Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

jointing techniques

Posts

jointing techniques

#1

jointing techniques

paul womack

>In an attempt to clarify recent comments, and stop a useful discussion being side tracked by disputes over jargon, I'm made a diagram.

This shows 3 techniques which can be used to make the edge of a board square to its face.

Photobucket

The leftmost image shows a straight blade, set to take a uniform shaving. The board is made squarer by taking a partial width shaving. The plane is kept stable by being seated firmly on the edge of the board. Multiple shavings using this technique will eventually make a square edge with "steps" which can be made into a smooth, square edge with a finishing pass.

The centre image uses a cambered blade. Again the plane is seated firmly on the edge, and the geometry of the camber allows a tapered shaving to be taken, again bringing the edge closer to square. Sucessive shavings are taken so that the successive tapers can out the error, leaving a square edge.

The rightmost image shows what may be the most obvious technique; the plane is held perpendicular to the edge of the board (i.e. with the sole at the desired angle for the edge) and a shaving taken. This makes a small surface at the correct angle; successive shavings will make the surface larger until it is full width.

I have attempted to make no comment on the relative merits or properties of these techniques; I've merely trying to present some kind of agreed jargon for a helpful discussion.

BugBear

Re: jointing techniques

#2

Additional technique

James Watriss

>One I've found useful.

Holding the plane square to the board with the blade square is great.

But holding the plane square to the board, and using the lateral adjust to take a shaving that's heavier on the high side of the board can also be really useful.

Some days, my sense of straight and square deceives me, and I'm the reason the board is out of square in the first place... or the reason it's out of square towards one end, as I pushed the plane over the side a little bit. Those are the worst. For those of you who are having a hard time gauging whether your plane is straight and square... or worse, whether it's STAYING straight and square, I recommend holding the edges of the plane, and dragging your fingertips along the sides of the board. You'll feel if the plane begins to tip.

Re: jointing techniques

#3

Re: jointing techniques

Marc Luxembourg

>Hi Paul,

I used to joint as is shown on your second scheme. It made sense as I didn't find a good how-to-do-description to do it different.

After a narrow wooden jointer made it up into my regular line-up, I came to the third method.

Interesting is that the woodie gives me a good feedback on the body and so on the iron too. I can easily feel if the body is vertical or otherwise said square to the board's face. This only happens because the wooden plane body is high, a metal version not. The bigger height magnifies the amount a plane is out of vertical. Useless to say that you can feel this with a metal version, but IMO takes a lot of practice .

Going on with daily practice, I'm more and more inclined to follow the slope of the straight blade, as it is a no fuss solution.

That's my two cents,

Marc

Re: jointing techniques

#4

Perfectly Straight

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I once annoyed a fellow on this forum who planed with a "perfectly straight" iron by asking him "How perfect is it?" I have never used a perfect iron. And I suspect that some of the perfect crowd actually have irons more convex than some of the cambered crowd. Concave blades do not work very well.

If one is planing a one inch wide edge with a plane that cuts .001 in the center and tapers to nothing at the edge, one can make an angular adjustment of 0.057 degrees with each pass (arctangent of .001). That is 1/17 of one degree. There are some who claim that they can hold the plane to this angle by feel or by eye as shown in Paul's diagram C. I am skeptical.

Re: jointing techniques

#5

It sounds impossible.......

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Of the hand tool techniques that I would find useful in a shop not eschewing power tools, this is the one that continues to elude me. I can do dovetails that aren't embarrassing, chop mortises, saw straight lines, sharpen, etc. But I have never successfully corrected an out of square edge with a hand plane. For the simple reason that Warren calculated, it would seem impossible to hold a plane sufficiently accurate along the length of a board to accomplish the task. Add to this challenge the awkward ergonomics of a metal plane for maintaining an angular orientation while pushing against the planing resistance and indeed the task seems even more impossible, and continues to be for me. But then I have been told that it should be impossible for bumble bees to fly, yet they figured it out..

.

Re: jointing techniques

#6

Re: It sounds impossible.......

Alex Grigoriev

>I resorted to shooting the edge, to get it square.

For long boards, one could also fashion a kind of vertical shooting board, along the workpiece, though I haven't tried that.

