New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*
Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX
>Look what Rockler has. A dovetail and two carcass saws from Disston. Anyone know about this Phoenix rising?
Disston dovetail saw
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
New Disston Saws at Rockler *LINK*
Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX
>Look what Rockler has. A dovetail and two carcass saws from Disston. Anyone know about this Phoenix rising?
Disston dovetail saw
discussion *LINK*
paul womack
>from August, over on woodnet
link to discussion
Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler
Bob Demers
>We are indeed living thru a renaissance period in WW. For the former big names in the game (Stanley, Disston et al) to take notice and attempt a comeback at quality tools.
I say attempt, because before these big old names can regain our confidence, they will have to prove themselves in the long run.
First impression of this saw, is that the handle look a tad blocky to me, and not ergonmically comfortable as claimed.
But at that price range i'll still favour Mike's saw, Adria, LN, LV and Gramercy thank you.
For I dont mind paying good money for a saw but I still expect service.
And that is hard to do for a big guy, with the exception of LV who has probably an unsurpassed well deserved reputation for service.
Bob, who really should get its butt off to work
Painful handles
Don in Northern Arizona
>One of Joel's handle maker rasps should be included with each purchase by Rockler. It doesn't look like Lie-Nielsen, Joel, Mike, Adria,etc. need to lose any sleep over these. I wonder if the teeth are somewhat crudely stamped out by machine like late 60s through 80s British saws, e.g., Tyzack. They also had painful handles.
Don
Butt Ugly
Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.
>
discussion *LINK*
paul womack
>
I wonder if the teeth are somewhat crudely stamped out by machine like late 60s through 80s British saws, e.g., Tyzack.
I have an ad here for Tyzack, from the mid 1960s.
"Beautifully balanced blades in top quality steel. Light.
Flexible. Polished to a sheen. And every single one hand
set and file-sharpened by craftsmen. For the easiest,
quickest, cleanest cut in the world. See our saws at all
good ironmongers and hardware shops."
That's just what the advert says,
who knows what the truth was?!
I do know that I rate *my* Tyzack saws pretty highly.
They've all been resharpened, of course...
BugBear
link to discussion
What were they thinking?
Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.
>My first take on the overall look of the saw is, it's an insult to my senses. I can only imagine what Hank D. would be thinking.
I see nothing innovative or special about the saw to even come close to justifying the high price of $125 for the DT version. Do they actually think their saws compare to say an LV or LN or MW or AL (Andrew Lunn)or Gramercy? Fa geta bout it!
They must have used as a model, one of the last saws that Sandvik made with the Disston name smeared on the blade. Those saws were so bad they hurt one's eyes to look at them. They should feel shame for offering such a poorly designed tool using the Disston name. Blasphamy!
My guess is, they are being made in China for about a buck fifty each.
IMHO.
Marv
What they are probably thinking is
Chuck Nickerson
>"If some guy and his sons in a shack in Oregon can get good money for saws, it should be easy for a big company like us to do the same." I've sat in meetings (not in tool industry) where similar things are said. The clueless are all around us.
Oranges and Prunes
Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.
>
Re: What were they thinking?
Ray Gardiner
>Who is "Hank Disston", There's Henry, and others , and of course Hamilton (one time largest landowner in the US).. Never heard of Hank. :-)
Maybe he's the one responsible for designing these saws?
Seriously, you are being unfairly critical, I think they should be judged on how they perform, the handle can be easily re-shaped, so I don't see an insurmountable problem there.
The etch looks pretty low down on the blade, and the back width looks a bit too wide, might be a bit unbalanced, but having never used one, I feel it's unfair to be too critical.
On thing I can be critical of..
The price is way too high, if they are going to succeed in the longer term, they will need to come down to at least be competitive with LV.
The answer to your question, what were they thinking?
Easy, like any manufacturer they want to make money.
And people **WILL** buy them.
I notice that Rockler have sold out, maybe they only got a couple to see how they sold?
Regards Ray
Re: New Disston Saws at Rockler------WebKitFormBou
Mark------WebKitFormBoundaryK1JjL8jFdRg+BMOC
>Perhaps someone knows who or what company is �Disston� now? I too suspect that these are Chinese made - I wonder if it�s true?
