We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>Get the cherry done good and it will look great. I need to get some pics of my nightstands poplar with black walnut danish oil w/earth green milk paint. Door front, raised side panels and top cherry w/BLO and wax. I think you'll like your results.
It doesn't mark when the 18 mo old whacks it with a toy, either.
It may be that it works that way with cherry, though. Here, the cherry is treated a bit differently, since we have to drag it all the way across the continent. Not a Waterlox problem, though. McCloskey Spar varnish doesn't mark, either.
>Blotching occurs around areas of reversing grain. Knots and other growth imperfections. I hardly ever worry about it because in a year or two, you'll never see it. That's one of the reasons I love cherry, it darkens over time.
>"soliveable" You may have topped my lousy spelling.
The Headley shop where I took a class last summer uses lacquer for the tops of their furniture for reasons of durability as well as ability to match looks of shellac. I had drifted away from lacquer over the years but I am drifting back after experimenting with about everything else. I have decided it makes no sense to spray shellac when lacquer gives me the same appearance with less grief and expense. I will continue to use conversion varnish where durability is a major issue, such as a dining table top. I sprayed my stair treads with conversion varnish and they are holding up fine after 14 years.
The typical nitrocellulose lacquer or CAB lacquer(which is mostly acrylic by the way) is not soluble in alcohol or hydrocarbon solvents such as naptha and mineral spirits. It takes a ketone or ester solvent to dissolve them.
>Blotching sounds like what we used to call figure, or depth, or liveliness. You can still see the liveliness from grain reversals in stuff I made decades ago. And, thank heavens, you can still see it in a cherry desk that has been in my family for seven generations.
>I was beginning to think I was the only person that thought cherry was supposed to have some figure. The backs of the chairs I recently finished (I bought the chairs as I don't do chairs) have much "liveliness" and I think it's great. I got to pick 4 chairs from a batch of 12 and I went for the ones that would be.....as the misguided magazine authors would say....blotchy. Now there is a pejorative word for what should be a desirable property.
I would like to agree with you and Warren, with one caveat. I think I know exactly what you're talking about. I am looking at a cherry table top right now, one that has some curl figure to it (though not outrageous like Hank's). It has a subtle mottling effect that brings out the figure, and is just beautiful. There is an overall rolling, sort of wide quilted effect. I began the finish of this top with one coat of 1/2 pound dewaxed blonde shellac, as a partial filler.
Now. Years ago, when my finish for everything was Minwax oil stain, I would sometimes have a cherry board, that when the oil hit it, it would be clear over most of the board, but would have one large patch of 'blotch'--maybe a patch of grain runout. Now that looked like hell, because it did not give that rolling effect that enhances the grain and figure--it simply looked like a stain, like something had been spilled on the wood. And it is deep--would not come out.
So. Hank's issue is to know what he has before he commits to a finish. I would suggest take two large enough pieces of raw planed scrap, and use a thin shellac coat on one, and oil on the other, and see whether he likes more contrast (oil finish) between dark and light in the curl figure, or a more subtle contrast (thinned shellac). If he wants a very clear even finish, he could try a 1-lb or higher cut. My point is, it is controllable.
I'm not sure what the magazine writers are talking about, but there is such a thing as random stain-looking blotch, which is not the same as as the natural rolling figure I think you are talking about.
>I wouldn't say there is anything wrong with that test. It's legitimate to see if the finish itself is scratch resistant. Lacquer is also a good finish, in the short run, for musical instruments. Great tonal clarity, and it will survive the sales process and looks great in a pimp sort of way.
But scratch resistence is only one measure of durability. It is perfectly reasonable to assume that wood will either be under or over-used for what lacquer can do. Lacquer does not last a long time, and becomes quite ungly as the surface degrades. It does not have the look some people want, and it if they are making low wear stuff, then why bother with durability. I have no difficulty keeping domestic furniture that has an oil type finish on it. On the other hand around the workshop, for example, the impacts will easily exceed what lacquer can deal with. So I finish workbenches or chisels etc... with oil because where lacquer might chip or crack, oil will be easier to repair and with stay with the surface of the object whatever becomes of it. If I oiled a mallet, even if the impact surface became severely dented it would still have some prottection. And more oil could be added at any time.
I prefer Maloof finish for tables etc... It has hardness and watermark resistence without having to worry about the problems with lacquer.
Spray is a great thing, but it vastly oversteps to say a serious woodworker needs to know how to use it. Many serious woodworkers won't go near it. I have spray in my shop, and mostly use it for cheap stuff like various built in cabinets. I spray a water based varnish that gives a somewhat oil like look. I also use it for instruments, and bikes. I do think though that it isn't really the hand tool type thing. Compressors and guns and all that. Of course it's a fast way to finish any projects with fake tool tracks of the master craftsman left all over it.
Of course it is... it's what you dissolve the flakes in...
Laquer and shellac do share a common advantage though. Because they're both solvent based (alcohol being the solvent for shellac), they're both much easier to refinish, because subsequent layers will partially dissolve, and merge with, previous layers, and make for a smoother refinishing job.
>I was just finishing up this spinning wheel part in maple, and it has a difinite blotch on it, so it isn't just cherry. It is a piece with very minimal curl, and there is this dark patch. I took a photo of it, but it doesn't show up. The left foot piece in the foreground, but it isn't visible.
Re: Hey Thom, what did you use as a finish on that
ThomD
>Thanks Scott. I used Watco on that piece. It is hard maple with a piece of spalted beech in it. It is a pretty spectacular piece of wood in person.