Re: jointing techniques

#7

Dale Lenz

Re: Agreed

Dale Lenz

>

Re: jointing techniques

#8

Re: Perfectly Straight

ThomD

>Warren, you could have a point about perfection, but the degree to which the perfection holds is certainly high enough that it would add to and not detract from the skill required. In other words, if I am trying to correct a gross visible error in an edge using a degree of camber that is invisible, how does that make my job easier? It might make it faster to the extent that there is an added factor reducing the angle by 1/17 of a degree, getting the angle right is not a mater of speed so much as a mater of being able to perceive the endpoint. And I don't see that as being helped by the presence of an imperceptible bias in the blade.

Also your suggestion that all stones are hollow to some extent is not true where people are using stuff like diamond stones, Bill's diamonds on laps, dress their stones a lot, use the whole stone, use replaceable blade planes, etc...

I don't doubt there is some room for what you are describing, just don't personally see it as much room.

"There are some who claim that they can hold the plane to this angle by feel or by eye as shown in Paul's diagram C. I am skeptical."

A few things:

- I don't hold the plane like that. I would have the center of the plane over the contact point, for balance. I would only hold it as he has it pictured if I was trying to produce the slope pictured.

- Everyone is "holding it like that" Whether one is doing the curved blade thing or the flat blade thing, or offsets etc... nothing much is gained by holding the wrong angle. It isn't appropriate only to one method

- These aren't different methods, they are on a partial continuum, where they can be used to some extent at the same time. Part of the effectiveness of the curved blade could just be that it is held off center. A and B aren't even different methods, and there are other methods than those shown I use the method James mentions often also, depending on the plane type.

- Also there is a scale issue. I suspect a lot of us would do C (in my case with plane centered) if that was the real edge angle. That with a coarse setting would be the simplest method to get rid of the material. Ok maybe a drawknife if the grain was straight enough. It's when we get down to the thous that sometimes a different method needs doing. One thing that bugs me about the curved blade method is that it basically works with boards that are < half the width of the blade. The method of grouping boards in the vise works faster and better for that situation, ATMO. What we really need is a method that works automatically for boards wider than a half blade width. There the angled blade could be the solution though several other methods work for planes that don't angle. Of course The curved blade can also be used on wide boards it just turns out to be no better than the other methods on predictability, it can do nicer cuts.

Re: jointing techniques

#9

Re: It sounds impossible.......

ThomD

>As long as you are getting the results you want...

Part of this comes down to the Neanderthal vs. whatever the other thing is, issue. When I used to be able to find the jointer, I would run the boards on that. It was pretty hard to mess that squareness up by hand plane refining. Particularly with a straight blade. But this place tends, at least in ethos, to take an all or nothing approach to hand work, rather than an integrated approach. So...

To me jointing is basically 4 things:

- Get the edge to the ballpark, arguably not part of jointing, but it might look seamless to a passerby. Also can be done on a table saw, power jointer, etc...

- Get the edge square, ok, so in the real world where power jointers and table saws are used; or in the world where boards are planed back to back; or where the edges are so fat they are like face surfaces and balancing the plane isn't necessary; or the parts are so small they get shot; or a tiny error isn't an issue... Gotta be 98% of the situations by now... That said a surprising number of my edges do come out clean to the square. There must be some error, but it is built into all the methods, including most machine methods, so the error presumably is within tolerances. A milling machine does not produce as clean a surface as a shaper, planer, or surface grinder, yet it is a pretty good gold standard...

- Get the right longi camber for edge spring, from zero to whatever. OK, this is determined by the plane/tool without reference to the type of blade used. The accuracy is well under what can be measured without a very large granite slab, for starters. So it is automatic. This is one feature that I prefer hand planes for. Power jointers have this feature but there are problems. It is more difficult to find a sweat spot where the cutter tracks, spring, blade sharpness, and geometry are in the zone. Sharpness for instance is something I can't always control over the lifetime of use between sharpenings.

- Surface smoothness. This can be too good at times, but there the blade or toothing blade is what you want, it should be automatic from the plane. This is another thing I pick up the plane for compared to the power jointer.

So I do see your point Bill, but when it's boxed in it would only be an issue now and again, and I think there are methods that take most of the risk out of it anyway. Of the four stages, one isn't difficult; two are fully jigged; the forth is normally fully jigged, can be nailed with methods, or is actually workmanship of risk. I don't think it is a very high risk though, compared to hand carving?

