Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

Posts

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#26

Re: I am surprised...

Joel

>"Ok, here's my point. I see no reason why modern CNC tooling can't re-create a saw that is designed by someone who knows what they are doing (yourself perhaps) but made with modern techniques, I am certain that 1095 spring steel would have been highly prized by early Sheffield saw makers. And if you had a CNC handle machine making in the 1800's every saw maker in Sheffield would want one."

Isn't that exactly what we are doing today? The best reason why we can create a proper late 19th century saw with late 18th century features is that we don't have any machinery from the 20 century sawmaking in our shop influencing how we make our tools. heck we don't even have a Foley sharpener.

The same applies to toothing and sharpening, a purpose built CNC machine should be able to reproduce the best hand sharpened, hammer set handsaw, even to to extent of programming in a bit of randomness if that's determined to be beneficial.

This I don't agree with because even with the best of equipment having a human both introduce a little bit of randomness and at the same time pay attention to the teeth, how the file is cutting which varies as the file wears, and things like that is next to impossible to do by robot. And incidentally sharpening and setting in the hands of someone who does it all day long isn't hard or time consuming.

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#27

Re: I am surprised...

MikeW

>Hi Ace, the way you frame your response it would be a big deal to me. However, different climates will affect a tight handle *as it leaves my shop*.

We do tighten the heck out of the bolts. However, wood eventually compresses under the bolts, and a handle will either swell or shrink. If not now, later. It is the nature of wood. Eventually bolts will need tightened.

If I am correct and these are made in England, the same use to happen with every plane tote and knob Record sent into the US. Heck, I've had LN and LV plane totes and knobs arrive at my residence with loose wood bits. I suspect neither LV nor LN shipped them thatta way (or at least didn't package them that way).

Take care, Mike

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#28

Re: I am surprised...

MikeW

>Hi Ray,

Yes, a 5 axis CNC can do a wonderful job. They are, however, slower than a human. As well, it isn't that hours of programming cannot write the program (at a goodly cost). It is the work holding that presents the challenge.

We've had some good companies try to sell us CNC equipment. I send them a handle and ask them to reproduce it below my cost in human effort--without factoring in the programming and false starts. They cannot do it without some human work following the CNC work. It is because some of what is waste must be left on the handle for the work holding that must come off following the machine.

But in the final analysis, I would rather put more people to work than expense a million dollar machine even if the labor versus machine cost was a wash.

Take care, Mike

at the end of a terribly long few weeks...

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#29

Re: Automation Effort Wasted...

Ray Gardiner

>Hi Joel, all good points..

Joel said:-"This I don't agree with because even with the best of equipment having a human both introduce a little bit of randomness and at the same time pay attention to the teeth, how the file is cutting which varies as the file wears, and things like that is next to impossible to do by robot. And incidentally sharpening and setting in the hands of someone who does it all day long isn't hard or time consuming."

No argument here, but take a look at the machine sharpened saws being sold (I'll include hard point saws here as well), and it is clear that a lot of the manufacturers don't know what they are doing... I bet that if you got Tim to program those machines it would be a vastly different result. As to whether it could **ever** be better than a highly skilled hand sharpened and set saw is a question of how much capital you can throw at it. (drifting off topic.. sorry) For the record, I am **NOT** thinking of Foley machines here, in the same sense as CNC automation, I am thinking more along the lines of what Vollmer Finimat is to TCT Circular saws. Diamond grinding wheels etc..

The point I am trying to make (perhaps badly) is that manufacturers (like Disston and others ) could use the technology they have to make a better design. CNC machinery exists that could make handles that are better than what is being offered to the market at $125.

Regards

Ray

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#30

Re: I am surprised...

Ray Gardiner

>Hi Mike,

MikeW said:-"But in the final analysis, I would rather put more people to work than expense a million dollar machine even if the labor versus machine cost was a wash. "

Couldn't agree more, but my point is that these guy's ALREADY have the automation, and they are wasting (misusing) it. They could have used the same equipment to produce a better product, if they had someone (a designer) who understood saws better.

It's the design I am being critical of, as much as the wasted effort.

Regards

Ray

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#31

Re: Automation Effort Wasted...

