Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

Posts

Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

#1

Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

Hank Knight

>Last weekend I glued up the top for the hunt baord I've been working on forever. Today I played hookey from my day job to plane it flat and smooth. The curl on this cherry is stunning. I can't wait to get a finish on it to see what it really looks like.

Hunt Board - Top Glue Up/Smoothing

What do you think?

Hank

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

#2

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

Ray Binnicker

>Hank,

I think you're about to get the hang of this woodworking thing (:-)It is indeed gorgeous !!!! Is that some the stuff you got on our "road trip" ? What kind of finish are you going to put on it?

Ray

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

#3

Indeed! any ideas from whence it came

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>In all the years we sold lumber I never saw but one curly cherry board and it was not near as spectacular as yours. I wonder if curly cherry occurs anywhere in its range or is it more common is some area? Supposedly most of the birds eye maple one sees in old furniture came from some place in the upper midwest.

When I was a kid we used to get birch slab firewood from a mill in Newcomb, NY. Much of it was exceptionally curly, as tight as any maple I have ever seen. I had to split it so I remember it well! I met the state Forester a few years back and he told me this area was noted for the prevalence of curly birch. The massive trees they were logging (3' in diameter) in the 1950's were trees that sprouted after a big forest fire that occurred 100 years earlier (birch seeds best in a mineral soil). Additionally, I recall huge birch burls, as big as a bath tub. These wouldn't move on the conveyors and they would roll them off on the ground near the burn pile. I thought at the time they would make a neat table top.

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

#4

I thought at the time they would make

Greg B�tit, Crown Point, NY.

>... a neat table top!

HFT! That's a new internet slang term for "Holy Toledo!" Can you imagine?

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

#5

Nice DBG

Neal in San Jose

>Drive By Gloat. You just "happened" to get a Norris, and a 112, and, and, and....in the picture. Very nice wood.

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

#6

Not SC Cherry!

Hank Knight

>We don't get big cherry down here in SC. This board came from Hearne's in Pennsylvania. I bought it seven or eight years ago for a project, but it was so pretty I decided to save it. It is perfect for this top. I plan to finish it with Waterlox. The piece is a sideboard (hunt board) for our dining room, so it will get some heavy use. I think Waterlox will give me the protection need. I plan to use a light shellac wash coat first to reduce the splotching. I've done some practice pieces and it looks pretty good. If anyone has suggestions, I'd appreciate any advice on finishing this piece.

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

#7

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

wilbur

>Hi Hank,

Boy, that is just astounding. Can't wait to see it finished. The board and the whole project.

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

#8

Damn right I do!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>And it's fantastic! Great rippling through it.

Nice job of matching the boards if I do say...

I just finished a job with curly cherry and mine didn't look like that...

Yes hank, I still owe you some pics myself.

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

#9

Waterlox warning

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Encouraged by the proponents of Waterlox I experimented with it for a piece. I found it to yield an exceptionally soft finish compared to the stuff I normally use-varnish, shellac and lacquer. Finish a test piece and then do the "see how easy it dents with a finger nail test". Additionally, I found it tedious to use. It required numerous coatings to build a protective film such as one would want for a top. And if that was not enough, it is expensive to buy and it "goes bad" quickly after some is used from the can.

While its proponents will disagree I think it is a finish that attracts people that don't want to learn to finish with better products.

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

#10

Re: Not SC Cherry!

Joshua A Clark

>Hank- That is some amazing cherry. What a beautiful top!

Before you apply any finish, test some on a scrap- preferably a scrap with some curl in it. I know the wash coat of shellac will prevent blotching (there was a good FWW article a while back about reducing cherry blotch) but it might not bring out the great figure in that piece. If you can, run some tests with oils first, then shellac or varnish. You want to get the best finish in the world on that table top!

On a related note, if you can plane that board then you're my hero. I just finished gluing up some cherry raised panel doors for my china cabinet project. The panels are book-matched curly cherry, though not nearly as spectacular as yours. I wound up scraping the panels rather than planing- even my best smoothing plane- a LN 4 1/2 with york pitch frog couldn't handle the curl.

Looks great!

Josh

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

#11

Re: Not SC Cherry!

Hank Knight

>Thanks for the compliments, Josh. My LN 4 1/2 and my A5 both did a pretty good job on the curl. There were some pretty deep gouges from the mill planer, most of which I was able to eliminate. I ended up going over the whole thing with my 112 and a using card scraper on some of the rough spots. All in all, I'm pretty pleased with it.

I've already done some sample pieces with the Waterlox. There is a real difference with and without the shellac. The shellac seems to enhance the figure and keep the blotching down pretty well. I agree, the one thing I don't want to do is obscure the fugure.

I've never used Waterlox before and Bill's comment has me second-guessing my choice. I chose it on Ellis's recommendation for a tough finish. So far it's behaved well on my sample pieces. We'll see.