Re: jointing techniques

#10

Re: It sounds impossible.. but it's actually easy

joel

>for a long time I struggled then one day I finally realized that I could hold a plane square. Then a little practice and that was it. I can now easily plane free hand so that thee is no light worth mentioning under my square, and my joints are slightly hollow so they glue up tight.

It's really a question of practicing and developing hand memory. It's like riding a bicycle. Seems impossible to be balanced on that thing but once you get it - it's nearly impossible to be out of balance.

Re: jointing techniques

#11

Re: jointing techniques

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Paul and all,

Excellent post!

I would like to pose a question of the group, in the interest of clarification:

This is regarding the cambered blade method (graphic B). Isn't this method a 'wandering blade' method? That is, the center of the blade is kept centered on the high line of the board, all the way down the edge. So for example, if the board is 'high right' for the first third of the board, and 'high left' for the second third, then the plane is centered over the right edge for one-third of the board, and then shifted so that the blade is centered over the left edge for the final two-thirds of the board. Correct, or not?

[NOTE: I use the graphic C method with a slightly cambered blade, and bias the pressure of the cut with the thumb of my lead hand--so rather than shift the plane to follow the high line, I shift my thumb pressure to track the high line. My blade is slightly cambered, many would call it straight.]

Wiley

Re: jointing techniques

#12

Re: jointing techniques

ThomD

>I don't quite get your question Wiley? Are you saying it would be bad if the blade wandered or good? The answer is that it would be bad, so the method depends on consistent lateral positioning, as other methods depend on consistent level. True of A and B.

Re: jointing techniques

#13

Re: jointing techniques

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thom,

I'll try again.....I think we could agree that all methods need to keep the blade cutting on the high line, rather than cutting in a low place. That said,

My understanding is that the 'cambered blade method' (graphic B in Paul's post) specifically depends on keeping the plane blade centered on the high line. Now the high line will not always be on one side or the other--the high line may wander. Therefore, the 'cambered blade' method wanders to follow the high line, wherever it goes. Or that is my understanding and now I am asking if that is what you and others understand. Not saying or asking if it is 'good' or 'bad'--do you agree or not agree that the cambered blade method involves keeping the blade centered (more or less) on the high line?

Wiley

Re: jointing techniques

#14

you give me hope... and more information

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>My last attempt might have gone better had the wood not been 8/4 white oak. I'll try some more with a wood that provides less planing resistance so I can concentrate more on the plane orientation and less on pushing it.

My typical need is correcting something off the power jointer. Because of knife wear edges from the jointer aren't guaranteed to be perfect. Not a problem for edge gluing because the board can be flopped edge to edge while jointing a boards for a panel assemble. This technique will cancel out any lack of edge orthogonality (I doubt that is an accepted word). For this reason I get sloppy about keeping the jointer fence perfect. Then when I need to stick a tenon into one of these edges I have a problem that needs to be fixed. It would be nice to have the skill to swish a plane down the edge and correct a 1 degree error(for example).

Thanks for the encouragement and I'll keep trying. I would love to see in person someone do an edge and then watch me try. I expect the result would be, "No dummy, you are approaching it all wrong". That was the result when Alan Batty watched me use a skew to roll beads with my self taught approach. In 5 min using his approach I was making beads with confidence. Damn there is a lot to learn to be able to efficiently make well made stuff.

Re: jointing techniques

#15

Yes

Paul Kierstead

>

Re: jointing techniques

#16

Re: you give me hope... and more information

joel

>1 - hold your plane in planing stance (in air away from wood) wiggle your hand back and forth a few times to try to sense when the plane is vertical. this is easiest with a wooden plane hardest with a bevel up plane. when you can sense the vertical you are most of the way there.

2 - now it gets harder to describe. What I need to do is write a blog entry about this. We need pictures. so I will stop now - but that first step is vital and I bet once you can feel that you are most of the way there.

Re: jointing techniques

#17

Yes, "wandering blade" is correct.

Chris Friesen

>With a cambered jointer blade, the idea is to keep the thickest part of the shaving on the highest part of the board, while letting the plane rest on the existing edge surface. This avoids the necessity of holding the plane square, but instead requires it to be "steered" left to right as you go along the board.

Given that sensing vertical is harder with a bevel-up jointer, it may be useful to try the "wandering blade" technique with that type of plane.

