Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon
Charles
>Paul, I think you're wrong.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon
Charles
>Paul, I think you're wrong.
Re: hagiography
Christopher Schwarz
>OK, I'll bite. Here are a *few*:
Moxon's writing on the fore plane was useful to me. After reading Moxon, I was more inclined to use a fore plane for more operations and to use it for traversing more often.
I found his description of honing with the stone in your left hand to be useful. Also, his description of planing miters freehand was liberating. I'm more inclined to do both those operations freehand now.
I find any description of mortise-and-tenon work to be valuable. Even though I don't like the way he marks out mortises, I think understanding other processes helps me with mine.
I use dividers a lot more thanks to Moxon. The way he uses them in layout and marking was quite helpful in my work.
I'm more inclined to make my own wooden squares like the ones he describes in Section 15. That will be one of my next projects (as soon as I get my face vise upgraded).
Even his description of the waving engine was useful. I've been researching waveform mouldings as a result.
There are more, but I've got some gerunds to wrangle.
Chris
Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon
Charles
>I also have to ask, was there ever a moment while you were reading it that your brain came up for oxygen long enough to realize the book wasn't all "about that"? Did you like it because you were supposed to - because your favorite pundits, publishers, and tool purveyors said they do (and invoked it often,,,, "well, Moxon this and Moxon that")? Were they themselves scared to admit they didn't see what the fuss was about.
Re: hagiography
Charles
>You use a foreplane more often now and you're going to make a wooden square.
OK.
Re: hagiography
Charles
>FWIW, there's a better ripple moulding article in an old Fine Woodworking (from the B&W days) if you decide to get into that.
Re: hagiography
Charles
>Dividers?
Check out Alan Peters' writings. Again, better stuff.
Re: hagiography
Christopher Schwarz
>No. I said here are a *few*.
Re: hagiography
Christopher Schwarz
>Actually, a better waving engine article is here:
aic.stanford.edu/sg/wag/2002/WAG_02_thornton.pdf
Re: hagiography
Christopher Schwarz
>Also unavailable. (Until May 1).
Re: hagiography
Charles
>Not available? Old Fine Woodworking articles.....
Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon
Paul Kierstead
>Did I say I liked it? I missed that part.
Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon
Paul Kierstead
>I also have to add, you clearly missed the point completely and thoroughly. I have not at all defended the book here, I have just attacked your argument as baseless,biased and unjustified. Again you employ the straw man; defending against an argument that was not made.
Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon
Charles
>Paul, the argument is made by the frequent invoking of Moxon, the writing of a book of commentary on Moxon, dressing up like Moxon, etc. etc.
A straw man argument has not been made, unless you want me to point to a specific post where somebody overtly says that Moxon is their hero, that nothing written after Moxon is worth spit, etc. Of course nobody is that overt, but the fact that we are even discussing the bleeding thing halfway proves my point and the rest of the proof is but a quick forum search away on the string "Moxon."
There's little if anything covered in Moxon not done better by other writers.
Alan Peters' book *LINK*
Christopher Schwarz
>I was referring to "Cabinetmaking: The Professional Approach" which will be available from Linden this spring. It should be available in the U.K. soon I am told.
Alan Peters book
Re: hagiography
Charles
>I take it you're a fan....
Re: Alan Peters' book
Charles
>I'll definitely buy it and I do appreciate the link.
In the meantime, you can read an article on drawer fitting and dovetailing he did in FW where he wielded dividers quite nicely and shows in almost excruciating detail how he uses them for dovetail spacing. Sorry, I don't have the link and issue reference but I can remember the picture of him in the article truing up drawer stock with his trusty Record No. 7. A thorough Brit.
Waveform Moldings
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>So far I've only looked at the pictures and read the captions, but that last photo of examples is most impressive. It should be the first photo.
Pam
Re: hagiography
Christopher Schwarz
>I was waiting here at lunch for you to spring your trap. Bravo!
I find Moxon interesting: useful in parts, useless in others, inspiring at times, frustrating in others. Clear on some points. Obscure in others.
I think what's important to remember is that the first time anything is written down it is likely to be less refined than future works.
Chris
Re: Waveform Moldings *LINK*
Christopher Schwarz
>Pam,
You can see another good example of "ripple" moulding on this page. Click on the frame and you get a good look.
Re: I just read the Schwarz commentary on Moxon
John Hoffman
>Charles,
This book is worth printing. It is the first book on the subject and to many of us interested in period techniques it is a valuable resource. You don't have to like the techniques or think they were the end all to apreciate the value of the text. Secondly since the book is out of print and we think it is worth making available to people so they can get the parts of Moxon that apply to woodworking. To add value to the text, Chris described in clear English the techniques Moxon describes and comments on the described techniques. You don't have to like Moxon or read Moxon to agree that the text is worth having in the community.
John H
I think there's another benefit to the early texts
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>which is to re-affirm how much can be done with how few tools.
There's a tendency in the modern affluent world (not by any means everywhere on this earth) to think that you need 18 saws, 25 chisels, 150 planes, etc. (or, for the power tool folks, similar "must have" lists - see next paragraph) to do anything of value. Texts like Moxon can remind us that a lot can be done with a little.
There was a recent thread on another forum, in the "general woodworking" portion, from a young man who seems to be just barely starting out, planning to build a kitchen as his first big project, and asking whether his proposed tool list was adequate. He listed probably $8,000-10,000 of tools (VERY light, almost non-existent, on hand tools, but that's a digression from my point here), like someone who'd just won the lottery and was equipping his lifetime shop. Several of us commented gently that his proposed list might be overkill.
I have way more tools than I need, mostly from rust-hunting; and it's good to be reminded that I could probably cut my kit down to 20 tools and still do serviceable work.
Hey Chris, question about Moxon
Kevin Adams
>Not to interrupt our program in progress, but I've had a rather serious question to ask you ever since I got my copy of your book:
Is that my old Marples jack plane on page 21? I think I recognize that decal. If it is, did you ever get it to work? That may be the only time one of my tools shows up in a book, especially a religious journal like this one.
Now, back to our regularly scheduled program...
Take care,
Kevin
Re: Waveform Moldings
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>Thanks, Chris, truly beautiful frame (don't like the second one so much, just too, too...). Will you do something in PopWW around these jigs/machines?
Pam
Re: Hey Chris, question about Moxon
Christopher Schwarz
>Kevin,
It is *indeed* your plane that appears in that photo.
And now you shall ascend into blah blah to deliver us from tear-out. For thine is the escapement and the chipbreaker for the strike button for wedge and for abuttment, ever and ever. Aw-heck.
Chris
Is this patter a Rick Moody influence?
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>