Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

Posts

I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#1

I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Interesting book. I'm not sure it's a must-have, and I doubt my sons/grandchildren will be fighting over who gets it, but I'm not unhappy to have purchased it. As a pretty much self-taught woodworker with a long-standing but not historically pure interest in hand tools, I found his commentary a nice if sometimes sketchy adjunct to the text. I have, over the years, read a little bit of Moxon, but much of it went right past me; with Chris along, I was able to delve a little more deeply into the text.

It becomes clear that Moxon was, indeed, writing about joiners and just joiners; and, in that context, how specialized the trade was. I was surprised at the paucity of joints listed - but, in the era, they may well have been enough for joiners.

In one paragraph that Chris politely refrains from commenting on, discussing the rule, Moxon says, "They {rules} commonly have both board and timber measures (and the like) marked upon them for finding...the...content of board or timber. The use of [these] lines and tables have been often taught by others, and being more mathematical than mechanical, [it] is un-proper for me to meddle with in this place but rather to refer to those books."

Um, yeah. Cynic than I am, I read behind these comments, "I gotta tell ya, I read those books on how to calculate board feet from the tables, and I am SO confused. No way can I explain that stuff."

The discussion on saws was interesting, too. I had to go back and re-read the section on setting saws, in which, at one point, he mentions that a pitsaw may be set to generate a 1/4" kerf - that's chainsaw territory, and the sawyers must have worked up a powerful thirst cutting lumber from logs with a kerf that wide. He discusses variations in saw set based on the type and condition of wood being cut, but seems to suggest just one tooth pattern, which sounds like a rip pattern.

Comment on the book itself: a good decision to use buckram binding and gold title and cover. It fits well with the historical nature of the text.

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#2

"poerful thirst," and pit sawyers...

James Watriss

>I read a book one that was written by a second generation wagon builder, who talked a bit about how it was to deal with the sawyers. His descriptions were pretty vivid. He said that half of the time, one or the other would show up late, thus preventing the other one from getting any work done, and they would storm off, and wind up down at the tavern. Then when the second arrived, he'd head down to the tavern to go look for the first one, and the two would be gone for the day. Or, One would get mad at the other partway through the day, and head down to the tavern to cool his head, so to speak, and so forth.

The author did say that when they were at work, they worked very hard, and got a lot done, but that in general, between the nature of the work, and the knowledge that theirs was a dying trade, (due to the advent of sawmills) that they were a generally surly lot. Hard working, when they were working, and very good at what they did. But Surly. They were pretty much indispensable, but he said he was also always glad to see them leave.

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#3

Ire' a tought life eh!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Robbin' to drink with Paul, George and Ringo...

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#4

Scott...you

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>spelt that wrong....it's spelt "tuff"

Marv

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#5

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

Charles

>Why would Schwartz "politely refrain" from commenting on any sections of the book?

Sounds like Schwartz penned a hagiography. Who needs that? I fail to understand the love affair some have with the Moxon volume.

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#6

hagiography

Christopher Schwarz

>Normally, I let stuff like this slide.

But you know, if you haven't read my "hagiography," then you don't know what you're talking about.

I'll take the spanking from people who have read it (Stephen, Bill), but I certainly don't think I hold Moxon up for religious praise. Anyone who reads it that way missed my point.

My point? Ah. First book on woodworking. Kinda interesting because of that.

Going back into my hole. Carry on.

Chris

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#7

Re: hagiography

Kevin Adams

>Well my good Catholic upbringing and I still had to look that one up...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hagiography

Chris, hope you are resting comfortably in one of your stick chairs with a nice cold one (or warm one if it's as cold there as it is in New England tonight). Take care and keep up the good work.

Kevin

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#8

Concur

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Chris does not sanctify Moxon - in fact, points out his frequent discrepancies between text and illustrations. I particularly like Chris' comment on Moxon's discussion of moulding planes: "I think that a Delta Machinery manual for a drill press might say more about moulding planes than Moxon does."

Chris does cheat at times, in my opinion, wandering from commentary on Moxon's text to offer prescriptive advice about subjects on which Moxon is kinda vague.

Still an interesting book.

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#9

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hello Charles,

This is not to challenge you, just to set the record straight. Chris did not write a hagiography. I had to look the word up: Definition: A biography idealizing its subject.

In fact, it is a strength of Chris' book that he is specific in pointing out inconsistencies and omissions in Moxon's text, as well as a variance or two from what is considered correct practice today. He does this in a matter of fact way, not a carping or fault-finding way.

Now I am one who has a 'love affair' with the Moxon book, and that may show in the review I wrote. I have a love affair with our English-language literary tradition. Moxon is not Shakespeare or Chaucer or the Beowulf poet. But Moxon did something circa 1670-1700 that no other English writer had done to that time: He made it his business to record the trade practices of various trades, as best he could follow what he was told, and what he observed. And he published it. It's the first such English language text.

