Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

jointing techniques

Posts

Re: jointing techniques

#51

OOPS....I meant Wilbur.......

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>

Re: jointing techniques

#52

Blind kinda like this...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>It really doesn't matter Wilbur, it's all about going for a "feel" More like getting the feel of thing instead of looking at it, trying for perfection. Just like when you throw junk mail into the trash...

You make it you feel good, ya don't Ahhh well...

Re: jointing techniques

#53

Possible, but nuts!?1

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Why go the trouble!?! The point here is the work involved. Flatten it square it and go to town! What's the big deal here?

Re: jointing techniques

#54

Threads and responses

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Well, perhaps it's time to change how you see the new messages? :)

Pam

Re: jointing techniques

#55

I see it this way

James Watriss

>It's pretty hard to take a 5-6' long stick, with a melon on top, and balance it. And yet, we do it every day. It's called standing.

Our bodies do a pretty good job of gauging plumb without our conscious help. It's not the simplest thing in the world to translate into planing, but it is possible.

Really, my biggest challenge was in realizing that I was leaning farther forward, and stretching my arms out, and tilting the plane away from me as I did so. I learned to walk the plane down really long wood, and to pay closer attention to how my arm movements took the plane out of plumb.

I suggest you start practicing spring joints... they'll give you the best gauge on how well you're able to square up the wood, or not.

Re: jointing techniques

#56

Re: Blind movements

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yeah, that's it. I found the golf episode, which is different than I remembered, but still germane (title: Brainy Putting, page 10 of results from a query of "balance").

The other show, not really applicable here, but I thought about it when I mentioned the golf episode, was truly fantastic. A couple of devices were implanted to retrain vision and/or balance. The results were that after retraining, the blind guy could "see" and the woman could ride a bicycle, without the training devices. I'd expect you to have access to the appropriate medical journals to find the original science. :)

Pam

Re: jointing techniques

#57

Re: I see it this way

Paul Kierstead

>OTOH, in spite of my ability to stand upright, I have to correct almost every single picture I take for a counterclockwise tilt of about a degree or two.

Re: jointing techniques

#58

I see it this way... YES! Me too!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: jointing techniques

#59

...Not really...

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Scott,

You're speaking to a tradesman who has to be able to do this as second nature, with the difference between profit and loss being how quickly it's finished. Yes, do it as quickly as possible.

But not any more, I'm teaching high school kids now.

So, yes, it's very easy but it comes with hours or months (literally) of non-stop planing.

I'm just pointing out that there's more than one way to get the correct result and that the old trade practice was to grind the edge square, removes a variable, while, I'd be guessing, the 'cambered' approach to jointing appears to be an innovation of the gentleman woodworker authors in the early parts of the 1900's. I'm by no means sure on this, however, as Charles Hayward has forgotten more than I've ever learnt in this game (ignoring the fact that he's forgotten it all now.)

I'd just been used to seeing only one method proposed of edge jointing ='shooting', knowing full well that it was at odds with the method taught to tradesmen for a fair while in history, and was starting to see this method being proposed as being the only one possible.

I'd be keen to see the take of Don McConnell on this re: history books. I hope that he remembers to post when the weather clears.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: jointing techniques

#60

camber method

paul womack

>It is a method of successive approximation,

yes, but method A is a step-wise approximation (digital, if you like), and method B is continuous (analogue).

There are similarities, as I have pointed out elsewhere, but also differences.

So, yes, the camber does matter, or at least make a difference.

BugBear

Re: jointing techniques

#61

Re: Threads and responses

Sgian Dubh

>That would be more clicking than I really want to do Pam. Read message- click. Read next message, click, etc, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: jointing techniques

#62

Re: Threads and responses

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>You don't read smilies either? :)

Of course I didn't mean for you to change your ways in order to satisfy a goal so trivial as associating a message with a person with a thread. It doesn't really matter all that much; and from now on I'll try to remember to say something in the body that's indicative of the message to which I'm replying.

Pam

Re: jointing techniques

#63

Re: camber method

Paul Kierstead

>Furthermore, if the camber is a little more severe (I use about 3 thou or a wee bit more), you can do it with the plane only a little off center, making it easier to balance and control. As well, with the camber method in general, you can hang near the center to make very small adjustments instead of practically tipping the plane off the edge.

They may be the same in general theory, but fairly different in practice.

