he has. He not only compares how they both cut dovetails, he also compares how they feel. Some interesting comments on his blog.

The message I'm getting from your post here and others, is, owning and learning how to use and maintain a Japanese saw is kind of like a religion. Pam compares it to her 76 BMW. Is there a ceremony that you all perform just before you use one of those saws? (just kidding)

A couple years ago I bought a bunch of old western handsaws from a tool collector who had a couple hundred saws laying around in various piles. In one pile there was a wierd looking saw that appeared to have a broom handle attatched to it. I think it was a Japanese saw. I'm wishing now I had bought it. As you might guess, I know nothing about the Japanese saws, so I guess I need to tread lightly around the subject.

I find it very interesting how those of you who have spent half a lifetime with a certain style tool have developed such a devotion and inner connection with something that performs very basic operations relating to sawing wood.

I'm not trying to sound like a smartass here, but if I were to spend an extended amount of time taking classes to learn something of such complexity, I think I might want to become a doctor or something similar.

Having an expensive tool in my shop such as a saw as you guys are describing, it's almost like having a saw made of glass or ceramic. If you could see my shop, we would both know that it is not a place for such a saw. A tool that shatters when dropped is not a tool that should be placed in my hands or even within reach.

Thank you all for convincing me to not mess with a Japanese saw. Because there appears to be so few people who can tune, "Metates"? a Japanese saw, I was toying with the thought to learn how to sharpen them. After reading the posts in this thread, no way do I want to take on that kind of responsibility. I'm imagining Pam or someone sending me their baby and me dropping it and breaking it and being sued for thousands of dollars.

Am I over reacting? :-))

Marv


Chris' Review

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#14

Re: Not boring...informative

wilbur

>"The message I'm getting from your post here and others, is, owning and learning how to use and maintain a Japanese saw is kind of like a religion."

No, it's just a matter of technique. I've found that if you take someone who has little experience with any type of hand sawing, they take to Japanese and western saws equally. But if you take someone with a lot of experience with western saws, they will have trouble using Japanese saws. Likewise, when I try to use western saws, I have trouble. It's the difference between learning a new skill and unlearning muscle memory to pick up a new skill.

This isn't just true for western and Japanese saws. I've had the same experience trying to learn how to snowboard after having skied for many years. Snowboarding is just not going to happen for me in this lifetime. Other skiers I know tell me the same thing.

"I find it very interesting how those of you who have spent half a lifetime with a certain style tool have developed such a devotion and inner connection with something that performs very basic operations relating to sawing wood."

The same might be said of your reluctance to change from using western saws to using Japanese saws. One person's devotion and inner connection is another's unwillingness to try a different tool that requires an alteration in one's technique. Besides, isn't there a single tool in your shop that you just love using? A favorite saw? A favorite plane? Same thing.

"Having an expensive tool in my shop such as a saw as you guys are describing, it's almost like having a saw made of glass or ceramic. If you could see my shop, we would both know that it is not a place for such a saw. A tool that shatters when dropped is not a tool that should be placed in my hands or even within reach."

Not all Japanese saws are expensive. Nor are they as fragile as you make them out to be. And would you use a Panther Head saw in your shop, if you had one?

I'm not necessarily saying that Japanese saws are better than western saws across the board. For me, I like them better, and I think that a big reason for that is that when I started woodworking, I started with a Japanese saw. Had I started with a western saw, I might have a different arsenal of tools in my shop.

So Marv, in the interest of continuing the discussion, let me turn the question around. For me, I don't have the issues of fragility that you are concerned with. Sharpening isn't an issue, since I can either replace the blade, or touch up the teeth myself. As I said before, I am learning how to sharpen Japanese saw teeth, which doesn't seem to be that much harder than sharpening western saw teeth. Why should I bother with western saws when (1) they will cut a bigger kerf and leave a rougher sawn surface than I will get with my Japanese saws, and (2) are harder to track straight since they don't work on the pull stroke?

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#15

Pam Said it

roninkokomo

>My dozuki knows how to cut dovetails. I just sort of slide it across the wood.

