Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

jointing techniques

Posts

Re: jointing techniques

#26

Re: Wide plane, narrow edge

Neal in San Jose

>LOL!!! Since most of my edges seem to be in the 3/4 range, and my doscher woodie is 2 1/8 and my Ohio #8 is 2 5/8 wide, that's enough.

Re: jointing techniques

#27

Re: The sun came out and the angels sang

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thanks Neal,

That answers it. I've been doing it the other way for a long time, but think I will try this to compare.

Wiley

Re: jointing techniques

#28

Blind movements

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Did you see that science show on PBS (Scientific American?) with Alan Alda in which he practiced things like putting a golf ball and shooting an arrow? He actually made the shots without looking. It was very interesting. And then there was the show on using different sensory body apparatuses to balance and see, different than the inner ear and eyes. Pretty cool stuff.

Pam

Re: jointing techniques

#29

Re: Blind movements

Sgian Dubh

>My, my, this thread is getting awfy precious. Two thou here, three thou there, pyramid shapes, orthagonality, tan this, arctan that. What's next? Paralellograms and dihedral angles on aeroplane wings?.

I don't generally find creating an edge joint on two planks needs us to get into precision laboratory equipment construction tolerances. We are talking of lumps of wood here. The stuff moves as soon as you open a door and let a cold, moist draught in.

I think I need a drink, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: jointing techniques

#30

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

paul womack

>A and B aren't even different methods,

One produces a step wise approximation to a surface, the other produces a continuous curved surface.

I'd call that different.

BugBear

Re: jointing techniques

#31

Re: that old bee thing

paul womack

>But then I have been told that it should be impossible for bumble bees to fly, yet they figured it out..

The guy who first came up with some laws of aerodynamics was aware that his laws were incomplete.

As evidence of this he pointed out that according to his laws, bumble bees couldn't fly. He knew that they could, so he knew his laws were incomplete.

No scientist ever said anything as damn stupid as "bumble bees can't fly".

BugBear

Re: jointing techniques

#32

Excellent, Paul.

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Paul,

Thanks for the posting.

All three are possible. The hardest is learning to keep the plane dead upright, so I don't use that method, but can do if needed.

The only comment that needs to be made is that, with correct technique, the plane tends to ride on the flat portion of the job behind the blade if possible

I had 20" spare at work today - knocked these images up quickly to show what I mean.

1.



2.



3.


The curved edge indeed has a tendency to follow the previous gutter, overcome by brute strength on the part of the user.

Best regards,

Andrew

Re: jointing techniques

#33

wandering

paul womack

>This is regarding the cambered blade method (graphic B). Isn't this method a 'wandering blade' method? That is, the center of the blade is kept centered on the high line of the board, all the way down the edge. So for example, if the board is 'high right' for the first third of the board, and 'high left' for the second third, then the plane is centered over the right edge for one-third of the board, and then shifted so that the blade is centered over the left edge for the final two-thirds of the board. Correct, or not?


Absolutely. A and B (I should have labelled them) are closely related in how they are applied. The difference is the shape of shaving taken and the surface left behind.

The cambered approach can be (I think) more accurate, because the degree of taper actually varies across the blade (as long as the blade is a good deal wider than the workpiece), so the nicety of the correction can be reduced as you approach truth.

BugBear

Re: jointing techniques

#34

wandering

paul womack

>3. Holding the plane verticle isn't a huge deal with this method but I do try to approach square. When the edge is square and true, actually as you approach square, the plane will naturally ride squarely on it, reducing the need for operator talent. That is the point of this method - let the stock guide the plane and you don't really have to think about it very much, or be very talented (if I can do it...).


Absolutely - this is the point of methods (A) and (B). The plane is always reference to the work surface. The plane ends up square to the board face only because the edge is square to the board face.

It is this use of a concrete reference that allows tiny corrections to be made using hand techniques.

BugBear

Re: jointing techniques

#35

width

paul womack

> The cambered blade method requires the plane to be considerably wider than the edge being jointed to work efficiently. I haven't seen this limitation mentioned anywhere.


That's because this limitation rarely occurs in practice. Even a namby-pamby #7 has a 2 3/8" blade, and that's enough to manage 1" stock nicely.

To be honest, preparing a square surface wider than 1" (e.g. for a bench top glue up) can be addressed by surface planing techniques.

BugBear

Re: jointing techniques

#36

camber method

paul womack

>Very nice Andrew.

I take issue with your sequence for the cambered blade (seq 2)

The plane should be canted just like seq 1, since the technique sits the plane firly on the edge. This shaving will reduce the angular error of the edge. In the second shot the plane body continues to be registered on the edge, so the angle of the plane will be closer to square. In the final shot, the plane should sit centrally on the (slightly concave) "square" edge.

