Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

Posts

Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#1

Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Hi, all -

Been working on a clock, and I'm getting close to finishing. I'd originally planned on a cherry-ish dye stain and a topcoat over it, but it looks like this old wood (which hung as rough paneling in my inlaws' living room for almost 30 years) is absorbing the dye differentially (didn't think dye stain would do that).

I found this page about "aging" pine, but when I tried it with some, um, home-brew brown wax, I got very disappointing results.

Anyone have a favorite finish for pine? I'm looking for something maybe not fool-proof, but definitely idiot-resistant.

Thanks,

Scott


img

Aging Pine

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#2

Jeff Jewitt... *LINK*

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>has a nice Pine finish in his book. I tried to find it on his website's forum, but I see the forum is down for maintenance. Sorry.

Anyway, gel stains work better on Pine.

Best, Ted


Jeff Jewitt's web site

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#3

Re: Finish for old knotty pine?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Scott,

My favorite finish for pine is to paint and grain it to look like other woods like mahogany or white oak.

But if you are going for a finish on pine so the grain shows, start with a coat of Boiled Linseed Oil and Turpentine (50/50), make sure to get a good coat on the end grain. Then add pigment, I use dry powdered pigments, to the oil mix and apply it to the oil wet pine. This process helps prevent too much stain uptake on the end grain.

To make the pine look old I will use two stains and it is one of the only ways to get that old look. Wood will change either yellow or red when it ages, so the first coat is either red or yellow. After that dries then I add a brown stain (burnt umber, blo/turps) over the top after the base color has dried for 24 hours.

It is better to work up to the color by using several lighter colored coats rather than trying to get the color all at once.

Stephen

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#4

How do you take your tea?

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Well, I've tried dye stain, colored wax over caustic-treated wood, gel stain, shellac, gel stain over shellac, all to no avail. BLO and powdered pigments sounds way too finicky for me. I read somewhere that you can brew up some strong tea and paint it on the pine to add some tannins to the wood, then brush on ammonia to effectively fume it, giving it an aged brown look.

I be brewin' now. Will post results...

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#5

Results of Tea Staining...

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Ok, here ya go:

Pine, Tea+Ammonia, Tea, Raw, no topcoat


Pine, Tea+Ammonia, Tea, Raw, One coat 2# shellac


The tea is some cheap stuff I bought. Twelve bags in a cup of boiling water. It gives a nice mellow honey-pine color, but the effect is somewhat minimized with the Bullseye shellac - the shellac coat is not far off from the tea alone when topcoated. The brown of the ammonia-washed tea is a little green, but the shellac fades that, too.

I need to pass this by the wife, but I think one of these two will work on the clock...

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#6

Dang it! I can't see the pics..

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>So your back in the shop eh homeboy?

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#7

Why not?!

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Here's one o' 'em, attached as per normal. See if'n 'at he'ps yas...

Yeah, back in the shop. Lots to do before school starts up again. Finish the clock for the inlaws at the top of the list.

And you?


img

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#8

Probably the dang filters here at work...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#9

Re: Probably the dang filters here at work...

Victor Parisian

>Scott has a job? What?

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#10

Maple stain

roninkokomo

>There is a well known brand of stain that is sold in paint stores

Comes in yellow can with black and read print.Can't remember the name of the brand due to creeping senility. The shade that I suggest is their Maple.

I really think it would be something for you to look at. I have used in in similar circs and I really like it.

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#11

Minwax?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>I had to look it up, too. CRS.

Wiley

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#12

Re: Minwax?

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>I like Minwax puritan pine. It's pretty oily stuff and alone makes a decent finish. The EWP walls in my shop are finished with that. I've also used it as a base to apply milk paint "glazes" over.

My nicholson bench is finished with walnut hull dye, which alone looks pretty bad- pretty gray. But I applied BLO over it to warm it up a little. It also lightened it some. Or so it seems.

I too really stink at finishing, Scott. I think like anything else, we just need to practice it until we find methods and materials we like.

Adam

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#13

I've heard of coffee filters

Bill Houghton, getting sunny in Sebastopol, CA

>but tea filters? You work for a strange company, Scott.

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#14

Yep! One with a bit of job security I hope...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>After 25 years of bouncing around the consumer market, now it's nice to work for a gov. defense contractor.

It's better I'm not designing things that take life's as well...

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#15

Their Spam filters...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Some of us have to watch our weight:^)

At least the coffee is Starbucks. Not my favorite, but hey we're drifting OT at this point.

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#16

Cold rolled steel?

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#17

Bad for your teeth too...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Heck Scott, remake it in cherry. I know you don't stain or die wood, wadda ya gettin yourself into!?!

How's about milk paint?

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#18

Here I Go Again

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>I think if you used a good mix of buttonlac shellac, you'd be quite pleased with the effect. No stain, no dye, no tea, no ammonia, just a dark shellac.

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#19

Re: Here I Go Again

John Pappas

>Patrick, I agree. Since I became aware of the "grain reversal" that occurs when pine is stained, I have not used stain on pine. I also like the look that pine takes on naturally over time. Patience required. Or, apply a coat of shellac or varnish and then use a glaze to add some color, then another coat of varnish or shellac.

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#20

Re: Here I Go Again

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I also agree. Your clock has a beautiful color. Why cover it up or change it? I suppose you could speed up the aging process with UV lights.

Pam

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#21

Re: Finish for old knotty pine?

David

>An old friend who is far more experienced than I likes to use shoe polish to age projects. The stuff I've seen looks good. Just make sure it's softened a bit first.

The floors in part of my house are Larch, aka Tamarack, which is in the pine family. When I redid them this time around, I used Hydrocote poly with a wee bit of their tint in the first coat, nothing in subsequent coats. They had that mellow aged look from the start and matched the 185 year old ash floors in the rest of the house. Just an idea, maybe.

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#22

The Larch, The Larch...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I love Monty Python when I can understand them;^)

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#23

Any problem with...

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>...using shellac with wax in it as a finish? I can only get Zinsser Bulls Eye amber shellac here (as opposed to Seal Coat). I don't think there'd be a problem, as I won't be topcoating over the shellac, but I've never used the stuff with wax in it 'afore.

Thanks for the help.

Scott

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#24

Re: Any problem with...

Chris Friesen

>If you're not topcoating with something else, the wax isn't really an factor. I _think_ it makes it slightly less water-resistant, but that's a minor issue.

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#25

Re: Any problem with...

Tony Zaffuto

>Surely in your part of PA you have a Lowes? The local Lowes (DuBois, PA) carries the Zinser Seal Coat shellac. If one has it, the other can get it, and in usually a day.

T.Z.