Yes I have an excellent Western Dovetail saw. Independence Tool serial # 125.. I can do a good job with it also.

BUT it is a lot easier with my 30 buck Dozuki. Have NO idea why. It just is.

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#16

Re: Not boring...informative

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Wilbur,

Thanks for your thoughts and comments....

I can't do "bold" on my computer here in this forum, so I'll just copy and paste...

----------------------------------------------------------------------

So Marv, in the interest of continuing the discussion, let me turn the question around. For me, I don't have the issues of fragility that you are concerned with. Sharpening isn't an issue, since I can either replace the blade, or touch up the teeth myself. As I said before, I am learning how to sharpen Japanese saw teeth, which doesn't seem to be that much harder than sharpening western saw teeth. Why should I bother with western saws when (1) they will cut a bigger kerf and leave a rougher sawn surface than I will get with my Japanese saws, and (2) are harder to track straight since they don't work on the pull stroke?

----------------------------------------------------------------------

Fragility is of major concern for me as it is with any tool. I think that Wiley described the fragility much better than I did.

In another thread, Manny indicated that he too sharpens his own Japanese saws but will at some point have them sent to Japan to be tuned up, which, I guess means, his sharpening messes them up to the extent that they no longer perform properly. The same is common with a western style saw, however, they can be tuned up without sending them overseas.

You said that you started out using Japanese saws. Your comment about western saws not sawing a smooth surface compared to your Japanese saws isn't a valid comparison. I don't think it has anything to do with pulling versus pushing the saw. Your experiences sharpening saws seems to be much more with Japanese saws versus western. Talk to any experienced saw filer who files western saws and they will tell you that a western type saw can be filed to cut just as smooth as any saw. I know because I do it all the time. The smoothness of the cut is mainly due to how the teeth are set. I'm sure that is true with Japanese saws as well. A properly filed and set western saw will tract without deviation. When I file a saw, that is one of my concerns. If it won't effortlessly follow a line, the saw is pretty much worthless, no matter how sharp the teeth are, IMO.

As for tuning a saw, whether it be Japanese or western, both style saws must be filed and set for certain purposes, such as type of wood and quality of kerf. Both type saws can be filed for wet soft wood or dry hardwood. This is partly done with adjusting the set in the teeth. A western type saw can easily be filed by changing the rake and fleam angles to both match what the saw will be used for and make the teeth remain sharp for a longer period of time. The angles can be adjusted to effect how aggressive the saw will cut. From what I've learned so far about the Japanese saws, those adjustments are not easily accomplished by anyone with a saw vise and a tapered file plus a little practice.

Teeth on a western saw will not fall off when you use one on soft wood that was filed to cut hardwood or visa-versa. From my standpoint that is a major concern. I realize it is easy to label or color code your Japanese saws, but with a western saw, it isn't even a concern.

We can talk pros and cons all day to each other and neather of us will change the way we think and feel about the subject. What's important in these conversations is what can be gleaned from our diatribe by those who have little or no experience with the use of either style saw. There are lots of folks who frequent these forums who never post. They just come, in the hopes they can learn how to make better decisions about things they are not yet experienced in. We were all there once.

Hell, I'm still there in countless ways. I learn a lot more by reading than I do typing.

Marv

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#17

Another long and boring answer

wilbur

>Hi Doug,

There are two ways to address this question.

The first is to look at what is meant by "designed" for softwood. I've come to think that the word "optimized" is probably better. It is true that Japanese saws can have softwood and hardwood crosscut teeth. In a softwood crosscut tooth, the gullets are deeper and the "knife" bevel at the tip of the tooth is longer. In a hardwood crosscut tooth, the gullets are more shallow and the "knife" is shorter. The thing is, you can take a file and convert a tooth from one type to the other. There isn't a threshold line where the tooth magically stops being a softwood tooth and turns into a hardwood one. It's really a just a matter of degree.

Just for completeness, there is a similar thing going on with the rip teeth. Softwood rip teeth have a very aggressive rake angle. Hardwood rip teeth have a more relaxed rake angle. Again, the only thing you need to convert one into another is a file.