I have a coffee table I am working on right now, and it is cherry with some blotch to it. The Watco has really done a beautiful job on it. I left it unfinished for a long time, so that now that I am finishing it, it has a deep dark red to it, very attractive. Unfortunately, every attempt to get a decent photograph of the colour, shimmer etc... has been a terrible failure.
>I stain most wood and at my level of expertise with planing and scraping I can't control stain take-up with a scraped or planed surface. However, properly sanded that place that stained dark would not have stained dark. I sand till the surface has a uniform luster. Places where there are grain reversals are prone to tearing and even on a micro scale they become stain absorbers. Also, they become sanding dust trappers. Until all this torn partial end grain is removed (and maybe burnished besides) it will trap sanding dust and appear dull. Hence, I sand till these places are the same luster as ever where else. Ditto for end grain edges. Again, properly sanded end grain stains just like the flat edges and faces.
When I finish cherry these grain variations appear as highlights, not blotches.
I expect that planed and scraped surfaces will need to be wash-coated to control "colorant" take up for surfaces with grain variations, whether the colorant is oil or stain. I had to wash coat the mahogany crotch I finished or the end grain portions would have turned almost black with oil. Veneer is nothing but micro-torn grain.
>There was an article in FWW a while ago about controlling blotching, and quoting from memory, sanding cherry to 400 grit did help a good deal in controlling blotching. I suspect that at this grit level the wood gets burnished as much as it gets sanded.
But this goes against my grain, I prefer planed surfaces.
I don't stain wood as a principle (YMMV), so blotching is less of an issue for me, besides I don't use oil much as a finish.
Using a washcoat does indeed eliminate most blotching. But one rationale behind an oil finish is to pop out the grain. I wonder if anyone has tried using a very diluted coat of clear oil as a first finishing step. Blotching occurs when an area sucks in more oil than the rest. If the oil is thinned a lot, there is not much oil that can get absorbed, yet it should create a barrier for the subsequent coats.
Wonderful post! Looking back at that experience, I totally agree with what you are saying! At the time this was happening, I was using only sandpaper, down through 320g, but no burnishing.
The proof of your method can be seen in end grain preparation, as in end-grain edges of table tops, which you refer to above. My experience is identical--that if the end grain is burnished down to where it has the same lustre as the flat grain, it will finish to the same brilliance.
So surely that same approach would have worked with the surfacing end grain (run out in my case) which caused my large patch of blotch.
So are you using BLO or an oil stain over the cherry, after it is sanded?
Returning to Hank's table top, I would like to emphasize a previous point from recent experience with my cherry table top. A wash coat of thin-cut shellac over a planed and scraped surface will give an excellent effect to curly cherry. It will show a rolling or quilted effect, with every part whether lighter or darker showing lustre.
Relating this back to your post, you mentioned the wash-coating of the veneer panels of your incredible crotch mahogany chest. Those panels are absolutely alive.
>My experience with cherry has been pretty good so far, but my finish method of choice is pretty labor intensive:
-sand to 400 or plane/scrape
-dye with a light coat of honey amber transtint.
-scrub down with a paste of BLO and very fine pumice powder to both burnish the surface, and fill the grain. (pumice is very porous, and with the oil, it completely disappears.)
-rag with straight BLO to remove excess pumice.
-very thick base coat of garnet shellac, followed almost immediately with rubbing down with thinner coats, finishing up with french polishing.
I think if I were to alter it in any way, I'd do the thin wash coat of super blonde to really get down in there.
I see a good finish as an optical path to the inside of the wood, to bring the true color to the surface. Think of a thin paper bag soaked with pizza grease... normally opaque, but with the grease in it, you can almost see right through it. The BLO does something similar, but I have a hunch that super blonde is more clear.
I use the honey amber to give added warmth to the finish, and the garnet really warms it up from there. Garnet also polishes up very easily.
One more argument for the Super blonde as a surface filler, there were a few spots on teh lid where the grain was softer and while it didn't exactly tear out, the pores really opened up, and it got a lot darker. I didn't really mind hte effect, but I think some of it is from heavy pockets of straight garnet shellac, and I think the blonde might have done more favors for it.
>So are you using BLO or an oil stain over the cherry, after it is sanded?
Cherry is a challenge to finish compared to the other stuff I work. First off there is northern cherry and "southern" cherry (in fact cold climate cherry and temperate climate cherry. The cherry above 4 or 5 thousand feet from around here looks like that from farther north. )
"Southern" cherry turns much darker than that from up north. I usually don't stain it as it gets plenty dark without. I do oil it after sanding to 220 grit followed by some film forming top coat- shellac, varnish, etc. The oil brings out the figure, which I like.
Northern cherry looks raw to me unless it is stained. Might be ok for a modern piece but not a reproduction, or anything else I build. I mix my own stains from linseed oil and ground mineral pigments (because they are light fast). I do not like the effect of traditional "chemical" (chromate, etc) stains on cherry. Because the stain is in oil there is no need to do a separate oil step. I apply stain like others apply shellac-with a rubber. This technique controls the "take". I regard the notion that stain "muddies" the appearance as crap. Certainly not if it is applied right.
I made a superficial effort at finishing planed and scraped surfaces (not sanded) and I could not control the staining to my satisfaction. Hence, what I do probably will not work on planed and scraped surfaces.
I have done some work with "aniline" stains but for cherry they didn't improve on my traditional approach so I have not learned to use them effectively and reliably.
I don't work much maple and I don't know how to finish it. My few attempts have been unsatisfactory. I expect some combination of oil and aniline dye would be successful. Walnut and oak I use pigment stain, and mahogany oil and aniline stain. I sometimes fill these woods. I have never successfully stained ash so I use it for modern pieces and leave it white.