I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>Interesting book. I'm not sure it's a must-have, and I doubt my sons/grandchildren will be fighting over who gets it, but I'm not unhappy to have purchased it. As a pretty much self-taught woodworker with a long-standing but not historically pure interest in hand tools, I found his commentary a nice if sometimes sketchy adjunct to the text. I have, over the years, read a little bit of Moxon, but much of it went right past me; with Chris along, I was able to delve a little more deeply into the text.
It becomes clear that Moxon was, indeed, writing about joiners and just joiners; and, in that context, how specialized the trade was. I was surprised at the paucity of joints listed - but, in the era, they may well have been enough for joiners.
In one paragraph that Chris politely refrains from commenting on, discussing the rule, Moxon says, "They {rules} commonly have both board and timber measures (and the like) marked upon them for finding...the...content of board or timber. The use of [these] lines and tables have been often taught by others, and being more mathematical than mechanical, [it] is un-proper for me to meddle with in this place but rather to refer to those books."
Um, yeah. Cynic than I am, I read behind these comments, "I gotta tell ya, I read those books on how to calculate board feet from the tables, and I am SO confused. No way can I explain that stuff."
The discussion on saws was interesting, too. I had to go back and re-read the section on setting saws, in which, at one point, he mentions that a pitsaw may be set to generate a 1/4" kerf - that's chainsaw territory, and the sawyers must have worked up a powerful thirst cutting lumber from logs with a kerf that wide. He discusses variations in saw set based on the type and condition of wood being cut, but seems to suggest just one tooth pattern, which sounds like a rip pattern.
Comment on the book itself: a good decision to use buckram binding and gold title and cover. It fits well with the historical nature of the text.



