Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

Posts

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#51

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

Charles

>John, I'm not the book police. I'm just offering a viewpoint on Moxon that's a little bit less than the rah-rah everybody seems to have gotten used to.

I don't dislkike Chris. I think Chris is valuable to the community for lots of reasons other than his book on Moxon. Chris never struck me as the kind of guy who needed to surround himself with hangers on who think he can do no wrong or worship every word that springs forth from his mouth or pen. To me, forums are at their worst when the 'regulars' circle the wagons when somebody offers a contrary viewpoint on a topic of interest. Insularity, of any kind. does not advance anybody's knowledge.

I'm going to buy his book. While I've read Moxon and wasn't bowled over like some, I'll give Chris's little tome a shot and see if perhaps there was a gem in the original that I overlooked.

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#52

Re: Waveform Moldings

Kevin Adams

>Pam--

I don't know if you'll agree or not, but I find the work of Michael Cullen to be somewhat similar and I like that he does it all by hand with a few simple carving tools. I think the irregularity of handwork, combined with the wonderful texture, makes for a beautiful surface. Not for everyone I understand (the design, color, etc.) and certainly not the "traditional" that we often see on this and other hand tool forums, but I find it fascinating--somehow both ancient and new. And for the traditionalists among us, he does use milk paint!

http://michaelcullendesign.com/index.php

http://www.knowth.com/newgrange.htm

I would be interested in any thoughts. Thanks.

Kevin

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#53

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

John Hoffman

>Hey Charles,

I was commenting on the book not the forum. As you have the right to state your opinion others have the same right to state thier's even if it is in support of a person. I have a feeling you are one of these guys that likes to stir the pot and has a smile when you type.

Regards

John

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#54

Re: Waveform Moldings

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Thanks, Kevin, Cullen certainly works real hard at producing those pieces. My second thought is how do you put a glass on such a table and what happens when the moisture starts following the cracks? Third thought is do you think/know that Cullen is Irish?

But they are truly beautiful, especially that Elephant Chest, what a work, reminds me of the Ecstasy of St. Theresa. I also very much enjoy the Girl Cabinet, really whimsical and extremely well done (I've long seen the apron bottom carvings (shells and the like) as masculine/feminine).

Pam

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#55

Thanks another interesting word to

Victor Parisian

>toss out at the club.

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#56

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

Charles

>Not a pot stirrer, but not a lemming either.....

When everybody's cheerleading I usually squint and take a closer look.

Try it sometime.