Hank

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

#12

Re: Waterlox warning

Hank Knight

>Bill,

Thanks for the heads-up. I chose Waterlox on Ellis's recommendation for a good tough finish for a serving top. Now you've got me thinking. I've already tried some sample pieces that turned out well, but I'll give them another look before I commit to the whole piece. If not Waterlox, what would you recommend for a heat and food resistant finish? Only the top, the drawer fronts and the door panels will be finished with a natural finish. The case is a rubbed-down black milk paint over dark mahogany-stained soft maple. I'm hoping it will contrast well with and set off the curly cherry.

Hank

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

#13

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Love it!!

I can just imagine the sweet smells as well

Jim

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

#14

Re: Not wanting to argue with Bill T.

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>but the Waterlox over white oak has been a really tough, grandchild resistant surface for me over the past five years.

I don't spray lacquer. I wipe oils, varnishes and shellac. Waterlox is in my skill sets, and works well.

But our place is NOT a formal place right now, and the oak still looks pretty good. I would not walk away from Waterlox.

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

#15

Re: Not SC Cherry!

R.J. Whelan

>Hank ... I have used, for several years now, Behlen's Rock Hard Table Top Varnish for pieces that will receive hard use. I don't care for high gloss finishes, but the lustre is easily controlled with bronze wool followed by wax.

Pretty top BTW ... rj

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

#16

depends on what you can apply successfully

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>If you spray, and anyone serious about making furniture should learn, it is hard to beat the properties of lacquer. In its various varieties it can be made to look like any other finish. Someone brought a Waterlox finished cherry piece to our club meeting and I would have no trouble getting something similar with lacquer or varnish. Surprising to me it seemed to have what looked like orange peel, yet he said he brushed and rubbed it. If you are stuck with brushing, a varnish hard enough to be rubbed out makes a nice finish for a top. And shellac has a lot going for it, but I find it more difficult to learn to apply, if you don't know already.

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

#17

did I get a good test?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Run the edge of your finger nail across the finish and tell me if it marks. It did easily on my test piece on cherry.

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

#18

And....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>If you want a closer to the wood look it can be thinned.

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

#19

Will someone explain "blotching"?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>People go to great lengths to find figured maple and mahogany and then do what they can to bring out this figure when finishing it. But some call this same figure "blotching" when its cherry and scorn it. It is this difference in attitude, which I think may be perpetrated by magazine editors (I never heard the term for the first 30 years of my woodworking) that needs explanation.

Admittedly, a crummy job of sanding (or planing)cherry that leaves the figured wood with torn grain will look ugly when stained. But the grain variations in a properly prepared surface look fine to my eye and I try to bring out this figure.

My cherry finishes all involve an application of oil to the raw wood to enhance this figure. The oil may or may not also contain stain. I have found that a brighter finish shows figure more than a dull finish.

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

#20

yes....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Cheery invites using dull blades to fill the shop with that lovely aroma.

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

#21

Re: Will someone explain "blotching"?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I'm with you, Bill. I have been planing curly cherry for 35 years and I finish without ever sanding. The curly cherry that I worked in the seventies looks awfully nice. I have no idea what blotching is.

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

#22

Re: Will someone explain "blotching"?

Ted

>My experience with curly cherry has been that oil causes some areas to have a dull, darker appearance than other areas. I believe this is due to more end-grain cells in these areas due to the figure. These end-grain cells absorb more finish which results in a blotchy, dull appearance. I have gotten this even on a surface that has been planed with no apparent tear out.

This has happened to me on several projects, so I no longer use oil on cherry, just shellac. An initial coat of thin shellac seems to stop the absorption in the problem zones allowing the finish to build without blotchiness. I get great figure and chatoyance with shellac, so I don't feel any need to go back to oil.

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

#23

Jelling in the can...

John in NM

>Easy fix for that (not that I expect to convert you, Bill - just for anyone else who might want to know) - rebottle it in old peanut butter or jam jars. Fill all the way to the top, as full as you can and screw the lid down tight. If it won't open when you're ready to use it, puncture the top in a couple places with a nail and pour into smaller jars (I've only had this problem if I stored them upsided down). I've had it last years this way.

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

#24

Re: Will someone explain "blotching"?

James Watriss

>What he said. I've seen some really beautifully finished pieces that took a while to get that way, because the cherry really soaked up a lot of shellac (or other finish) in certain spots, but not in others, and it took a while until the grain was full enough that it allowed the finish to sit on the surface.

Re: Pssst! Wanna see spme pretty cherry?

#25

Re: Will someone explain "blotching"?

ThomD

>I think you are dead right to question what people are complaining about. I do find the average piece of cherry is quite likely to have grain reversals, where some maple might not. When I harvest my own wood it always amazes me what a great looking tree it takes to get even some crummy wood. Admitedly there is a lot of wood south of the border from longer growing seasons, but we all know certain species like redwood, at least in the past, seemed to lend themselves to really clean wood.

I think the complaint comes because a lot of very regular looking cherry boards will none the less have the odd piece of endgrain producing what some might judge an inharmonous effect. I rarely see a piece of cherry as dead straight as many other woods, yet not figured to the extent that it is special. People do prize curly maple, but I doubt they will pay extra to get a board with nice straight grain with a few patches of curl here and there. That can be typical of cherry. I don't personally mind much since the stuff darkens so quickly It quickly becomes less obvious that there are tonal variations.