Mark
------WebKitFormBoundaryK1JjL8jFdRg+BMOC
Re: discussion
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>Yeah, I liked my Tyzack backsaw circa 1980 a lot, made some perfect dovetails with it, sawed lots of tenons with aplomb. It's still very good.
Pam
Re: What were they thinking?
Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.
>Ray,
My Father's name was Henry. His friends, what few he had, called him Hank.
Whoever it was who designed the Disston wannabee saws no doubt was attempting to maximize their profits. Nothing wrong with that, but....they made a cheap product on about the same quality level as the last Disston saws made, not by Disston but by Sandvik. Take a cheaply made saw and then capitalize on the Disston name by silkscreening it on the blade.
Yes, they will fool a lot of people, those who have no idea what the old Disston name stands for.
Even if it cuts like a dream, it still isn't worth anything near $125. If they had priced their saws around $27.95 we probably wouldn't be having this kind of discussion.
Marv
Re: What were they thinking?
Ray Gardiner
>I think we agree, it's not in keeping with Henry's (sorry, Hank's) legacy.
Hank...transatlantic humor doesn't travel at all well.... next thing you'll be telling me Chuck is short for Charles...
Regards
Ray
Re: What were they thinking?
Ace Karner
>I was in the Rockler Store in Mesquite yesterday. They had a display on the counter at checkout with all three saws on it. I picked up the dovetail saw and found at least a 1/4 inch of play in a very loose handle. Thinking that a saw that lists for 125.00 that must have been an anomaly, so I tried the other two saws, all had the same problem.
I doubt that anyone buying these saws was able to pick them up before hand and I also doubt they've probably never held or used a proper back saw.
Articulation is at the absolute bottom of my list of attributes I'd like to see in a back saw. :)
Further discussion: I probably got a bad one
Don in Northern Arizona
>Paul and Pam,
Here is a very bad drawing of my Tyzack saw's teeth as seen through a hand lens. The top shows one side of the blade with a pronounced U shaped depression under alternate gullets. The bottom shows a pronounced L shaped depression on alternate teeth and a small v shaped depression on the other teeth. I suppose these could have been done by a worker hand setting saws while in a hurry to meet his or her quota of product for the day. The saw has too much set, and I will get it redone one day. I have reshaped the handle to be quite comfortable. All complaints aside it is a lovely looking saw with a shiny heavy brass back. My ancient pitted steel-backed Disston which was hand sharpened and set by a hobbyist craftsman cuts much better, however. Not a fair comparison, I realize, as it has thinner steel and the hobbyist was not working against the clock. I do apologize. I shouldn't have singled out saws with a British marque, and obviously my sample is absurdly small, based on the one Tyzack and a Slack Sellars I bought from Lee Valley many years ago. I have two old Drabble and Sanderson saws that are very fine. My complaints would probably apply to many post 1950 saws made before Independence Tool started up.
Don
If their market people are paying attention
Bill Houghton, overcast in Sebastopol, CA
>they'll feed back that the saws need work.
Of course, some folks will probably buy them on the name.
Re: If their market people are paying attention
MikeW
>Disston knows the choices they made between better materials, nicer shaping, fit, and finish. Not to mention the ill-sized and placed "etches."
The paid the maker at a given price point and positioned the retail where it is by design.
It isn't the marketing people's decisions at work, here. Go higher up the food chain.
Take care, Mike
Re: If their market people are paying attention
Tony Zaffuto
>You're right Mike,
Disston is not aiming at the guys/gals who frequent the various forums or read various WW'ing magazines. I'd be curious to see how many saws Disston wants to sell.
We've got to remember that not every person who works wood as a hobby or as a profession, knows about LN, Wenzlof, Adria, Gramercy etc. Compare the new Disston to Groz and Anant. It didn't take Groz long to come out with a higher end line (Kamal, although we haven't heard much about these yet), and Anant has always positioned itself as the same (for vises) as the Record of old, from whom they bought the patterns (and with nearly comparable prices!).
I question the validity of the Disston price: is this suggested retail that will soon be deeply discounted after the retailers discover there isn't a run on the saws? Will Disston come out with a higher end, more refined saw? I have never been in a Rocklers and really don't look at their catalogs much. Are there any other saws in their stores or catalogs?