Re: jointing techniques

#64

Re: Threads and responses

Sgian Dubh

>"You don't read smilies either? :)"

I sure do read them and notice them. I don't use them myself, but I guess you notice when I stick in a ha, ha at the end. Slainte.

Re: jointing techniques

#65

Yep, ha, ha :)

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: jointing techniques

#66

Thanks Andrew!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Coming from someone here like you I really appreciate your response.

Scott, Hoping all you all down under are not under water or sweating to death.

I wish you could send the rain here.

Re: jointing techniques

#67

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

ThomD

>"A and B aren't even different methods,

One produces a step wise approximation to a surface, the other produces a continuous curved surface.

I'd call that different."

You could get a good result without changing a single thing in your technique. It is the case that the surface of the wood would look a little different on the way to the end result. But that is all at a time when one doesn't even care about what it looks like. Who cares whether there is a step or a concavity on the way to the square edge. I would be willing to "call that different" I wouldn't be willing to call it a different method. I make no distinction when planing a surface using a canbered blade or not. It's all called planing.

Re: jointing techniques

#68

Re: Blind movements

ThomD

>A comon technique in practicing archery is to shoot with the eyes closed into a proximate bale. It really isn't anything like what you are refering to, but it is darn helpful. Archery is pretty difficult and cutting the eyes out of it so one can concentrate on something other than amning is a useful process. Only slightly related to the idea of the best shots being the result of being blind, angry, and surprised.

Re: jointing techniques

#69

camber method

paul womack

> It's all called planing.

If you're not interested in the distinctions, I guess this thread isn't for you.

There's plenty of other threads.

BugBear

Re: jointing techniques

#70

Re: camber method

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thanks Paul,

I really appreciate your insights. Which I take to be that (1) camber gives a variable depth cut, always deeper to the center, which will tend to keep the edge from going convex, and (2) an edge which is tapers down to nothing reduces the angular error, plus allows a very fine adjustment.

I also appreciate Richard jones' insight, which is that one can edge joint with any damn thing, once one is good at it.

Judging from the responses, as well as my own practice, it seems in real life that a number of experienced practitioners are not using a cookbook or paint-by-the-numbers method, but are proceeding intuitively and letting the edge tell their hand what to do.

I too hope that Don McConnell will be back with us soon, and hope that all in the midwest are somehow managing to get through this extreme winter.

Wiley

Re: jointing techniques

#71

Re: Blind movements

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>How does shooting blind into a proximate bale help when you're aiming at the target?

Pam

Re: jointing techniques

#72

OT: archery

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>"Only slightly related to the idea of the best shots being the result of being blind, angry, and surprised."

Somehow, I'm reminded of a presentation by a classmate's brother when I was in jr. high of Zen archery. The particular path the brother was pursuing was one in which everything in the process - the bow, the arrow, the manner of holding them - biased toward one side; then, at the moment of release, the archer moved in a way that biased toward the other side. The result was, of course, more than somewhat random in its effects. Kind of like my planing efforts, but with more thought behind it.

Re: jointing techniques

#73

Re: camber method

ThomD

>I am interested in distinctions. It is a distinction to say that another distinction is, well indistinct. I could be wrong, but I feel entitled to make the point as much as anyone who may have some aggrandizing gatekeeper role in mind. I am unlikely to be swayed by non-arguments.

If it is the same action, to follow the same means to alter the angle, that's the same method as far as I am concerned. I think it is worth saying just to get to at what is or isn't happening with the methods. The person with only one plane, one straight blade style, and little interest in complicating things, needn't feel shut out from getting the same results as the person with a curved blade.

Re: jointing techniques

#74

camber method

paul womack

>If it is the same action, to follow the same means to alter the angle, that's the same method as far as I am concerned.

A similar argument would apply to riding a two stroke versus a four stroke motorbike.

There are similarities, but also differences. The differences exist; wether you deem them important or significant, and worthy of discussion depends on your particular emphasis.

I adopt no gatekeeper role - to the contrary, you were the one who seemed to be attempting to curtail the discussion.

BugBear

Re: jointing techniques

#75

Re: I see it this way

James Watriss

>Some of us have what's called a hemisphere shift... at some point along the way, the dominant side of your brain changes. Results in a host of weird things... drawings are a little crooked, from seeing the paper from a different angle. Head is sometimes held at a different angle... (I got a lot of teasing for this in 8th grade... totally unaware that it was happening, too.) and of all the odd things, sometimes, when writing things, I start with the second letter of the word, and have to go back to write the first part of the word. Not always, but sometimes.