BugBear

Re: jointing techniques

#37

Yes, you're right. I'll fix that. Cheers,

Andrew F in Australia

>

Re: jointing techniques

#38

Fixed

Andrew F in Australia

>

Re: jointing techniques

#39

Ellis Walentine

FWIW

Ellis Walentine

>My approach is to hold the plane vertical, with my left fingertips wrapped under the sole to reference on the face of the board. From there, it's all about sensing whether the plane is square to the edge as I plane. I keep a little square handy and use it along the length of the board to see if there are any areas that are out of square worse than others. If so, I take a few swats in those areas to correct things, taking longer passes each time to average out the squareness. My final passes are with a very tiny shaving, full width and full length, again checking along the edge for square.

I'm intrigued, though, with these methods you've suggested. I'll give them a try and see if I have anything to add. Thanks for a good discussion.

Ellis

Re: jointing techniques

#40

Agree

roninkokomo

>I find it easier to do than rip to a line.

Re: jointing techniques

#41

Re: To Warren in Lancaster--help!

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I use a Record #7 plane that I bought new in 1983. At that time there were not a lot of options. The sole has never been adjusted, but I would work on it if there were performance issues. The iron has never seen a grinder. I use a wooden trying plane for face work because it is lighter and less tiring, but a jointer is only used for short periods. I am a little fussier with the jointer depth of cut, so I prefer the Bailey mechanism, but I might enjoy a wooden jointer as well.

I rarely flatten my stones. I sharpen in a way that concentrates the wear on the outer portions of the stones to avoid dishing the stone and on the center portion of the iron to reduce camber. If you sharpen right down the center of the stone you will get dishing and too much camber. I like the iron to have enough camber so that it takes a very thin shaving roughly .001 at the center tapering to nothing at the edge. So I adjust the camber by the way I sharpen over time.

To make angular adjustments on an edge I center the plane on the high side and let the differential depth of cut effect the adjustment. "Wandering" around seeking out high spots is a little misleading. Usually there is one of three problems: one side higher or one corner high or opposite corners high, in which case the planing is diagonal. All this stuff takes a lot less time and thought with experience. It is a lot easier than learning to throw a football or baseball.

Re: jointing techniques

#42

Re: wandering

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>"Absolutely - this is the point of methods (A) and (B). The plane is always reference to the work surface. The plane ends up square to the board face only because the edge is square to the board face."

The interesting thing about Paul's insight (and Neal's identical insight)--is that camber appears to have nothing to do with it. Having a method to track the high line is what produces the result you describe, and that could be done as well with a straight-bladed plane. It is a method of successive approximation, using a reference square and eye until you converge to the edge you want.

Wiley

Re: jointing techniques

#43

Re: jointing techniques

Ace Karner

>I use two different approaches. If the edge is grossly out of square I use a #5 with a cambered iron. When the edge is barely out I use a HNT Gordon joiner, it has the Chinese style handles which I find makes it intuitive to keeping the plane horizontal. After just a few months of using it I find that I can get the edge right almost every time.

Re: jointing techniques

#44

you make it sound easy.......

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I need to have another go at this capability, this time not on 6/4 oak.

Thanks to all for the encouragement.

Re: jointing techniques

#45

damn!

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>After the encouraging words of Joel and Warren I was ready to renew the quest with optimism. Then you say "After just a few months of using it I find that I can get the edge right ***almost*** every time. "

Never-the-less I am going to try again

Re: jointing techniques

#46

I think you've got it!

rononkokomo

>

Re: jointing techniques

#47

Re: Blind movements

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Richard, I was responding to Wilbur, to encourage him in trying new things. Better than discouraging with criticism. No?

Also, the two shows I mentioned were fascinating, something I thought Wilbur might enjoy. Not at all intended for those less sensitive to the myriad of ways woodworking can be practiced and enjoyed.

And I tell you, as one who's fighting like mad to keep her teeth, hair, and balance as she ages, you can bet that I'll continue to take note of the science in this area.

Pam

Re: jointing techniques

#48

Re: Blind movements

wilbur

>I think the series you're talking about is Scientific American Frontiers. I found the show's webpage on the PBS website. I couldn't figure out exactly which episodes corresponded with the golf ball/arrow and the different sensory apparatuses, though.

Re: jointing techniques

#49

Re: Blind movements

Sgian Dubh

>Pam I was making some wry tongue-in-cheek commentary in general. I wasn't aware I was responding to something you had said. Maybe it's the way I have the listing set up to display, but I don't see any threaded lists that would really indicate who is responding to whom. Nor is there anything definite in any message I read to indicate which message it is a response to; sometimes the title of a message gives me a clue, but not very often. I only know you responded to my contribution because you used my name; but for that I would not have realised your response was to me. When I open up a topic what I see is every message in full, and all the messages seem to be in a random order.

I guess that's as clear as, er, well, mud, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: jointing techniques

#50

Re: you give me hope... and more information

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Wiley,

I used to pitch horseshoe tournaments. To be good at throwing consistant ringers, it is best to not watch the shoe as you toss it. It's all done with balance, stance, proper swing, rythem, follow through, and how the shoe is held and released. There are other factors, such as practice, but basically, what you refer to is what it takes to throw a ringer.

Marv