Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

Posts

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#26

Re: Any problem with...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>Since the next thing I do after shellac is wax, I don't think you'd have any problem. There's a can of Zinsser Clear Waxed Shellac on my bench now. Used it last on a set of maple and cherry shelves for my wife's workroom, and for the kids' Christmas toy trains I'm building.

It's what your grandfather would have used.

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#27

Thanks, guys!

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>The test piece looks wonderful, and got wife approval! I'm almost ready to start applying...

Scott

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#28

No Chris, I believe there is some misinformation

Patrick Gibbons

>Shellac with wax is more resistant to moisture. It makes sense if you think about it. Wax repels moisture. Taking it out does not make the mixture more water resistant.

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#29

Re: No Chris, I believe there is some misinformati

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Patrick,

If it's important to you, search a string on Google like 'shellac water resistance', and you will find it to be common knowledge that dewaxed is more water resistant. Jeff Jewitt says it's because the wax makes for a shorter chain resin molecule, but goes no further into the chemistry than that.

Incidentally, we all know that shellac is famous for getting a white mark from actual water contact, e.g., a sweating glass set down on it. However, for retarding seasonal wood movement due to moisture changes, shellac scores very highly in US Forest Products testing.

Wiley

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#30

White marks on shellac

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I have used shellac for many years, but have never tried dewaxed shellac. Since 1986 I have had a table in my kitchen with nothing on the top but shellac. With children growing up during that time, there have been plenty of drinks and spills on it, but no white marks.

Last evening I got a sample from the shop with shellac on it and put a teaspoon of water on it. I leveled it up so the water would stay put. When I got up this morning, there was just a little water left so evaporation took about ten hours. What must one do to get white marks?

I don't think anyone with a reasonable amount of experience would discourage Scott from using shellac on his clock.

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#31

Shellac

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Just an update - here's the bonnet sans door with about four coats of amber Zinsser Bulls Eye. Needs to be rubbed out, and my brushing technique needs a bunch of work, but I'm happy with how it's coming.

Thanks again for the help.

Scott


img

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#32

Re: White marks on shellac

Alexander Grigoriev

>I'm afraid you were too cheap. Go ahead, spill some champaign, wine, or, if you still feel cheap, some beer, and put a glass on the spill.

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#33

Discourage? Far from it

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Warren,

I am a big fan of shellac, and applaud its use on the clock. The clock speaks for itself--it's magnificent with the shellac.

Patrick and I were simply having a difference as to whether dewaxed or waxed is more water resistant. I'm relying on Jeff Jewitt in this regard, who has run tests, whereas I have not. Jewitt's test (which I can't locate right now, but am still looking) indicated that both the waxed and dewaxed were considerably tougher shells than they are often given credit for.

Regarding shellac versus water. I was trying to distinguish between shellac's reaction to a glass placed on it to sweat and make a ring, as opposed to shellac's resistance to moisture in the air, which is very high. The moisture example--where shellac scores high--is more relevant to the clock and to most projects, other than coffee or dining tables. Your observation is that shellac doesn't get white rings easily. My experience is that I'm looking a white ring in front of me. I don't argue with peoples' experience. There is always an explanation for anecdotal differences, though we may never know the reasons.

Again, I am very positive about shellac, and have no problem with people taking their own chances with white rings, and making their own choices as to dewaxed versus waxed, for their own reasons. The published evidence is that dewaxed is more water resistant, and is clearer. I haven't tried it both ways, and others may bring out reasons for using waxed which outweigh water resistance and clarity.

Wiley

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#34

Reinforcing Warren's observation re water

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi all,

Found one of the Jeff Jewitt references I have been searching for. This one is the book Hand Applied Finishes. On pp. 94-95, he presents a series of simple tests, which compare the resistance of dewaxed shellac, water-based lacquer, and solvent lacquer to various substances and scratching procedures.

Let me start with water, since Warren called me on that one. Jewitt tested cold water by placing three ice cubes on the finish and letting it sit overnight (12 hours). All three finishes 'passed'--no visible damage. He then tried 150F water, poured on the panel and a coffee mug placed in the middle of the hot water for 5 minutes. Results: All three panels passed with no visible damage. When boiling water at 212F was used with the coffee mug, the shellac failed, but both lacquers passed. Moral 1: Don't pour boiling water on shellac. Moral 2: Listen to Warren.

Now for alcohol. Jeff used a series of dilutions. 10% alcohol, simulating wine; then 50% and 100% alcohol. Ethyl alcohol placed on the finish for 5 minutes. Results: All three finishes passed the 10% alcohol test, no damage noted. At 50% alcohol, shellac failed, as did water-based lacquer; solvent lacquer passed. At 100% alcohol, all finishes failed, though solvent lacquer did better than the others.

As for other issues....Shellac failed applications of ammonia, acetone, and scratches with hard pencil (1H and higher). Shellac passed applications of mineral spirits, vinegar, and scratches with soft pencil (B and 2B).

Jewitt does not list water damage as a particular threat to shellac, dewaxed in this case. Warren is right. Though I am still looking at a white ring, which Jewitt says can be taken off by wiping lightly with alcohol--not ringing wet alcohol, 'dogs nose' alcohol.

Wiley

Re: Finish for old knotty pine? *LINK*

#35

Wipe it don't brush it ...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Scott it's looking fine. Half coats and rock on!

I wanna see it complete!