Joel

>"No argument here, but take a look at the machine sharpened saws being sold (I'll include hard point saws here as well), and it is clear that a lot of the manufacturers don't know what they are doing... I bet that if you got Tim to program those machines it would be a vastly different result. As to whether it could **ever** be better than a highly skilled hand sharpened and set saw is a question of how much capital you can throw at it. (drifting off topic.. sorry) For the record, I am **NOT** thinking of Foley machines here, in the same sense as CNC automation, I am thinking more along the lines of what Vollmer Finimat is to TCT Circular saws. Diamond grinding wheels etc.."

certainly, people are doing it already in Japan and you can get a very very good result. But not as good as doing it by hand.

"The point I am trying to make (perhaps badly) is that manufacturers (like Disston and others ) could use the technology they have to make a better design."

first they don't have. Disston doesn't exist today. They would have to invest in machinery or outsource the project and they decided not to.

"CNC machinery exists that could make handles that are better than what is being offered to the market at $125."

Regards

Ray "

Okay - what features could make our handles better than what we currently offer? This is a serious question as I think our CNC handles reflect the current state of the art on what can be done using CNC to make handles. how could we improve? (and I am not talking shape- that is a design decision - but what features are we missing?)

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#32

Re: What were they thinking?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Rockler is a very good company, maybe a notch below Highland Hardware. They carry many quality products and the owner and her family are active woodworkers.

Maybe they're just testing the waters, seeing the reaction of their customers.

Pam

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#33

I probably got a bad one... Well Don...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Could be I have 3 Tyzack's. 1 Panel, 2 back saws. The panel saw cuts great after a stoning. The back saw are a different story. I have a 6" and a 10-12" not in the shop right now. They have way too much set and way too many teeth IMHO. I like the quality of them and I'm a sucker for Elephants that's why I bought these saws. I like feeding 'em and their fun to ride too.

Anyway, I'm making up a package to send off for filing.

So, All I need to do is figure out what I want and how they should be filed...

Easier said than done!

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#34

Agreed! ;^)

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#35

Re: Automation Effort Wasted...

Ray Gardiner

>Hi Joel,

Quote:" Okay - what features could make our handles better than what we currently offer? This is a serious question as I think our CNC handles reflect the current state of the art on what can be done using CNC to make handles. how could we improve? (and I am not talking shape- that is a design decision - but what features are we missing?)"

None, my comments are not referring to your saws. I think yours are a great example of the way it should be done.

I am talking about the new Disston's saws, (or saws being sold with the Disston Brand if you want to be pedantic.) That's what I thought we were discussing.

Regards

Ray

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#36

Sorry Joel, A CNC can't do it...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>You'd have to stand the blank vertically (on it's edge) to cut the teeth they would never be sharp, have way too much set (mostly for being deformed by the cutting process) and would need sharping after forming. Not a task for a CNC IMHO.

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#37

Re: Sorry Joel, A CNC can't do it...

Ray Gardiner

>Hi Scott,

Ever seen an EDM or a wire cutter in action?

Regards

Ray

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#38

They weren't... You are!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#39

Hi Ray, Everyday. But a wire EDM...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Is VERY different than a CNC. NO many how axis's it's has.

Now Ray, walk away from the computer and go watch SNL :^)

Get the ice cream first...

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#40

Re: Hi Ray, Everyday. But a wire EDM...

Ray Gardiner

>Hey! I am missed SNL,

Actually it's Sunday Afternoon here...Australia.. Almost 6pm.

A friend who has a engineering shop and he has a wire cutter, truly awesome machine, but I never thought about cutting saw teeth, till now. I must pay him a visit next week, see what he thinks about trying a couple of saws. I wonder what he will make of fleam/gullets etc..

I would still refer to it as CNC.

Regards

Ray

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#41

Good Day! Ray

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Well wadda ya know. Say, what's for dinner?

A EDM would be the ultimate foe cutting saw teeth IMHO. Just feed it in and out bingo! A 80 TPI blade;^)

Talk about smooth.

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#42

Re: Good Day! Ray

Ray Gardiner

>Hi Scott,

Must go and find out what's on for dinner, here we call it tea.

I will find out more about the wire cutter in the next week, if I can

get a couple done, just to see if there is any future in the idea.

The market for premium saws, will always favour hand filed saws, but lower down the spectrum, who knows. Can't be any worse than what's already out there.

Regards

Ray

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#43

Did LV just do this?

Alan DuBoff

>Ray,

Didn't LV just in fact do just that?

They produced a better saw for the price, with little touch of human hands by the looks of it.

It is these Disstons and the other crappy saws that have been on the market which LV is competition with.