This probably seems weird to most people since with western saws, the teeth are pretty much the same in terms of geometry, regardless of what saw you have. But there are parallels in other tools we all use. We talk about using a higher angle plane for woods with a lot of figure. We talk about more acute bevel angles being better for a paring chisel, as opposed to a mortise chisel. Again, these are all differences of degree. You could use a mortise chisel to pare something, but it just wouldn't be much fun to do so.

In other words, the softwood/hardwood issue is a bit of a non-issue. I have "softwood" Japanese saws that I use in very hard woods all the time without problems.

The second way to look at your question is to view it as an issue of what Japanese saws are readily available in the US. This is an issue that I have been mulling over for a while now. To start, consider a typical list of what western handsaws are needed in a shop. This one is from Chris Schwarz:

Carcasse saw (crosscut), 14 ppi

Dovetail saw (rip), 20 tpi

Tenon saw (rip), 10 ppi

Large crosscut saw (crosscut, duh), 7 ppi

Large rip saw (rip, duh again), 5 ppi

Now let's see how that compares to what's readily available here in the US: 240 mm ryobas, and a dozuki with crosscut teeth. A 240 mm ryoba has about 16 tpi on the crosscut side and 7 tpi on the rip side. In other words, the only match in the need-to-have western saw list is the carcasse saw. The 7 tpi on the rip side is going to be a bit too coarse to replace the tenon saw, and not fine enough to work well as a dovetail saw. A dozuki will have crosscut teeth, not rip teeth, and isn't going to work well as a dovetail saw, which is what most people want to use them for.

Again, this is really a matter of degree. You can use a 240 mm ryoba as a good all-around saw, meaning that it's going to be pretty good at making a lot of different cuts, but not excellent at any one of them.

My list of need-to-have Japanese saws, looking to optimally duplicate the functionality of the need-to-have western saw list, would be this:

180 or 210 mm ryoba (replaces tenon and carcasse saws), for joinery cuts.

300 mm ryoba (replaces large crosscut and rip saws), for breaking down stock.

Dozuki with rip teeth (replaces dovetail saw), for dovetails (duh).

For ryobas, the tpi of the teeth varies with the size of the saw. Bigger saws = coarser tpi, and vice versa.

And, these saws should have teeth profiles that are more optimized for North American hardwoods.

So where can you get this set? Right now, you can't, really, unless you get them custom made, or if you buy some ryobas and have the tooth geometry reconfigured. The one exception is the rip tooth Dozuki, which has become more popular and available recently.

I think that one of the things that has led to the "Japanese saws are too delicate" issue is that for the type of woodworking that is done most often here in the US, the right saws aren't being sold. It's like if you were looking to buy a mortise chisel and all the ones that were sold had a 25 degree bevel angle.

To put it another way, it's not an issue of what good is a softwood crosscut dozuki in a cabinet shop. It's more an issue of why the dozukis sold here aren't all rip tooth dozukis with teeth optimized for hardwoods.

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#18

Re: Not boring...informative

Manny

>"....I guess means, his sharpening messes them up to the extent that they no longer perform properly."

LOL! I do? You sure do a lot of guessing. As does Mr. Schwarz when he writes about something he knows very little about. His blog amused me as did his articles.

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#19

Re: Not boring...informative

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Manny,

Why else would you send your saws to Japan for tuning if they aren't messed up? Is there a better word that I should have used? I used the word "guessed" because of not being sure why you send your saws to Japan.

I wasn't trying to be demeaning. Your negative response is not warranted or informative and certainly not helpful to people coming here to learn.

Marv

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#20

Re: Not boring...informative

Manny

>"is not warranted or informative and certainly not helpful to people coming here to learn"

Neither is your guessing.

There are many reason to send a saw back for metate. I'm not going to spend anymore time explaining. I'll just let you guess.

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#21

Re: Not boring...informative

Alan DuBoff

>Manny wrote:

"LOL! I do? You sure do a lot of guessing. As does Mr. Schwarz when he writes about something he knows very little about. His blog amused me as did his articles."