T.Z.
Re: What were they thinking?
Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.
>Only two things that can cause that much play....too small of screws in big holes or too large of holes for small screws.
Somehow I'm not surprised by the look of the rest of the saw. Now I'm wondering if this level of quality is consistant with other Rockler products.
When you go to their website, they show that they are sold out on all three saws. They aren't sold out, they are merely testing the market.
Rockler has just dropped to the bottom of my list of tool sites.
Thanks for your "articulate" post.
Marv
I am surprised...
Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret
>that there are so many opinions about a saw that apparently no one has used?
If loose handles are a concern, don't buy any old saws as many of the blades are loose. A friend has an early stamped Spear & Jackson hand saw with a very loose handle. The shank on one of the saw nuts was worn over half way through from its contact with the steel blade.
And dismissing Rockler for offering this saw is like killing the messenger because you don't like the message.
Stephen
Not surprised.....
Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.
>It's not surprising when buying an old saw for it to have most anything wrong with it including a loose handle and worn screws.
But when paying from $125 to $135 for a new saw you expect it to do everything you are buying the saw to do and that includes it having a tight handle. It's not surprising to see someone being critical when they pick up an expensive saw and find that the handle is nearly falling off.
As for trying to capitalize on the Disston name, perhaps the maker of the saws only examined the bastardized saws that H.K. Porter and Sandvik produced. However, Disston also produced some junky saws during the war years and until they were bought out by H.K. Porter in 1955. The maker of the Rockler/Disston saws would probably have a winner if they had gone farther back in time and made saws that more resembled Disston saws made prior to 1928.
The least expensive saws on the market can cut well so why do people pay so much more for a saw that not only cuts well, but has an ergonomically designed tote made of a type of wood that is gorgeous? I guess I just answered my own question.
Any company who would put on display a new product that is grossly over priced, poorly designed and has an obvious defect must be suspect regarding how they make decisions regarding other tools they sell. And it wasn't just one saw, it was all three on display!
Marv
Re: I am surprised...
MikeW
>"I am surprised...that there are so many opinions about a saw that apparently no one has used?"
Sort of like LV spoon bits, eh? ;^)
To be fair, you did try them later on.
For the money, they should use better steel. They should at least try to place the bolts a little better on the DT. They should shape the handles a tad better. The etch? Perhaps a smaller scale on the DT and higher up.
They should have used a better DT saw pattern from Disston's earlier work--not the #70, earlier. And they should have not simplified what they did in order to have Flinn or whoever automate the handle making. For the money, that is.
I have test cut with one. I'll leave that out of my criticism--people should be able to sharpen a saw that doesn't suit them to one that does. People should try it for themselves. My opinion on the loose bolts? I doubt they were loose when they left the country of origin. A screwdriver solves that, big deal.
Take care, Mike
Re: I am surprised...
Ace Karner
>My guess is that if you shipped a saw with a floppy loose handle it would be a big deal to you :).
Re: I am surprised...
Ray Gardiner
>Hi Mike,
You have touched on a significant point, something that has been bugging me for ages, I could argue that backsaw design reached it's zenith in Sheffield in the early 19th Century, the backsaws that yourself and Joel are making are reflective on that period. (and a little earlier as well)
Ok, here's my point. I see no reason why modern CNC tooling can't re-create a saw that is designed by someone who knows what they are doing (yourself perhaps) but made with modern techniques, I am certain that 1095 spring steel would have been highly prized by early Sheffield saw makers. And if you had a CNC handle machine making in the 1800's every saw maker in Sheffield would want one.
The same applies to toothing and sharpening, a purpose built CNC machine should be able to reproduce the best hand sharpened, hammer set handsaw, even to to extent of programming in a bit of randomness if that's determined to be beneficial.
Ok that might be heresy to some...
But there is no excuse for those who already have the machine capacity to continue to re-create the worst of the 1950's, when with a bit of thought in the design process they could make something so much better and retail much less than $125
A CNC made early 1800's style backsaw for a fair price. Should be possible or am I missing something?
Regards
Ray