Of all the tool makers, LV is the only one who has really innovated.

LV is already selling quite a few of their new saws, they have a loyal following of customers and many of them are buying them just because they like LV products. I bet they haven't had any returns either.

Adria uses water cut blades, which are cut in Japan, that is a fairly high tech process, much more efficient than other means of stamping teeth, so that aspect is moving forward with better technology than was used in the past.

That said, I don't want to let go of tradition, speaking for myself. But I have to believe that eventually makers like LV will eclipse most makes using traditional methods of tool making.

For that matter, doesn't LN produce a decent machined handle also? Look at the numbers of saws they sell, I have to think that LN might be one of the largest saw makers in terms of QTY.

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#44

Report

Marc on a Sunday morning in Luxembourg

>Hi Mike,

Just a customer report - of the 3 of your saws, one I won, none came with loose bolts. On none I've had to put in my screwdriver yet. Just to let you know, that shipping overseas (continental Europe) didn't affected the wood handles at all.

Marc

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#45

Re: Did LV just do this?

Ray Gardiner

>Hi Alan,

Yes, good observation, if LV can do it why can't Disston (or whoever it is) produce a good design.. (admittedly I was thinking early 1800's) but LV shows innovation and signs that a great deal of thought went into the design process..

I think it was you that made the observation that LV is like what Henry Disston was in the 1850's.. with respect to design and innovation. I agree completely.

An opportunity lost.

Regards

Ray

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#46

Re: Did LV just do this?

Alan DuBoff

>Yeah, there are a lot of similarities in Rob Lee and Henry Disston, but Disston was gone when his company went down the toilet, and I think some of the vision was lost.

Disston was all about bringing you the best value at the time, using the best materials within reason.

But LV has one up'd Disston, he has a saw that requires very little in the way of hands touching the saw to manufacture, Disston would have marveled at that idea, and been envious. :-)

Disston continually brought the quality down in regards to the handles getting worse and worse. LV didn't do that really, they appear to have good quality and the handles are one of the nice features of their saw, it is a pretty nice bubinga handle from the looks of it. Where Disston was ahead of all the other folks was in producing steel, he could produce his own steel.

The handle attachment is probably an improvement over split-nuts (time will tell, plenty of fubar plane handles exist;-), and people can still make their own handle. I mentioned before that people could have different handles with different hangs if they want, but that probably doesn't make sense for a dovetail saw.

Interesting though, will be how traditional crafted tools are effected, if at all, by the the LV (or similar in the future) saw(s).

None the less, the low end market is not somewhere to battle, one would be up against folks like LV and even MikeW has mentioned low cost saws...if he could figure out how to machine the handles...Steve Knight is close to him, Steve was using his shop-bot to machine plane handle...I'm not sure how you would motivate Steve Knight though...:-/

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#47

Re: Sorry Joel, A CNC can't do it...

Joel

>Scott - it's done all the time - you just gang up 50 or 100 or more blanks and mill them all at much.

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#48

Re: I am surprised...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Mike,

You wrote....

We do tighten the heck out of the bolts. However, wood eventually compresses under the bolts, and a handle will either swell or shrink. If not now, later. It is the nature of wood. Eventually bolts will need tightened.

----------------------

A good reason to use bolts that don't require a special screwdriver. We've had this discussion before.

Disston seasoned their wood for three years and then kiln dried it before using it for handles. All of that and the screws still loosened.

Like you said, "it's the nature of the wood".

You make some very nice saws. I haven't purchased one yet, I might be too old, but if or when I do own one, I will be a bit miffed when I need to tighten the screws and can't because of not having a proper tool for the job.

Actually, I do have one. A good friend of mine bought two from Joel and gave one to me. Then I found that it was too thick to fit the older split nuts. I had to grind the tines thinner.

It's probably just me, but I see no practical reason to require a special screw driver for such a simple problem to solve.

Marv

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#49

Ahhh, I get it now!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*

#50

Re: I am surprised...

MikeW

>Ah, Marv.

We do live in a "Have it your way" world, don't we?

While I might someday have the so-called improved bolts/nuts, I will only use them on the era of saws for which they were common.

See, to me, it takes less than a couple minutes to make a split nut driver. Just use an appropriate width spade bit, grind the tip off, grind the end to width and file a slot about 3/16" deep with a round file--or even a saw file.

I don't look at that as onerous. You do evidently do.

Take care, Mike