A book like Moxon's, or Pepys' Diary, or Boswell's Life of Johnson, is like living in a long room, such that you can walk back a few rooms, and look out the window onto a portion of the 17th or 18th century, and see where we came from, and what our ancestors did.

But that's my take, not Chris's. Chris is unsentimental and objective about Moxon. He has done us a good service, because a Praeger or EAIA copy of Moxon is usually going to cost in the ballpark of $100. Chris' book is $17.

It would be interesting to hear your own take on Moxon, since it sounds like you're perfectly familiar with the book.

Wiley

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#10

Marz...Guess I can't get nuthin wright eh

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#11

Re: hagiography

Charles

>Chris, if you're going to write you'd better get used to the idea that people will listen to other people's review and impression of what you've written.

Have you ever read a book review in the New York times? Reviews on Amazon?

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#12

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

Charles

>Yep, I've read Moxon and like I said in my first post in this thread I've never understood the hoopla surrounding the book.

I tend to read with a cool detachment and have never warmed up to Mr. Moxon. The gates of heaven did not open up nor was the information in his book transformative for my own woodworking.

Clearly, other people's mileage has varied on this.

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#13

Re: hagiography

Christopher Schwarz

>Charles,

You know I have read book reviews. Is what you wrote a book review?

Like I said above, I'm happy to receive criticism from people who have read the book. I don't think I'm above it. And I'm always happy to refund anyone's money who bought the book.

Keep swinging for the fence!

Chris

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#14

Re: hagiography

charles

>Have you ever wondered why the Times publishes reviews and why people read book reviews?

I'm happy to admit my bias. I've read Moxon and never understood what all the fuss was about (beyond "it's all we've got"). The likelihood that I would enjoy your commentary on Moxon is remote. That said, I'm reading the informal reviews of your book on the woodworking boards. Who knows, I might change my mind.

And just so you know, I don't read books and ask for a refund of my money if I happen not to like them.

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#15

Re: hagiography

Paul Kierstead

>You missing the point. You criticized the book *without* reading it. That isn't a book review.

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#16

Re: hagiography

charles

>Yep, I sure did. I made the comment "it sounds like...." based on somebody else's review.

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#17

Re: hagiography

Christopher Schwarz

>Hilarious!

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#18

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

Dan Donaldson

>There are a lot of books that show processes or techniques that are very different from what we do today. To me, the thing about a book like this is that it tells what they were doing (at least as far as he could tell) at the time, whether right or wrong, or whether it gives you any insights into what you do today. That really doesn't matter in the scheme of things. To many, it is interesting how people did things in the past, not necessarily as a guide to how they should do it now. It may not be your intention, but from what you have written here it appears to me that you do not care at all about history unless it can apply to you today, which is fine. But others appreciate things just for the history and perhaps for no other reason, which is also fine.

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#19

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

Greg B�tit, Crown Point, NY.

>Well, I'm not so sure that's what he was doing in the section on rules. There are comments that question whether Moxon really understood exactly what he was reporting on in other sections, the fact that he let's Moxon slide on this topic to me is not that big a deal. Get the book, or borrow a copy first, you'll end up getting the book anyway.

greg

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#20

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

Greg B�tit, Crown Point, NY.

>Woops, I didn't realize there was a "controversy" when I made that original post.

I'm an 18th Century History buff, and am especially interested in 18th Century woodworking. I'm also a hand tool woodworking hobbiest. To me it is obvious that a huge body of knowledge about the "arts and mysteries" of wood working back in the day has been lost.

Moxon is a piece of the puzzle. Recognizing that Moxon himself never made a living doing what he was describing, Mr. Schwarz has added commentary that also gives us the benefit of his own search for this lost woodworking knowledge. No one knows for sure how they cranked out that wonderful furniture with such clumsy tools, but this book is a major milestone in the re-discovery process. IMHO.

greg

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#21

I was teasing El Schwarz a little, Greg

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#22

my workshop

paul womack

>I've read Moxon and never understood what all the fuss was about (beyond "it's all we've got").

I feel the latter is rather the point.

BugBear

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#23

Re: hagiography

Charles

>What, specifically, has Moxon done for your woodworking?

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#24

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

Charles

>It's really become a sacred cow that one dare not say anything derogatory about. A trained historian would have no problem saying "well, this is all we've got but unfortunately it ain't much." The "it ain't much" part is what gets backs arching on the woodworking boards. Well, it ain't much. I suspect that there are a lot of people who agree, who found it a total yawner, but wouldn't dare risk their 'forum cred' by saying so. The book doesn't deserve the frequency of its invoking nor the beatification of late.

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

#25

Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon

Paul Kierstead

>BS. This is a complete straw man argument. You continue to pound on the point that people are deifying Moxon, but there is no such thing occurring. Sure, when people get into an argument about how it was done historically they bring up Moxon (and that is one of the oldest historical points we have) but people continue to quote and reference a very wide variety of authors. Not to mention mostly make random assertions without reference, a fine internet tradition.

Your perception of general forum leanings and predisposition against an author is no excuse for slagging a book you haven't even picked up, let along read.