Re: I am surprised...
Joel
>"Ok, here's my point. I see no reason why modern CNC tooling can't re-create a saw that is designed by someone who knows what they are doing (yourself perhaps) but made with modern techniques, I am certain that 1095 spring steel would have been highly prized by early Sheffield saw makers. And if you had a CNC handle machine making in the 1800's every saw maker in Sheffield would want one."
Isn't that exactly what we are doing today? The best reason why we can create a proper late 19th century saw with late 18th century features is that we don't have any machinery from the 20 century sawmaking in our shop influencing how we make our tools. heck we don't even have a Foley sharpener.
The same applies to toothing and sharpening, a purpose built CNC machine should be able to reproduce the best hand sharpened, hammer set handsaw, even to to extent of programming in a bit of randomness if that's determined to be beneficial.
This I don't agree with because even with the best of equipment having a human both introduce a little bit of randomness and at the same time pay attention to the teeth, how the file is cutting which varies as the file wears, and things like that is next to impossible to do by robot. And incidentally sharpening and setting in the hands of someone who does it all day long isn't hard or time consuming.