Re: jointing techniques

#18

Re: you give me hope... and more information

wilbur

>I've mentioned this before, but one thing that helps me a lot is to close my eyes when trying to hold a plane level. I'll place the plane on the edge of the board, close my eyes to figure out where level is, and take a stroke.

There's something about taking away your visual cues that seems to make your sense of level that much better.

Re: jointing techniques

#19

The sun came out and the angels sang

Neal in San Jose

>The first time I tried the "wandering blade" technique. O.K., that's a slight exageration - there was only one angel. My edges were straight and square, and I couldn't believe how easy it was. This is now the only method I use, but I understand that there is no "right" way to joint boards any more than there is one "right way" to sharpen, cut mortices or whatever.

Re: jointing techniques

#20

Wide plane, narrow edge

David Cockey

>The cambered blade method requires the plane to be considerably wider than the edge being jointed to work efficiently. I haven't seen this limitation mentioned anywhere.

Re: jointing techniques

#21

You sure?

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Your post make very little sense to me Paul.

It's seems to me that no.1 is going to produce a very pyramid if your not extremely careful. No. 2 going make a great cove molding, again if your not careful. No. 3 is the only approach for someone with little (or a lot for that matter) experience to actually get a square joint relatively quickly.

Although the the one Wiley talks has some interesting merritt to it.

Re: jointing techniques

#22

Re: Wide plane, narrow edge

Paul Kierstead

>I haven't seen this limitation mentioned anywhere.

That is because they are usually too busy listing the other problems and limitations that keep the the technique from working. Unless, of course, you just employ the technique, in which case it seems to work extremely well in the vast majority of cases.

Re: jointing techniques

#23

Re: The sun came out and the angels sang

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Neal,

I would like to ask you a couple of details, if you don't mind telling.....First off, about how much camber do you like to use? I mean, is it in the low thousandths, or something more? Second, as the edge begins to converge on square, do you end up going right down the middle for a final pass? I'm interested in what you're seeing and doing in the last couple of passes.

Final question is whether at some point, you are trying to bring the plane vertical.....Paul's diagram for the cambered blade approach shows the plane sitting on the high edge, with no consideration as to whether the plane is held vertically or not. I understand how that would be done when the edge is quite rough, but as the edge comes into squareness, do you begin to think about holding the plane vertical on the final pass, or no?

Much thanks for whatever you can offer on these,

Wiley

P.S. Also, anyone else's answers on the same questions would be much appreciated!

Re: jointing techniques

#24

To Warren in Lancaster--help!

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>No offense to the others providing useful advice but you seem to build lots of stuff and hence I value advice from this quarter as having passed the test of time and utility, for what ever you do has been optimized and proven through long experience.

Will you:

1.describe what plane you use for making a board edge suitable for gluing.

2. describe as best you can how much camber is on the iron

3.describe how your approach for fixing an edge that is not yet suitable for gluing because it is out of square or what ever. Specifically, do you teeter the plane on the high edge as in diagram C or some other approach?

Re: jointing techniques

#25

Re: The sun came out and the angels sang

Neal in San Jose

>Wiley:

1. Camber. I don't measure it, but it is slight, I'd guess in the 2 to 3 thousands from edge to center range. It is easy to see when the blade is held to a straight edge with a light behind it. I use a steadily decreasing camber in my planes with the scrub being very aggresive, at least 1/16 from edge to center, jack plane less than half that, fore plane maybe .010, then the jointer and smooth both slight but definite.

2. I don't make a pass down the center when everything is square just to make a pass, because that is really the end game. The last squaring pass is from end to end, and I know I'm finished when I make a full width shaving from end to end. I frequently (but not always) take a couple of extra passes in the center to "spring" the joint; more often on pieces that will be the focal point, like table tops, less often on door panels, etc.

3. Holding the plane verticle isn't a huge deal with this method but I do try to approach square. When the edge is square and true, actually as you approach square, the plane will naturally ride squarely on it, reducing the need for operator talent. That is the point of this method - let the stock guide the plane and you don't really have to think about it very much, or be very talented (if I can do it...).

As others have mentioned, I seem to get better, quicker results with my woodie than with a metal plane, but I do keep my old Ohio Tool #8 tuned with a cambered blade and use it about as often as my Doscher woodie.

HTH Neal