This is not just Chris, it's quite humorous to see so many Gaijin that really don't know or understand the Japanese culture or language toss around words like "metate", "nomi", "kanna", who really have no clue other than they appear to be cool using them...:-/

These people's use of the Japanese language makes them appear like a banana...yellow on the outside, but white on the inside...(also true of Ni-sei, San-sei, etc...:-) My wife and kids get a kick out of this banana reference, because of the analogy, but it is fitting for these folks using it for their woodworking tools that have no command of the Japanese language/culture. Very similar to hearing a Gaijin order at a sushi bar, sometimes the pronunciation of something so simple as Hamachi can leave one laughing...;-)

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#22

Re: Not boring...informative

wilbur

>Hi Marv,

I'm not sure that you really got some of my points, so let me summarize what you might have missed:

In my experience:

1. Japanese saws are not as fragile as they are made out to be.

2. Japanese saws are not as hard to sharpen as they are made out to be.

3. Japanese saws that are designed/optimized for softwoods can also cut hardwoods.

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#23

Re: Not boring...informative

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Thanks Wilbur for your informative follow-up,

From what I have read and what some of you guys are saying, there are Japanese saws, then there are Japanese saws, just like with western style saws. They ain't all good and they ain't all bad.

Wiley talks about a 4x4 falling on his $300 saw and breaking it. I take it that, that is a saw that was made by the master saw makers in Japan? The guys who take three months to make a saw? Is it true that three months would be considered high production?

"Metate"...love that word.

Then there are saws that are not brittle, the kind that you refer to?

It's the brittle saws that cost an amount of money it takes to feed myself for six months that bothers me. I wouldn't purchase a saw of that kind even if it does stay sharp ten times longer than a western style saw. The words "brittle" and "saw" used in the same sentence just don't work for me.

I did get your points. I thank you for being civil with your response to my questions and comments.

Do you think it's important that we learn to speak the Japanese language in order to be qualified to discuss the Japanese style saws? That's kinda the message I got from Alan's post.

"Metate"...love using that word! It's cool! LOL

I suppose if we all knew a few Japanese words to toss around, we could think of ourselves as being on a higher plain of expertise than others.

Ok, I'm off to Google Japanese words.

Catchalater, Wilbur...*grin* Thanks again

Mitsubishi, Homoguchi, Honda, Sushi, taco, no that's not right...

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#24

Re: Not boring...informative

wilbur

>"It's the brittle saws that cost an amount of money it takes to feed myself for six months that bothers me. I wouldn't purchase a saw of that kind even if it does stay sharp ten times longer than a western style saw. The words "brittle" and "saw" used in the same sentence just don't work for me."

All I can say is that I have one completely handmade Japanese saw, which cost about the same as what Wiley mentioned. It's a 210 mm ryoba, that I use for joinery cuts for the most part. Most people who have seen it say that it's a real delicate looking saw. I've had more accidents with it than I care to admit, but it hasn't broken on me. So again, I don't think that these saws are as fragile as you think they might be.

FWIW, for the most part I tend to avoid Japanese even when I'm discussing Japanese tools, mainly because I don't speak Japanese. Also, these discussions tend to involve people who aren't real familiar with Japanese tools, so why muddle the conversation with terms that will need to be defined anyway? I like to pride myself on speaking in plain language and not doctor-talk with my patients and their families as well.

Looking back over my posts in this discussion, I think the only Japanese words I've used were ryoba and dozuki, which is just as well because the phrases "double edged Japanese saw" and "single-edged backed Japanese saw" gets a bit unwieldy.

Re: dozuki broken teeth

#25

Crosscut vs rip dozuki

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I disagree that crosscut dozuki aren't good for dovetails. In fact, in the process of cutting dovetails one performs a mix of crosscutting and ripping, so either is a good solution. Many say rip is better. I say rip may be minimally, and I do mean minimally, faster; but in my experience, both work just fine. It takes me 3 strokes to cut the average dovetail with both crosscut (and not even an expensive one, the LV Professional dozuki with hardened blade) and rip (a $250 Kaneharu).

Pam