Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

Posts

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#51

Hold on a second *LINK*

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>Compare the new Disston with the Pax 1776. Looks and price seem very similar. Don't know about how well it works. I originally wondered if anyone had info about where it's made, how well it works, etc. I was pleased to see this as another indication that hand tools are continuing to be mainstreamed. That is a great thing, to me. Why the negativity?


Pax 1776

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#52

Split nuts vs Chigago bolts

Bob Demers

>After all these years, I dont think they have come up with a better screw design for attaching the handle on a saw plate than the split screw system.

Yes its a bummer to find the correct spanner to thighten them, but its quick and simple to make.

I think its way better as a screw than the commun, now a day, chicago bolt system, because as the wood shrink and you need to thighten ever more so slightly, the chigago screw will eventually bottom out, preventing anymore turn, The split nut on the other hand will just let the screw thread protude a bit more.

Simple, elegant, work like a charm. Or course, what else but a simple slot could you put on it? As our Brits cousins will say, you need a spanner...

Now if they had just standardized that on that darn slot, one would not need acollection of spanners..

Bob, with a few too many (?) spanners

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#53

I kind of agree, however...

Alan DuBoff

>Bob,

I agree with you on the split-nuts, to me the Chicago Bolts don't work for me, aesthetically.

So, appearance wise I am completely with you.

Functionally, it seems to me that they fail in more than one way, but have found that a wider slot allows for more tension to be applied, safely. Even so, I have way more horked up split-nuts on old saws due to people not having the spanner, or making one, even I'm guilty of it.

In some cases the spanners just jump out of the small slots, or that the wall of the slot is too small to hold the spanner so that the nut does turn.

I think it's possible to create a better saw nut, but MikeW has made a good point in the past of, "why ?". As you also mention, it seems to work about the best...they certainly look the best, IMO.

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#54

18th century rivets, pics anyone?

Alan DuBoff

>Speaking of split-nuts, prior to the use of split-nuts, saw makers used rivets. Most all the pics I've seen of old saws, looking like they have some type of split-nut, but I think I might have some of the rivets possibly on one or two saws.

Did most of the makers file the rivets flat also? I have some saws that don't appear to have any split and/or way to tighten them, the maker appears to have done that purposely by filing both sides flat. I do have some that have rounded heads on them, but newer saws around the turn of the 20th century, and as such have slotted screws on them.

Is the two flats with no slot, a rivet? And for extra credit, how were the rivets swagged together? Did the makers use some type of tool? Were they just hammered together tight?

The Kenyon saws also appear to have flat, and I would guess those are most certainly rivets since they were made around the turn of the 19th century.

Saw screws do have an interesting history, with Washburn's patent in 1867 for brassing the screw shank to the head, Munger's patent in 1869 for swaging the shank to the screw head, and Glover's 1887 patenet for swaging the shank to the head of a label screw and stamping the head with logo/mark.

I suspect the saws I mention above are what the rivets look like? No split, just both flat faces on both sides?

Presumably MikeW will put split-nuts on copies of the Kenyon dovetail saw that resurrected at WIA. This will be the new holy grail of dovetail saws...:-) I wouldn't mind understanding the saw, hope Mike gets to disassemble it. Interesting that it is close to the Grammercy dovetail saw. Joel did his homework on that one. :-)

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#55

machines *LINK*

paul womack

>For that matter, doesn't LN produce a decent machined handle also?

According to TLN, most visitors to the factory are astounded at the amount of handwork in the handles.

Certainly the "step-by-step" display board at trade shows is informative...

(anyone got a photo?)

BugBear


link to discussion